And how exactly is it decided who should be there and who shouldn't? If someone is shooting at your troops, they are an enemy combatant (or an American if your troops are British). If they are not shooting at your troops they are a civilian.
The international laws of armed conflict determine who should and shouldn't be there. Bear in mind these groupings only apply once you DETAIN someone. While in combat, ANYONE or ANYTHING that is being employed to wage war against your side is a legitimate target. And that includes a five year old boy with a pair of binoculars and a radio, or a hospital with a machine gun nest on it.
Category B consists of people who are not involved in combat, but are not not involved in combat. Even if you somehow define category B as mercenaries who are magically not enemies or combatants, that would mean they are being paid to fight for a cause that is not their own, which is not the case for anyone who voluntarily joined Al Quaeda to fight for what they believed.
The above statement doesn't make sense, but let me explain in further detail.
It is illegal, under the international laws of armed conflict, to partake in a conflict that does not involve your nation. Third-party involvement is prohibited. These are broadly labelled as "mercenaries". So if there's a war in Afghanistan between the Taliban on one side, and the USA/Northern Alliance/Coalition on the other side, anyone from a foreign country fighting on the Taliban side is violating the laws of armed conflict. That includes all non-Afghani members of Al Qaeda.
Great idea. Lets just lock them up for a few years and torture them shall we?
That's a strawman. I never said torturing people was acceptable.
Do you really believe they don't have the right to food, water, air, not being tortured, having someone actually prove that they are guilty of anything at all? If so I really hope I never meet you or anyone like you.
We're talking about the Geneva Conventions. They have no rights under the Geneva Conventions. If you don't like that, fair enough. But that's the law.
You're also, like others, trying to apply civil law to war. You can't. Note you said "prove they are guilty of anything at all".
As if there should be a trial with evidence, and a jury to convict them or find them not guilty.
That's not how it works at all, in war. Here's how it works in war:
Soldiers are in a gun battle. They finally defeat the enemy and storm into their strong point, capturing a number of them. One of them turns out to be a foreigner. That means he's a mercenary, and not protected by the Geneva Convention.
EVERYTHING, and I do mean EVERYTHING, in armed conflict is determined by PERCEPTION, not fact.
For example. It's illegal to bomb a hospital. But if you THINK the enemy have weapons in the hospital you are allowed to bomb it. It's actually IRRELEVANT whether they do or not. What matters is what you THINK is happening.
This is a fundamental part of armed conflict law, and if you do not comprehend this basic aspect, you won't ever understand the nature of warfare and its laws.
-Gumboot