Terra revolving round Sol question

sol invictus, thank you very much, that's making sense now. One more question, if you would indulge me. :D Where do these patches of inflation occur, or are they a yet-unobserved prediction of the inflationary model?

If our universe is undergoing eternal inflation, then the part of the universe we can see is part of a patch that at some point exited from the eternally inflating phase. That patch is surrounded, probably on all sides, by eternally inflating volume.

That volume hasn't been observed, but that could just be because our patch is very large.
 
No, either you spun the top or you stopped it from spinning.
Please explain how a top lying down on a surface can be spinning about it’s central axis. Also explain how an otherwise unsupported top standing on it’s tip can do so without spinning.
 
Please explain how a top lying down on a surface can be spinning about it’s central axis.

The whole surface could be spinning.

Anyway, it's kind of funny how people get this way. I think that we evolved for this slow-moving stuff. So Aristotelian stationary, absolute physics makes a lot of sense. When we learn more, we want it to make sense again. So we insist on these things like inertial, non-rotating frames of reference. Then we get to think, "Ah, I can sort of understand. This is just like a big forest, only with weird time." This works pretty well up through Special Relativity.

Then General Relativity comes along and smacks us in the face and says, "Sucker! You think it gets simple? It doesn't. There are no inertial frames! HAH! You think you are going to get out of solving ten coupled differential equations? Sucks to be you."

At least, though, the compensation is that you get to make the coordinate system whatever the hell you want. You want to see the universe from the point of view of a power ball in the Addams Family pinball machine? Go ahead.
 
The whole surface could be spinning.
It would have to be spinning about the central axis of the top. So would the person that “spun” the top. Why doesn’t this person experience the forces of this spinning and be thrown against the wall of the room by centrifugal force? Same applies to everything else in the room and the entire Universe that would also have to be spinning about the central axis of the top.

What about a second top on the same surface? Can they both be spinning about their own axis and also spinning about the axis of the other? How does the surface spin about the axis of both tops at the same time?
 
It would have to be spinning about the central axis of the top. So would the person that “spun” the top. Why doesn’t this person experience the forces of this spinning and be thrown against the wall of the room by centrifugal force? Same applies to everything else in the room and the entire Universe that would also have to be spinning about the central axis of the top.

What about a second top on the same surface? Can they both be spinning about their own axis and also spinning about the axis of the other? How does the surface spin about the axis of both tops at the same time?

Because, as I said earlier, the top analogy isn't an accurate one. The person, table, room, top, Earth, etc. are all within the same reference frame when the top is at rest. You apply force to it and the top spins for a while, but slows down due to the friction created due to the table and air (both in the Earth's reference frame). The top will feel centrifugal force because it's running into all this other stuff in the Earth's reference frame. The person, table, etc. does not feel this force because they're all in the same reference frame.
 
If our universe is undergoing eternal inflation, then the part of the universe we can see is part of a patch that at some point exited from the eternally inflating phase. That patch is surrounded, probably on all sides, by eternally inflating volume.

That volume hasn't been observed, but that could just be because our patch is very large.

Thanks for the great info! Much appreciated!
 
It would have to be spinning about the central axis of the top. So would the person that “spun” the top. Why doesn’t this person experience the forces of this spinning and be thrown against the wall of the room by centrifugal force?

Who are you to say they aren't? Why did you think their tie was stuck to the window anyway?
 
Because, as I said earlier, the top analogy isn't an accurate one. The person, table, room, top, Earth, etc. are all within the same reference frame when the top is at rest. You apply force to it and the top spins for a while, but slows down due to the friction created due to the table and air (both in the Earth's reference frame). The top will feel centrifugal force because it's running into all this other stuff in the Earth's reference frame. The person, table, etc. does not feel this force because they're all in the same reference frame.
Don’t know what your discussing but I’m discussing the question whether we can know from observation whether a top is spinning about it‘s central axis or not. The top isn’t an analogy it‘s a real thing.
 
Last edited:
Who are you to say they aren't? Why did you think their tie was stuck to the window anyway?
Humour (if that's what it's meant to be) is always good but in this case I would prefer and appreciate a serious answer if you can provide one.
 
Last edited:
It would have to be spinning about the central axis of the top. So would the person that “spun” the top. Why doesn’t this person experience the forces of this spinning and be thrown against the wall of the room by centrifugal force? Same applies to everything else in the room and the entire Universe that would also have to be spinning about the central axis of the top.

What about a second top on the same surface? Can they both be spinning about their own axis and also spinning about the axis of the other? How does the surface spin about the axis of both tops at the same time?

Because the actual laws of motion in the frame with the top at rest are not the same as the laws of motion in the frame where the top is spinning.

a) In the frame where the top is spinning and the ground is at rest, the observer says "the top is spinning, and I'm standing here next to a wall".

b) In the frame where the top is at rest and the ground is spinning, the observer says "the top is at rest, I am standing on the spinning ground, and there's an equivalence-principle-obeying, gravity-like force pulling me inwards so I don't crash into that wall."

If you forget to include the 2nd part---the coordinate-dependent forces---then you're not doing GR, and it's not valid to treat all coordinate systems as equal.
 
(But it's the same thing that happens in "familiar" curved spacetime. Take an astronaut on the space station. He's going around and around the Earth at a rate such that, if you were using the laws of flat space, you'd expect him to be plastered against the back wall of the space station, like a passenger in a fairground ride, by an 9.8g centripetal force. But he's not, for reasons that appear different from different perspectives. An observer in the space station says "Of course I'm not plastered against the wall, I'm sitting still with respect to the wall and obeying Newton's Laws." An observer on the ground says "Of course he's not plastered against the wall, he's being kept away from it by an equivalence-principle-obeying force I will call 'Earth's gravity'".)
 
Because the actual laws of motion in the frame with the top at rest are not the same as the laws of motion in the frame where the top is spinning.
Two different laws of motion apply to the same event at the same time? Different frames have different observational perspectives of the same event but I don’t see how perception anomalies can change the reality of the event (or the actual laws of motion).
a) In the frame where the top is spinning and the ground is at rest, the observer says "the top is spinning, and I'm standing here next to a wall".
b) In the frame where the top is at rest and the ground is spinning, the observer says "the top is at rest, I am standing on the spinning ground, and there's an equivalence-principle-obeying, gravity-like force pulling me inwards so I don't crash into that wall."
If you forget to include the 2nd part---the coordinate-dependent forces---then you're not doing GR, and it's not valid to treat all coordinate systems as equal.
So the laws of motion can be broken but an equivalence principle must be obeyed? Convenience principle?

Where does this "gravity-like force " come from and go to?
 
Last edited:
Two different laws of motion apply to the same event at the same time? Different frames have different observational perspectives of the same event but I don’t see how perception anomalies can change the reality of the event (or the actual laws of motion).

Remember, "the laws of motion" are merely things like "if I know the x,y,z coordinates of the ball at time t=0, what will the x,y,z coordinates be at time t=1". Think of how complicated it is to make the same statement in spherical coordinates---"I know the r, theta, phi of the ball at t=0, what will the r,theta,phi be at t=1?". All we're talking about is your ability to do that with a rotating collection of coordinate labels. Or a distorted collection. Or a time-dependent collection.

The point of this discussion is: there are certain oddities---free-falling objects follow weird paths!---that show up in coordinate systems distorted by gravity. The surprising-ish thing, and the counterintuitive thing, is that exactly the same oddities---free-falling objects follow weird paths!---show up in rotating (or otherwise accelerating) coordinate systems.

The laws of physics are perfectly happy predicting the coordinates of a baseball (Or a photon, or a wave in an atomic clock, or whatever) as it follows a weird path through the familiar distorted coordinate-system we use near Earth. It turns out that the laws of physics are equally happy predicting the coordinates of a baseball (or a photon, or an atomic clock, etc.) if you drop it while sitting on a merry-go-round, using distorted merry-go-round coordinates and all of the centripetal/Coriolis stuff that is attached.

Where does this "gravity-like force " come from and go to?

Where does Newtonian gravity "go" when for an observer in freefall? Nowhere. Newtonian gravity---9.8m/s/s downwards---is something you have to include in your equation-of-motion if your coordinate system is glued down at a fixed radius from the Earth. It's not something you have to include if your coordinate system is inertial. It's a coordinate-system-dependent pseudoforce.
 
Last edited:
Where does Newtonian gravity "go" when for an observer in freefall? Nowhere. Newtonian gravity---9.8m/s/s downwards---is something you have to include in your equation-of-motion if your coordinate system is glued down at a fixed radius from the Earth. It's not something you have to include if your coordinate system is inertial. It's a coordinate-system-dependent pseudoforce.
Gravity (it's not Newton's) doesn't "go" anywhere for an observer in freefall. Merely the ability to "feel" it is "gone". It remains in place and it's force remains fully active as is evident by the falling. That the freefalling observer doesn't experience that force doesn't mean the force has gone away (actually does experience it but does so equally on every atom). I've never been able to understand how or why the ability to observe or experience an event can have any effect on the actual event. Illusions don't make illusion fact.

Given I'm not freefalling toward the top in your a) scenario why don't I experience this equivalence-principle-obeying, gravity-like force pulling me toward the top? So I repeat - Where does this mysterious force come from in b) and where does it go to in a)?
 
Last edited:
The point of this discussion is: there are certain oddities---free-falling objects follow weird paths!---that show up in coordinate systems distorted by gravity. The surprising-ish thing, and the counterintuitive thing, is that exactly the same oddities---free-falling objects follow weird paths!---show up in rotating (or otherwise accelerating) coordinate systems.
I may be derailing this thread but my point of this dicusion is whether or not it can be known whether a thing is spinning or not (specifically a top).
 
Gravity (it's not Newton's) doesn't "go" anywhere for an observer in freefall. Merely the ability to "feel" it is "gone". It remains in place and it's force remains fully active as is evident by the falling.

OK. So now suppose you and Bob are arguing about whether the top is spinning. Bob says it's not. You say it is, and to prove it you say: "And I know I'm in a non-rotating frame, because I do experiments which don't feel any centripetal forces." Bob's reply would sound just like yours above:

Bob as ynot said:
Centripetal forces don't "go" anywhere for an observer in freefall, i.e. in circular an orbit around the centripetal force center. Merely the ability to "feel" centripetal forces is "gone". The centripetal force remains in place and it's force remains fully active as is evident by your trajectory, which is going around and around the stationary top.
 
OK. So now suppose you and Bob are arguing about whether the top is spinning. Bob says it's not. You say it is, and to prove it you say: "And I know I'm in a non-rotating frame, because I do experiments which don't feel any centripetal forces." Bob's reply would sound just like yours above:
But I'm not freefalling toward the top and I'm not doing anything I know of which could or would remove my ability to feel any centripetal forces. We know and can explain why freefall doesn't feel gravity (or isn't aware it does) how would Bob (you) otherwise explain not feeling either centripetal forces or this "gravity-like force"? Also the top is displaying properties of having centripetal forces. How would Bob (you) explain it's ability to stand on it's point if it wasn't spinning?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom