Surprising Developements

Lets stick to the leeches then.

Indications for treatment with medicinal leeches:

- cardiovascular diseases, including essential hypertension and ischemia disease, phlebogene diseases of the lower extremities;
- chronic bronchitis, pneumonia, bronchial asthma;
- gastrointestinal tract diseases (hepatitis, cholecystitis, pancreatitis, stomach ulcer);
- ENT diseases;
- paradontosis and other teeth diseases;
- urological diseases;
- male sterility;
- skin diseases (neurodermatitis, psoriasis, eczema, herpes);
- gynaecological disorders (commissural processes in the small pelvis, female sterility, chronic adnexitis, parametritis, endometriosis, fibromastopathy);
- systemic diseases (rheumatic arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus, scleroderma);
- osteochondrosis and radiculitis;
- eyes diseases, including glaucoma;
- infantile cerebral paralysis (ICP) and other diseases.

Is this the source where you found this info?

http://www.leeches.biz/leech-hirudotherapy.htm

Kinda looks like a woo woo farm to me.

The way of leech secret injection is very simple: being placed on the skin it bites the skin, then the secret of the leech saliva falls into the blood channel and goes to the disease focus through vessels. In the treatment we use hirudoreflexotherapy placing the leeches on the reflexogenic points as a "Life needle".

Ooooo Kay. :con2:

The existence of skin-visceral connections with the definite organs is well known. Biologically active substances act to organs during the blood-sicking work of medicinal leeches through viens. It promotes the improvement of blood circulation in the concrete organ,renders trombolitic,antiinflammatory,immunostimulating action,raises nutrition of tissues, strengthens tissues immunity. It’s impossible to name all diseases which can be treated with using of hirudotherapy

Concrete organ? :confused:

Ahhh.... and now we come to it:

http://www.leeches.biz/leech-powder.htm

Leech Powder

Biologically active substances in leech saliva help the cells to absorb the necessary nutrition and to eliminate toxic waste.

We supply leech powder in capsules. This 100% pure leech extract is derived from laboratory bred Hirudo Medicinalis. The effect of application of the Hirudo powder is similar to the alive leech application. The anticoagulant effect of Hirudo powder encourages the natural process of regeneration of blood vessels.

Snake oil.

In the future, you may want to take a closer look at the sources you're quoting.
 
I was in error. Unreasonable men have been using leeches for at least 4000 years. And modern science has found exactly why they worked, just as the ancients recorded it. Damn. This is some whack stuff them leeches.

Here are the modern terms for what the ancients were observing, when they used leeches.

general reflexogenic
hypotensive
bloodletting
immunopotentiating
internal decongestion
bacteriostatic
anticoagulant
anti-inflammatory
protective antithrombotic
local anti-edematous
thrombolytic
analgesic
removal of microcirculation disorders
antiatherosclerotic
anti-ischemic
removal of abnormal intersystem interactions

Damn, I don't know what half that stuff means. I will bet you money that leeches doing that is considered woo by reasonable men.
 
You slipped in! But proved my point beyond all doubt. Reasonable men don't want to even look at any research that shows ANY of that crap to be true. After all, we all know leeches is snake oil. Except for surgery. And some other stuff. But them leeches, they can't do anything else. 4000 years of leeching people was woo man. Leeches. Ick.
 
I'm not sure what point you are trying to make. You miss the point about leeches. Most of the traditional uses are bunk. Because the anti-coagulating effects have found a use in recovery from some surgeries does not validate any of the other uses, but con men are ever willing to promote it for dozens of other uses.

Here's another example: the discovery that H. Pylorii bacteria "cause" some forms of ulcers. The initial report was greeted sceptically, and rightfully so, because there was a lot of work that had to be done to prove the concept. Nevertheless, the scientific community jumped on it and began the hard work of proving the connection, which took many years and multiple studies. Many cases of ulcers are now cured with antibiotics. But it is an evolving story. I put "cause" in quotes because it is still an open question. H. Pylorii is common, and not everyone with it gets ulcers. There is some indication that H. Pylorii protects against stomach cancer. The relationship between H. Pylorii and humans is an area of active research today.

Some proponents of SCAM try to claim that the initial scepticism that ulcers could be cured with antibiotics proves that traditional doctors are close minded. But they are wrong. The initial report showed that there was likely a connection between H. Pylorii and ulcers, but it did not, by a long shot, prove the connection. That took years of research by multiple groups (some of whom made huge profits selling antacids, a market drastically reduced by this discovery). The vindication of the theory proves exactly the opposite - that science is open to testing new ideas.
 
I'm not sure what point you are trying to make. You miss the point about leeches. Most of the traditional uses are bunk.

You help me make my point. Current research and evidence on OTHER uses in medicine for leeches is current and ongoing. There is a vast amount of data on leeches, and overwhelming evidence that they can and are used to treat many conditions. But the reasonable man won't even look at the data. It takes an unreasonable man to investigate such an absurd concept.

Which is my perception of what this topic is about. While there are other issues on the table, leeches seem to be one of the most obvious examples. Most reasonable Doctors and skeptics won't even look at research on this. It would be silly. Claims that leeches can restore infertile men is unreasonable. And no matter how many test are done, no matter how much research is available, it is unreasonable to even discuss such a thing.

:wackywink:
 
Is this the source where you found this info?

http://www.leeches.biz/leech-hirudotherapy.htm

Kinda looks like a woo woo farm to me.

It looked that way to me as well. So I did some research. It seems that leeches (and maggots) are a hot research item, as well as common in use. I had no idea. I picked that source because it was the most woo sounding site I could find. But there is a lot of hard science on this. Most strange. Most unreasonable.
 
Leeches, lovely little buggers...dated a few.

Seriously, leeches do have multiple medical uses and have been accepted, standard of care treatment for at least 20 years.

http://www.sp.uconn.edu/~mcbstaff/graf/AvHm/MedUsemain.htm

http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3867/is_199806/ai_n8807297

http://www.annals.org/cgi/content/full/139/9/I-22

http://www.livescience.com/humanbiology/050419_maggots.html

http://www.biotechnologyhealthcare.com/journal/fulltext/3/1/BH0301014.pdf


The study of medicine often leads researchers in places they weren't expecting. One of the first medications for regrowing hair was initially a blood pressure medication, low and behold these patients started noticing that the hair on the scalp started filling in. Side effects are interesting things.


As far as something today not thought of 50 years ago, HIPPA laws. *shudder*



Boo
 
My son, a freshman in college, has his hands on more computing power than NASA had in the 60's, and god knows what he is doing with it!

"Modern computers can hold, in something a little larger than a breadbox, more computing power than computers that used to fill rooms. They're capable of doing work orders of magnitude more complex than the earliest supercomputers could. I can use that computer to link to the Internet, a network of thousands of similar computers, and transfer more data in a minute than the entire ARPANET did in it's first decade. And what do we use all that amazing power for? Video games and porn." -- attribution lost, and quote somewhat paraphrased.
 
Leeches, lovely little buggers...dated a few.

Seriously, leeches do have multiple medical uses and have been accepted, standard of care treatment for at least 20 years.

Thanks for the links. I'm trying to imagine what it was like for the first researchers who started testing leeches, and actually published the data. Over the holiday I talked to someone about leeches, and was surprised to find that people never stopped using them. Even when Modern Medicine advocates insisted they were woo as woo can be. Leeches were one example used to show how stupid and backward our ancestors were about medicine.

After considering this twist of reality, and if you accept that leeches, (a most unreasonable idea), actually have huge health benefits, and always did, one might wonder what research was done that led to leeches becoming quackery of the highest sort?

Was there any research at all? Or did somebody just declare them on a par with witchdoctors and ban them from all modern medical work?
 
The following is speculation on my part.....

With the rise of modern chemistry, pharmaceutical manufacturing, modern medicine and increased availability of university trained physicians; many treatments that relied on 'traditional cures' fell out of disfavor. It's only fairly recently (last 50 years or so) that research began re-evaluating or testing treatments that had been discarded in favor of 'modern medicine'. Some of the practices continued to be used in remote parts of the world and cultures that were isolated from modern technology.

Something that needs to be kept in mind before older traditions or treatments are discarded out of hand; if a treatment has been in continued use over many generations and across many cultures, it should be investigated.




Boo
 
You slipped in! But proved my point beyond all doubt. Reasonable men don't want to even look at any research that shows ANY of that crap to be true. After all, we all know leeches is snake oil. Except for surgery. And some other stuff. But them leeches, they can't do anything else. 4000 years of leeching people was woo man. Leeches. Ick.

Yea, and what about the purgatives? We need more poison in our medicinces to properly purge our bodies?

It was woo. And you have not provided any support for the successful use of leaches in non microsurgical situations.
 
In a related thread, I myself am experiencing the reasonable problem of accepting that acupuncture can work. It seems unreasonable. I don't like all these scientist doing research that shows something we all know is woo, may not be all woo. It is most unreasonable. They even use rats! And double blind experiments.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2200712#post2200712

So does homeopathy, but that doesn't mean the study is valid.

To quote you in that thread

Robinson said:
Using that study to conclude "acupuncture works" would be dumb. And I would like to know how they determine acupuncture points for rats, or any other animal as well. That sounds woo to me, and excuse me for being more than a little skeptical about the entire procedure as well. Just assuming there ARE acupuncture points for rats, or any other animal, sounds fookin nuts to me.
[url="http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2220844&postcount=95]link[/url]

You do not seem to be having a consistent view of that study.
 
Leeches, lovely little buggers...dated a few.

Seriously, leeches do have multiple medical uses and have been accepted, standard of care treatment for at least 20 years.

http://www.sp.uconn.edu/~mcbstaff/graf/AvHm/MedUsemain.htm

http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3867/is_199806/ai_n8807297

http://www.annals.org/cgi/content/full/139/9/I-22

http://www.livescience.com/humanbiology/050419_maggots.html

http://www.biotechnologyhealthcare.com/journal/fulltext/3/1/BH0301014.pdf


The study of medicine often leads researchers in places they weren't expecting. One of the first medications for regrowing hair was initially a blood pressure medication, low and behold these patients started noticing that the hair on the scalp started filling in. Side effects are interesting things.


As far as something today not thought of 50 years ago, HIPPA laws. *shudder*



Boo

The leech ones seem to be all about circulation, except the knee OA one, and that made statements that did not fit with my mothers experince(she had a variety of treatments for years then a double knee replacement about 3 years ago) The treatments do work depending on the dammage to the knee and once you get them replaced they don't hurt anymore(the holes needed to get to your knees do hurt until they heal)
 
The following is speculation on my part.....

With the rise of modern chemistry, pharmaceutical manufacturing, modern medicine and increased availability of university trained physicians; many treatments that relied on 'traditional cures' fell out of disfavor. It's only fairly recently (last 50 years or so) that research began re-evaluating or testing treatments that had been discarded in favor of 'modern medicine'. Some of the practices continued to be used in remote parts of the world and cultures that were isolated from modern technology.

Something that needs to be kept in mind before older traditions or treatments are discarded out of hand; if a treatment has been in continued use over many generations and across many cultures, it should be investigated.

Yea where the the psychaitrists using bleeding to treat Sanguine personality problems? It is tradition after all.
 
There are several issues here.

I don't need to do your homework for you. If you want to see the research on leeches, nobody will stop you. There is a lot of it, but if you won't accept the results, what can anyone do?

As to "acupuncture", what a whack situation. I don't believe in it, yet scientist are doing research that shows there is something to it. What to do, what to do ...
 
I mean, cmon already. Leeches, acupuncture, maggots. All we need is somebody to prove snake oil really works for something, and we are back in the dark ages again. Next thing you know, we will be using Vitamins or antineoplastons to cure cancer, or some other woo idea.

Most unreasonable.
 
The LED... Was it immediately preceeded by a non-light emiting diode?

Sort of... I believe the first LED was a transitory byproduct of converting an ordinary rectifier diode to SED. Subsequent developments permitted producing photons directly from electron energy transitions induced electronically rather than from thermal effects in the early smoke-emitting-diode models.

Sorry, couldn't resist ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom