Terra revolving round Sol question

Perpetual Student, perhaps part of the problem is the difference between:

a) "A coordinate system in which the top happens to be at rest" and
b) "A coordinate system glued to the top, with its Z-axis along the top's handle and its x-axis aligned with this particular spot of paint."

The former is the sort of thing GR normally talks about. (It can handle the latter, sort of, but, ugh.) You describe "I know I spun up the top". Well, in coordinate system (a), you started out with a spinning top on a spinning table, and a spinning person reached over and stopped the top from spinning. That can happen, right? If you went to the North Pole, sat down, and started playing with a very slow top, that's exactly what an outside observer would see. "A spinning top on a spinning planet, then the spinning person set it down and made it stop."

(system (b) changes with time. "for t<0 we choose one coordinate system, and at t=0, PS exerted a force on the top, and for t >0 we transform to a different system", such that the top is "at rest" both before and after you exert the force. This is a mess.)

Let me translate your "I know I spun the top" to another system, see if your intuition does something different. We're hovering in outer space watching a soccer ball fly away from us. I tell you that SR allows me to treat this soccer ball as being at rest. You just define a set of coordinates that are moving along with the ball, and in those coordinates we're moving away from the ball, right?



Does that help?

Very challenging comments. Thinking...
 
I misspoke earlier in the thread.

I did not mean that real world evidence makes other models physically invalid.

I only meant that it is possible to have real world evidence that shows which, of a certain set of perfectly valid physical models, is the one occurring in reality. That does not make the other models any less physically valid.
 
WhatRoughBeast, that's really awesome! I didn't think there was enough mass outside of the sun to move the COM that much. Thanks for the info!
 
WhatRoughBeast, that's really awesome! I didn't think there was enough mass outside of the sun to move the COM that much. Thanks for the info!

De nada. And, just as a bonus, when you add the fact that earth's orbit is elliptical rather than circular, if counter-earth existed it would sometimes be visible. Since no such observation has occurred, this directly disproves the counter-earth myth.
 
If it was already spinning it would “stand”. If it was then stopped it wouldn’t “stand”. That it wasn’t standing initially and was after seems pretty conclusive evidence that it wasn’t previously spinning and now is.

That's your item (1), not your item (2), which is what I was responding to.
 
If it was already spinning it would “stand”. If it was then stopped it wouldn’t “stand”. That it wasn’t standing initially and was after seems pretty conclusive evidence that it wasn’t previously spinning and now is.

Spinning relative to what? Standing relative to what? Relative to the CMB, the top is performing all sorts of fantastical gyrations, regardless of whether it's standing relative to the tabletop, or spinning relative to you.

It seems like all these examples actually boil down to, "first, pick an arbitrary frame of reference, then describe the history of an arbitrary object subject to arbitrary forces, relative to that arbitrary frame of reference."

We don't know that the top is spinning. We think of it as spinning because we've already selected an arbitrary frame of reference in which it is convenient to think of the top as spinning.
 
I conclude that the top is spinning for two obvious reasons . . .

(1) A spinning top “stands” a non-spinning top doesn’t. You don’t have to remember you spun it to know it’s spinning.

(2) Either you spun the top or you spun the entire Universe. Pick the only one we know to be possible.

I would like to point out that my case was not what I will call #2a, which I believe is just Occam's razor; but #2b which is that it is possible to have real world evidence that has the ability to exclude certain particular models from being one of the possible ones that is occurring in reality. Not that it excludes it from being a valid physical model.
 
Last edited:
I have a new question (or a new wrinkle to the question).

First of all we are referring to the interesting model that appears when you have the Earth be the center and the Sun orbiting it (the Earth).

I assume that it is just as complicated, but not much more, to have the Earth be the center and the black hole from the center of our galaxy orbiting it (the Earth). (Or perhaps I should replace the Earth with the Sun in this scenario to make it even more like the Earth/Sun model from Page 1...)

My question is, how much more complicated would a model be that has the Earth at the center and a black hole from the center of another galaxy orbiting it (the Earth). I.E. objects from separate galaxies.

Or perhaps even even more complicated, the Earth is the center and a star from another galaxy is orbiting it?

Is this even possible since galaxies don't really normally orbit each other (or anything?)?

Even if it is possible, I assume the black hole at the center of our galaxy would make both of those models very complicated?

Instead of just Star - Planet - Moon you would have: other galaxy - black hole from the center of our galaxy - star - planet - moon.
 
I just realized typing that post that typing out "the black hole at the center of our galaxy" is really annoying to type out! :D

So I googled it to try and find the correct name.... Is it called Sagittarius A?
 
...Even if it is possible, I assume the black hole at the center of our galaxy would make both of those models very complicated? ...
Sure. They'd be perversely complicated. And we know quite enough about general relativity and gravity and cosmology to know that in this real universe, the little things go round the big things. And the big things go round the even bigger things. Et cetera. Anybody who tries to suggest to you that GR says otherwise is talking bollocks.
 
I just realized typing that post that typing out "the black hole at the center of our galaxy" is really annoying to type out! :D

So I googled it to try and find the correct name.... Is it called Sagittarius A?

I think Sagittarius A* is slightly better. Sgr A* is one part of Sgr A.
 
I only meant that it is possible to have real world evidence that shows which, of a certain set of perfectly valid physical models, is the one occurring in reality.
I understand that this is tricky, but what you said here doesn't actually mean anything.
Some phenomenon occurs in reality, and we can model it in any number of ways. If we do the modelling correctly these ways are all equivalent; none of them can be said to be more true, or to be the one occurring in reality, because they all describe the occurring phenomenon with the exact same accuracy.
 
I understand that this is tricky, but what you said here doesn't actually mean anything.
Some phenomenon occurs in reality, and we can model it in any number of ways. If we do the modelling correctly these ways are all equivalent; none of them can be said to be more true, or to be the one occurring in reality, because they all describe the occurring phenomenon with the exact same accuracy.

I'm going to have to disagree.

I'm sorry if I gave the impression that we are determining "the one occurring in reality". What I am proposing is excluding perfectly valid models after real world evidence is gathered.

In certain situations, if you are choosing between a specific number of perfectly valid models you can use real world evidence to exclude any number of them from actually being a contender for one that is occurring in reality as we know it.

That is not the same thing as saying that any particular model is definitely the correct one or even the only correct one. I'm talking about excluding models that are otherwise valid because of evidence that is gathered.

So if we are discussing two perfectly valid models of the same objects, and one of the models has legitimate real world problems, it can be excluded in favor of the other. There's no reason to ignore evidence and history about any particular situation.
 
I'm going to have to disagree.

I'm sorry if I gave the impression that we are determining "the one occurring in reality". What I am proposing is excluding perfectly valid models after real world evidence is gathered.

In certain situations, if you are choosing between a specific number of perfectly valid models you can use real world evidence to exclude any number of them from actually being a contender for one that is occurring in reality as we know it.
This assertion is internally inconsistent. If the models are all perfectly valid, then they all have the exact same predictive power, and will predict the exact same outcome.
In fact, we're discussing different formulations of one single model. It is impossible to say which of these formulations describe the real occurrence best, because the descriptions are exactly equivalent.

That is not the same thing as saying that any particular model is definitely the correct one or even the only correct one. I'm talking about excluding models that are otherwise valid because of evidence that is gathered.
And I'm telling you that this is not something that is logically possible.
It's like trying to gather evidence to decide the question whether I am sitting under a tree, or if the tree is standing over me.

So if we are discussing two perfectly valid models of the same objects, and one of the models has legitimate real world problems, it can be excluded in favor of the other. There's no reason to ignore evidence and history about any particular situation.
Yes, so now consider this: Not only are they not two models, but neither formulation of the one model can possibly have "legitimate real world problems" that the other doesn't, because they both predict the exact same outcomes for any given input.
 
Last edited:
This assertion is internally inconsistent. If the models are all perfectly valid, then they all have the exact same predictive power, and will predict the exact same outcome.

I'm sorry but that is where we disagree.

The models can all be perfectly valid in a physics sense. Real world evidence and context information can then exclude one of the models.

I have a feeling you are just going to repeat yourself again, and then I will have to repeat myself. So be it.

And I'm telling you that this is not something that is logically possible.

Then you must not be understanding what I am saying at all. I'm sorry.

Models can accurately describe a situation. That does not mean you cannot then apply evidence and context information to exclude one of them.
 
OTT, because ben m said it so much better than I'm likely to, I'd like to highlight this bit from upthread and ask you to respond to it:

Let me translate your "I know I spun the top" to another system, see if your intuition does something different. We're hovering in outer space watching a soccer ball fly away from us. I tell you that SR allows me to treat this soccer ball as being at rest. You just define a set of coordinates that are moving along with the ball, and in those coordinates we're moving away from the ball, right?
modified PS said:
On the other hand we have our knowledge of history: I used to have the ball at rest, then I kicked it, so it's really moving. The ball was really in my hand a minute ago, and the only force that acted on it was that of my kick, so I know how much the ball accelerated. So SR may very well give us the powerful tool of looking at it from any frame of reference but is incapable of telling us anything about that history and so it cannot tell us what is actually currently happening.

Would you say that your viewpoint is in agreement with the "modified PS" quote in there?
 
We would know that because, in this hypothetical, the Earth came from the disc section, which by it's very nature forms around the center. Most importantly because the disc starts out as a whole and ends up breaking apart, while the center always remains the center. Therefore a product from the disc section cannot be the center, otherwise it wouldn't have been from the disc section.

This assumes the center of the disk cannot rotate around a point near its edge. That isn't the case.


Since we aren't talking about the center of any old disk, and we are in fact talking about a protoplanetary disk, correct me if I am wrong, but are you proposing that a protoplanetary disk can rotate around a point that is not the nebula??
 
I'm sorry but that is where we disagree.

The models can all be perfectly valid in a physics sense. Real world evidence and context information can then exclude one of the models.

I have a feeling you are just going to repeat yourself again, and then I will have to repeat myself. So be it.



Then you must not be understanding what I am saying at all. I'm sorry.

Models can accurately describe a situation. That does not mean you cannot then apply evidence and context information to exclude one of them.
In my world, that's exactly what that means*, but since you seem convinced that it doesn't, I'd be curious about an example.
For instance what kind of evidence or context would be needed to decide whether I'm sitting under a tree, or the tree is standing over me?

*Unless convenience is the "context information" you're talking about, because then we completely agree.
 
Would you say that your viewpoint is in agreement with the "modified PS" quote in there?


That is exactly the problem I am talking about. There is no reason for us to exclude evidence, historical information, and context. That is one of the benefits of being a sentient species.
 
For instance what kind of evidence or context would be needed to decide whether I'm sitting under a tree, or the tree is standing over me?

I can only say that that is a very poor analogy to what we are discussing? It doesn't even make sense.

Perhaps form an analogy where you knock the tree over.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom