So, You're Living In A Police State.

It was bad intelligence from the RCMP that caused Arar's turmoil in the first place.

The US deported Arar based on that flawed intelligence.
The Canadians have said so, I'm not arguing that. The US still has Arar on the no fly list and listed as a terrorist suspect. Canada has tried to correct that and the US will not admit the error.

But keep in mind as well, even if the Canadians gave the US bad info, that's all it took for our lovely government to arrest, detain, and have this man tortured without a trial, without sufficient evidence, for no reason whatsoever except a ridiculous atmosphere of fear.
 
Last edited:
Amazingly, although we live in a Nazi-like police state, which commits mass murder against its own citizens and oppresses any dissenting view, very few of them seem the least bit worried about speaking publicly against the government. It is not exactly like they are Soviet dissidents, secretly passing around Samizdat type on hidden typewriters and listening to the BBC in the dead of the night.

Sure, like you really are James Bond! I actually live in Montreal. :D
 
I always find it funny when the CTs come out swinging, saying how we are on the verge of facism, all the crazy things the Gov't can do, etc.,etc.

What none of those idiots seem to realize is, if this was really the case, none of them would be spewing their idiocy in public. I mean, even Alex Jones can't believe half the stuff he says. They'd have him killed. Believe me, as big as his audience may be, MOST American's have never heard of him, and if he just simply dissapeared, no one would care.
 
Not nearly as funny as John Conner trying to get arrested for being a terrorist by playing in traffic while shouting "9/11 was an inside job!" in front of a police station. His conclusion (after not being arrested): "I guess there are still a few good cops left."
And a few good drivers, too. Damn...
 
It's more relaxing than I had imagined it would be.

No kidding! When I was with you guys at GZ back in September a B-2 bomber flew overhead and the bearded kook with the weird eyes said the flyover was to keeping an eye on him and the rest of the twoofers.

I asked him if he was the least bit scared by such a show of force and for some reason he refused to answer.

I mean, damn - how can these people think the guv sends up state of the art bombers to intimidate them and yet at the same time allows them to spew their message in public in the first place?
 
The Canadians have said so, I'm not arguing that. The US still has Arar on the no fly list and listed as a terrorist suspect. Canada has tried to correct that and the US will not admit the error.

But keep in mind as well, even if the Canadians gave the US bad info, that's all it took for our lovely government to arrest, detain, and have this man tortured without a trial, without sufficient evidence, for no reason whatsoever except a ridiculous atmosphere of fear.

That is true, he has been through a lot. But the government has been very forgiving to this man, who was rewarded around 10 million dollars for this grave mistake.

This is going to be a nice stain on the RCMP for quite some time
 
But keep in mind as well, even if the Canadians gave the US bad info, that's all it took for our lovely government to arrest, detain, and have this man tortured without a trial, without sufficient evidence, for no reason whatsoever except a ridiculous atmosphere of fear.

The US did not torture him, Syria did. It's true though that the problem is that they had to know that sending him to Syria would mean that he would be tortured, but you cannot say that the US tortured him, that is just factually wrong and an obviously politically loaded statement.

Also, because of 9/11, I don't think that your "ridiculous atmosphere of fear" statement is correct. It's an atmosphere of increased awareness and hightened security, for sure, which can lead to some mistakes, as in this case, but I don't think it is ridiculous. It could be less frantic, but it is not ridiculous.

If you really want to link this to some kind of idea that the US is turning into a police state, then you would need more than one example. Arar's case is a very nasty and unfortunate mistake nonetheless and I agree with you that the US should make somekind of apology and think twice before they deport someone again.
 
Last edited:
I always find it funny when the CTs come out swinging, saying how we are on the verge of facism, ....
When Nixon was about to resign, more than a few people were afraid he might declare martial law to remain in power. It didn't happen.

And there are people saying they fear again Bush could take some kind of action like that now.

I don't think the rest of the government would stand for it, nor do I think Bush could declare war on Iran which many people also fear as part of the scheme to stay in office. And while he might be able to send a bombing raid over Iran, I don't think he could do much more than that in the current political climate.

However, I'm also not foolish enough to scoff that it couldn't happen here. The Posse Comitatus Act can be overturned if needed according to the current administration. Bush essentially gave himself the power to ignore habeas corpus by creating the category of enemy combatant and proclaiming he could arrest and detain foreign nationals indefinitely without charges. And the claim these guys were "picked up on the battlefield" is false. People were arrested without due process in many countries including this one.

Regardless of how you feel about those actions, the point is it took a single incident and the killing of ~3,000** people for the American people to allow widespread government spying without warrants, arrest and indefinite detention without trial, and without writ of habeas corpus, officially discounting the strength of the Posse Comitatus Act, denial of the use of air travel without due process (people are on that Do Not Fly list who pose no risk to anyone, it's simply an harassment tool), and widespread deportations of people here legally (while the border to the south remains wide open). Not many people are protesting these actions.

So what do you think might happen to our freedom if an even worse terrorist act is carried out in the USA? What would it take for the current Bush administration actions against foreign nationals to be used against American citizens? They did it to the Japanese Americans in the 40s.

I'm not claiming we are near that point. I think we are much further from it given the last election. But I wouldn't be so foolish to scoff that it could never happen here. I never thought my government would openly condone torture or arrest people without trial. Such things went on I'm sure during the Vietnam War, but never as official public policy.


**For perspective, ~40,000 people are killed by automobiles and ~60,000 more by other accidents every year in the US, the flu kills ~35,000 a year and I didn't bother to look up murder rates but I can guarantee it's a lot more than 3,000/year.
 
The US did not torture him, Syria did. It's true though that the problem is that they had to know that sending him to Syria would mean that he would be tortured, but you cannot say that the US tortured him, that is just factually wrong and an obviously politically loaded statement.

Also, because of 9/11, I don't think that your "ridiculous atmosphere of fear" statement is correct. It's an atmosphere of increased awareness and hightened security, for sure, which can lead to some mistakes, as in this case, but I don't think it is ridiculous. It could be less frantic, but it is not ridiculous.

If you really want to link this to some kind of idea that the US is turning into a police state, then you would need more than one example. Arar's case is a very nasty and unfortunate mistake nonetheless and I agree with you that the US should make somekind of apology and think twice before they deport someone again.
Give me a break, Pard. The CIA flew this guy there and turned him over to them. You really need to read a bit more about the whole "special renditions" because it's a lot more widespread that just Arar's case. You need to read about how many people with absolutely no ties to terrorism were deported right after 911. You need to read about the people who are still in Guantanamo who got there because the US offered people ~$5,000 US to turn in "Taliban". It resulted in all sorts of people turning in anyone for the reward. Those are the kind of actions carried out by overreaction to a threat.

I didn't say we were turning into a police state. I said it shows how little it would take to happen.
 
Regardless of how you feel about those actions, the point is it took a single incident and the killing of ~3,000** people for the American people to allow [...]

It's not just 9/11, there have been quite a few terrorist attacks since 9/11 around the world, and multiple planned attacks were twarted. The threat is real.
 
So what do you think might happen to our freedom if an even worse terrorist act is carried out in the USA? What would it take for the current Bush administration actions against foreign nationals to be used against American citizens? They did it to the Japanese Americans in the 40s.

I'm not claiming we are near that point. I think we are much further from it given the last election. But I wouldn't be so foolish to scoff that it could never happen here.

So the fear on which the Bush administration is running its policies is the fear of a impending major terrorist attack, which may or may not happen. And the fear you base your politics on is the fear of an impending fascist police state, which may or may not happen.

ETA: you call the former "ridiculous fear", and I call it a reasonable threat. I call the latter politically biased fear and you call it reasonable fear. There must be somewhere in between where we could meet? :)
 
Last edited:
Pard, are you willing to give up the values our country stands for in order to have "security"? I'm not.

And why are the terrorist threats today any more dangerous than the "communist" threats we were fighting during the Vietnam War?

Bush uses fear to increase his authority. I believe we need to deal with the threats in our lives including the insane actions of terrorists. But one, I don't believe that our priority should be to spend hundreds of billions on a threat which killed 3,000 people 5 years ago while we are fine with 40,000 car accident deaths every year, and two, I don't believe the actions Bush is taking prevent more terrorism. They don't have squat to show for the spying or torture or detentions or deportations. Bush came up with a few vague claims in the State of the Union speech and this time even the mainstream news shot the claims down. They have nothing to show for their actions, nothing.

We all know by now the war in Iraq has made things worse, not better. Only a few di-hards still believe that war is over anything except an oil supply for Bush's cronies.
 
But one, I don't believe that our priority should be to spend hundreds of billions on a threat which killed 3,000 people 5 years ago while we are fine with 40,000 car accident deaths every year

Hey Skepticgirl :)

I don't wish to engage in any argument on the topic and for the most part I agree with you.

But the point I have quoted you on I do disagree with.

Car accidents have no political grounding, they do not influence foreign policy and they aren't acts of murder (for the most part). Vehicle accidents are predominantly the fault of one of the people involved due to drinking, wreckless driving etc.

I could expand further, but like I said, it's a political issue and I don't wish to get involved in a debate about it :)
 
That is true, he has been through a lot. But the government has been very forgiving to this man, who was rewarded around 10 million dollars for this grave mistake.

This is going to be a nice stain on the RCMP for quite some time

The Government have been forgiving of him, what the hell does he need forgiveness for?

Ok so he has been financially compensated, but that does not excuse the screw up of the RCMP who falsely accused him of terrorist activities, NOR the US government who used that faulty information to arranged for this innocent man's torture.
 
Anyone who makes any claims about the US (or any other liberal western nation) being a police state has quite clearly never lived in, nor talked to someone who has lived in, an ACTUAL police state.

Such people are insulting those that have and still are experiencing the ACTUAL horrors and misery of a REAL police state.

Americans seriously have no idea just how good they have it.

-Gumboot

(No, I have never lived in a police state either, but I have many good friends who have, and I have actually listened to what they have said, and I am very aware that their experiences exceed anything I could imagine).
 
Hey Skepticgirl :)

I don't wish to engage in any argument on the topic and for the most part I agree with you.

But the point I have quoted you on I do disagree with.

Car accidents have no political grounding, they do not influence foreign policy and they aren't acts of murder (for the most part). Vehicle accidents are predominantly the fault of one of the people involved due to drinking, wreckless driving etc.

I could expand further, but like I said, it's a political issue and I don't wish to get involved in a debate about it :)
Leave cause out for a second and consider instead, priority risk reduction.

We perceive and therefore act on risk for a variety of reasons that don't correlate with actual risk. In this case you are saying we should invest in risk reduction based on motive, guilt, or however it is you are viewing the difference. What I am saying is investment in risk reduction should be based on more scientific analysis of risk.

In the case of terrorism, we certainly need to consider potential risk. So the possibility of a massive terrorist attack of some kind deserves higher priority than just the 3,000 deaths of 911 presents. But the actions we are taking are doing very little to prevent nuclear or biological attacks. If anything we are just growing more terrorists.

A more intelligent approach would be to take the emotional crap out that says we have to get revenge or show they can't attack us without consequences or it's political when vehicle accidents are not and so on. Instead we should take a more analytical approach.

In the discussion of a police state, tell my how we are safer deporting thousands of innocent people, torturing, detaining and all that when our border to the south is literally wide open?
 
Anyone who makes any claims about the US (or any other liberal western nation) being a police state ....
I don't think anyone is saying we are in one, GB. I think if you read the posts there is discussion about how easily it could happen if we don't pay attention. That's what I've said anyway.
 
I agree skeptigirl.

We know the US isn't a police state and neither is Australia, but to quote some famous old white guy: "The nation which gives up freedom to gain security will loose both and deserve neither" (or something like that).

The war on terror could IMO be called the biggest recruitment drive for terrorists since Mohammad played fullback for Mecca.
 
Last edited:
For anyone interested:

The case of Khalid El-Masri, a German man mistakenly abducted by CIA, tortured then kept a few extra months after the US discovered it was a mistake. Apparently Conde Rice was too embarrassed to tell the German government what we did to one of their citizens so they let him rot a few extra months while they tried to find a way to explain.

There are enough references in this Wiki article to verify the story.

Extraordinary rendition

Again, this Wiki article is extremely well documented. There are more than enough citations to investigate the information. The US has admitted the CIA transfer of 'prisoners'. The EU citizens have registered protests and are seeking investigations because they feel their governments illegally allowed the US to do this in their countries.

Article about the book, "Ghost Plane", which recounts details of the special rendition flights obtained by tracking the CIA plane movements in Europe and elsewhere.


Next week's episode: Thousands of deportations of innocent people after 911. You'd think the government had gone bonkers.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom