Terra revolving round Sol question

No probs re usage of a coordinate system appropriate to your situation. But in the end the buck really does stop with the universe. You just can't say that the universe is moving with respect to something else, because the universe is everything there is.

That may or may not be true. But it's also irrelevant, because we cannot see the entire universe. Indeed, the current standard cosmological model posits an infinite universe of which we can (obviously) only see a finite part, and in fact - although this is little discussed - it's a universe in which the portion we can see is guaranteed to be rapidly rotating with respect to any other distant portion.
 
...and in fact - although this is little discussed - it's a universe in which the portion we can see is guaranteed to be rapidly rotating with respect to any other distant portion.
I'm afraid to ask, because I'll probably not understand much of the answer, but could you explain a little about why this is so likely. It seems a really weird idea to me.
 
Last edited:
I'm afraid to ask, because I'll probably not understand much of the answer, but could you explain a little about why this is so likely. It seems a really weird idea to me.

Well, in the standard cosmological model the universe is flat (meaning basically that it's infinite in spatial extent). Moreover, it underwent a period of so-called inflation in its very early evolution shortly after the big bang.

Inflation causes regions of the universe to expand away from each other very rapidly, and it produces random fluctuations in density and pressure. It is those fluctuations that seeded the stars and galaxies we see around us.

There are essentially two possibilities regarding inflation - it last forever going back into the past, in which case any two distant regions were close together at some point during inflation and the region in between them was filled by inflationary fluctuations produced after they separated, or it lasted for a finite time.

If it lasted for a finite time, sufficiently distant regions were never close together. Because the period before inflation was extremely inhomogeneous and anisotropic, one expects very large fluctuations in the characteristics of such distant regions, including large relative rotation.

If it lasted forever, the perturbations produced during inflation accumulated indefinitely. That means that sufficiently distant regions are again disconnected in the sense that one expects no correlation in their characteristics.
 
Well, in the standard cosmological model the universe is flat (meaning basically that it's infinite in spatial extent). Moreover, it underwent a period of so-called inflation in its very early evolution shortly after the big bang.

Inflation causes regions of the universe to expand away from each other very rapidly, and it produces random fluctuations in density and pressure. It is those fluctuations that seeded the stars and galaxies we see around us.

There are essentially two possibilities regarding inflation - it last forever going back into the past, in which case any two distant regions were close together at some point during inflation and the region in between them was filled by inflationary fluctuations produced after they separated, or it lasted for a finite time.

If it lasted for a finite time, sufficiently distant regions were never close together. Because the period before inflation was extremely inhomogeneous and anisotropic, one expects very large fluctuations in the characteristics of such distant regions, including large relative rotation.

If it lasted forever, the perturbations produced during inflation accumulated indefinitely. That means that sufficiently distant regions are again disconnected in the sense that one expects no correlation in their characteristics.
I think I sort of get that, superficially. Though you are talking about the rotation of regions of spacetime, right? I don't think I know what that actually means, but I'll just allow it as something that I may come to grasp one day.

ETA: Something I just thought of that could help me grasp it: Is rotating spacetime at all comparable to vorticity in fluid dynamics?
 
Last edited:
ETA: Something I just thought of that could help me grasp it: Is rotating spacetime at all comparable to vorticity in fluid dynamics?

I don't want to put words in sol invictus's mouth, but I don't think that's what he's saying. It's more that massive objects close together in the early universe had rotation and, as the universe expanded, these "portions of space" (i.e. the massive objects within that volume) continued to rotate relative to other portions of space. Of course, there is something like vorticity in space-time as well: http://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2011/04may_epic/.

sol invictus, I've really only heard that inflation lasted for a finite period of time. Is this more accepted than the other view? Or is the other view new and I just haven't heard of it yet? If inflation is always occurring, is there something that weakened/diffused that repulsion so today it is negligible? Or is this a possible candidate for dark energy?
 
I don't want to put words in sol invictus's mouth, but I don't think that's what he's saying. It's more that massive objects close together in the early universe had rotation and, as the universe expanded, these "portions of space" (i.e. the massive objects within that volume) continued to rotate relative to other portions of space.
Are you sure, because that seems to me too obvious and Newtonian for the whole CMB-inertial reference frame business. I mean, what you're saying is basically already true for the solar system itself.

Of course, there is something like vorticity in space-time as well: http://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2011/04may_epic/.
Cool!
 
Are you sure, because that seems to me too obvious and Newtonian for the whole CMB-inertial reference frame business. I mean, what you're saying is basically already true for the solar system itself.

No, I'm not sure. I think that's accurate for the scenario in which inflation is finite, but I bet sol invictus will correct me if I'm wrong. In the example of infinite inflation, I think the unique rotations are introduced by the random fluctuations, but I'm not at all familiar with this hypothesis.
 
ETA: Something I just thought of that could help me grasp it: Is rotating spacetime at all comparable to vorticity in fluid dynamics?
This is an interesting one. Strictly speaking the answer is no. However there is a relationship between spacetime and vorticity, see this NASA article on gravity probe B. Note though that it's the Earth that's rotating, whilst spacetime is "twisted" rather than rotating:

"If Earth were stationary, that would be the end of the story. But Earth is not stationary. Our planet spins, and the spin should twist the dimple, slightly, pulling it around into a 4-dimensional swirl".

Whilst a gravitomagnetic field and indeed a magnetic field is a "turn" field in that gyroscopes precess or a compass needle rotates to point North, this occurs because motion through a twisted region results in a rotation. Not because the region is rotating. A region of spacetime rotating bodily with respect to another would be a magnetic monopole, which doesn't exist in nature. People do speculate that they might, but an electron has an electromagnetic field. It doesn't have an electric field. A particle cannot have an electric field all on its own, and in similar vein a particle cannot have a magnetic field all on it own. It's the same for a region of space, because space is "connected", something like elastic. The region cannot rotate freely like some roller bearing disconnected from surrounding regions.

Also note re an earlier post that a flat universe does not imply an infinite universe, and that inflation is thought to have been of brief duration, and responsible for smoothing out fluctuations rather than causing them.
 
I think I sort of get that, superficially. Though you are talking about the rotation of regions of spacetime, right? I don't think I know what that actually means, but I'll just allow it as something that I may come to grasp one day.

ETA: Something I just thought of that could help me grasp it: Is rotating spacetime at all comparable to vorticity in fluid dynamics?

Yes, it's comparable. Spacetime is strange stuff in GR; it's not like an aether because it has no rest frame, but it can "wave" (i.e. waves of spacetime exist), and it can rotate and drag things along with it. Sound waves in a fluid with vorticity behave in ways that are quite analogous to light in a rotating spacetime. You do have to be careful with this analogy (it's mathematically precise, but in a slightly tricky and non-obvious way) because there's no rest frame.

I don't want to put words in sol invictus's mouth, but I don't think that's what he's saying. It's more that massive objects close together in the early universe had rotation and, as the universe expanded, these "portions of space" (i.e. the massive objects within that volume) continued to rotate relative to other portions of space.

It's both. Objects will tend to rotate with the spacetime locally, because they get dragged along with it. At the same time a rotating mass sources rotating spacetime around it (and inside it). Going back to the fluid analogy, if you had a porous object in a fluid, it would both drag fluid with it and get dragged along by it.

You might expect distant parts of the fluid to slow each other down until they cease to rotate with respect to each other. Something like that happens in the universe too, but only if the regions are close enough together that they've been able to interact (in a fluid, if the regions are separated by a distance longer than the time the system has existed times the sound speed, they can't have affected each other).

sol invictus, I've really only heard that inflation lasted for a finite period of time. Is this more accepted than the other view? Or is the other view new and I just haven't heard of it yet?

It's actually kind of hard (theoretically) get get inflation not to last forever. Because it's an accelerating expansion it's a runaway process by its very nature, and it tends to reproduce itself. It is possible to write down models where this doesn't happen, but they don't seem particularly natural.

If inflation is always occurring, is there something that weakened/diffused that repulsion so today it is negligible? Or is this a possible candidate for dark energy?

Inflation likes to last forever in the sense that most of the universe at any given time is inflating. Nevertheless, if you pick a random point, inflation always eventually ends at that point (at least in the models that might describe our universe). Those two statements are compatible because inflation keeps producing more volume.

As for dark energy, if that's due to a vacuum energy/cosmological constant it means a new phase of inflation has just begun in our region of the universe - but it's a different phase, with a much slower acceleration rate, than the one in our past.
 
Last edited:
Yes, it's comparable. Spacetime is strange stuff in GR; it's not at all like an aether because it has no rest frame, but it can "wave" (i.e. waves of spacetime exist), and it can rotate and drag things along with it. Sound waves in a fluid with vorticity behave in ways that are quite analogous to light in a rotating spacetime. You do have to be careful with this analogy (it's mathematically precise, but in a slightly tricky and non-obvious way) because there's no rest frame.
Okay, that definitely helps. I'll need to think about this, though, and perhaps finally get myself a physics textbook and hobby myself through general relativity.

Fascinating stuff.
 
It's actually kind of hard (theoretically) get get inflation not to last forever. Because it's an accelerating expansion it's a runaway process by its very nature, and it tends to reproduce itself. It is possible to write down models where this doesn't happen, but they don't seem particularly natural.

Thanks for the information! I've been reading this post over and over for a while and it still has not registered fully. Please forgive my ignorance, but if inflation is an accelerating expansion, wouldn't that mean our universe ought to be expanding faster than it ever has in the past? And isn't it true that the inflationary epoch was the most rapid expansion of space-time in our universe's history? Or am I conflating something here?
 
Thanks for the information! I've been reading this post over and over for a while and it still has not registered fully. Please forgive my ignorance, but if inflation is an accelerating expansion, wouldn't that mean our universe ought to be expanding faster than it ever has in the past? And isn't it true that the inflationary epoch was the most rapid expansion of space-time in our universe's history? Or am I conflating something here?

Let's separate two things: (a) the inflationary epoch and (b) "dark energy". The inflationary epoch (or so this well-tested hypothesis says) was an era when the vacuum energy density was huge, and drove a period of wild acceleration. There was a particular field (the "inflaton") responsible for this energy density, and after the field had decayed, the inflationary behavior ended.

Modern dark energy has an inflation-like behavior, and, yes, it drives an accelerating expansion. Unlike the inflaton, its energy density is very low. Also, dark energy's acceleration has to fight against the gravitational pull of normal matter (baryons + dark matter), which together work to decelerate the expansion. In the past, when the universe was smaller and attractive-gravity better able to work, the deceleration effect was more important. In the present and future, the normal matter is spread out and its mutual-attraction-acceleration is small, so the inflation-y effects of dark energy are just now starting to dominate. So, yes, in the future dark-energy acceleration will drive an ever-increasing rate of expansion, just as inflaton-acceleration it did in the early universe.
 
ben m, that's how I've always understood it: the inflationary epoch is something entirely distinct from dark energy. What has me confused is this notion of an infinite inflation. If inflation is an accelerating expansion and it is infinite (continuously occurring?), it would seem to me that there must be some force/pressure that either counteracts it or dilutes its effects to a large degree. I say this because I was always led to believe that inflation was a finite process in which the universe expanded greatly for a short period of time, and then returned to a "normal" expansion rate (the graphs I've seen show a kind of saddle-like curve for this period). After this, as you said, we have periods in which matter dominates and, now, dark energy.

So, does the inflaton field still affect us? If so, is there something negating this effect? Or am I misusing the term infinite?
 
So, does the inflaton field still affect us? If so, is there something negating this effect? Or am I misusing the term infinite?

If I understand this correctly, you should think of the inflaton as as short-lived high-energy particle. For a short while this particle existed, and then it decayed into a low-energy state, and having decayed it's now not there any more---so, no, it doesn't affect us any more.

The tricky part is understanding why "a high energy particle exists", or "a high-energy particle is decaying", would look like vacuum energy. The answer is that the particle needs to be a vacuum condensate, sort of like the Higgs boson, so that its energy density does not dilute as the universe expands.

Combine the two pictures, and roughly what you have is that *the vacuum itself* was in a high-energy state, then the vacuum decayed completely to the modern-day low-energy state, and inflation occurred only during this short-lived decay process.
 
ben m, great info! And the best part... I get it! :D Inflation always bugged me because even though it seemed like just a way of writing off the magnetic-monopole problem, it was so widely accepted in Cosmology. I watched some Cosmology lectures that helped boost my confidence a bit, but I still didn't understand it that well. This concept of a high-energy vacuum really makes sense though, so thank you very much!
 
ben m, that's how I've always understood it: the inflationary epoch is something entirely distinct from dark energy. What has me confused is this notion of an infinite inflation. If inflation is an accelerating expansion and it is infinite (continuously occurring?), it would seem to me that there must be some force/pressure that either counteracts it or dilutes its effects to a large degree. I say this because I was always led to believe that inflation was a finite process in which the universe expanded greatly for a short period of time, and then returned to a "normal" expansion rate (the graphs I've seen show a kind of saddle-like curve for this period). After this, as you said, we have periods in which matter dominates and, now, dark energy.

So, does the inflaton field still affect us? If so, is there something negating this effect? Or am I misusing the term infinite?

In theories of eternal inflation, inflation is always occurring somewhere - just not around here. The way it works is that once inflation starts somewhere, it ends locally in patches, but other patches are still inflating and producing yet more volume. Then in those new volumes inflation ends in some patches, but in others it's still going and produces even more, etc.
 
sol invictus, thank you very much, that's making sense now. One more question, if you would indulge me. :D Where do these patches of inflation occur, or are they a yet-unobserved prediction of the inflationary model?
 
Get yourself a stress-ball, squeeze it down in your fist, then let go. It would be neat if you could find a black one with little white specks on it. Einstein didn't talk about stress-energy for nothing. And if they'd had stress-balls in his day, he wouldn't have made his greatest blunder.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom