Surprising Developements

How about the Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR). I read a story by the inventor about how he thought of it and how many of his co-workers were sceptical when he explained the idea. But he made it work and it revolutionized DNA analysis in a very short time. I believe he received a Nobel Prize for it. It is now used in automated equipment that is bringing the cost of gene sequencing down radically.
 
Yes, but robinson, you're missing the whole point. The research was done. The evidence was provided, and now leeches are accepted by the scientific establishment as an effective treatment for some things. Once again, reasonable men have been convinced by sound and solid evidence. You keep making my argument for me.

Here, this is the way you are supposed to play it. Give us an example of something for which sound and solid evidence has been provided but has not been accepted.

I think robinson's argument is more along the lines of "here are some examples of things which were rejected when there was no evidence, but which became accepted once evidence was found.

Therefore all things with no evidence should be taken seriously"
 
Cloning?
Doesn't cloning work just the way it's not supposed to?
I once recall reading that to clone a more clomplex organism (like a sheep), we'd first have to learn to clone separate types of organs, and then figure out how to put them all together.
But, then, voila! Hello, Dolly.
Maybe I'm way off.
 
BTW, vIQleS
I'm curious as to the origin of your chosen screen name.
tlhIngan Hol DajatlhlaH
And why ghawran for your avatar?
 
How about the Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR). I read a story by the inventor about how he thought of it and how many of his co-workers were sceptical when he explained the idea. But he made it work and it revolutionized DNA analysis in a very short time. I believe he received a Nobel Prize for it. It is now used in automated equipment that is bringing the cost of gene sequencing down radically.

I don't know what this is, but it sounds like the sort of thing i was looking for (wondering about)...

But what came immediately before it? Was it a logical progression from another peice of technology, or did it come completely out of the blue?

The LED... Was it immediately preceeded by a non-light emiting diode?

Cloning a sheep seems a logical progression from cloning organs (i assume they were doing that first...) (although I might have started a litle smaller...)

I'm talking about the sort of "oh my god, if i connect this to that, i get unlimited energy and antigravity, and i can read minds..." sort of discoveries...

Or to put it a little more realisticly - playing around with, say, a cassette tape, and inventing DVD. Or jumping from punch cards to plasma screens...
 
BTW, vIQleS
I'm curious as to the origin of your chosen screen name.
tlhIngan Hol DajatlhlaH
And why ghawran for your avatar?


nuqneH skullerello

I was working for a client one day and their login name was viclesh (Victor and Elizabeth i think). I mentioned that it sounded like tlhIngan Hol, and they said i could use it.

Best picture of a Klingon I could find at short notice...
 
I think robinson's argument is more along the lines of "here are some examples of things which were rejected when there was no evidence, but which became accepted once evidence was found.

Therefore all things with no evidence should be taken seriously"

Well, you can think whatever you like, but that is dumb. One of the cool things about writing stuff down, and doing it in a way that is easy to understand, is anyone reading it can see what you are saying. Obviously, nobody but you is saying something like, "Therefore all things with no evidence should be taken seriously". See? Its easy. You said that, and it is dumb.

What I am writing about here are things that seemed dumb, and even when evidence was shown, produced, researched, people still didn't believe it. It happens all the time. It always has. It is almost a built in thing. It is so common, so everyday, we don't even have a word for it.

It is quite easy to understand. I feel the same way when someone says they have found a way to levitate, without any technology. I don't believe it. I don't want to even hear anymore after that. End of story.
 
How about the Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR). I read a story by the inventor about how he thought of it and how many of his co-workers were sceptical when he explained the idea. But he made it work and it revolutionized DNA analysis in a very short time. I believe he received a Nobel Prize for it. It is now used in automated equipment that is bringing the cost of gene sequencing down radically.

Excellent example. That would be Kary Mullis, who is still doing stuff and saying stuff that gets skeptics riled up, as well as other researchers and scientist. He publicly states that there is no evidence that HIV causes AIDS, or in his own words"
I’m one of the few outspoken people who say that there’s no good scientific evidence that the diseases that are called AIDS are really caused by the retrovirus called HIV—in spite of its name. I’ve had a lot of trouble from people over that issue, because many are convinced that it does. But my assessment is that it is an unsupported and unsubstantiated belief.

And he is working on a project that right now that will no doubt get him another Nobel prize, (Altermune). A project that probably no one would fund or even consider, if he hadn't won the Nobel prize, the Thomas A. Edison Award, the Japan Prize, and the California Scientist of the Year Award. As well as being in the National Inventors Hall of Fame. So when he says unreasonable things, sometimes people still listen to him.
 
What I am writing about here are things that seemed dumb, and even when evidence was shown, produced, researched, people still didn't believe it.

So, why don't you provide us an example of something like that?
 
So, why don't you provide us an example of something like that?

Don't be dumb. This thread is now an example of what I am talking about. I give you examples, post links to hard evidence, and you ask a dumb question like that. See? Its like you are helping me make the point.
 
I'm talking about the sort of "oh my god, if i connect this to that, i get unlimited energy and antigravity, and i can read minds..." sort of discoveries...

Or to put it a little more realisticly - playing around with, say, a cassette tape, and inventing DVD. Or jumping from punch cards to plasma screens...

The first thing I thought of was Tesla when he said he had invented a brushless electric motor (induction motor). The other scientist at the time (Edison was particularly virulent), claimed he was trying to make a PMM, and that it would never work. Of course now nobody thinks that, but at the time it earned him a reputation as a crackpot. His response to the skeptics was telling;

"... The present is theirs. The future, for which I really worked, is mine."

Small comet bombardment is another really good example.
 
Don't be dumb. This thread is now an example of what I am talking about. I give you examples, post links to hard evidence, and you ask a dumb question like that. See? Its like you are helping me make the point.

You haven't given an example of anything that has hard evidence that it works, that is not accepted by the reasonable community.

I agree with theboypaj, it looks to me like you are saying that because some currently accepted scientific discoveries drew laughter and derision in the beginning, that all claims without evidence should be treated seriously.

You said he was dumb to think that, I don't think he was dumb at all, he read what was in front of him.

Having read several of your posts and observed the patterns, I suspect you are trolling. Would I be correct?
 
Hello vIQleS,

People used to think that a 4 minute mile was physically impossible. There is some of the essence of what your asking in that example in this sense:

No they did not think a human could do it, not that it was impossible. That is an example of an engeneering challange not a discovery. It is like saying you can't build a bridge over X length. Doing it is an accomplishment not a discovery.
 
Another example. Leeches. While the reasonable man scoffed and mocked the oldtime idiots who used them, and even used them as an insult to medical Doctors who claimed stuff that sounded crazy, the unreasonable men who actually did the research, and dared to publish, brought leeches back. Now, once again, they are considered invaluable, and it turns out them leech Doctors were right about a lot of stuff. They weren't quacks. Leeches are amazing. And FDA approved!

This is so wrong. You are claiming that the FDA has aproved the use of leaches for ballancing humors. That is complete crap. Their current use has nothing to do with their historic use, or you would see a real rise in bloodletting.

They had no medical use for a long them, then surgery advanced to the point that its very abilities created a problem that the leach was a good solution for.
Funny isn't it? But not in 1980. Then the statement that leeches are a wonderful medical tool would have brought reasonable men howling to attack. Before they even looked at the data, the research, the science.

Well, connecting their current use to thier historic use is pretty funny.
 
The most amazing development in technology of the present era has been the development of the personal computer. When computers were first developed and durring the first decades of their development, the universal understanding as to how this tech. would progress was that computes would get larger and larger, more expensive, and that only huge governmental and corporate entiteis would ever posses them. They would only be understood by a very small cohort of genius programmers. In the 1970's novelist Ira Levin (of Rosemary's Baby fame) wrote a distopian novel "This Perfect Day" where the whole world was controlled by a giant computer called "Omni" that was controlled by a ruling elite of about five people. The concept did not seem overly outlandish at all, today the story would seem comical. My son, a freshman in college, has his hands on more computing power than NASA had in the 60's, and god knows what he is doing with it!

The thing here is that there was a failure of imagination of what they could be used for, not a failure in understanding how they worked. Especially after the invention of the silicon chip, which covers a fair amount of the period that you are talking about.

The difference here is when a scientist says something is impossible they are often right, but when they are depending on what is practical and useful, that is a different situation entirely. They did not think of the applications of the technology, but that does not mean that they would have thought it violated physical laws.

For example I will say that no one will ever build a bridge from New York to London. That is not saying that such a bridge violates physical laws, but it is still impossible because it does not fit into any kind of reasonable cost benefit analysis that I can imagine.

Or to look at a real suggested project, building a dam across the straights of Gibraltar and emptying the Mediterranean for farm land. This will never happen, but it is possible.
 
How about the Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR). I read a story by the inventor about how he thought of it and how many of his co-workers were sceptical when he explained the idea. But he made it work and it revolutionized DNA analysis in a very short time. I believe he received a Nobel Prize for it. It is now used in automated equipment that is bringing the cost of gene sequencing down radically.

The problem is that people are confusing engeneering challanges and scientific impossibilities.

I will say that a family car will never get 500 miles to a galon of gas, but that does not mean that it violates the laws of physics if someone built one.
 
This is so wrong. You are claiming that the FDA has aproved the use of leaches for ballancing humors. That is complete crap.

No, you said that, and it is crap. Nobody said anything like that, except you.

Their current use has nothing to do with their historic use, or you would see a real rise in bloodletting.

Obviously you know nothing about leeches, or you wouldn't say dumb stuff like that.

They had no medical use for a long them, then surgery advanced to the point that its very abilities created a problem that the leach was a good solution for.

I'm not quite sure what you are trying to say, "They had no medical use for a long them,"??? Is English not your primary language?

Well, connecting their current use to thier historic use is pretty funny.

Almost as funny as your spelling.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom