The problem with the American Police State is that nobody seems to have noticed whom its victims are.
What the Bush Administration is doing is they're interpreting the Constitutional protection of the rights of US Citizens completely literally, and by corollary deducing that non-US Citizens do
not have the basic human rights guaranteed to everybody. Even the 14th Amendment, introduced specifically to make sure that it was understood that anybody born in the US was a US Citizen and could not be deprived of the same rights as everybody else, whether they were ex-slaves or not, has been perverted to be interpreted as meaning that
only US Citizens have the natural human rights that everybody is supposed to enjoy.
And this is nonsense. There actually isn't a country in the world,
regardless of their politicial system that does not treat foreigners under suspicion of crime, in the exact same way that they treat their own citizens. The United States has had 230 years of law, plenty of time to have accumulated what must be as many as thousands of cases of non-US Citizens standing trial. But throughout that time, the fact that a defendant was not actually a US Citizen has not meant in practice that they were deprived of the right of
Habeus Corpus, that unwarranted searches were conducted in their domiciles, that they were deprived of due process, the right to counsel, or trial by jury.
In point of fact, quite apart from prosecuting foreigners who happen to be accused of crimes in the United States, America is quite happy to
drag foreign citizens to the United States in order to prosecute them for crimes which never took place on American soil. But again, in
those cases the defendants have legal counsel, have been given bail rights, and were only remanded (to custody or bail) after a hearing.
For some reason, if a) the foreigner in question is at
least Arabic-
looking that means that b) the War on Terror can be invoked and the rights to
due process and freedom from
unreasonable searches can just be thrown out of the window.
The new law that was passed with the help of Republican congressmen who knew it was unconstitutional is the latest form of that kind of abuse. Note that even the liberal establishment have complained that the problem with the law is that it gives the President the right to determine who is and who isn't an American citizen
specifically so that they can be treated differently (locked up without trial, tortured, etc) - and yet nobody seems to have noticed that in fact,
regardless of what it says in the Constitution, there are in fact
no grounds whatsoever for treating non-US Citizens differently from US Citizens.
It is in fact a demonstration of the strength of the Constitution
and its chief justification and vindication that the Administration only even dares to do these things to non-citizens. And I personally think its a severe indictment of even the most liberal people, even those who have contributed on this topic, that the main problem was that it was done to a
Canadian-Syrian.
The closing of Guantanamo Bay has to be the first priority when Hillary Clinton takes over,
doubly so if it's actually John McCain. Or America can be rightly pilloried for having besmeared its reputation in the world for having destroyed the standards that the whole world looks to it to formulate and uphold.