So, You're Living In A Police State.

With those things in place that you mention, we have more than 40,000 deaths a year. If you took the money we are spending because 3,000 people were killed 5 years ago and used it to make the roads safer you could bring the fatality rate down considerably.

So you want more police on the streets, to control traffic and civilians in their cars, but less police to chase down the bad guys who want to destroy your country and mine?
 
Lesse, now:
Captured, carrying a loaded weapon, with a bunch of other guys carrying loaded weapons, all of whom had been shooting at US troops is kind of a dead giveaway...
Really? And you know that's what happened, that's the evidence they have? Because a lot of people were turned in for $5,000 rewards.

And for people like Lind and this Aussie guy, they went to Afghanistan long before 911. Maybe they were idiots, maybe even deserve to be jailed for beating women, but without a trial how do you know they weren't just idiots in the wrong place at the wrong time?

Bush likes to use the example, "captured in the field or in battle" when he describes enemy combatants. But the reality is that isn't where most of these guys were actually picked up. It's where Bush would like you to believe they were, but the evidence says otherwise.

Here are 7 examples of Gitmo prisoners' stories. The Aussie was turned over to the US by the Northern Alliance. It says he told his dad by phone he was going to defend the Taliban. That doesn't say he was or wasn't aware of all the things the Taliban were doing. Maybe he is guilty. In this country and in Australia, people get trials before 5 years in a prison, no contact with friends or family, tortured, and no idea how long you'll be there. We don't treat the worst serial killers that poorly.
 
Last edited:
So you want more police on the streets, to control traffic and civilians in their cars, but less police to chase down the bad guys who want to destroy your country and mine?
And you think more police is how I'd spend resources to decrease traffic fatalities?

That's a really bad assumption.
 
Pard, you also make the same very bad mistake assuming we are chasing down the bad guys in Iraq, and with Bush's spying and torturing. I think there's a growing majority consensus in the US and around the world that Bush has made us and the whole world LESS safe by his incompetent corrupt actions.
 
And that's why I don't understand the demands for legal defenses and trials. Such perks are unprecedented for enemies captured on a battlefield, yet people sqwauk as if the Bush admin. is doing something that hasn't been done for the entire history of the US.
Just how many were captured on the battlefield and how many were picked up elsewhere?

And how do you know?
 
Pard, you also make the same very bad mistake assuming we are chasing down the bad guys in Iraq, and with Bush's spying and torturing. I think there's a growing majority consensus in the US and around the world that Bush has made us and the whole world LESS safe by his incompetent corrupt actions.

So who are these people we are fighting against in Afghanistan and Iraq, and these terror cells the FBI is monitering?
 
With those things in place that you mention, we have more than 40,000 deaths a year. If you took the money we are spending because 3,000 people were killed 5 years ago and used it to make the roads safer you could bring the fatality rate down considerably.

So since I am much more likely to die in a car crash as opposed to being murdered, all the homicide detectives should be moved to traffic enforcement.
 
Really? And you know that's what happened, that's the evidence they have? Because a lot of people were turned in for $5,000 rewards.

And for people like Lind and this Aussie guy, they went to Afghanistan long before 911. Maybe they were idiots, maybe even deserve to be jailed for beating women, but without a trial how do you know they weren't just idiots in the wrong place at the wrong time?

Bush likes to use the example, "captured in the field or in battle" when he describes enemy combatants. But the reality is that isn't where most of these guys were actually picked up. It's where Bush would like you to believe they were, but the evidence says otherwise.

Here are 7 examples of Gitmo prisoners' stories. The Aussie was turned over to the US by the Northern Alliance. It says he told his dad by phone he was going to defend the Taliban. That doesn't say he was or wasn't aware of all the things the Taliban were doing. Maybe he is guilty. In this country and in Australia, people get trials before 5 years in a prison, no contact with friends or family, tortured, and no idea how long you'll be there. We don't treat the worst serial killers that poorly.

Even if every example is true lets compare with the war no one dare criticize.

World War Two: US and Britan calmly decide to use the tactic of deliberatly burning cities full of civilians to the ground. Hundreds of thousands die.

Horrible things happen in war, from a historical perspective this war has been the least cruel and taken greater steps to protect non combatents than any in history.

Just for a change of pace lets talk about sawing a screaming persons head off with a dull knife and posting the video on the Internet.

Another good benchmark for comparison would be to Google Pfc. Kristian Menchaca, and Pfc. Thomas L. Tucker.
 
So who are these people we are fighting against in Afghanistan and Iraq, and these terror cells the FBI is monitering?
The question isn't who are those people, the question is who else is the Bush administration fighting in addition?
 
So since I am much more likely to die in a car crash as opposed to being murdered, all the homicide detectives should be moved to traffic enforcement.
Actually I believe the murder rate is higher than the vehicle death rate but I didn't want to take the time to find a data source.


You are, however using straw to make your point. One can address all risks that are amenable to changing. But once in a while resources are poured into a single risk at an obviously disproportionate level relative to the actual risk. And that was my point.
 
Even if every example is true lets compare with the war no one dare criticize.

World War Two: US and Britan calmly decide to use the tactic of deliberatly burning cities full of civilians to the ground. Hundreds of thousands die.

Horrible things happen in war, from a historical perspective this war has been the least cruel and taken greater steps to protect non combatents than any in history.

Just for a change of pace lets talk about sawing a screaming persons head off with a dull knife and posting the video on the Internet.

Another good benchmark for comparison would be to Google Pfc. Kristian Menchaca, and Pfc. Thomas L. Tucker.

How will you recognize when we come close to or actually cross the line from necessary actions for the publics' best interest to overkill that threatens our freedom and democracy? I understand crime is fairly low in Saudi Arabia. Iraq was more secure under Saddam than now. Totalitarian regimes can be quite secure.

How do you feel about Bush's attempts to include political dissidents in with terrorists?

There is a Frontline 4 part program on that very issue as it applies to the press. First one is tomorrow night, Tue 2-13 on PBS.
 
The fact that he was an ex POW may not have been the reason for reporting to the police. It could have been just because he was an alien (I mean non-British).


He wasn't an ex-POW. On paper he still WAS a POW. Which is my point. He was never repatriated.

-Gumboot
 
Just how many were captured on the battlefield and how many were picked up elsewhere?

And how do you know?



Under the Laws of Armed Conflict, ANY person located in the war zone (in this case Afghanistan and bordering areas), can be detained by forces engaged in the conflict.

These fall into two basic categories:

A) Protected persons (people who SHOULD be there, including civilians and enemy combatants)
B) Non-protected persons (people who SHOULD NOT be there, such as mercenaries).

The foreigners captured in Afghanistan are non-protected persons, under the Geneva Conventions. They fall into group B.

You will note that people falling into category A) (such as Taliban fighters and Afghani citizens) have not been taken to camps outside Afghanistan. They have been kept in camps inside their homeland, and in the case of civilians, generally are not detained.

People in category A) Have to be cared for, protected, and generally granted appropriate rights. They should be returned to the home when it is suitable (i.e. when fighting ends). People in category B) have no rights whatsoever.

That is the law.

-Gumboot
 
Actually I believe the murder rate is higher than the vehicle death rate but I didn't want to take the time to find a data source.


There are about 16,000 murders in the US each year. Statistics here.

No stat for 2006, but 2005 was 16,692.

-Gumboot
 
Bush essentially gave himself the power to ignore habeas corpus by creating the category of enemy combatant and proclaiming he could arrest and detain foreign nationals indefinitely without charges.

Bush did not create that category - it existed long before he was born and the concept is older than the United States itself.
 
Under the Laws of Armed Conflict, ANY person located in the war zone (in this case Afghanistan and bordering areas), can be detained by forces engaged in the conflict.

These fall into two basic categories:

A) Protected persons (people who SHOULD be there, including civilians and enemy combatants)
B) Non-protected persons (people who SHOULD NOT be there, such as mercenaries).

The foreigners captured in Afghanistan are non-protected persons, under the Geneva Conventions. They fall into group B.

You will note that people falling into category A) (such as Taliban fighters and Afghani citizens) have not been taken to camps outside Afghanistan. They have been kept in camps inside their homeland, and in the case of civilians, generally are not detained.

People in category A) Have to be cared for, protected, and generally granted appropriate rights. They should be returned to the home when it is suitable (i.e. when fighting ends). People in category B) have no rights whatsoever.

That is the law.

-Gumboot
emphasis mine

Are you unaware of the people detained while in all these countries, or just ignoring or denying they exist?
 
Now you lost me.
Pard, you and Gumboot both keep repeating the Bush mantra, "picked up in combat and picked up in the war zone". You asked, "who are these people we are fighting against in Afghanistan and Iraq, and these terror cells the FBI is monitering?"

Why are you so confident Bush is only going after terrorists and men in battle?

They have arrested and torture resulted of innocent men. There are kids at Gitmo under age 16, no trial, no judge to decide if the kid was forced to fight, coerced to fight or was actually old enough to be considered responsible. There are innocent people at Gitmo who were turned over for the cash reward. Despite all the claims of uncovering terrorists' plots, they have a couple of osama wannabes in Florida and some guys in England who talked about mixing some liquids on a plane. Bombs that went off in Madrid and London were not caught ahead of time. Reporters have been arrested, war and government protesters investigated and spied on.

Yet you and Gum talk as if all the actions here from torture to holding innocent people without trial are legitimate security actions. I don't see it that way. I think torturing anyone is unacceptable, but even from a security standpoint, many experts feel it does nothing but gain false information which wastes time pursuing. I don't want Canadians picked up in airports and sent off to be tortured in Syria. If there's evidence, arrest them and try them here. If there isn't enough evidence to arrest them then don't arrest them, I'll risk it, thank you.
 
Aha, but was he from Holland or the Netherlands? And if the latter, can you guess what I'm going to say about having an "English" registered car?

But that's just my personal bugbear, as you all know.....:boggled:

Den Haag.

With respect to the registration, I did think about this before posting. The car was registered in Buckinghamshire, so English is correct.

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom