So, You're Living In A Police State.

There go the CT loons again...
Politics is elsewhere.
I want evidence of the truth of your spoutings. Not proof--just evidence.
....
Right. Eight years of Monicagate and all the other relentless attacks on the most insignificant matters during the Clinton years aren't evidence.
 
Bush and company claim they are fighting Al Qaeda and they imply they are fighting Al Qaeda and "terrorists" exclusively.

But they are fighting terrorists, that's my point. There are terrorists in Afghanistan, who are helping the Taliban, and terrorists in Iraq helping the insurgency. So the US is fighting terrorists in these countries.

In addition, they have used the "fighting terrorists" as an excuse to do all sorts of things that benefited themselves and their cronies as well as to intimidate political opponents.

These political opponents (Iran) are helping the terrorists, so they are part of the War on terror.

And they exaggerate the "be afraid" mantra as a campaign tactic.

Why do you keep denying the reality of the threat of Islamic terrorists? I find this really odd.

There are two subjects here when you speak of fighting terrorists. One is fighting terrorists, the other is fixing Iraq.

In an oversimplified summary of what I would do, in Iraq, hire Iraqis, not crony held companies, rebuild the infrastructure, get out of their oil fields, stop building and occupying permanent bases. Provide medical care and stop killing ANY/ALL collaterals.

How can you do all that when Al Qaeda is helping the insurgency? How can you help Iraq rebuild when terrorists are boming Baghdad every day? How can you do all that without the use of force? Iraq needs to be secure beffore all of that can be done.

For terrorism itself, invest in getting out of oil. With all the billions we are wasting on war, we could probably do it easily.

Good idea, but oil can't be replaced that fast. I agree we should invest in other technologies but it won't happen overnight.

Invest in security in the way of inspecting cargo containers, making air travel safer, monitoring the borders properly and efforts of that nature.

All that is being done already.

I could accept spying if it were truly being used for terrorism.

It is.

But instead, Bush has been spying on news reporters to find and or intimidate "leakers' who leak politically damaging information, not security information.

I'm afraid I don't know much about that, but it seems very anecdotal.
 
These political opponents (Iran) are helping the terrorists, so they are part of the War on terror.
No they aren't. They are Bush opponents who have nothing to do with terrorism.
Why do you keep denying the reality of the threat of Islamic terrorists? I find this really odd.
I haven't denied any terrorist threats. I do believe Bush has made things worse. That's a big difference.
How can you do all that when Al Qaeda is helping the insurgency? How can you help Iraq rebuild when terrorists are boming Baghdad every day? How can you do all that without the use of force? Iraq needs to be secure beffore all of that can be done....

Good idea, but oil can't be replaced that fast. I agree we should invest in other technologies but it won't happen overnight....
I told you it was the simplified version. The point is Bush has gone about everything very poorly, there were and still are other options. I think there are many things that could have been and still can be done differently. Why do you think Bush has done such a great job and why do you believe there isn't a better way?

It's so obvious Bush has really screwed up yet people like you just won't believe your eyes. And to think there is only one way, that's not even logical.

Cargo containers are not being inspected and the borders most certainly aren't secure. 14 million illegal immigrants didn't all get here by overstaying their tourist visas.

I'm afraid I don't know much about that, but it seems very anecdotal.
What do you mean it's anecdotal? Of course it's anecdotal. Are you expecting a scientific study to see if any incidents of this occurred?
 
Last edited:
No they aren't. They are Bush opponents who have nothing to do with terrorism.

Iran has a large influence over Palestine, Syria, and the Iraq radicals. If you honestly think that Iran doesn't have a bone to pick with the USA, do some research on the Iran Hostage Crisis. It's been 25 years in the making.
 
The point is Bush has gone about everything very poorly, there were and still are other options. I think there are many things that could have been and still can be done differently. Why do you think Bush has done such a great job and why do you believe there isn't a better way?

It's so obvious Bush has really screwed up yet people like you just won't believe your eyes. And to think there is only one way, that's not even logical.

Don't you think this sounds like you're making the "denying the antecedent" fallacy?

Bush says he is fighting terrorism.
Terrorism has not been beaten
Therefore, Bush is not fighting terrorism.

I agree that his administration hasn't done good job, it has done poorly, especially the decision to go to Iraq was a huge mistake. But that doesn't mean that they are not fighting terrorism.
 
Iran has a large influence over Palestine, Syria, and the Iraq radicals. If you honestly think that Iran doesn't have a bone to pick with the USA, do some research on the Iran Hostage Crisis. It's been 25 years in the making.
Where do you see me saying I'm talking about Iran?

I'm talking about anti-war protesters marching in Seattle which have nothing to do with terrorism now do they? How about the innocent Canadian and the innocent German who the CIA detained and had tortured? They weren't in the Middle East and they weren't terrorists. How about the news guy who filmed the WTO protests and is in jail on contempt because he won't testify in a grand jury to the names of people with masks on in his film? How about tapping the phones of the Wa Post reporters to find out who leaked politically embarrassing things from the White House? How about outing Valerie Plame to discredit Ambassador Wilson's report which said the report Bush was using to justify invading Iraq was false? We know now that the White house outed Plame and the intelligence used to claim WMDs were in Iraq was false.
 
Don't you think this sounds like you're making the "denying the antecedent" fallacy?

Bush says he is fighting terrorism.
Terrorism has not been beaten
Therefore, Bush is not fighting terrorism.

I agree that his administration hasn't done good job, it has done poorly, especially the decision to go to Iraq was a huge mistake. But that doesn't mean that they are not fighting terrorism.
For Pete's sake Pard, Bush is in the running for worst President the country ever had. Don't you read anything?

They lied to get in a war they thought would be a piece of cake, then they screwed up so badly that not only were they wrong, but they even made it worse than that.
 
For Pete's sake Pard, Bush is in the running for worst President the country ever had. Don't you read anything?

They lied to get in a war they thought would be a piece of cake, then they screwed up so badly that not only were they wrong, but they even made it worse than that.

I know all that Skeptigirl, my problem is that you seem to use Bush's mistakes to deny that the US is even fighting terrorism, which is wrong to me. The US is fighting terrorism, regardless of this administration's errors and corruption. That might be the only thing that they are saying that is true.
 
No, Bush is making mistake after mistake in his actions to fight terrorism. That's a big difference from your interpretation of my position.

We are worse off than if we had done nothing.
 
No, Bush is making mistake after mistake in his actions to fight terrorism. That's a big difference from your interpretation of my position.

We are worse off than if we had done nothing.

Let's just end my participation on this by saying --I'm glad there are folks like skeptigirl and perry around, but I'm even more glad that they are not in charge of our Nation's security.
ETA--see4 my signature line
 
First, if the CIA renditions are a separate issue, do you really think half of the Bush admin is following the rules and half isn't?


No, I think sometimes they're following the rules and sometimes they're not.



And as for Al Qaeda, what about the people turned in for cash rewards? Don't you think that obviously netted innocent people?


No, I don't think that's obvious. Why would it be obvious?



You don't hold 5 year old kids responsible because someone made them do something. You may need to deprogram them. But you don't hold them responsible. What choice does a 5 year old have?


What on earth are you talking about. It is FRIKKEN WARFARE. My God, some people really need a sharp dose of reality. If a five year old is helping the enemy kill your troops, you don't "deprogram" them, you frikken stop them any way you can. An airstrike usually does the trick.



In the case of the young detainees, a court and defense lawyer would be a reasonable expectation.


A court and defense lawyer for WHAT?



I'm glad to hear you don't agree with torture or the special renditions. Your posts, #105 and #95, from my review of lots of evidence, just don't reflect what is actually going on. So while it's nice you only support the ideal moral 'Geneva Conventions in war' examples you cited, that is idealistic view and reality is much different. If you think the idealistic version is occurring and I see evidence that isn't the case, then which statements have I made that were false about your position here?


You said I supported torture. I don't.


You believe these guys are following the rules. You only agree it's OK if they are following the rules.

They aren't following the rules. Your support of the actions being taken is unjustified.


My problem is not what they are doing. My problem is the characterisation of what they are doing that is given by ignorant people like you.

If people are being tortured, bad. If people are being snatched out of countries all over the place, bad. I agree on these points. But when you use the blanket argument "held for years without trial" (and you continued to use it in this post) you are displaying gross ignorance of the laws of war. Many of the people held by the US Government appear to be legitimate detainees that the US Government has the total right to detain indefinately. You might not like that. Tough. That's the law.

-Gumboot
 
Right Gummy, I'm ignorant. You would treat a 5 yr old POW no differently than an adult POW.

...

I was talking about combat. Not POWs.

A five year old kid with a pair of binoculars, calling out your troop positions over a radio is an enemy combatant, and you can drop a mortar round on his head. War is an ugly nasty business for EVERYONE involved. It's not pretty and it's not fair.

For F-'s sake, pay attention.

-Gumboot
 
...

I was talking about combat. Not POWs.



For F-'s sake, pay attention.

-Gumboot
Ok, I lied.
Gunboot:
What cynicgal and her ilk fail to see is that combat is a different world than, say, the streets of San Francisco-in some ways.
In either case, if someone is spraying your troops with gunfire, you make him stop. Now. By whatever means possible. Those are the rules you live by--quite literally. Police do have different ROE than soldiers, and she doesn't see that. In a combat zone, everyone that isn't you is a bad guy, and if he is shooting at you, he must be stopped. That means you shoot first and question later.
After he surrenders, the rules change. They don't see that, either. The fact that a POW actually lives better while a prisoner than he did as a combatant doesn't matter to these people. We have deprived them of freedom without a trial!
The fact that a trial is to establish guilt or innocence doesn't matter. They get upset and scream "unnecessary force" when a bank robber who has killed 2 people gets shot while in the act.
To these people, courts, not actual deeds, establish guilt.
 
Ok, I lied.
Gunboot:
What cynicgal and her ilk fail to see is that combat is a different world than, say, the streets of San Francisco-in some ways.
In either case, if someone is spraying your troops with gunfire, you make him stop. Now. By whatever means possible. Those are the rules you live by--quite literally. Police do have different ROE than soldiers, and she doesn't see that. In a combat zone, everyone that isn't you is a bad guy, and if he is shooting at you, he must be stopped. That means you shoot first and question later.
After he surrenders, the rules change. They don't see that, either. The fact that a POW actually lives better while a prisoner than he did as a combatant doesn't matter to these people. We have deprived them of freedom without a trial!
The fact that a trial is to establish guilt or innocence doesn't matter. They get upset and scream "unnecessary force" when a bank robber who has killed 2 people gets shot while in the act.
To these people, courts, not actual deeds, establish guilt.


The other thing the fail to understand is that, in war, detainment is not about "guilt" or "crime". It is about "threat" and "control".

You detain people - be they POWs, mercenaries, or civilians - because they either threaten your forces directly (i.e. by shooting at them) or they threaten your control of the region (such as refugees).

(Indeed, in some rare cases you're required to detain people for their own protection).

It's not about locking up criminals. It's about holding people who are hindering your war effort. They haven't necessarily done anything illegal. But until the war effort ends, you continue to detain them.

That's what people fail to understand. The war in Afghanistan is not over. The country is still unstable and dangerous, and the coalition is still fighting and dying there. Until all of this changes, the coalition will continue to detain ANYONE who hinders their operations there. That's how war works.

-Gumboot
 
skeptigirl:Right Gummy, I'm ignorant. You would treat a 5 yr old POW no differently than an adult POW.

Gummy: I was talking about combat. Not POWs.

Gummy:Quote:
A five year old kid with a pair of binoculars, calling out your troop positions over a radio is an enemy combatant, and you can drop a mortar round on his head. War is an ugly nasty business for EVERYONE involved. It's not pretty and it's not fair.
For F-'s sake, pay attention.
Right, and in addition to paying attention, maybe you should work on getting a longer attention span.

The exchange about minors started here:

skeptigirl: There are kids at Gitmo under age 16, no trial, no judge to decide if the kid was forced to fight, coerced to fight or was actually old enough to be considered responsible.

Gum: A five year old kid with a pair of binoculars, calling out your troop positions over a radio is an enemy combatant, and you can drop a mortar round on his head. War is an ugly nasty business for EVERYONE involved. It's not pretty and it's not fair.

Do you think the Hitler Youth who fought at the end of WW2 got trials before the US bombed them and shot them?


[and the last exchange was here]

skeptigirl: You don't hold 5 year old kids responsible because someone made them do something. You may need to deprogram them. But you don't hold them responsible. What choice does a 5 year old have?

Gum: What on earth are you talking about. It is FRIKKEN WARFARE. My God, some people really need a sharp dose of reality. If a five year old is helping the enemy kill your troops, you don't "deprogram" them, you frikken stop them any way you can. An airstrike usually does the trick.

skeptigirl: In the case of the young detainees, a court and defense lawyer would be a reasonable expectation.

Gum: A court and defense lawyer for WHAT?



I said there were minors at Gitmo that were pretty young and you went on with your fantasy that all the prisoners at Gitmo are guilty, no trial needed.

There are some prisoners in Gitmo who were NOT picked up on any battlefield and they haven't had a trial or access to any legal council. I'm sorry boys but that's unAmerican. You can fantasize it's "war" all you want. There is a war going on and there have been more than one battlefields, Gitmo isn't one of them.

Gitmo is Bush's wet dream of torturing hundreds of Al Qaeda "cowards" into revealing all their plots and giving up all their leaders so Bush could then point to his accomplishments and say he was doing a great job fighting those terrorists.

There were some claims about "they all broke" under the clever tactics of the CIA. Bill O'Reilly bragged about it. But it turned out of all the "information" obtained, almost none of it was useful and some of it wasted a lot of soldier's time.

O'Reilly on show interviewing Brian Ross from ABC about Ross's investigative report on Gitmo torture

The Factor reiterated that harsh tactics can be useful. "In all 14 cases coerced interrogation was used, and in all 14 cases they gave it up. And you say more than a dozen plots were stopped. I want to make it crystal clear that what we have said is true."


the real story from Ross himself

Nov. 18, 2005 — Harsh interrogation techniques authorized by top officials of the CIA have led to questionable confessions and the death of a detainee since the techniques were first authorized in mid-March 2002, ABC News has been told by former and current intelligence officers and supervisors.

It is "bad interrogation. I mean you can get anyone to confess to anything if the torture's bad enough," said former CIA officer Bob Baer.

"What real CIA field officers know firsthand is that it is better to build a relationship of trust … than to extract quick confessions through tactics such as those used by the Nazis and the Soviets."

His statements became part of the basis for the Bush administration claims that Iraq trained al Qaeda members to use biochemical weapons. Sources tell ABC that it was later established that al Libbi had no knowledge of such training or weapons and fabricated the statements because he was terrified of further harsh treatment.

"This is the problem with using the waterboard. They get so desperate that they begin telling you what they think you want to hear," one source said.

In Bush's State of the Union Addresses he has tried to claim all these successes foiling terror plots. If these guys had gotten any useful information, Bush wouldn't have had to exaggerate his claims of success citing the pitiful examples he cited. The successes were pitiful and both Spain and England's terrorist plots were not stopped.

We don't have Bin Laden. Al Qaeda and the Taliban have regrouped. Iraq is a mess after many strategic mistakes.

Enjoy your fantasies, boys. Some of us are paying attention to the real version. And finally the majority of Americans are getting the picture too.
 
Last edited:
Right, and in addition to paying attention, maybe you should work on getting a longer attention span.

Yadda yadda.


Fine, I'll repeat myself AGAIN. This time please pay attention.

There are two separate issues being discussed here.

1) The detainment of people by the USA
2) The treatment of these detainees

The discussion was initially raised on point 1) with the argument that it is not acceptable to detain people without trial.

I have continually and consistantly tried to explain that the nature of "detainment" in regards to warfare is not the same as "arrest" under which civil detainment occurs.

Despite explaining this repeatedly, you still don't seem to get it.

Point 2) was later raised in an effort to prop up the weakness of the initial argument. From the get-go I have made it ABUNDANTLY clear that I do not support the mistreatment of detainees.

Your argument essentially appears to be that the legality of 1) should be rejected because of the illegality of 2). This is flawed reasoning.

If people are being tortured, the correct response is not to let them go. It is to determine who is doing the torturing, punish that person, and prevent future torture.

Given that prisoner abuse in US custody has been, and continues to be investigated, and people have been, and will continue to be prosecuted for mistreatment, it appears things are working as they should, if reluctantly.

Let's just make something absolutely clear, however. If you are a detainee, and are tortured, that torture does not then mean you deserve to be released.

-Gumboot
 
If you're an illegal detainee, you should be released.

If this had happened under a Democratic President, everyone would call it the atrocity it is, and we could move on to other things.
 
Last edited:
If you're an illegal detainee, you should be released.

If this had happened under a Democratic President, everyone would call it the atrocity it is, and we could move on to other things.
Point 1: Nobody disagrees with that.
Point 2:
Evidence, not anecdotes, please.

It becomes completely obvious to me at least that if you knew what you were talking about,you'd be half-right about your wittiness.

The 911 troofers got nothing on you as far as conspiracy theories go, do they?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom