Surprising Developements

The first thing I thought of was Tesla when he said he had invented a brushless electric motor (induction motor). The other scientist at the time (Edison was particularly virulent), claimed he was trying to make a PMM, and that it would never work. Of course now nobody thinks that, but at the time it earned him a reputation as a crackpot. His response to the skeptics was telling;

"... The present is theirs. The future, for which I really worked, is mine."

Small comet bombardment is another really good example.

The problem here is that edison never really had a good understanding of electricity, could you find a number of noted physicists who at the time said it would be impossible, you know someone who understood maxwells equations?
 
Lets stick to the leeches then.

Indications for treatment with medicinal leeches:

- cardiovascular diseases, including essential hypertension and ischemia disease, phlebogene diseases of the lower extremities;
- chronic bronchitis, pneumonia, bronchial asthma;
- gastrointestinal tract diseases (hepatitis, cholecystitis, pancreatitis, stomach ulcer);
- ENT diseases;
- paradontosis and other teeth diseases;
- urological diseases;
- male sterility;
- skin diseases (neurodermatitis, psoriasis, eczema, herpes);
- gynaecological disorders (commissural processes in the small pelvis, female sterility, chronic adnexitis, parametritis, endometriosis, fibromastopathy);
- systemic diseases (rheumatic arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus, scleroderma);
- osteochondrosis and radiculitis;
- eyes diseases, including glaucoma;
- infantile cerebral paralysis (ICP) and other diseases.
 
The problem here is that edison never really had a good understanding of electricity, could you find a number of noted physicists who at the time said it would be impossible, you know someone who understood maxwells equations?

Its hard to find good data back then, but from what I have read, everyone who was working with motors or electricity slammed Tesla.
 
No, you said that, and it is crap. Nobody said anything like that, except you.

Then why are you comparing two things that have no connection other than that leaches are involved? Before micro surgery there was no use for leaches, it is not that their traditional use was shown to be effective.

As such making any connection between there past use that you will not find any doctors supporting and their current use is totally wrong.

And it represents a misunderstanding of the different meanings of impossible that you have made repeatedly. One is that it violates known science, the other is that it is not an engineering problem that can be solved.

Obviously you know nothing about leeches, or you wouldn't say dumb stuff like that.

???

What property of leaches am I missing? The use of leaches before microsurgery that everyone was talking about was balancing the four humors, the current one is to remove excess blood from an area to let in new blood and permit healing.
 
Lets stick to the leeches then.

Indications for treatment with medicinal leeches:

- cardiovascular diseases, including essential hypertension and ischemia disease, phlebogene diseases of the lower extremities;
- chronic bronchitis, pneumonia, bronchial asthma;
- gastrointestinal tract diseases (hepatitis, cholecystitis, pancreatitis, stomach ulcer);
- ENT diseases;
- paradontosis and other teeth diseases;
- urological diseases;
- male sterility;
- skin diseases (neurodermatitis, psoriasis, eczema, herpes);
- gynaecological disorders (commissural processes in the small pelvis, female sterility, chronic adnexitis, parametritis, endometriosis, fibromastopathy);
- systemic diseases (rheumatic arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus, scleroderma);
- osteochondrosis and radiculitis;
- eyes diseases, including glaucoma;
- infantile cerebral paralysis (ICP) and other diseases.

Please provide some evidince for any of those.
 
Its hard to find good data back then, but from what I have read, everyone who was working with motors or electricity slammed Tesla.

So in other words you can not support your statement then.

Just because they where working with electricity did not mean they knew and understood Maxwell's equations and so had any idea what they where talking about. So if you can show the part of Maxwell's equations that was missing then and has been discovered as a result, that would support your argument.
 
Lets stick to the leeches then.

Indications for treatment with medicinal leeches:

- cardiovascular diseases, including essential hypertension and ischemia disease, phlebogene diseases of the lower extremities;
- chronic bronchitis, pneumonia, bronchial asthma;
- gastrointestinal tract diseases (hepatitis, cholecystitis, pancreatitis, stomach ulcer);
- ENT diseases;
- paradontosis and other teeth diseases;
- urological diseases;
- male sterility;
- skin diseases (neurodermatitis, psoriasis, eczema, herpes);
- gynaecological disorders (commissural processes in the small pelvis, female sterility, chronic adnexitis, parametritis, endometriosis, fibromastopathy);
- systemic diseases (rheumatic arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus, scleroderma);
- osteochondrosis and radiculitis;
- eyes diseases, including glaucoma;
- infantile cerebral paralysis (ICP) and other diseases.

But...but...didn't you just tell us that studies had been done, and leeches had become accepted as effective treatment for some conditions? Are these those conditions, or are these conditions for which the use of leeches is not accepted?
 
But...but...didn't you just tell us that studies had been done, and leeches had become accepted as effective treatment for some conditions? Are these those conditions, or are these conditions for which the use of leeches is not accepted?

That is a good question. And to tell you the truth, I have no idea. And neither do you. Which gets to the crux of the matter. There seems to be some sort of belief that there is a general "currently accepted as true by reasonable men" that you can look these things up and find out.

There isn't. In fact, what is accepted as true is not universal, and it certainly is not static. So not only is there no consensus on some matters, the many varied concepts that people have, also change, sometimes daily.

Now of course I am not talking about everyday common sense stuff, nor would anyone be interested in that. Unless somebody showed that the laws of physics could be broken. But then, if that happened, (it has happened many times before), we just change the theory to match the new data.

:wackywink:
 
This is a very sarcastic assertion with not just a few flaws in it.

Yeah, they laughed at Newton when he invented gravity, Einstein when he made it better, everyone who did quantum, Maxwell, Boyle, Kelvin, the discoverers of new planets, Hubble, Shcrodinger, Feynman, Fermat, etc.. Oh, wait, no they didn't.

A lot could be said about all of it but I'll begin with just a look at Newton and his ideas on optics...

The roots of these unconventional ideas were with Newton by about 1668; when first expressed (tersely and partially) in public in 1672 and 1675, they provoked hostile criticism, mainly because colours were thought to be modified forms of homogeneous white light. Doubts, and Newton's rejoinders, were printed in the learned journals.

I didn't find any thing on how people responded when Newton 'invented' gravity but it seems his 'invention of light' wasn't too well received.

Gene
 
No, that isn't what I said at all. Learn to read and understand stuff, then you won't ask dumb questions. Now go back and read it again. Its not rocket science.

I know, I have done rocket science. You claim that Tesla's motor was thought to be impossible by the science of the time. I want your evidence and now supporting statements is too much to ask for?
 
Before micro surgery there was no use for leaches, it is not that their traditional use was shown to be effective.

Wrong.

What property of leaches am I missing? The use of leaches before microsurgery that everyone was talking about was balancing the four humors, the current one is to remove excess blood from an area to let in new blood and permit healing.

Wrong. That isn't how leeches work. This points to the crux of the matter. What leeches do, have always done, isn't just about sucking blood. That is the sort of simpleminded misunderstanding that led to leeches being considered on the same level as killing a chicken to read its entrails.

And if you think the researchers who discovered how and why leeches work were greeted with admiration and joy, boy have you got a good imagination.

All over the world however, Medical men and patients are glad that the unreasonable men who raise the leeches that are used, never stopped raising them. Several have been raising them for over 150 years.

That seems to me about as unreasonable as it gets. Raising leeches. All those years. When everybody knew that leeches were as useful in medicine as killing a goat.

Now in the US, it seems leeches are only considered for post-op surgery. But that isn't the case in most countries. It seems that the ancients who used leeches (at least 2500 years of leeches), knew a lot about the unique properties of these disgusting little animals. And even knowing that they really do work, I still find the idea of leeches a bit disturbing. It seems to violate a law of physics or something.

One can only imagine what this could lead to. Next thing you know they will use wasp to detect diseases.

Oh wait... they already do.
 
As I read a little further down in this article on Newton I found that his 'invention' of gravity took a little while to catch on also...

Newton's work in mechanics was accepted at once in Britain, and universally after half a century. Since then it has been ranked among humanity's greatest achievements in abstract thought. It was extended and perfected by others, notably Pierre Simon de Laplace, without changing its basis and it survived into the late 19th century before it began to show signs of failing. See Quantum Theory; Relativity.

Gene
 
I know, I have done rocket science. You claim that Tesla's motor was thought to be impossible by the science of the time. I want your evidence and now supporting statements is too much to ask for?

Actually it isn't too much to ask. But you are going to have to wait, or do your own research. I will amend my statement, (at the time I was using memory, not the best tool).

Crookes and Lord Kelvin both supported Tesla.
 
Actually it isn't too much to ask. But you are going to have to wait, or do your own research. I will amend my statement, (at the time I was using memory, not the best tool).

Crookes and Lord Kelvin both supported Tesla.

So then it looks rather like people did not regard it as a violation of physical laws and thus not impossible, but rather as an engineering challenge that they did not feel was doable. That is an entirely different class of effect there.

I am not making claims of items being invented that where thought to be impossible, I don't think that has happened since the birth of science. Meaning that the effect gets notices and understood in a scientific setting first before any application of it gets used.
 

Why? Please provide something on all your claims here.
Wrong. That isn't how leeches work. This points to the crux of the matter. What leeches do, have always done, isn't just about sucking blood. That is the sort of simpleminded misunderstanding that led to leeches being considered on the same level as killing a chicken to read its entrails.
So the anti coagulating saliva helps with pneumonia? Evidence?
And if you think the researchers who discovered how and why leeches work were greeted with admiration and joy, boy have you got a good imagination.
What on earth do you mean by work?
All over the world however, Medical men and patients are glad that the unreasonable men who raise the leeches that are used, never stopped raising them. Several have been raising them for over 150 years.
And people have been practicing homeopathy for 200 years, it must work right?
That seems to me about as unreasonable as it gets. Raising leeches. All those years. When everybody knew that leeches were as useful in medicine as killing a goat.

And at the time they where, removing blood from a post operative site while waiting for blood vessels to reattach was not important then. When you start sewing fingers back on it becomes more needed.
Now in the US, it seems leeches are only considered for post-op surgery. But that isn't the case in most countries. It seems that the ancients who used leeches (at least 2500 years of leeches), knew a lot about the unique properties of these disgusting little animals. And even knowing that they really do work, I still find the idea of leeches a bit disturbing. It seems to violate a law of physics or something.

Yes they are most effective at adjusting the body humors, that is what they where used for for most of that time. The ancients knew more than us right? What next you will suggest that the geocentric model is not preferable to current models
One can only imagine what this could lead to. Next thing you know they will use wasp to detect diseases.

Oh wait... they already do.

And bombs.
 
So then it looks rather like people did not regard it as a violation of physical laws and thus not impossible, but rather as an engineering challenge that they did not feel was doable. That is an entirely different class of effect there.

Tesla, Crooke and Kelvin wrote some of the laws of physics. They were unreasonable men. Reasonable men knew that they had to be wrong. Despite inventing radio, the AC motor, and dozens of other things we take for granted now, Tesla died broke and alone. Reasonable men knew he was crazy, until it was obvious he was not, then reasonable men stole his ideas. Its hard to imagine now, but at the time, he really was considered crazy by reasonable men. He was bouncing energy off the atmosphere, measuring thunderstorms around the globe, and people just knew he had lost it. You can't bounce energy around the world, and you sure as hell can't detect the energy of thunderstorms on the other side of the world! Reasonable men knew this.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom