Terra revolving round Sol question

There's a difference between mapping and modeling. No one is modeling a geocentric universe, because the idea is stupid--we're demonstrably not the center of our own solar system, let alone galaxy, let alone the universe. They MAP the universe based on Earth at the center, sure; but again, mapping isn't modeling.
I don't see any difference that's applicable here.

Yes, if you add epicycles in an ad hoc way to match the observations, that's theoretically quite alarming, though it might have some practical value. On the other hand, if you have a mathematical mechanism that that predicts exactly what epicycles are to be added, then it is that mechanism that's a law of nature. There isn't any particular problem with it, and it creates a model that's geocentric.

The latter sort of situation, as sol invictus notes, is analogous to GTR. So the problematic issue is not whether you have a geocentric model, but how that model came to be.
 
Are there physicists who concentrate on modeling the universe in this way? It seems like it could lead to some breakthrough trying to look at the universe from this frame. Or maybe not.

It was modeled in this way before Copernicus pointed out that putting the sun at the center (and using simple circular orbits) made a lot of the computations much simpler to perform. At that point, they were doing three level epicyles (circular motions compounded upon circular motions) in order to approximate the truly elliptical orbits. It wasn't until Kepler that calculations of sun-centered models became more accurate than the earth-centered epicycles, though.

In Ptolomy's computations, epicycles absorbed two sources of computational complexity: the fact that orbits went retrograde and near retrograde (which is a relativistic problem) and the insistence on circular rather than elliptical orbits, which was an error-in-fact. Copernicus and Galileo eliminated the first reason, and Kepler the second.
 
Last edited:
General relativity, our current best theory of gravity and a massive conceptual advance (one that has still not been fully appreciated by most people) allows us to choose any coordinate system we like. Its predictions for all physical experiments are independent of coordinate choice, and - unlike in Newtonian theories - there is nothing that prefers one coordinate system over another apart from convenience. There are no inertial frames, and all gravitational "forces" are "fictitious" in the sense of Newton.... etc...

Great post, clear and concise.
 
General relativity, our current best theory of gravity and a massive conceptual advance (one that has still not been fully appreciated by most people) allows us to choose any coordinate system we like. Its predictions for all physical experiments are independent of coordinate choice, and - unlike in Newtonian theories - there is nothing that prefers one coordinate system over another apart from convenience. There are no inertial frames, and all gravitational "forces" are "fictitious" in the sense of Newton.

As a result, you're perfectly free to choose coordinates in which the sun goes around the earth, or in which the earth isn't rotating and all the stars go around it once/24 hours. Do those coordinates "require many novel forces and assumptions"? Nope, not in the slightest - no assumptions are necessary, nor are there any new forces. Are they more complex? Not really - calculations can be done in whatever coordinates are the most convenient, and the results transformed to any other, so on that basis it's very hard to argue that one set of coordinates are more complex than another.

But come on - doesn't the earth really go around the sun? Well, people used to think that there was an absolute rest frame, and really things at rest with respect to the earth and air where at rest. Galileo and Newton overturned that notion by making it clear that "at rest" is a meaningless statement, one that only has relative meaning. General relativity to a large degree overturned even the notion that acceleration or rotation is absolute, because it allows one to use any coordinates whatsoever, and proves that all physical predictions are unchanged.

:sefrown:
 
My friend and I are sitting in chairs facing each other. Our chairs are on a very large spinning disk. The background is black and the only lights present are flashlights that we shine on our face (so we can see each other). One of our chairs is placed on the outer edge of the disk, the other in the center. Each of us has a watch that were originally perfectly synchronized.

Can we tell which one of us is sitting in the center chair and which is sitting in the outer chair, i.e. who is orbiting whom?
 
The above can also be expanded to include a simple Newtonian conservation law. What forces (aside from gravity) and/or pseudo-forces are involved in the scenario?
 
But come on - doesn't the earth really go around the sun?

Aside from being able to model it both ways*, don't we "know" that the Earth goes around the Sun because of how the Earth (and the Sun) formed**?


*Since there are of course more, both ways in my question are A: Sun goes around a point closest to or inside of Earth and B: Earth goes around a point closest to or inside of the Sun.

**The protoplanetary disk.
 
Aside from being able to model it both ways*, don't we "know" that the Earth goes around the Sun because of how the Earth (and the Sun) formed**?


*Since there are of course more, both ways in my question are A: Sun goes around a point closest to or inside of Earth and B: Earth goes around a point closest to or inside of the Sun.

**The protoplanetary disk.

Pick a coordinate system in which the coordinate-origin is 1AU from the center-of-mass of our protoplanetary cloud. Further specify the coordinate system such that the center-of-mass is moving in the "theta" direction at 2pi radians per 24 hours.

Work out the laws of physics in this coordinate system. Those laws (messy though they are) work out to describe the formation of a star (not at the origin), of a disk (not at the origin), of planets, etc.. And these laws of physics, complicated and Coriolis-choked though they are, correctly describe the eventual migration of a small rocky planet called "Earth" to the coordinate origin, where it eventually slows its theta-rotation until it's actually at rest with respect to the coordinates.

That description of things is exactly as real as any other, differing only in the coordinate labeling convention.
 
Pick a coordinate system in which the coordinate-origin is 1AU from the center-of-mass of our protoplanetary cloud. Further specify the coordinate system such that the center-of-mass is moving in the "theta" direction at 2pi radians per 24 hours.

Work out the laws of physics in this coordinate system. Those laws (messy though they are) work out to describe the formation of a star (not at the origin), of a disk (not at the origin), of planets, etc.. And these laws of physics, complicated and Coriolis-choked though they are, correctly describe the eventual migration of a small rocky planet called "Earth" to the coordinate origin, where it eventually slows its theta-rotation until it's actually at rest with respect to the coordinates.

That description of things is exactly as real as any other, differing only in the coordinate labeling convention.

I assume you are suggesting a collision of either 2 solar systems, or 2 protoplanetary disks?

If so, wouldn't there be evidence of that?

Whatever your answer is, let us now assume in my hypothetical that we have evidence that the Earth and the Sun were formed from the same protoplanetary disk with no interference.

In that case we would know that the "Earth revolves around the Sun model" is the correct one, no?
 
Aside from being able to model it both ways*, don't we "know" that the Earth goes around the Sun because of how the Earth (and the Sun) formed**?

Sol is right, but let me take a different perspective. If we go far away from the sun and the earth (our only two objects in the universe), and sit in a locally inertial reference frame, then in that frame the earth and sun are orbiting around their common center of mass, which is well inside the sun and only slightly offset from the sun's center of mass.

Now, there is no theoretical reason to view this reference as superior to any other reference frame. But that doesn't mean that it's not advantageous to do so. In particular, this reference frame is easier to intuitively grasp than many other available reference frames because it essentially mimics the Newtonian answer. I don't think there's anything wrong with preferring a Newtonian-like reference frame when such a frame is available (as it is here), even if that preference has no fundamental significance.
 
I assume you are suggesting a collision of either 2 solar systems, or 2 protoplanetary disks?

No, not at all. What makes you say that? I'm saying that, because the laws of physics (including the laws of protoplanetary disks) don't care what coordinates they are written in, they can be written in a coordinate system in which the physical-center-of-mass is moving around and around and around the origin. One such choice of coordinate system is the one where the modern Earth happens to appear "at rest".
 
No, not at all. What makes you say that? I'm saying that, because the laws of physics (including the laws of protoplanetary disks) don't care what coordinates they are written in, they can be written in a coordinate system in which the physical-center-of-mass is moving around and around and around the origin. One such choice of coordinate system is the one where the modern Earth happens to appear "at rest".

OK, now I am confused (or more confused :D).

I thought that in a protoplanetary disc the star forms at the center and the planets form around it, coalescing from a disc?

Since (at least in the early stages) the entire disc spins as a whole, I don't see how the center can be anything but the center...

Also, you replied to the first part of my post but not the second....
 
Last edited:
I thought that in a protoplanetary disc the star forms at the center and the planets form around it, coalescing from a disc?

I thought that at a bus stop the bus moves to (and from) the stop. The stop doesn't move toward (and away from) the bus.

Except it depends on your coordinate system.
 
I thought that at a bus stop the bus moves to (and from) the stop. The stop doesn't move toward (and away from) the bus.

Except it depends on your coordinate system.

That would be an apt analogy if the disc did not form into individual planets.

We are discussing one of the planets left over from the disc section. Versus the center of the disc, which stays being the center and does not break up like the disc did.
 
That would be an apt analogy if the disc did not form into individual planets.

We are discussing one of the planets left over from the disc section. Versus the center of the disc, which stays being the center and does not break up like the disc did.

It's only an analogy. I think ben m's post is pretty clear, but I was just trying to offer something to help you see it more clearly on a re-read.

There is a coordinate system in which the earth (today) is at rest and the sun is revolving around it. If we look back in time we can use that coordinate system to model the early solar system (though it will be very messy).

No coordinate system is more real than any other: they all make the same predictions about experiments. They all capture the actual behavior of the objects involved. Anything else is metaphysics.
 
There is a coordinate system in which the earth (today) is at rest and the sun is revolving around it. If we look back in time we can use that coordinate system to model the early solar system (though it will be very messy).

No coordinate system is more real than any other: they all make the same predictions about experiments. They all capture the actual behavior of the objects involved. Anything else is metaphysics.

OK, I agree with that. There are multiple models and they are all just as valid. What I am proposing is beyond that.

That is, that it is possible for real world evidence to be found which can exclude one of the otherwise very legitimate models.
 
Last edited:
Again to clairify.

In my hypothetical, proof is found that the Earth came from the disc section, and the Sun came from the center section, both from the same protoplanetary disc. With no outside interference.

In that case, even though other models are technically just as valid, we would know the the Earth revolves around the Sun as opposed to the other way around.

We would know that because, in this hypothetical, the Earth came from the disc section, which by it's very nature forms around the center. Most importantly because the disc starts out as a whole and ends up breaking apart, while the center always remains the center. Therefore a product from the disc section cannot be the center, otherwise it wouldn't have been from the disc section.
 
Last edited:
...No coordinate system is more real than any other: they all make the same predictions about experiments. They all capture the actual behavior of the objects involved. Anything else is metaphysics.
No coordinate system is real at all. The objects are real, along with their motion.

Roboramma said:
I thought that at a bus stop the bus moves to (and from) the stop. The stop doesn't move toward (and away from) the bus.
We say it's the bus moving because we feel the acceleration as it starts and stops. You don't feel yourself leaning as the bus draws up to your stop.

I sincerely hope that nobody here is trying to peddle woo by suggesting that the sun goes round the earth is just as valid as the earth goes round the sun. It isn't. One coordinate system is as valid as another, just as one map is as valid as another. But the map is not the territory. A coordinate system is not real. An object does not "move in a coordinate system". It moves relative to other things in the universe, and in the end it moves relative to the universe itself.
 
My friend and I are sitting in chairs facing each other. Our chairs are on a very large spinning disk. The background is black and the only lights present are flashlights that we shine on our face (so we can see each other). One of our chairs is placed on the outer edge of the disk, the other in the center. Each of us has a watch that were originally perfectly synchronized.

Can we tell which one of us is sitting in the center chair and which is sitting in the outer chair, i.e. who is orbiting whom?

It's hard to answer your question, because it's hard to know what you mean by "spinning". Let me explain.

If your disk, the chairs, and you and your friend are the only things in the universe, and by "spinning" you mean rotating with respect to inertial coordinates far away from the disk, then yes, of course you can tell. One of you will feel pressed back in your chair, and one will not.

But suppose instead the entire disk is inside a huge, spherical shell of matter. Further, suppose that shell is rotating with respect to an inertial frame far outside it. In that case, if your disk rotates with the shell, you may not be able to tell.

The above can also be expanded to include a simple Newtonian conservation law. What forces (aside from gravity) and/or pseudo-forces are involved in the scenario?

I don't understand your question.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom