Perpetual Student
Illuminator
- Joined
- Jul 8, 2008
- Messages
- 4,852
Perpetual Student, perhaps part of the problem is the difference between:
a) "A coordinate system in which the top happens to be at rest" and
b) "A coordinate system glued to the top, with its Z-axis along the top's handle and its x-axis aligned with this particular spot of paint."
The former is the sort of thing GR normally talks about. (It can handle the latter, sort of, but, ugh.) You describe "I know I spun up the top". Well, in coordinate system (a), you started out with a spinning top on a spinning table, and a spinning person reached over and stopped the top from spinning. That can happen, right? If you went to the North Pole, sat down, and started playing with a very slow top, that's exactly what an outside observer would see. "A spinning top on a spinning planet, then the spinning person set it down and made it stop."
(system (b) changes with time. "for t<0 we choose one coordinate system, and at t=0, PS exerted a force on the top, and for t >0 we transform to a different system", such that the top is "at rest" both before and after you exert the force. This is a mess.)
Let me translate your "I know I spun the top" to another system, see if your intuition does something different. We're hovering in outer space watching a soccer ball fly away from us. I tell you that SR allows me to treat this soccer ball as being at rest. You just define a set of coordinates that are moving along with the ball, and in those coordinates we're moving away from the ball, right?
Does that help?
Very challenging comments. Thinking...