So, You're Living In A Police State.

If you're an illegal detainee, you should be released.


By this I assume you mean the people allegedly snatched by the CIA in foreign countries such as in European states?

I agree completely. Those people are not involved in a war. They're criminal suspects who should be treated like any other criminal suspect (tried and convicted or released). Like any other criminal suspect, they also should be arrested, with all rights and protcols that entails, not simply snatched off the street.

If insufficient evidence exists to arrest them, they should be left the hell alone.

-Gumboot
 
Fine, I'll repeat myself AGAIN. This time please pay attention.

There are two separate issues being discussed here.

1) The detainment of people by the USA
2) The treatment of these detainees

The discussion was initially raised on point 1) with the argument that it is not acceptable to detain people without trial.

I have continually and consistantly tried to explain that the nature of "detainment" in regards to warfare is not the same as "arrest" under which civil detainment occurs.

Despite explaining this repeatedly, you still don't seem to get it.

Point 2) was later raised in an effort to prop up the weakness of the initial argument. From the get-go I have made it ABUNDANTLY clear that I do not support the mistreatment of detainees.

Your argument essentially appears to be that the legality of 1) should be rejected because of the illegality of 2). This is flawed reasoning.

If people are being tortured, the correct response is not to let them go. It is to determine who is doing the torturing, punish that person, and prevent future torture.

Given that prisoner abuse in US custody has been, and continues to be investigated, and people have been, and will continue to be prosecuted for mistreatment, it appears things are working as they should, if reluctantly.

Let's just make something absolutely clear, however. If you are a detainee, and are tortured, that torture does not then mean you deserve to be released.

-Gumboot
The train of thought you lost here was on the very young detainees at Gitmo and the idea you think blowing up a 5 yr old is peechy keen.

Re your view of what has happened at Gitmo and with the other detention locations, and what continues to happen, you are simply ignoring the volume of credible evidence and maintaining a fairytale version in your mind about what is occurring. It's too bad you believe the John Wayne version of reality when we really need people to maintain oversight over the dangerous direction this administration has taken this country. They have made torture an overt policy and you speak as if a few incidents are being rightly investigated.
 
The train of thought you lost here was on the very young detainees at Gitmo and the idea you think blowing up a 5 yr old is peechy keen.


How young? 16? We dont consider 16 that young here. I understand it's very young for Americans. We grow up faster here.

Feel like quoting where I thought anything about war was "peechy [sic] keen"?



Re your view of what has happened at Gitmo and with the other detention locations, and what continues to happen, you are simply ignoring the volume of credible evidence and maintaining a fairytale version in your mind about what is occurring.


I don't have a version of what's happening there. I couldn't care less. None of my countrymen are there.




It's too bad you believe the John Wayne version of reality when we really need people to maintain oversight over the dangerous direction this administration has taken this country.


Again, this isn't something that concerns me. If you want to sort your country out, go for it. I couldn't care less.



They have made torture an overt policy and you speak as if a few incidents are being rightly investigated.

Actually it was my understanding that they recently (in the past 6 months) decided actually they WOULD follow the rules (hardly a decision worth applauding since they never should have deviated from them) and it was this decision which in part intiated all of the ongoing investigations.

If you have issues with it go write a letter to your Congressman. Just don't expect someone living thousands of miles away on the other side of the Pacific to care.

-Gumboot
 
The train of thought you lost here was on the very young detainees at Gitmo and the idea you think blowing up a 5 yr old is peechy keen.

I believe the specific example was of a 5 year old kid being used to aid enemy fighters in a war zone.

For instance, let us assume a 5 year old child is placed on a rooftop with a radio and binoculars and is being used to guide enemy fighters towards the location of an army patrol

Let's also assume that you are in charge of the patrol. If that 5 year old continues to reveal your position, you or your soldiers might die.

How do YOU stop that?

Now let us assume that the child is actually 14 and is somehow able to be captured alive. Although 14, the child is adamant that, if released, they will keep fighting.

How do YOU prevent that?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom