Fine, I'll repeat myself AGAIN. This time please pay attention.
There are two separate issues being discussed here.
1) The detainment of people by the USA
2) The treatment of these detainees
The discussion was initially raised on point 1) with the argument that it is not acceptable to detain people without trial.
I have continually and consistantly tried to explain that the nature of "detainment" in regards to warfare is not the same as "arrest" under which civil detainment occurs.
Despite explaining this repeatedly, you still don't seem to get it.
Point 2) was later raised in an effort to prop up the weakness of the initial argument. From the get-go I have made it ABUNDANTLY clear that I do not support the mistreatment of detainees.
Your argument essentially appears to be that the legality of 1) should be rejected because of the illegality of 2). This is flawed reasoning.
If people are being tortured, the correct response is not to let them go. It is to determine who is doing the torturing, punish that person, and prevent future torture.
Given that prisoner abuse in US custody has been, and continues to be investigated, and people have been, and will continue to be prosecuted for mistreatment, it appears things are working as they should, if reluctantly.
Let's just make something absolutely clear, however. If you are a detainee, and are tortured, that torture does not then mean you deserve to be released.
-Gumboot