Terra revolving round Sol question

We would know that because, in this hypothetical, the Earth came from the disc section, which by it's very nature forms around the center. Most importantly because the disc starts out as a whole and ends up breaking apart, while the center always remains the center. Therefore a product from the disc section cannot be the center, otherwise it wouldn't have been from the disc section.

This assumes the center of the disk cannot rotate around a point near its edge. That isn't the case.
 
Again to clairify.

In my hypothetical, proof is found that the Earth came from the disc section, and the Sun came from the center section, both from the same protoplanetary disc. With no outside interference.

It seems you're describing a very simple solar system and that's where the confusion lies. In this example, both the planet and star comprise a bound system whose center of gravity lies nearly at the center of mass of the star. But think of a binary system and you'll begin to see the problem with this scenario. Two stars of relatively similar mass (compared with the planetary objects) will have a center of gravity close to the center of these stars (with minor variation due to massive planets). So, in this case, which star is rotating around which? It's still a bound system, like the single-star system in your example, but its center of gravity isn't near the center of mass of the star.

Hopefully that makes some sense. Essentially, in a bound system, all objects are rotating around a common center of gravity. In a single-star system, it appears that the star is the center, but it too is orbiting around the center of gravity and, to be accurate, the Earth is still not rotating around the sun, but the center of gravity. Of course, for practical reasons and because the center of gravity is very nearly the center of mass of the star, one can say the Earth is orbiting the sun.
 
If the Earth were the only thing in the universe you could determine it was rotating.
 
If the Earth were the only thing in the universe you could determine it was rotating.

Assuming gravity gradients aren't really large at your location, you can always do an experiment and find a locally inertial frame. Something not rotating in that frame won't experience "fictitious forces"; it won't feel centrifugal stress for example. So it can be said to be "not rotating".

Most of the subtlety here arises because

(a) A rotating shell with very, very large radius can change the state of rotation of the locally inertial frames inside it. Similarly, two things each of which is "not rotating" by the above definition can be rotating with respect to each other.

(b) You are always perfectly free to use "rotating coordinates", in which a rotating object is static. Of course the presence or absence of centrifugal stresses is independent of coordinate choice (it's a real physical effect, so it had better be), but see (a).
 
Last edited:
This has been debated again and again on many threads here. For example: General Relativity. I'm not sure there exists a real final answer given our current tools and understanding -- but I hope I'm wrong!

1. On the one hand, we have GR totalitarianism, which holds that any sense we have of some notion of reality involving rotation -- like the earth actually does revolve around the sun or there is a top really spinning on my table -- is an illusion. All frames are equal; there is no real frame of reference to tell us what rotates or revolves around what -- according to this doctrine.

2. On the other hand we have our knowledge of history: I spun the top on my table so it is really spinning; the earth sun system was formed from a primordial cloud as described above, so the earth is really revolving around the sun. So GR may very well give us the powerful tool of looking at it from any frame of reference but is incapable of telling us anything about that history and so it cannot tell us what is actually currently happening.

I have been told by some here that option 2 above is wrong and that the key is in understanding the mathematics of GR. Maybe so and maybe not -- I'm working on it.
 
Last edited:
This has been debated again and again on many threads here. For example: General Relativity. I'm not sure there exists a real final answer given our current tools and understanding -- but I hope I'm wrong!

1. On the one hand, we have GR totalitarianism, which holds that any sense we have of some notion of reality involving rotation -- like the earth actually does revolve around the sun or there is a top really spinning on my table -- is an illusion. All frames are equal; there is no real frame of reference to tell us what rotates or revolves around what -- according to this doctrine.

2. On the other hand we have our knowledge of history: I spun the top on my table so it is really spinning; the earth sun system was formed from a primordial cloud as described above, so the earth is really revolving around the sun. So GR may very well give us the powerful tool of looking at it from any frame of reference but is incapable of telling us anything about that history and so it cannot tell us what is actually currently happening.

I have been told by some here that option 2 above is wrong and that the key is in understanding the mathematics of GR. Maybe so and maybe not -- I'm working on it.
I conclude that the top is spinning for two obvious reasons . . .

(1) A spinning top “stands” a non-spinning top doesn’t. You don’t have to remember you spun it to know it’s spinning.

(2) Either you spun the top or you spun the entire Universe. Pick the only one we know to be possible.
 
Perpetual Student, #2 is indeed incorrect. Or, at least, it's not as accurate as #1. The Earth is not revolving around the sun, but both the Earth and sun are revolving around a common center of gravity (along with all the other planets, asteroids, etc.). Because this center of gravity is within the mass of the sun, it's practical to say that the planets orbit the sun, though it is theoretically incorrect.

To put it concisely, the center of gravity around which other massive objects orbit is not necessarily the center of a star's mass. This is made clear when discussing multi-star systems, whose masses also share a common history. In a multi-star system, even though everything within that system condensed from the same nebula, the planets and other stars do not orbit a central star, but a point somewhere between the stars (because stars have the majority of the mass within a system).

So history doesn't determine that the Earth revolves around the sun, just as history wouldn't be able to determine which star of a multi-star system a planet orbits. It's not orbiting a star at all... it's orbiting their common center of gravity. It's merely coincidence that the center of gravity in a single-star system is very nearly the center of mass of the star.
 
The spinning top isn't a great analogy. Namely, the rotation of the top is slowed by forces that wouldn't affect massive objects like planets and stars; forces that exist within the frame of reference of the Earth and the top-spinner. If the top were spinning out in space, with or without the knowledge of who put it there, the frame of reference for the top would be equally as valid as any other frame of reference. Knowing the history of the object is an entirely separate question.
 
Perpetual Student, #2 is indeed incorrect. Or, at least, it's not as accurate as #1. The Earth is not revolving around the sun, but both the Earth and sun are revolving around a common center of gravity (along with all the other planets, asteroids, etc.). Because this center of gravity is within the mass of the sun, it's practical to say that the planets orbit the sun, though it is theoretically incorrect.

To put it concisely, the center of gravity around which other massive objects orbit is not necessarily the center of a star's mass. This is made clear when discussing multi-star systems, whose masses also share a common history. In a multi-star system, even though everything within that system condensed from the same nebula, the planets and other stars do not orbit a central star, but a point somewhere between the stars (because stars have the majority of the mass within a system).

So history doesn't determine that the Earth revolves around the sun, just as history wouldn't be able to determine which star of a multi-star system a planet orbits. It's not orbiting a star at all... it's orbiting their common center of gravity. It's merely coincidence that the center of gravity in a single-star system is very nearly the center of mass of the star.
Are you claiming that the gravity of the Sun has nothing to do with the mass of the Sun? If the Sun disappeared are you claiming the gravity would remain? Are you serious?
 
Last edited:
The spinning top isn't a great analogy. Namely, the rotation of the top is slowed by forces that wouldn't affect massive objects like planets and stars; forces that exist within the frame of reference of the Earth and the top-spinner. If the top were spinning out in space, with or without the knowledge of who put it there, the frame of reference for the top would be equally as valid as any other frame of reference. Knowing the history of the object is an entirely separate question.
Nobody tell the Space Station and all the satellites orbiting Earth that gyroscopes don’t work in space.
 
Are you claiming that the gravity of the Sun has nothing to do with the mass of the Sun?

No, not at all. Mass is the reason for gravity.

If the Sun disappeared are you claiming the gravity would remain? Are you serious?

Some gravity would remain because there are other massive objects in the solar system, but the sun is such a large object compared to these others that removing the sun would remove most of the gravity we experience. It's important that you consider all of the mass within a bound system for its net gravitational force though, and that's why it's "merely coincidence that the center of gravity in a single-star system is very nearly the center of mass of the star."

Nobody tell the Space Station and all the satellites orbiting Earth that gyroscopes don’t work in space.

Either your reading comprehension isn't that great, or you're just looking for an argument.
 
Perpetual Student, #2 is indeed incorrect. Or, at least, it's not as accurate as #1. The Earth is not revolving around the sun, but both the Earth and sun are revolving around a common center of gravity (along with all the other planets, asteroids, etc.). Because this center of gravity is within the mass of the sun, it's practical to say that the planets orbit the sun, though it is theoretically incorrect.

To put it concisely, the center of gravity around which other massive objects orbit is not necessarily the center of a star's mass. This is made clear when discussing multi-star systems, whose masses also share a common history. In a multi-star system, even though everything within that system condensed from the same nebula, the planets and other stars do not orbit a central star, but a point somewhere between the stars (because stars have the majority of the mass within a system).

So history doesn't determine that the Earth revolves around the sun, just as history wouldn't be able to determine which star of a multi-star system a planet orbits. It's not orbiting a star at all... it's orbiting their common center of gravity. It's merely coincidence that the center of gravity in a single-star system is very nearly the center of mass of the star.
Everyone one here knows about rotation about the center of gravity -- using the sun as the center is merely a simplification for discussion purposes. You missed the point entirely. Under GR, it is claimed that "(your comment) In a multi-star system, even though everything within that system condensed from the same nebula, the planets and other stars do not orbit a central star, but a point somewhere between the stars (because stars have the majority of the mass within a system)." is also not a description of reality. Any frame other than the center of gravity is equally valid as a frame of reference.
 
Perpetual Student, perhaps part of the problem is the difference between:

a) "A coordinate system in which the top happens to be at rest" and
b) "A coordinate system glued to the top, with its Z-axis along the top's handle and its x-axis aligned with this particular spot of paint."

The former is the sort of thing GR normally talks about. (It can handle the latter, sort of, but, ugh.) You describe "I know I spun up the top". Well, in coordinate system (a), you started out with a spinning top on a spinning table, and a spinning person reached over and stopped the top from spinning. That can happen, right? If you went to the North Pole, sat down, and started playing with a very slow top, that's exactly what an outside observer would see. "A spinning top on a spinning planet, then the spinning person set it down and made it stop."

(system (b) changes with time. "for t<0 we choose one coordinate system, and at t=0, PS exerted a force on the top, and for t >0 we transform to a different system", such that the top is "at rest" both before and after you exert the force. This is a mess.)

Let me translate your "I know I spun the top" to another system, see if your intuition does something different. We're hovering in outer space watching a soccer ball fly away from us. I tell you that SR allows me to treat this soccer ball as being at rest. You just define a set of coordinates that are moving along with the ball, and in those coordinates we're moving away from the ball, right?

modified PS said:
On the other hand we have our knowledge of history: I used to have the ball at rest, then I kicked it, so it's really moving. The ball was really in my hand a minute ago, and the only force that acted on it was that of my kick, so I know how much the ball accelerated. So SR may very well give us the powerful tool of looking at it from any frame of reference but is incapable of telling us anything about that history and so it cannot tell us what is actually currently happening.

Does that help?
 
Last edited:
Perpetual Student, I've apparently missed the point again. And I also don't see how my quoted statement contradicts the fact that any frame of reference is as valid as the next. Could you elaborate?
 
This has been debated again and again on many threads here.
...
2. On the other hand we have our knowledge of history: I spun the top on my table so it is really spinning

We have indeed discussed this many times, and many times I've tried to explain to you that causality has absolutely nothing to do with this. Changing to a rotating frame is not in any way, shape, or form equivalent to physically rotating the entire universe. They are two distinct and different things.

Let me translate your "I know I spun the top" to another system, see if your intuition does something different. We're hovering in outer space watching a soccer ball fly away from us...

I've tried a very similar argument several times, to no avail. But PS has been studying GR (and I think you're better at explaining these things), so perhaps that will work.

I conclude that the top is spinning for two obvious reasons . . .

(1) A spinning top “stands” a non-spinning top doesn’t. You don’t have to remember you spun it to know it’s spinning.

That indeed tells you that the top is spinning with respect to the local inertial frame. What it doesn't tell you is whether it's spinning with respect to another top somewhere else that won't stand up.

(2) Either you spun the top or you spun the entire Universe.

No, either you spun the top or you stopped it from spinning.
 
No, not at all. Mass is the reason for gravity.
So why do you say it’s a “coincidence” that the centre of gravity of the solar system is near the centre of the greatest mass in the solar system (Sun = more than 99.8%)?
Some gravity would remain because there are other massive objects in the solar system, but the sun is such a large object compared to these others that removing the sun would remove most of the gravity we experience. It's important that you consider all of the mass within a bound system for its net gravitational force though, and that's why it's "merely coincidence that the center of gravity in a single-star system is very nearly the center of mass of the star.".
The Sun and Earth both have independent mass that creates independent gravity. If the Sun disappeared the Earth would retain it’s gravity but would tend to travel in a straight path rather than circular. Without the Sun the solar system wouldn’t be a “bound system”.
Either your reading comprehension isn't that great, or you're just looking for an argument.
I’m looking for clarification and understanding. I’m happy to argue in the form of debate in the process.
 
Last edited:
ynot, I agree with everything you've just said. What I mean by "coincidence" is that all the massive objects are orbiting the center of gravity, not any particular massive object.
 
ynot, I agree with everything you've just said. What I mean by "coincidence" is that all the massive objects are orbiting the center of gravity, not any particular massive object.
Seems an inappropriate use of the word to me. Are you saying the Solar System has a discrete centre of gravity that the Sun orbits?
 
No, either you spun the top or you stopped it from spinning.
If it was already spinning it would “stand”. If it was then stopped it wouldn’t “stand”. That it wasn’t standing initially and was after seems pretty conclusive evidence that it wasn’t previously spinning and now is.
 
Perpetual The Earth is not revolving around the sun, but both the Earth and sun are revolving around a common center of gravity (along with all the other planets, asteroids, etc.). Because this center of gravity is within the mass of the sun, it's practical to say that the planets orbit the sun, though it is theoretically incorrect.

Actually, the center of mass of the solar system lies outside the surface of the sun a majority of the time, at least durning the current time period. Depending on the alignment of the planets, primarily Jupiter and Saturn, the seperation between the center of mass of the sun and the COM of the solar system varies from about .134 solar radii to 1.98. During the 21st cetury the solar system COM will lie outside the sun about 63% of the time.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom