Surprising Developements

There are several issues here.

I don't need to do your homework for you. If you want to see the research on leeches, nobody will stop you. There is a lot of it, but if you won't accept the results, what can anyone do?

Way to go, the support my claims of use yourself arguement. So in other words you refuse to support your claims.
As to "acupuncture", what a whack situation. I don't believe in it, yet scientist are doing research that shows there is something to it. What to do, what to do ...

And then you say "what that can't possibly be right" when you find out the details.
 
I mean, cmon already. Leeches, acupuncture, maggots. All we need is somebody to prove snake oil really works for something, and we are back in the dark ages again. Next thing you know, we will be using Vitamins or antineoplastons to cure cancer, or some other woo idea.

Most unreasonable.

And and strong purgatives have to be good for something to, that doesn't mean the anchients where right to be taking poison with the idea the taking something so bad your body rejects it and makes you vomit is a good thing.
 
Hey this is the number one entry in Google for "Leeches Male Sterility"

Looks like something Robinson made up.
 
To drag the thread away from leaches and back toward I understood the original topic was, can I propose noble gas compounds and "high" temperature superconductivity?

To quote Wikipedia on the latter, One of the top unsolved problems in modern physics is the question of how superconductivity arises in these materials, that is, what mechanism causes the electrons in these crystals to form pairs.

So it is a demonstratable effect for which science still does not have a total explanation. :shocked: :shocked:
 
To drag the thread away from leaches and back toward I understood the original topic was, can I propose noble gas compounds and "high" temperature superconductivity?

To quote Wikipedia on the latter, One of the top unsolved problems in modern physics is the question of how superconductivity arises in these materials, that is, what mechanism causes the electrons in these crystals to form pairs.

So it is a demonstratable effect for which science still does not have a total explanation. :shocked: :shocked:

There is plenty that science doesn't know, it is how much inovation is suprising to science.
 
Tesla, Crooke and Kelvin wrote some of the laws of physics. They were unreasonable men. Reasonable men knew that they had to be wrong. Despite inventing radio, the AC motor, and dozens of other things we take for granted now, Tesla died broke and alone. Reasonable men knew he was crazy, until it was obvious he was not, then reasonable men stole his ideas. Its hard to imagine now, but at the time, he really was considered crazy by reasonable men. He was bouncing energy off the atmosphere, measuring thunderstorms around the globe, and people just knew he had lost it. You can't bounce energy around the world, and you sure as hell can't detect the energy of thunderstorms on the other side of the world! Reasonable men knew this.


Interesting thread.

Robinson, you have a problem or two.

Tesla is one person where your notion of reasonable and unreasonable men falls apart. Most of Tesla’s opposition came from Tomas Edison (backed by Morgan and other investors), who would be on your list of unreasonable men. Edison was unreasonable for quite a bit more than that his own inventions. He did everything he could to undermine Tesla (who was backed by Westinghouse, another person who could be seen as quite unreasonable.)

One quick and short page on Tesla:

http://flyingmoose.org/truthfic/tesla.htm

I have done some reading up on the man other than using the internet.

The typical response of most people to Tesla’s ideas was:

Huh?

There were few people around who understood anything about what he was doing. Edison wanted DC as a standard and was willing to work hard to stop Tesla. He had personal investment (both psychological and financial) in DC and is considered by many to have been unable to understand the math behind AC. There was very little resistance to Tesla by anybody else.

Another “unreasonable” man was Henry Ford. Ford was friends with Edison and went right along with the DC idea. The Ford Rouge complex power plant was originally equipped with large DC generators. (I have yet to find out when those generators were replaced. I also used to work on the Rouge complex for another company.)

As for Tesla’s ideas being stolen, that is bit of an overgeneralization. Some ideas were copied. Tesla deferred many payments from the Westinghouse Company. Eventually he signed over the rights for nothing.

I would suggest you drop the “reasonable” and “unreasonable” man rhetoric. Humans cling to their biases. That is our nature. Your unreasonable men just have a slightly different set of biases that still tend to come back and bite them in the rear at some point.

As for leaches, I would like to see you provide evidence. Don’t tell me to do my homework. The burden of proof rests on those who make the claim.

The fact that leaches are used today does not mean past uses or ideas on their use were correct. Even a stopped clock is right twice a day.

http://www.nytimes.com/2005/08/25/health/25fda.html?ex=1167886800&en=61c865312b0b7284&ei=5070

For centuries, doctors used leeches in the mistaken view that they would help balance a patient's body fluids, or "humors." Doctors are said to have drained quarts of blood from an ailing George Washington before he died.
 
I never claimed leeches work. I find the idea repulsive. It is most unreasonable that scientist are claiming they do. I can accept the use for surgery, but all this stuff about arthritis and infertility and other stuff sounds woo to me. I didn't even know about leeches until this topic got me searching for unreasonable ideas.

I agree about the reasonable/unreasonable terms. It is confusing.
 
So - the question is:

Can anyone think of anything that's been invented in the last 50 years or so, that's been really surprising, and/or a radical departure from the accepted scientific understanding of the universe?

I like Enlightenment's answer of the Hubble Telescope. Who in the world would have thought about "dark" energy and matter? But the telescope itself wasn't a real radical departure.

Here's something that, at the time, blew people away. In seeming definance of Earnshaw's theorem, a guy named Roy Harrigan invented the Levitron. A permanent magnet that levitates above another permanent magnet. See one in action here.

But of course, it was explained using physics.
 
The fact that leaches are used today does not mean past uses or ideas on their use were correct.

I agree. I was surprised to learn that the morphine-like substance leeches produce stops pain better than drugs. And that they produce anti-clotting substances, and that they can analyze and change blood chemistry. While I doubt the ancients knew why they worked, I don't doubt that leeches do work. Exactly what they help with, seems to be still under investigation.

I don't find anyone claiming they work by woo means. It seems to be science based research being done. There are many substances the leech produces, and there is a feedback loop between the leech and the blood supply. I don't want to say this is unreasonable, but what other word works?
 
I like Enlightenment's answer of the Hubble Telescope. Who in the world would have thought about "dark" energy and matter? But the telescope itself wasn't a real radical departure.

Here's something that, at the time, blew people away. In seeming definance of Earnshaw's theorem, a guy named Roy Harrigan invented the Levitron. A permanent magnet that levitates above another permanent magnet. See one in action here.

But of course, it was explained using physics.

Yeah - i've got one of those, it looks really spooky, but it doesn't seem terribly outragous to think that a magnet might 'levitate' over another magnet... Maybe that's hindsight :shrug:
 
To drag the thread away from leaches and back toward I understood the original topic was, can I propose noble gas compounds and "high" temperature superconductivity?

To quote Wikipedia on the latter, One of the top unsolved problems in modern physics is the question of how superconductivity arises in these materials, that is, what mechanism causes the electrons in these crystals to form pairs.

So it is a demonstratable effect for which science still does not have a total explanation. :shocked: :shocked:

Good stuff - so we don't know how its done? Therefore no one would have predicted superconductors? Anyone know more about this sort of thing?

Edit: I just read it again, you're talking about non-cooled superconductors? Is this a huge leap from the type that needs to be cold? I'm not really conversant re superconductivity...
 
Last edited:
I think the most surprising thing I've heard of in the last 50 years is that Hawking lost his bet with Kip Thorne. In other words, you CAN get some information out of a black hole. They're still arguing over whether you can get it ALL out, if I understand correctly.
 
Good stuff - so we don't know how its done? Therefore no one would have predicted superconductors? Anyone know more about this sort of thing?

Edit: I just read it again, you're talking about non-cooled superconductors? Is this a huge leap from the type that needs to be cold? I'm not really conversant re superconductivity...

The term "High" temperature superconductivity is a little misleading. It really means relatively high. Previously superconductivity could only be done by cooling things close to absolute zero. Then a breakthrough occurred with certain complicated ceramics (such as Y-Ba2-Cu3-O7)that could superconduct at temperatures easily achieved with liquid nitrogen rather than with liquid helium.

"High" temperature or not I still wouldn't want to stick my hand in there. We are still talking around 150K.

I am unsure as to the highest temperature where superconductivity has been achieved. Obviously room temperature is the holy grail.
 
Re-animation of the corpse

As for leaches, I would like to see you provide evidence. Don’t tell me to do my homework. The burden of proof rests on those who make the claim.

:deadhorse

Ack, the damn leeches. Ever since I used them as an example, they seem to have stuck with me, trailing goo around various topics. I agree that the burden is on the claimant. I didn't claim leeches worked, I pointed to scientific studies, and one sort of woo site about them.

I don't like leeches, or maggots for that matter, yet my scientific mind can accept that they are probably the best option for some medical issues. Medical history is replete with organic, natural methods of healing, most of which were dropped when the germ theory came into acceptance. While some would make great additions to the topic, the cutoff of 50 years puts most of them out of the picture.

Yet, a few have re-emerged of late. Or, upon investigation, have re-emerged in the Western view, having never fell out of favor in the outer reaches of the world.

The fact that leaches are used today does not mean past uses or ideas on their use were correct. Even a stopped clock is right twice a day.

One could put it another way, if you accept that sort of reasoning. "The fact that leeches were considered quackery does not mean they did not have medical value".

Or,

"That one use of leeches is found to be worthless, does not mean all uses of leeches are worthless".

Or something like that. The link I provided showing scientific evidence that leeches help with arthritis was a surprise to me. YMMV
 
Damn the leeches. Moving on...

Recent news: Virgin Olive Oil, claimed for centuries to have health benefits, including treating ulcers, is shown in scientific experiments, (surprise), to actually help, at least in the lab.

In the study, published in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, researchers used laboratory experiments to simulate conditions found in the human stomach in order to evaluate olive oil’s ability to fight H. pylori bacteria.

Researcher Conception Romero and colleagues of the University Hospital of Valme, in Seville, Spain, found that the healthy phenolic compounds in virgin olive oil remained stable for hours in simulated acidic conditions of the stomach.

These phenolic compounds also had a strong antibacterial effect. The results of the lab studies showed olive oil’s phenolic compounds were effective against eight strains of H. pylori, including three that are resistant to some antibiotics.

The surprise, to me, is that it actually acts on the pathogen thought to cause many ulcers, which was a previous surprising discovery. In fact, without the discovery of H. pylori, the Olive Oil couldn't have been verified, at least scientifically.

While it may seem trite to some, with millions of people suffering from ulcers, and H. pylori becoming resistant to drugs, a possible treatment, especially one that is safe and cheap, might seem like big news.

Now you woos, please don't jump on this as proof that all natural time tested remedies work. Until science shows it to be true, it isn't.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom