Surprising Developements

vIQleS

Muse
Joined
Dec 14, 2005
Messages
841
Split from:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=64917

(Carrying on the derailment, on page 7)

vIQleS said:
At one stage scientists didn't believe that rocks could fall from the sky, that was a pretty preposterous idea.

Until someone demonstrated that they could. And then replicated it.

Has anyone replicated a PMM?

It's OK to postulate an absurd hypothesis (although I'd try and keep it mostly to myself) - but you have to make it work before anyone will take you seriously. Especially if it destroys the basic and well-tested rules of the universe...

ETA: Try this - think of something that has been invented in the last, i don't know, 50 years that when people looked at it didn't say - "Oh, yeah... That's a really obvious progression of what we already know."

In other words how surprising is the technology that we're inventing 'now' on a day to day basis?

ETA2:I'm actually interested to know if anybody can think of anything... I'm trying - I'll let you know.
 
So - the question is:

Can anyone think of anything that's been invented in the last 50 years or so, that's been really surprising, and/or a radical departure from the accepted scientific understanding of the universe?
 
Well, I'm not sure I understand your logical progression. There wasn't an invention that actually led to the understanding that rocks fell from the sky, rather direct and indirect evidence led to the "discovery".

Maybe a more appropriate question is to ask what invention over the last 50 years led to a discovery that made a radical departure from scientific understanding.

In this case, there are many. Off the top of my head, the hubble telescope.

Any invention is going to derive from known scientific theory. Maybe it is I who is unclear of your meaning. I haven't followed the thread from which you split this topic from, so maybe I am being ignorant.
 
Last edited:
So - the question is:

Can anyone think of anything that's been invented in the last 50 years or so, that's been really surprising, and/or a radical departure from the accepted scientific understanding of the universe?
I was asking this very question a couple of weeks ago - I'll try to find a link to it.

Laser was the last really new field, as far as I can see.
 
Well, I'm not sure I understand your logical progression. There wasn't an invention that actually led to the understanding that rocks fell from the sky, rather direct and indirect evidence led to the "discovery".

Maybe a more appropriate question is to ask what invention over the last 50 years led to a discovery that made a radical departure from scientific understanding.

In this case, there are many. Off the top of my head, the hubble telescope.

Any invention is going to derive from known scientific theory. Maybe it is I who is unclear of your meaning. I haven't followed the thread from which you split this topic from, so maybe I am being ignorant.

In the other thread, one poster appeared to be claiming that no discoveries were made by normal people or processes, only by unreasonable people. I believe vIQleS is asking if anyone can think of anything that has been invented that was completely out of the blue and not based on previous scientific knowledge. For example, both LEDs, LASERs and the Hubble telescope were predicted and designed on purpose based on theory. Said poster is currently working on a perpetual motion machine, and this would be considered completely revolutionary since it is contradicted by known science. The question is less relevant now, since he has clarified that the claim is based on some legal jargon about reasonable people and is in fact completely meaningless.
 
The major use for Viagra was discovered by serendipity; does that count?
 
Hello vIQleS,

People used to think that a 4 minute mile was physically impossible. There is some of the essence of what your asking in that example in this sense:
  • Can people do what is 'known' to be impossible?
Where I think the example differs from your point is that we are sure we can run and we're sure there's a limit to the rate, we just aren't exactly sure where the limit is. We admit that today. Before the 4 minute mile, a lot of people believed that was the boundary.

If I'm correct, that example is close to what you're asking but it isn't at the heart of it. I think you're asking, 'After so many intelligent people exhaustively examined an idea, is it possible they missed something; something that would be the opposite conclusion that they originally came to?'

Did I hit the nail on the head?

Gene
 
So - the question is:

Can anyone think of anything that's been invented in the last 50 years or so, that's been really surprising, and/or a radical departure from the accepted scientific understanding of the universe?

Somehow I missed this topic and its creation.
 
I was following it on the other thread, and the first thing I thought of was computers, and the software/websites that the Net enabled.
 
Sorry, triple posting

So - the question is:

Can anyone think of anything that's been invented in the last 50 years or so, that's been really surprising, and/or a radical departure from the accepted scientific understanding of the universe?

While it might seem pedantic, a definition of "accepted scientific understanding of the universe" really is required to answer the question. Because the term 'accepted scientific understanding of the universe' is a fluid, dynamic, changing sort of concept, and certainly not anything that one can pin down and say "here it is", the question really isn't valid at all.

In the last 50 years, as in the last 500, the "accepted scientific understanding of the universe" has changed. It will change in the time you read this. Because science allows new discoveries, new research, and surprising revelations, all the time.

The best examples of late would be cancer research, and small comet bombardment. In medicine and astronomy, new stuff is common, and ANYTHING that goes against the "accepted scientific understanding of the universe" seems to be greeted by some with derision and doubt by some.

Even the stuff that is really really cool, and later will come to be part of the "accepted scientific understanding of the universe".

The Milky Sea is another example.

Whoa! And right here in this very forum -
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2195099#post2195099

How surprising!

And here-
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2193892#post2193892

Another surprise!
 
Last edited:
Surprizing developments

The most amazing development in technology of the present era has been the development of the personal computer. When computers were first developed and durring the first decades of their development, the universal understanding as to how this tech. would progress was that computes would get larger and larger, more expensive, and that only huge governmental and corporate entiteis would ever posses them. They would only be understood by a very small cohort of genius programmers. In the 1970's novelist Ira Levin (of Rosemary's Baby fame) wrote a distopian novel "This Perfect Day" where the whole world was controlled by a giant computer called "Omni" that was controlled by a ruling elite of about five people. The concept did not seem overly outlandish at all, today the story would seem comical. My son, a freshman in college, has his hands on more computing power than NASA had in the 60's, and god knows what he is doing with it!
 
Indeed. The transistor is a good example of an invention that was considered impossible. And even after it was patented, and being produced, reasonable men said it was worthless. The Japanese, being unreasonable, used it to make small portable radios. Another device that was considered by reasonable men to be worthless.

While that sounds ridiculous, it is a historic fact. Remember that a transistor is the same as a tube that produces electron transfer while not being hot. I think it was 1924 or so when it was first demonstrated. Scientist of the time claimed the inventor was a crackpot, and didn't believe this was possible.
 
Last edited:
Indeed. The transistor is a good example of an invention that was considered impossible. And even after it was patented, and being produced, reasonable men said it was worthless. The Japanese, being unreasonable, used it to make small portable radios. Another device that was considered by reasonable men to be worthless.

While that sounds ridiculous, it is a historic fact. Remember that a transistor is the same as a tube that produces electron transfer while not being hot. I think it was 1924 or so when it was first demonstrated. Scientist of the time claimed the inventor was a crackpot, and didn't believe this was possible.

Yes. So?

I fail to see your point.
 
So - the question is:

Can anyone think of anything that's been invented in the last 50 years or so, that's been really surprising, and/or a radical departure from the accepted scientific understanding of the universe?

Yes. The point is simple. The question is, "Can anyone think...", and I made a simple point, that yes, yes most people can think of something. That you don't get the point, makes it seem you are a reasonable man.
:wackywink:
 
The major use for Viagra was discovered by serendipity; does that count?
The scary part about that is that the same point was raised in the other thread I mentioned. Amazing what a bit of advertising can do.
 
Ah... serendipity. What a wonderful thing.

From the MDC changes thread:

I don't understand your point, robinson. Are airplanes scoffed at now by any "reasonable" people? Sure, new things take time to become widely accepted. That does not change the fact that all of the things you have mentioned have become widely accepted. Therefore, your argument that sound, solid evidence does not convince reasonable men is disproven by your own examples.

I was speaking to when new things are discovered, that seem to contradict current understanding of the universe and science and stuff. Of course after it is in use, most people don't question stuff. I understood the query being about new stuff when it was new.

Obviously not everything is like this. Usually it is the out there stuff that gets the reaction, the dismissal.
 
Another example. Leeches. While the reasonable man scoffed and mocked the oldtime idiots who used them, and even used them as an insult to medical Doctors who claimed stuff that sounded crazy, the unreasonable men who actually did the research, and dared to publish, brought leeches back. Now, once again, they are considered invaluable, and it turns out them leech Doctors were right about a lot of stuff. They weren't quacks. Leeches are amazing. And FDA approved!

Funny isn't it? But not in 1980. Then the statement that leeches are a wonderful medical tool would have brought reasonable men howling to attack. Before they even looked at the data, the research, the science.
 
Another example. Leeches. While the reasonable man scoffed and mocked the oldtime idiots who used them, and even used them as an insult to medical Doctors who claimed stuff that sounded crazy, the unreasonable men who actually did the research, and dared to publish, brought leeches back. Now, once again, they are considered invaluable, and it turns out them leech Doctors were right about a lot of stuff. They weren't quacks. Leeches are amazing. And FDA approved!

Funny isn't it? But not in 1980. Then the statement that leeches are a wonderful medical tool would have brought reasonable men howling to attack. Before they even looked at the data, the research, the science.

Yes, but robinson, you're missing the whole point. The research was done. The evidence was provided, and now leeches are accepted by the scientific establishment as an effective treatment for some things. Once again, reasonable men have been convinced by sound and solid evidence. You keep making my argument for me.

Here, this is the way you are supposed to play it. Give us an example of something for which sound and solid evidence has been provided but has not been accepted.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom