So, You're Living In A Police State.

He wasn't an ex-POW. On paper he still WAS a POW. Which is my point. He was never repatriated.

-Gumboot

Yep, I made a mistake in what I typed. I don't know whether it would make a difference to what I said.

As a derail, when I was doing fire resistance testing, one of my customers was a component manufacturer from South Wales. A representative of that company was an ex POW (German paratrooper). He joined the British Legion, as he said, "they asked if I had been in the armed forces, they didn't ask which side".

Dave
 
A) Protected persons (people who SHOULD be there, including civilians and enemy combatants)
B) Non-protected persons (people who SHOULD NOT be there, such as mercenaries).

And how exactly is it decided who should be there and who shouldn't? If someone is shooting at your troops, they are an enemy combatant (or an American if your troops are British). If they are not shooting at your troops they are a civilian. Category B consists of people who are not involved in combat, but are not not involved in combat. Even if you somehow define category B as mercenaries who are magically not enemies or combatants, that would mean they are being paid to fight for a cause that is not their own, which is not the case for anyone who voluntarily joined Al Quaeda to fight for what they believed.

People in category B) have no rights whatsoever.

Great idea. Lets just lock them up for a few years and torture them shall we? Do you really believe they don't have the right to food, water, air, not being tortured, having someone actually prove that they are guilty of anything at all? If so I really hope I never meet you or anyone like you.
 
And how exactly is it decided who should be there and who shouldn't? If someone is shooting at your troops, they are an enemy combatant (or an American if your troops are British). If they are not shooting at your troops they are a civilian. Category B consists of people who are not involved in combat, but are not not involved in combat. Even if you somehow define category B as mercenaries who are magically not enemies or combatants, that would mean they are being paid to fight for a cause that is not their own, which is not the case for anyone who voluntarily joined Al Quaeda to fight for what they believed.



Great idea. Lets just lock them up for a few years and torture them shall we? Do you really believe they don't have the right to food, water, air, not being tortured, having someone actually prove that they are guilty of anything at all? If so I really hope I never meet you or anyone like you.
Consequences mut be consistent-and known. Mercenaries got not gripe. The consequences of beeing caught are well known--a subject of international law. Tends to thin the herd.
The entire object of people losing their lives for a cause is to further that cause. In the case of a young man in the field, that cause is not some lofty purpose--it is simply to protect himself and his buddies.
You catch a gun-toting individual in the area, he is guilty. Period. No need for a trial--he's bloody well carrying a gun. If he resists, he's DRT. If he surrenders, he's a POW.
You do not turn POW's loose to repeat their sins on the dead guy's buddies. That would mean his death was a total waste. You keep POW's until it is safe for your people to let him go.
Mercenaries--like spies-- are made an example of.
Consequences mut be consistent-and known. Mercenaries got no gripe. The consequences of being caught are well known--a subject of international law. Tends to thin the herd.
It will maybe slow down any influx of outsiders who are simply in it for the money/glory.
 
Pard, you and Gumboot both keep repeating the Bush mantra

And you're repeating the anti-Bush mantra, so?

Why are you so confident Bush is only going after terrorists and men in battle?

Because they are.

They have arrested and torture resulted of innocent men. There are kids at Gitmo under age 16, no trial, no judge to decide if the kid was forced to fight, coerced to fight or was actually old enough to be considered responsible. There are innocent people at Gitmo who were turned over for the cash reward. Despite all the claims of uncovering terrorists' plots, they have a couple of osama wannabes in Florida and some guys in England who talked about mixing some liquids on a plane. Bombs that went off in Madrid and London were not caught ahead of time. Reporters have been arrested, war and government protesters investigated and spied on.

Why would the Bush administration deliberately arrest innocents and minors? What would be the purpose of that? And what about the guilty people that did get arrested, the terrorist plots that did get twarted thanks to these arrests?

War can't be perfect, especially with an ennemy like al Qaeda, who don't fight according to any conventions.

ETA: Tell me, how would you fight the terrorists, and the states and people who finance, train and harbor them?
 
Last edited:
And how exactly is it decided who should be there and who shouldn't? If someone is shooting at your troops, they are an enemy combatant (or an American if your troops are British). If they are not shooting at your troops they are a civilian.


The international laws of armed conflict determine who should and shouldn't be there. Bear in mind these groupings only apply once you DETAIN someone. While in combat, ANYONE or ANYTHING that is being employed to wage war against your side is a legitimate target. And that includes a five year old boy with a pair of binoculars and a radio, or a hospital with a machine gun nest on it.



Category B consists of people who are not involved in combat, but are not not involved in combat. Even if you somehow define category B as mercenaries who are magically not enemies or combatants, that would mean they are being paid to fight for a cause that is not their own, which is not the case for anyone who voluntarily joined Al Quaeda to fight for what they believed.


The above statement doesn't make sense, but let me explain in further detail.

It is illegal, under the international laws of armed conflict, to partake in a conflict that does not involve your nation. Third-party involvement is prohibited. These are broadly labelled as "mercenaries". So if there's a war in Afghanistan between the Taliban on one side, and the USA/Northern Alliance/Coalition on the other side, anyone from a foreign country fighting on the Taliban side is violating the laws of armed conflict. That includes all non-Afghani members of Al Qaeda.




Great idea. Lets just lock them up for a few years and torture them shall we?


That's a strawman. I never said torturing people was acceptable.




Do you really believe they don't have the right to food, water, air, not being tortured, having someone actually prove that they are guilty of anything at all? If so I really hope I never meet you or anyone like you.

We're talking about the Geneva Conventions. They have no rights under the Geneva Conventions. If you don't like that, fair enough. But that's the law.

You're also, like others, trying to apply civil law to war. You can't. Note you said "prove they are guilty of anything at all".

As if there should be a trial with evidence, and a jury to convict them or find them not guilty.

That's not how it works at all, in war. Here's how it works in war:

Soldiers are in a gun battle. They finally defeat the enemy and storm into their strong point, capturing a number of them. One of them turns out to be a foreigner. That means he's a mercenary, and not protected by the Geneva Convention.

EVERYTHING, and I do mean EVERYTHING, in armed conflict is determined by PERCEPTION, not fact.

For example. It's illegal to bomb a hospital. But if you THINK the enemy have weapons in the hospital you are allowed to bomb it. It's actually IRRELEVANT whether they do or not. What matters is what you THINK is happening.

This is a fundamental part of armed conflict law, and if you do not comprehend this basic aspect, you won't ever understand the nature of warfare and its laws.

-Gumboot
 
emphasis mine

Are you unaware of the people detained while in all these countries, or just ignoring or denying they exist?


The CIA renditions are an entirely separate issue. As far as I am aware it's utterly illegal, and any sort of activity like that should be stopped.

I'm talking about the Al Qaeda members captured in Afghanistan and held at Guantanamo Bay.

-Gumboot
 
There are kids at Gitmo under age 16, no trial, no judge to decide if the kid was forced to fight, coerced to fight or was actually old enough to be considered responsible.


A five year old kid with a pair of binoculars, calling out your troop positions over a radio is an enemy combatant, and you can drop a mortar round on his head. War is an ugly nasty business for EVERYONE involved. It's not pretty and it's not fair.

Do you think the Hitler Youth who fought at the end of WW2 got trials before the US bombed them and shot them?


Yet you and Gum talk as if all the actions here from torture to holding innocent people without trial are legitimate security actions.


I have never said any such thing. I expect you will quote where I said anything of that nature, or withdraw your false statement? I don't appreciate having lies spoken about me.

-Gumboot
 
And you're repeating the anti-Bush mantra, so?
I'm discussing what the evidence shows, not what the talking points memo said.

Because they are.
In other words, you have no evidence, only the words of a president who has no credibility according to the majority of Americans. And I have evidence, lots of it from multiple sources.

Why would the Bush administration deliberately arrest innocents and minors? What would be the purpose of that? And what about the guilty people that did get arrested, the terrorist plots that did get twarted thanks to these arrests?

War can't be perfect, especially with an ennemy like al Qaeda, who don't fight according to any conventions.

ETA: Tell me, how would you fight the terrorists, and the states and people who finance, train and harbor them?
What you are blind to here Pard is some of the people arrested and tortured were the result of sheer incompetence and the refusal to own up to it. They kept the German man several months after they knew he was innocent because they were afraid to tell the German government. Then they dumped him off someplace. No apology, not even a ride home.

No apology to the Canadian and they left him on the no fly list.

All of this is to protect their own asses from embarrassment. How would you like to linger in a prison a few extra months just because the people who arrested you by mistake don't want to look bad by admitting their incompetence.

The other people being harassed by the Bush admin are political protesters. Protest the war, expect to be on the watch list. Do it enough and you get on the no fly list. Do it and write for the news media and you might get a subpoena to reveal your sources or go to jail. They, like the Nixon admin are using their office to suppress political opposition by intimidation and harassment.
 
The CIA renditions are an entirely separate issue. As far as I am aware it's utterly illegal, and any sort of activity like that should be stopped.

I'm talking about the Al Qaeda members captured in Afghanistan and held at Guantanamo Bay.

-Gumboot
First, if the CIA renditions are a separate issue, do you really think half of the Bush admin is following the rules and half isn't?

And as for Al Qaeda, what about the people turned in for cash rewards? Don't you think that obviously netted innocent people?
 
A five year old kid with a pair of binoculars, calling out your troop positions over a radio is an enemy combatant, and you can drop a mortar round on his head. War is an ugly nasty business for EVERYONE involved. It's not pretty and it's not fair.

Do you think the Hitler Youth who fought at the end of WW2 got trials before the US bombed them and shot them?





I have never said any such thing. I expect you will quote where I said anything of that nature, or withdraw your false statement? I don't appreciate having lies spoken about me.

-Gumboot
You don't hold 5 year old kids responsible because someone made them do something. You may need to deprogram them. But you don't hold them responsible. What choice does a 5 year old have?

In the case of the young detainees, a court and defense lawyer would be a reasonable expectation.

I'm glad to hear you don't agree with torture or the special renditions. Your posts, #105 and #95, from my review of lots of evidence, just don't reflect what is actually going on. So while it's nice you only support the ideal moral 'Geneva Conventions in war' examples you cited, that is idealistic view and reality is much different. If you think the idealistic version is occurring and I see evidence that isn't the case, then which statements have I made that were false about your position here?

You believe these guys are following the rules. You only agree it's OK if they are following the rules.

They aren't following the rules. Your support of the actions being taken is unjustified.

I do believe the majority of soldiers are doing their best to follow the rules. But they are some of the ones who reported about the cash rewards not bringing in Taliban fighters. Unfortunately those complaints were ignored and it certainly appears that was willful ignorance on the part of the top leaders. It's all about the politics of looking good, looking competent, looking successful fighting the "war on terrorism" while your crony friends suck billions out of the taxpayer pockets and you get re-elected.

But the facade can only hold up so long before people start to see what's really behind it. The fact Bush is no longer getting the support of the people in this country is evidence that facade isn't holding up. If those rules were being followed, Bush would have a lot more support than he does.
 
Last edited:
Excellent posts, SkeptiGirl.

Let's face it: if Gitmo had happened under a Democratic President, these guys would be calling it the worst atrocity in history.
 
Last edited:
Double standard on politics at JREF

The politics forum is that way ---->
Sounds like I stepped on a corn.

There are whole threads here devoted to calling Democratic politicians "woo-woos," based on phrases heard in YouTube clips. The threads are nothing more than partisan smears at Democrats, disguised as conspiracy debunkings.

These threads go on and on and are filled with cheesy put-downs of Democrats by our right-wing brethren. They have nothing to do with the pros and cons of conspiracy theories. And no one seems to think this crap should be moved to the politics section.

I submit there is a blatant double standard about politics at JREF. The wingers at JREF use conspiracy theories as a way to smear Democrats all the time. If they can play politics in the conspiracy forum, so can I.
 
Last edited:
In other words, you have no evidence, only the words of a president who has no credibility according to the majority of Americans. And I have evidence, lots of it from multiple sources.

I don't even know what we're talking about anymore, that's what happens when you keep switching the goalposts. I'm asking simple questions about the terrorists we are fighting, and yet you keep moving the blame back to the US. Why is that?

Are we fighting Al Qaeda and the people who sponsor them in Iraq and Afghanistan? Yes, there is ample proof of that. Ask any military person.

Are we surveilling Al Qaeda and other terrorist cells all over the planet? Yes, there is ample proof of that.

Now, is AlQaeda and their friends fighting according to Geneva conventions? No.

Thank you.

So what would be your plan to fight the terrorists, and the people who help them?
 
Last edited:
Excellent posts, SkeptiGirl.

Let's face it: if Gitmo had happened under a Democratic President, these guys would be calling it the worst atrocity in history.
There go the CT loons again...
Politics is elsewhere.
I want evidence of the truth of your spoutings. Not proof--just evidence.
You got none. I resent your characterization of myself and others who think similar thoughts. STFU, please, or put up.
 
There are whole threads here devoted to calling Democratic politicians "woo-woos," based on phrases heard in YouTube clips. The threads are nothing more than partisan smears at Democrats, disguised as conspiracy debunkings.

I think you're making a mountain out of a molehill. People who believe CTs are all over the political map.
 
I don't even know what we're talking about anymore, that's what happens when you keep switching the goalposts. I'm asking simple questions about the terrorists we are fighting, and yet you keep moving the blame back to the US. Why is that?

Are we fighting Al Qaeda and the people who sponsor them in Iraq and Afghanistan? Yes, there is ample proof of that. Ask any military person.

Are we surveilling Al Qaeda and other terrorist cells all over the planet? Yes, there is ample proof of that.

Now, is AlQaeda and their friends fighting according to Geneva conventions? No.

Thank you.

So what would be your plan to fight the terrorists, and the people who help them?
Seems like "switching goalposts" has become a claim when convenient but not necessarily when it is factual. I have switched no goal posts but you may have lost track of the exchange. That happens often with forum format.

Bush and company claim they are fighting Al Qaeda and they imply they are fighting Al Qaeda and "terrorists" exclusively. But they have included many innocent people in their fight and they have sought to cover that fact up.

In addition, they have used the "fighting terrorists" as an excuse to do all sorts of things that benefited themselves and their cronies as well as to intimidate political opponents. And they exaggerate the "be afraid" mantra as a campaign tactic.

You seem to be sticking to the claim everything these guys do is legitimate and correct. That is not the case.


There are two subjects here when you speak of fighting terrorists. One is fighting terrorists, the other is fixing Iraq.

In an oversimplified summary of what I would do, in Iraq, hire Iraqis, not crony held companies, rebuild the infrastructure, get out of their oil fields, stop building and occupying permanent bases. Provide medical care and stop killing ANY/ALL collaterals.

It's already such a mess there are a lot of details needed to get to those goals.

For terrorism itself, invest in getting out of oil. With all the billions we are wasting on war, we could probably do it easily. Invest in security in the way of inspecting cargo containers, making air travel safer, monitoring the borders properly and efforts of that nature. I could accept spying if it were truly being used for terrorism. But instead, Bush has been spying on news reporters to find and or intimidate "leakers' who leak politically damaging information, not security information. There's more but this is the idea.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom