Surprising Developements

That is so cool...

ETA: Based on the fact that the 'holes' face upward, I'm guessing it has something to do with air pressure. Would the downward air pressure (equal non the top and on the holes) keep the water in?
 
Last edited:
That is so cool...

ETA: Based on the fact that the 'holes' face upward, I'm guessing it has something to do with air pressure. Would the downward air pressure (equal non the top and on the holes) keep the water in?
It's similar to holding water in a straw by holding your finger over the top hole of the straw. Since water can't expand (much) no water can leave without being replaced by air (or something) to fill the vacant space. As long as there is no way for air to get in, no water can leave.

The air pressure doesn't hold the water in. But all the feeding holes have to be at the same height or else there would a difference in the water pressure between the two holes and then water would flow between the two holes.
 
It is just a basic siphon. Nothing remarkable about it in the least.
The current picture is just a siphon. The picture at the link has changed and the earlier photo showed an aquarium with feeding portals in the side of the tank below the surface of the water.
 
My impression is that the examples being sought are not just 'surprising' discoveries, but discoveries that contradict known laws. There is a difference.

An example of a surprising discovery in the last 50 years in my field of study: retrotransposons. aka: "jumping genes". These are dna segments that migrate from place to place in the genome, and replicate independently.

Their existence was proposed, but not accepted until research demonstrated their existence beyond a doubt. However, there is nothing about them that violates a law of physics: they were rejected because there was no evidence for them at the time. The proposal did not conflict with what we knew - it was just undemonstrated. Once their existence was demonstrated, a Nobel Prize was awarded.

Free energy machines are different - the principle contradicts existing findings. A priori rejection is appropriate due to the conservative nature of science, but - as always - the claimant is welcome and invited to prove the rest of science wrong. Failure to do so over a long timeframe is relevant to the claimant's ongoing credibility and ultimately, his academic currency.



Cryptozoology is similar: there is no scientific reason that Loch Ness doesn't harbour a large aquatic animal - the ocean is filled with whales, giant squid, &c. We find large primitive fish in deep ocean trenches that resemble animals thought to be extinct for millions of years. The reason it's rejected is that the claimants haven't produced persuasive evidence, despite great effort and abundant opportunity.
 
The current picture is just a siphon. The picture at the link has changed and the earlier photo showed an aquarium with feeding portals in the side of the tank below the surface of the water.

I just noticed that as well. And now I can't find any page with the fish feeding holes. Damn Internet. Stuff changes.
 
My impression is that the examples being sought are not just 'surprising' discoveries, but discoveries that contradict known laws. There is a difference.

Yep. But the original question got burned out long ago.

So - the question is:

Can anyone think of anything that's been invented in the last 50 years or so, that's been really surprising, and/or a radical departure from the accepted scientific understanding of the universe?

The real question might be, what is the "accepted scientific understanding of the universe" ? And how often does it change?

Some people think they know it all, and they are always wrong. Because they don't.
 
The current picture is just a siphon. The picture at the link has changed and the earlier photo showed an aquarium with feeding portals in the side of the tank below the surface of the water.

That does not make it less a siphon. THe same principle applies, it just has some air traped in it. Now if they had two open feeding portals at different hights then it would be an example of photoshop.
 
That does not make it less a siphon. THe same principle applies, it just has some air traped in it. Now if they had two open feeding portals at different hights then it would be an example of photoshop.
Well, I don't think the original photo quite meets the definition of a siphon (since a siphon is defined as a device for moving water over a barrier). But, I would agree that the imcompressibility of water is important in both the siphon and the feeding portals.

Came across some links though. This dictionary entry is a bit confused on the role of atmospheric pressure in a siphon:

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/siphon

But the wikipedia seems to have the major points correct:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siphon
 
Well, I'm not sure I understand your logical progression. There wasn't an invention that actually led to the understanding that rocks fell from the sky, rather direct and indirect evidence led to the "discovery".

Maybe a more appropriate question is to ask what invention over the last 50 years led to a discovery that made a radical departure from scientific understanding.

In this case, there are many. Off the top of my head, the hubble telescope.

Any invention is going to derive from known scientific theory. Maybe it is I who is unclear of your meaning. I haven't followed the thread from which you split this topic from, so maybe I am being ignorant.

If we are just counting discoveries, the fact there are giant black holes in the centers of galaxies was a departure from previous thought, I think. But I take it you are looking for something more 'out there' such as countering previous physics or something?
 
Last edited:
Well, I don't think the original photo quite meets the definition of a siphon (since a siphon is defined as a device for moving water over a barrier). But, I would agree that the imcompressibility of water is important in both the siphon and the feeding portals.

Came across some links though. This dictionary entry is a bit confused on the role of atmospheric pressure in a siphon:

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/siphon

But the wikipedia seems to have the major points correct:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siphon


A Siphon makes the fluid level even between two(or more) areas of water. If you added water to one tank then it becomes a siphon, the same thing if you take water out. It is just a siphon that has reached equilibrium.
 
A Siphon makes the fluid level even between two(or more) areas of water. If you added water to one tank then it becomes a siphon, the same thing if you take water out. It is just a siphon that has reached equilibrium.
The article says that water is pumped from one tank to the other (not through the siphon tube) which will generate a difference in water pressure to maintain a flow of water through the siphon. I had a similar set up for a small fish tank in which water is pumped from a sump into the main tank with a siphon return. The water in the sump is slightly lower than the main tank. It's not clear from the pictures but the two tanks might be on slightly different levels to generate a good siphon effect.
 
The article says that water is pumped from one tank to the other (not through the siphon tube) which will generate a difference in water pressure to maintain a flow of water through the siphon. I had a similar set up for a small fish tank in which water is pumped from a sump into the main tank with a siphon return. The water in the sump is slightly lower than the main tank. It's not clear from the pictures but the two tanks might be on slightly different levels to generate a good siphon effect.

Probably is like that to keep the water clean in the siphon.

It's cool, but it is basic plumbing and water management.
 
A Siphon makes the fluid level even between two(or more) areas of water. If you added water to one tank then it becomes a siphon, the same thing if you take water out. It is just a siphon that has reached equilibrium.
Yes, I know, the current photo of a "fish highway" is a siphon. The original photo wasn't.
 
LEDS? They were just trivial. Far more exciting was the integrated circuit. A mainframe was now possible on a chip the size of your fingernail.
Exciting, yes, but not a very good example, I think, because the integrated circuit evolved in a pretty orderly way from the transistor. Granted, it was a stroke of genius, and won Jack Kilby a Nobel prize, but nobody challenged his physics when he presented it. If you'd predicted in 1960 that this technology would end up with cell phone cameras and pentium processors, and so on, you'd probably have been dismissed as a science fiction nut, but I don't think there's ever been a stage in the development of IC's at which somebody came up with something that seemed to violate the laws of physics, or that was believed impossible when it actually occurred.
 
If we are just counting discoveries, the fact there are giant black holes in the centers of galaxies was a departure from previous thought, I think. But I take it you are looking for something more 'out there' such as countering previous physics or something?

Well, that too, but mostly stuff like - "Wow - compact disks" or "OMG - a machine that flies"

A DVD wouldn't count, but a microwave might. What _new_ technology has been invented in the last 50 odd years. (we've a few good examples, but not many everyday things)
 
A tad more than 50 years ago antibiotics were discovered.

Antivirals came with genetic science and proliferated with money for HIV research.

It took a little less than 10 years to find the HIV in the late 70s-early 80s. It took only a few months to find the SARS virus in this decade.

There was a lab breakthrough which made studying DNA faster, cheaper, and easier. That opened the floodgates in genetic research and designer drugs.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom