Terra revolving round Sol question

That is exactly the problem I am talking about. There is no reason for us to exclude evidence, historical information, and context. That is one of the benefits of being a sentient species.

Sorry, what is "exactly the problem [you are] talking about"?

I'm not clear what your answer was to the question: do you agree or disagree with the quoted text?
 
Sorry, what is "exactly the problem [you are] talking about"?

I'm not clear what your answer was to the question: do you agree or disagree with the quoted text?

Perhaps I misread the quote but this seems apt:

So SR may very well give us the powerful tool of looking at it from any frame of reference but is incapable of telling us anything about that history and so it cannot tell us what is actually currently happening.

It seems we are arguing strict science versus logic.
 
I can only say that that is a very poor analogy to what we are discussing? It doesn't even make sense.

Perhaps form an analogy where you knock the tree over.

To be clear: you agree with both "I am sitting under the tree" and "the tree is over me" describe the situation accurately and that both models are true. But you suggest that while that's the case in this very simple example, it's not the case with respect to the choice of coordinates in GR, correct?

(I'm just looking for clarity, there's a good chance the the above is incorrect and you're saying something else, but I'm not sure if your are or what that other thing could be) :)
 
To be clear: you agree with both "I am sitting under the tree" and "the tree is over me" describe the situation accurately and that both models are true. But you suggest that while that's the case in this very simple example, it's not the case with respect to the choice of coordinates in GR, correct?

(I'm just looking for clarity, there's a good chance the the above is incorrect and you're saying something else, but I'm not sure if your are or what that other thing could be) :)


I specifically do not agree that that is analogous to the Earth/Sun situation at all. Not even close. That's like saying that from a certain POV that when the Sun is currently to the left of the Earth, the Earth is currently to the right of the sun.

Just because 2 valid models are equally accurate in one situation does not mean that all valid models in all situations are equally accurate.
 
Perhaps you could give your opinion on my post from the previous page??

I have a new question (or a new wrinkle to the question).

First of all we are referring to the interesting model that appears when you have the Earth be the center and the Sun orbiting it (the Earth).

I assume that it is just as complicated, but not much more, to have the Earth be the center and the black hole from the center of our galaxy orbiting it (the Earth). (Or perhaps I should replace the Earth with the Sun in this scenario to make it even more like the Earth/Sun model from Page 1...)

My question is, how much more complicated would a model be that has the Earth at the center and a black hole from the center of another galaxy orbiting it (the Earth). I.E. objects from separate galaxies.

Or perhaps even even more complicated, the Earth is the center and a star from another galaxy is orbiting it?

Is this even possible since galaxies don't really normally orbit each other (or anything?)?

Even if it is possible, I assume the black hole at the center of our galaxy would make both of those models very complicated?

Instead of just Star - Planet - Moon you would have: other galaxy - black hole from the center of our galaxy - star - planet - moon.
 
I specifically do not agree that that is analogous to the Earth/Sun situation at all. Not even close. That's like saying that from a certain POV that when the Sun is currently to the left of the Earth, the Earth is currently to the right of the sun.

Just because 2 valid models are equally accurate in one situation does not mean that all valid models in all situations are equally accurate.

:confused: I didn't ask you if you agreed that it was analogous. I basically said "You agree that both of those statements are true, yes or no?" you haven't answered that question.
I then said that I think you don't agree that it's a good analogy (so you seem to be agreeing with me about that), because while some models can be indistinguishable and both true, in the specific case of the earth/sun system and rotation, you feel there's other evidence that we can draw on to distinguish them.

Rather than arguing with the above, which isn't an argument, can't you just answer the actual questions I'm asking? I'm only trying to clarify what you're saying.
 
I can only say that that is a very poor analogy to what we are discussing? It doesn't even make sense.

Perhaps form an analogy where you knock the tree over.
First of all, I want to make clear that I'm not joking about the tree.

The main point of the analogy is this:

There is a physical occurrence that can be described as:

1. H'ethetheth sitting under a tree
2. A tree standing above H'ethetheth
3. H'ethetheth and a tree rotating at 15°/hour and moving east at 1000 km/h.
4. H'ethetheth, a tree, more trees, a planet, and a star in a galaxy moving on a complicated sinusoidal path through intergalactic space at 30 km/s

Which of these really describes the the actual physical occurrence?

A secondary point is that it's not an analogy so much as a simpler example of exactly what you are describing.
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry, but if I haven't made my position clear by now I have certainly failed.

I'll take that as "I think it's more complicated than that presented in the post you quoted, so can't answer yes or no." Because answering either yes or no would have been much easier than posting what you just posted.

I'm seriously not trying to be argumentative. Anyway, I'll take a look at your last post when I get a chance, late for work! :)
 
Since we aren't talking about the center of any old disk, and we are in fact talking about a protoplanetary disk, correct me if I am wrong, but are you proposing that a protoplanetary disk can rotate around a point that is not the nebula??

Yes.
 
I have a new question (or a new wrinkle to the question).
Okay, I'm no expert on this. Just an interested layman, which is why I didn't answer. I figured you were looking for the answers of the experts (like sol). But since you asked I'll do my best. :)

First of all we are referring to the interesting model that appears when you have the Earth be the center and the Sun orbiting it (the Earth).

I assume that it is just as complicated, but not much more, to have the Earth be the center and the black hole from the center of our galaxy orbiting it (the Earth). (Or perhaps I should replace the Earth with the Sun in this scenario to make it even more like the Earth/Sun model from Page 1...)

My question is, how much more complicated would a model be that has the Earth at the center and a black hole from the center of another galaxy orbiting it (the Earth). I.E. objects from separate galaxies.

Or perhaps even even more complicated, the Earth is the center and a star from another galaxy is orbiting it?
I don't know that it would be more complicated. To put it another way, the coordinate systems that you are talking about are useful for particular questions. If you want to figure out where a cannonball launched from a particular place on earth will end up, the frame in which the earth is stationary is likely the most convenient. Anything else is much more complicated for that particular problem.

If you are trying to model the entire universe I think that as Zig said, the CMB rest frame is the most convenient. I honestly don't know if one can be said to be more complicated than the other, since they can be transformed into each other. But I honestly don't know.

Is this even possible since galaxies don't really normally orbit each other (or anything?)?
I suspect "orbit" isn't really the best word, but one galaxy's motion with relation to another would look different in a frame in which the earth is at rest than one in which, say, the black hole at the center of the milky way is at rest.

Even if it is possible, I assume the black hole at the center of our galaxy would make both of those models very complicated?

Instead of just Star - Planet - Moon you would have: other galaxy - black hole from the center of our galaxy - star - planet - moon.

Don't you have those in any model, though? I mean, if you use the CMB rest frame, the actual motion of the galaxies with respect to each other doesn't change: (that's probably sloppy wording) what I mean is that any experiments will have the same results.
 
I can only say that that is a very poor analogy to what we are discussing? It doesn't even make sense.

Perhaps form an analogy where you knock the tree over.

Knock the tree over relative to what?

ETA: Pick frame of reference--any frame of reference. Figure the current forces on the tree, in that frame. Apply a new force to the tree. Figure the outcome, in that frame. Do the same thing in another frame. It's the same outcome, every time. Pick one of the frames. Declare it to be the "best" frame, or the "correct" frame. Explain why.
 
Last edited:
Knock the tree over relative to what?
Relative to the ground.

ETA: Pick frame of reference--any frame of reference. Figure the current forces on the tree, in that frame. Apply a new force to the tree. Figure the outcome, in that frame. Do the same thing in another frame. It's the same outcome, every time. Pick one of the frames. Declare it to be the "best" frame, or the "correct" frame. Explain why.
Because it's the simplest, and because it helps us to understand the world. Which is why we do physics.

And when we do, we are reminded that a reference frame is merely an artefact of measurement. Stars exist, galaxies exist, planets exist, and other things too. These things exist in the universe, and they move. They are real and so is their motion. But you cannot point up to the clear night sky and say "look, there's a reference frame". We understand reference frames, we use them as appropriate, but we do not allow an artefact that has no actual existence to cloud our understanding of the things that do. All maps are equally valid, but the map is not the territory. The Sun does not "go round the Earth in a suitable reference frame", just as the Earth is not rectangular whatever the map. That reference frame is not something that actually exists, so the Sun and the Earth are not "in it". They're in space. They exist, and their motion exists, in this universe which also exists. And in that universe, the Earth goes round the Sun.
 
the Sun and the Earth are [...] in space. They exist, and their motion exists, in this universe which also exists. And in that universe, the Earth goes round the Sun.
I agree with almost your entire post, except this sentiment.
This is just your preference, just as it is your preference to evaluate me knocking over a tree in a reference frame in which the universe is rotating, and the cosmic background radiation is shifted by about 30 km/s, if I recall correctly.
 
It's kind of like the buck stops with the universe, H'ethetheth. We say motion is relative, but we can use the CMBR dipole anisotropy to gauge our motion with respect to the universe. Different people moving in different ways might all try to claim that it's "perfectly valid" to say that the universe is moving instead. But when you put them together in a room and let them fight it out, they soon realise that they can't all be right, and then they end up seeing sense.
 
Yes, it's kind of like that, but not really, because the buck almost always stops well before that, depending on what you're describing, and what the most intuitive description is.
People sitting under a tree never say they're closely accompanying a tree on its polycycloid path in the general direction of the constellation hydra at about 300 (I recalled incorrectly) km/s.
There is no need for the buck to stop if we can stop it anywhere we prefer. In fact, general relativity states that all the people in your room can all be right, and if they did their homework correctly, they are all right.
 
No probs re usage of a coordinate system appropriate to your situation. But in the end the buck really does stop with the universe. You just can't say that the universe is moving with respect to something else, because the universe is everything there is.

Yes, the people in the room can be all right. The idea is that they compare notes and make allowance for their different coordinate systems, then reach a consensus. That's what the coordinate-independence of general relativity is like, something like you take a step back and see the big picture.

For example if you're moving fast towards a star, and you say it's length-contracted like this |, and if I'm heading towards it from an orthogonal direction and say it's length-contracted like this ―, we don't fight like cat and dog. We compare notes and we recognise that we each see the world in a different fashion, and then we step back and see the big picture of how the world really is, and how we see it different when our motion through it is different.
 
Last edited:
No probs re usage of a coordinate system appropriate to your situation. But in the end the buck really does stop with the universe. You just can't say that the universe is moving with respect to something else, because the universe is everything there is.

Yes, the people in the room can be all right. The idea is that they compare notes and make allowance for their different coordinate systems, then reach a consensus. That's what the coordinate-independence of general relativity is like, something like you take a step back and see the big picture.

For example if you're moving fast towards a star, and you say it's length-contracted like this |, and if I'm heading towards it from an orthogonal direction and say it's length-contracted like this ―, we don't fight like cat and dog. We compare notes and we recognise that we each see the world in a different fashion, and then we step back and see the big picture of how the world really is, and how we see it different when our motion through it is different.
Alright, I'm just going to say we basically agree then, except for the fact that I do not see the relevance of the buck stopping anywhere at all.
 
For example if you're moving fast towards a star, and you say it's length-contracted like this |, and if I'm heading towards it from an orthogonal direction and say it's length-contracted like this ―, we don't fight like cat and dog. We compare notes and we recognise that we each see the world in a different fashion, and then we step back and see the big picture of how the world really is, and how we see it different when our motion through it is different.

Funny thing about the Lorentz contraction - it doesn't result in visible contraction ;)

(just a curious aside that, doesn't affect any arguments here)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom