So, You're Living In A Police State.

There is an Australian citizen (David Hicks)being held in Guantanamo bay. He has been there 5 years. Our (Aus.) government won't ask to have him released because they say that when he was captured by US forces in Afghanistan he wasn't breaking any Australian laws.

WTF??

OK the guy had run off and joined the Taliban apparently, but they were not our enemy at the time. He hasn't been tried or found guilty of any crime and yet our government has done nothing to get him home.

He might be the biggest terrorist in the world, but I think he needs a trial at least.
 
There is an Australian citizen (David Hicks)being held in Guantanamo bay....He might be the biggest terrorist in the world, but I think he needs a trial at least.
This is truly horrible, my friend. There's no doubt the unelected right-wing extremists who have controlled the U.S. for the last six years have instituted police-state tactics wherever they could. There is no doubt they are war criminals.

The Constitution and the Republic have not been under such sustained attack since the days of the Civil War. Tragedies abound, and the amount of damage is severe. Truly, the years 2000-2006 constitute a dark page in American history.

Nevertheless, it seems to me that if the U.S. were a real police state (as opposed to a faltering republic), we would not even be seeing news stories about the horrors of Guantanamo and having debates about it on forums. Certainly, the conspiracy guys would not have radio and TV shows where they can say one irresponsible thing after another. Alex Jones would not be making a comfortable living off 9/11. That sounds more like a screwed-up republic than a dictatorship.

Fortunately, the Democrats have been called in to clean up the countless messes the Republicans have made. Talk about deja vu...
 
Last edited:
There is an Australian citizen (David Hicks)being held in Guantanamo bay. He has been there 5 years. Our (Aus.) government won't ask to have him released because they say that when he was captured by US forces in Afghanistan he wasn't breaking any Australian laws.

WTF??

OK the guy had run off and joined the Taliban apparently, but they were not our enemy at the time. He hasn't been tried or found guilty of any crime and yet our government has done nothing to get him home.

He might be the biggest terrorist in the world, but I think he needs a trial at least.
Our hypocritical government gave John Walker Lind a trial because he was an American citizen. His story was the same otherwise.
 
..

Nevertheless, it seems to me that if the U.S. were a real police state (as opposed to a faltering republic), we would not even be seeing news stories about the horrors of Guantanamo ..
Again, not to claim we are in a police state but the amount of secrecy about Guantanamo is extreme and you are not getting much. What we do know has come from a few people that have been released and a couple of Americans who told their story after leaving the military, and one Canadian who was an undercover spy for he US who also spoke up after leaving.
 
The Canadian undercover spy at Guantanamo, Abdurahman Khadr. I have heard him speak in a news interview on Democracy Now but I can't find the archived report. It was quite a while back. He certainly appears to be a credible witness and his story checked out as far as I know.
 
Not to go off on a tangent.....but does anyone else think we it's mildly funny when Alex Jones is getting all purple in the face while he's yelling about a Police State infront of like 20 cops. And he's able to walk away.


If they did arrest him, it would prove his point.

If they don't arrest him, it proves everyone else's point that he's a rule8ing psycho.

I don't get why he doesn't like bush - he is a right winger after all.
 
The problem with the American Police State is that nobody seems to have noticed whom its victims are.

What the Bush Administration is doing is they're interpreting the Constitutional protection of the rights of US Citizens completely literally, and by corollary deducing that non-US Citizens do not have the basic human rights guaranteed to everybody. Even the 14th Amendment, introduced specifically to make sure that it was understood that anybody born in the US was a US Citizen and could not be deprived of the same rights as everybody else, whether they were ex-slaves or not, has been perverted to be interpreted as meaning that only US Citizens have the natural human rights that everybody is supposed to enjoy.

And this is nonsense. There actually isn't a country in the world, regardless of their politicial system that does not treat foreigners under suspicion of crime, in the exact same way that they treat their own citizens. The United States has had 230 years of law, plenty of time to have accumulated what must be as many as thousands of cases of non-US Citizens standing trial. But throughout that time, the fact that a defendant was not actually a US Citizen has not meant in practice that they were deprived of the right of Habeus Corpus, that unwarranted searches were conducted in their domiciles, that they were deprived of due process, the right to counsel, or trial by jury.

In point of fact, quite apart from prosecuting foreigners who happen to be accused of crimes in the United States, America is quite happy to drag foreign citizens to the United States in order to prosecute them for crimes which never took place on American soil. But again, in those cases the defendants have legal counsel, have been given bail rights, and were only remanded (to custody or bail) after a hearing.

For some reason, if a) the foreigner in question is at least Arabic-looking that means that b) the War on Terror can be invoked and the rights to due process and freedom from unreasonable searches can just be thrown out of the window.

The new law that was passed with the help of Republican congressmen who knew it was unconstitutional is the latest form of that kind of abuse. Note that even the liberal establishment have complained that the problem with the law is that it gives the President the right to determine who is and who isn't an American citizen specifically so that they can be treated differently (locked up without trial, tortured, etc) - and yet nobody seems to have noticed that in fact, regardless of what it says in the Constitution, there are in fact no grounds whatsoever for treating non-US Citizens differently from US Citizens.

It is in fact a demonstration of the strength of the Constitution and its chief justification and vindication that the Administration only even dares to do these things to non-citizens. And I personally think its a severe indictment of even the most liberal people, even those who have contributed on this topic, that the main problem was that it was done to a Canadian-Syrian.

The closing of Guantanamo Bay has to be the first priority when Hillary Clinton takes over, doubly so if it's actually John McCain. Or America can be rightly pilloried for having besmeared its reputation in the world for having destroyed the standards that the whole world looks to it to formulate and uphold.
 
The problem with the American Police State is that nobody seems to have noticed whom its victims are.

What the Bush Administration is doing is they're interpreting the Constitutional protection of the rights of US Citizens completely literally, and by corollary deducing that non-US Citizens do not have the basic human rights guaranteed to everybody. Even the 14th Amendment, introduced specifically to make sure that it was understood that anybody born in the US was a US Citizen and could not be deprived of the same rights as everybody else, whether they were ex-slaves or not, has been perverted to be interpreted as meaning that only US Citizens have the natural human rights that everybody is supposed to enjoy.

And this is nonsense. There actually isn't a country in the world, regardless of their politicial system that does not treat foreigners under suspicion of crime, in the exact same way that they treat their own citizens. The United States has had 230 years of law, plenty of time to have accumulated what must be as many as thousands of cases of non-US Citizens standing trial. But throughout that time, the fact that a defendant was not actually a US Citizen has not meant in practice that they were deprived of the right of Habeus Corpus, that unwarranted searches were conducted in their domiciles, that they were deprived of due process, the right to counsel, or trial by jury.

In point of fact, quite apart from prosecuting foreigners who happen to be accused of crimes in the United States, America is quite happy to drag foreign citizens to the United States in order to prosecute them for crimes which never took place on American soil. But again, in those cases the defendants have legal counsel, have been given bail rights, and were only remanded (to custody or bail) after a hearing.

For some reason, if a) the foreigner in question is at least Arabic-looking that means that b) the War on Terror can be invoked and the rights to due process and freedom from unreasonable searches can just be thrown out of the window.

The new law that was passed with the help of Republican congressmen who knew it was unconstitutional is the latest form of that kind of abuse. Note that even the liberal establishment have complained that the problem with the law is that it gives the President the right to determine who is and who isn't an American citizen specifically so that they can be treated differently (locked up without trial, tortured, etc) - and yet nobody seems to have noticed that in fact, regardless of what it says in the Constitution, there are in fact no grounds whatsoever for treating non-US Citizens differently from US Citizens.

It is in fact a demonstration of the strength of the Constitution and its chief justification and vindication that the Administration only even dares to do these things to non-citizens. And I personally think its a severe indictment of even the most liberal people, even those who have contributed on this topic, that the main problem was that it was done to a Canadian-Syrian.

The closing of Guantanamo Bay has to be the first priority when Hillary Clinton takes over, doubly so if it's actually John McCain. Or America can be rightly pilloried for having besmeared its reputation in the world for having destroyed the standards that the whole world looks to it to formulate and uphold.
Take this to Politics guys. This is not the place.
 
Sorry, I continued to post, because I assumed the whole thread would be taken over there by a moderator.
 
Again, not to claim we are in a police state but the amount of secrecy about Guantanamo is extreme and you are not getting much.

Didn't UN and Human Rights organisations have had plenty of access to it, and did visit it in a number of occasions?
 
There is an Australian citizen (David Hicks)being held in Guantanamo bay. He has been there 5 years. Our (Aus.) government won't ask to have him released because they say that when he was captured by US forces in Afghanistan he wasn't breaking any Australian laws.

He fought along side the Taliban. I'd say that's enough reason to detain him.
 
I agree skeptigirl.

We know the US isn't a police state and neither is Australia, but to quote some famous old white guy: "The nation which gives up freedom to gain security will loose both and deserve neither" (or something like that).

The war on terror could IMO be called the biggest recruitment drive for terrorists since Mohammad played fullback for Mecca.


The quote is actually:
Those who give up essential liberty to gain temporary security deserve neither liberty nor security.

The two bolded words are the key part of the quote, and they are often left out.

-Gumboot
 
There is an Australian citizen (David Hicks)being held in Guantanamo bay. He has been there 5 years. Our (Aus.) government won't ask to have him released because they say that when he was captured by US forces in Afghanistan he wasn't breaking any Australian laws.

WTF??

OK the guy had run off and joined the Taliban apparently, but they were not our enemy at the time. He hasn't been tried or found guilty of any crime and yet our government has done nothing to get him home.

He might be the biggest terrorist in the world, but I think he needs a trial at least.


I don't want to go off into politics here, but I just thought I'd point out that this guy (and many others) could be classed in two ways.

A) They are enemy combatants, and therefore POWs, and should be detained by the USA until such time as the war ends and they are no longer considered a threat, after which they can be repatriated to Afghanistan. They should be granted all rights owed to them under the Geneva Convention and the Hague.

However, once the war in Afghanistan ends and they are repatriated to Afghanistan, what Afghanistan decides to do to them for fighting with the Taliban is Afghanistan's concern. Bear in mind, repatriation does not occur the instant hostilities end. After WW2 the British did not repatriate German POWs until they were convinced they had relinquished their Nazi ideology. Some Germans remained POWs for decades, and one particular German; Rudi Lux, was never repatriated, and died in Britain in 2004, technically still a POW (he even continued reporting to a local police station until 1961). There is, therefore, a historic precedent for the US refusing the repatriate these POWs until such time as they relinquish their Fundamental Islamic ideology.

Or alternatively;

B) As he is an Australian, not an Afghani, he is a mercenary, acting in violation of the International Laws of Armed Conflict. Under the Geneva Conventions and the Hague, Mercenaries are not protected persons, therefore not offered any protection or rights.

In previous wars captured mercenaries (especially if citizens of states allied with the opposition) were usually summarily executed.

However, in this instance, some sort of investigation would need to be carried out by a military tribunal to determine if the prisoners are mercenaries (illegal combatants). Until such a determination is made, they are to be treated like other protected persons. The US has shot itself in the foot by determining that it is not allowed to carry out such a tribunal (an interesting determination by the US Judiciary, since such a tribunal is actually a REQUIREMENT under International Law, and the US has signed and ratified said laws, thus the US Judiciary's determination is in violation of the laws of armed conflict). Until such a tribunal goes ahead, therefore, the POWs must be held like a regular POW - and that means continuing to be held without trial.

Confused yet?

-Gumboot
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom