So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't think many (if any) people are defending EG's jerkish behavior.

I beg to differ. In this thread alone:

I am not used to being on this side of a feminist argument, but this is ridiculous.

I am not waiting around to load a video and skip through to the point where she describes exactly what happened, so I will have to take this from her blog:



Are you kidding me? He asked her to his room for coffee? The nerve! Why don't they lock this predator up right now!!!!!1!!!1 Oh noes!!!!

I usually avoid these discussions (gender equality) as I consider it to be unworthy of discussion. Of course women should be treated equally to men (disclaimers for the obvious...). So I don't even really see anything to talk about.

Then I read Mr. Plait's blog and was horrified.

Men, please note: Do not talk to women, do not get on an elevator with women (just do the noble thing and get off).

I am sympathetic to women's concerns about being attacked, but if you can't handle an elevator ride then maybe you should re-evaluate your decisions that put you there in the first place.

That the message I take away from this is "Don't talk to women, because it might creep them out and if it does, that's the guy's fault."

Kinda sad, but there you go.

Oh, I get that this particular set of circumstances creeped this particular woman out. But I don't really get why it would, or how he could possibly have been expected to have known in advance that it would.

To me what he did, as she described it, seemed perfectly polite and reasonable.

If this guy was never sexually assaulted on an elevator, and doesn't know or has never met anyone who has, how would he know how she would feel? What about people who have given birth on an elevator? People who have had heart attacks in elevators? People who have been stung by bees in elevators? Are we supposed to know every single circumstance that has ever happened in an elevator so we can know how to act for every single person we meet on an elevator? Are we supposed to have questionaires before getting on elevators so we know what we can and can't do so as not to freak others out?

Has Rebecca taken into account how hard it is for men to meet women and get dates because the vast majority of the time it expected that the man make the first move? Doing so, for some men, requires a lot of courage, and that's why they can seem "creepy", but still, the ball is most of the time in our court.

It's quite possible this man was harmed far more by the situation than Rebecca, and her reaction may have simply served to humiliate him into never asking a woman out again.

When she says "Guys, don't do it", I think she needs to clarify EXACTLY what it is guys shouldn't do, because it could certainly be read that she is saying "Guys, don't make your attraction and interest in another woman known to her in a public place", which is obviously ridiculous, right?

What's acceptable to her? Don't ask her out at all? Don't ask her out when drunk? Don't ask her out at a conference? Don't ask her out in an elevator? Don't talk to her at all in an elevator? Don't get in an elevator with her? Don't ask her for coffee? Don't ask to continue a conversation?

Who knows, we're just not supposed to "do that".

Why was she so uncomfortable, is it because she felt there was a decent chance she was going to get raped or something, because that's pretty sexist on her part if so.

Let's support the cause of feminism! Women are every bit as capable as men, and every bit their equal. Of course, we should be careful how we act around them, especially in enclosed spaces, because they're a bit delicate and scare very easily.

You know, somewhere there's probably a perfectly innocent - if socially awkward - man thinking what a presumptuous egomaniac Rebecca is for assuming that because he offered coffee and a chat, he must have been sexually attracted to her.

Wow, talk about a storm in a teacup.

I'm afraid that men are allowed to speak to ladies. Even in elevators.

I'm afraid that men are allowed to attempt to pick up ladies for casual sex. Even in elevators.

...

Oh, and if someone has a particular problem with being alone with a stranger in elevators then perhaps they should use the stairs.


It's tricky, and you have to understand the labelling.


Creep = awkward sexual advance from someone found unattractive
Player = confident sexual advance from someone found unattractive

Endearing = awkward sexual advance from someone found attractive
Hot = confident sexual advance from someone found attractive.


This works for both hetero and homo and for the staff and the distaff. The labelling may shift slightly, but 'creep' is in the eye of the beholder.

The trick is knowing into which category the prospective mate puts you. If you make a mistake because you're not psychic, you risk being labelled a creep or a player. It's a problem. As far as I can see, the men that get laid most (or rather with the most women) are men that don't care about being thought of as a creep or a player.

No, I have no idea how to work it out either.

How is it sad that we don't "get that" when you can't even put it into concrete terms yourself? You didn't say what makes a woman feel uncomfortable. Why? Because we all know it can be absolutely anything. This woman was made uncomfortable by the most polite and harmless advance I could imagine.

So what is it? Is asking a woman to have coffee not acceptable? Or is it the time of day? Or is it the dreaded fear of being alone in a enclosed space with a male (gasp!)

You act like it's simple and easy to figure out when it's absolutely not. It's different for every single woman on the planet and you don't let us know beforehand the rules of the game. You just quietly wait for us to do something wrong and then act shocked.

And that helps you for this particular woman, in this particular circumstance. The next one will have different rules, and the one after that will have different rules, and so on. Men are expected to know them all, somehow.


Personally I think he did absolutely nothing wrong. At worst he thought he'd try his chances with a woman he'd been talking to and so made a polite offer and backed off when it was declined. If that's rude then FSM help the human race, because we're going extinct.

His only crimes seem to be bad timing and being unattractive.

In other crazy news, a socially awkward man was encountered at a meeting for Skeptics, of all places.

But as described, he did nothing wrong that I can see.

What seems to have happened is that in a social setting someone made what others have said is a clear proposition for sex. I don't see why from a rational standpoint (I have already said I know where it comes from in our societies) that should be any different than asking someone for a coffee, for a further discussion and a myriad of other social interactions.

Oh no, there's no code. if you can't work it out from context, you're ******. Or not, as the case may be.

What excuses? It is not making excuses to state that given the evidence we have that there are many different interpretations and explanations for the claimed event. Indeed we do not know if there was even any behaviour that needs to even be explained never mind excused.
 
I don't know if you are that naive, or if Irish culture is that different than North American culture, or if you're just playing devil's advocate, but I certainly find it exceedingly unlikely that it was not a proposition for sex with all those circumstances combined.
Actually, as I pointed out quite some time back, the social mores in such matters are actually very different in Ireland/the UK/Europe than they are in America. OK, one or two people disagreed with that, but a lot more didn't. I mean, it's even encapsulated on the Wikipedia page for dating, so it's clearly not an obscure/subtle difference.
 
Passing thought : After this I for one certainly wouldn't feel comfortable getting into an elevator alone with Ms Watson, or indeed being any place alone with her. And if I found myself so, I'd be quite concerned about it and want to get out as fast as I could.

Don't worry, I'm sure the feeling is mutual.
 
Never mind the presumptions. How many affected women do you think is an insignificant number? How many is not enough to care about?

I know you're not posing the question to me, but I'll chime in. I would say any number that is greater than the number of similar reports at a 'typical' event. If for example, at a CES (Consumer Electronics) show in Vegas, they expect to see 5 in 100 women say that they had an 'uncomfortable' encounter (to phrase it in Rebecca's terms), then that would be the sort of baseline I would expect.

I don't know what that number is (I use 5 out of 100 as a guess). But I wouldn't hold the skeptical community to a higher or lower standard than what the broad 'tradeshow' world deals with.

We are not the only organization with creepy / sexist guys roaming the halls & elevators.
 
Well put, and I was wondering about this as well. What I'm getting from some of the posters is that TAM is worse in this regard than some other conference that brings together 1500 people from all over the world. I don't understand why that would be the case.
Don't know about TAM and it's ilk, but when I used to do genre media/SF conventions, more than once I heard hotel staff say that we were a lot less hassle than business/sales conference attendees, what with us not getting obnoxiously (operative word) drunk, treating staff like crap, touching up the waitresses, letting off fire extinguishers, etc.
 
Last edited:
Never mind the presumptions. How many affected women do you think is an insignificant number? How many is not enough to care about?

I won't speak for @Skeptic Ginger, as I don't know what she thinks, and she doesn't need me anyway.

I think that 5% is a reasonable figure. One in twenty. That seems to be about the number of completely crazy people who get dismissed anyway.
 
Except that that experience is not unique to women. I've had women make me feel "uncomforable," but I didn't seek a platform to denouce them as sexist objectifying misandrists.

See, I think that's where the streams are getting crossed. The remarks about experiencing sexism were given prior to the incident in the elevator and as a reponse to some of the comments left under the videos. I've read through them, some of rational or respectful, even when they disagree with RW but some are downright sexist and misogynistic. One that sticks out, which backs up exactly what she was saying, occured right after the video of the conference was posted, before all of this blew up; Richard Dawkins needs to rape Rebecca Watson. (It's right there on youtube, just keep clicking next page and it's right there on the bottom) So when she's talking about the sexism and misogyny, I think she is talking about the whole feedback experience and not necessarily the elevator experience.
 
See, I think that's where the streams are getting crossed. The remarks about experiencing sexism were given prior to the incident in the elevator and as a reponse to some of the comments left under the videos. I've read through them, some of rational or respectful, even when they disagree with RW but some are downright sexist and misogynistic. One that sticks out, which backs up exactly what she was saying, occured right after the video of the conference was posted, before all of this blew up; Richard Dawkins needs to rape Rebecca Watson. (It's right there on youtube, just keep clicking next page and it's right there on the bottom) So when she's talking about the sexism and misogyny, I think she is talking about the whole feedback experience and not necessarily the elevator experience.

I'm interested by this comment sgtbaker.

Someone posted a (disgusting) comment reference to a video of RW's. Presumably that comment was not posted by RD. It could've been posted by someone with an axe to grind vs Rebecca. It could've been posted by a theist who follows Rebecca's feeds and regularly trolls her. Hell, it could've been posted by a woman.

So - yes, I agree that Rebecca shouldn't have to put up with ****. Especially not hateful messages like that. But I don't see a correlation between a comment posted on her video from an unknown source (who may not even be an atheist / skeptic) to indicate a specific sexism issue within 'our community'.
 
See, I think that's where the streams are getting crossed. The remarks about experiencing sexism were given prior to the incident in the elevator and as a reponse to some of the comments left under the videos. I've read through them, some of rational or respectful, even when they disagree with RW but some are downright sexist and misogynistic. One that sticks out, which backs up exactly what she was saying, occured right after the video of the conference was posted, before all of this blew up; Richard Dawkins needs to rape Rebecca Watson. (It's right there on youtube, just keep clicking next page and it's right there on the bottom) So when she's talking about the sexism and misogyny, I think she is talking about the whole feedback experience and not necessarily the elevator experience.
Then the words "self," "prophecy," and "fulfilling" spring to mind....
 
See, I think that's where the streams are getting crossed. The remarks about experiencing sexism were given prior to the incident in the elevator and as a reponse to some of the comments left under the videos. I've read through them, some of rational or respectful, even when they disagree with RW but some are downright sexist and misogynistic. One that sticks out, which backs up exactly what she was saying, occured right after the video of the conference was posted, before all of this blew up; Richard Dawkins needs to rape Rebecca Watson. (It's right there on youtube, just keep clicking next page and it's right there on the bottom) So when she's talking about the sexism and misogyny, I think she is talking about the whole feedback experience and not necessarily the elevator experience.

OK, but look. I'm sure it's possible to collect comments from Evil Male Sexists. I'm also sure it's possible to collect comments from Evil Female Sexists. Ultimately, you can prove anything you like.

Is that what this is about? Is it a given that all the Evil Male Sexist comments represent a trend that is Really Important?

I quoted a comment in a blog, not just a random comment, about this bruhaha to the effect that men (unqualified) rely on the fear of rape to get laid. The only response I got was stated as facetious. I'll ask you directly. Do you take this crap as important as you take misogynistic comments?
 
Never mind the presumptions. How many affected women do you think is an insignificant number? How many is not enough to care about?
What is it about "it's the basis for the conclusion, not the number of people affected" do you not understand?
 
I'm interested by this comment sgtbaker.

Someone posted a (disgusting) comment reference to a video of RW's. Presumably that comment was not posted by RD. It could've been posted by someone with an axe to grind vs Rebecca. It could've been posted by a theist who follows Rebecca's feeds and regularly trolls her. Hell, it could've been posted by a woman.

So - yes, I agree that Rebecca shouldn't have to put up with ****. Especially not hateful messages like that. But I don't see a correlation between a comment posted on her video from an unknown source (who may not even be an atheist / skeptic) to indicate a specific sexism issue within 'our community'.

You're right, it could have been. I doubt we can seperate the theistic responses from the atheistic responses, simply by their appropriateness. It's a pretty safe bet to say that at the very least, some of the negative responses are from atheist/skeptic. I will say that she said a majority of the rape threats are from the religious.
 
No people aren't saying shut up. I'm not worth bothering about. But clearly that wasn't the case with Dawkins. He used sarcasm to illustrate how minor he viewed the elevator incident. I happen to agree with him.
I happen to agree with the point he was making, but I felt that his tactic was one that has the effect of suppressing dissent. I also think he is too skilled a communicator not to be aware of that, but perhaps I think too highly of him in that regard.
And this point of view is being vilified.
No more so than the other POV.
I do think the subject can be discussed neatly.
Sure, but only when everyone is in agreement. Allow dissent and it stops being so neat.
I've tried to bring the discussion back to the core issues. Is there really evidence of this sexism driving women from the atheist and skeptical events? I sure haven't seen any evidence of it. And is hitting on a woman evidence of objectifying? As Linda noted, what are the cues to the difference?
I don't think these are the core issues. At least not for me. I happen to agree with you that it isn't necessarily sexism, objectification or misogyny. I think the behaviors that have been reported and discussed are the core issues. However you label them, I think they do have the effect of driving women away from atheist and skeptical events.
Is it really a surprise that name calling includes sexual references to Rebecca when people reply to her blogs? Have you read many of PZ's "I get EMail" blog entries? That's evidence people say really nasty things when you threaten their god and other woo beliefs. Those are not atheists and/or skeptics, those are nut-jobs.
Actually, Rebecca specifically said that some of them were from guys who identified as atheists and/or skeptic.

I'm a woman. And I've moved about in the world relatively uninhibited by people's expectations of what feminine behavior should be. It has cost me but it has also rewarded me. I think I have a pretty good idea of what real sexism is and some guy hitting on you as was described in this case is not it.
I've worked in a male dominated profession and a male dominated industry for over 20 years. I know what real sexism is too and I agree, what Rebecca described is not necessarily what I term sexism. That doesn't mean it isn't a problem.
If it only took as little as unwanted male attention for women to be offended, I'd need therapy for chronic affrontedness. It's my opinion that such annoyances pale in comparison to the real issues women face. Why waste energy whining about such things when there are so many more important hurdles in the world for women.
Because Rebecca would like to see more women brought into the skeptic/atheist community and those annoyances are keeping women away. That means that if you, like Rebecca, would like to see more women at skeptical and atheists conferences, it's a problem you want to bring out into the open to discuss and look for solutions. You know, like telling people that propositioning a women alone in an elevator at 4 a.m. is not appropriate and not to do that because a lot of guys in the atheist/skeptical community don't appear to be aware of the social nicety of making sure the woman has an easily accessible escape route when making such an offer.
If I let sexist men keep me from doing anything, be it attending an event or getting on an elevator in a hotel alone, I'm the one who loses. If I let some action of a sexist man get under my skin, I'm the one who loses. I can control my reaction to these things and I chose not to be bothered by such trivial issues. There are real issues out there worth my energy. Reacting to a jerk isn't one of them.

Speaking up so other women can hear this point of view is a real issue worth my energy. Don't let sexist men, jerks or otherwise, affect your life. If you recognize they have no power over you, problem solved.

Unfortunately, it is a fact of life that for many reasons, jerks - whether sexist or otherwise - are often in positions of power. It is not always easy or simple to extricate yourself from such situations. In many cases, the cost of doing so (changing employers or even professions might be required) may be difficult and costly enough that people either are unable to do so or don't feel it worth the cost. Speaking up for themselves in such a situation can easily result in worse treatment rather than an improvement. So they put up with the jerk BECAUSE he is in a position of power over them.

OTOH, if the place where the jerk behavior is occurring is something you do voluntarily like going to an atheist/skeptic conference, the equation regarding whether to speak up, tolerate, or just avoid the situations is much difference. I find it easy to understand that for women who are bothered by such behavior, it's a better use of their time and money to choose to go somewhere where it isn't happening and they don't have to decide how to deal with it.

I don't think many (if any) people are defending EG's jerkish behavior. The issue is claiming the behavior represented sexism and is common enough among skeptics and atheists as to affect a significant number of women's experience at formal events.

Yes, it's common and yes it does affect women's experience and willingness to attend such conferences.

When I attend conferences, which I do once or twice a year, they are professional engineering conferences in my industry. The male/female ratio there is similarly skewed and the guys are almost exclusively engineers with average social skills stereotypical of engineers. I don't experience the constant hitting on, the unwanted *accidental* touching or inappropriate conversations/invitations in that setting but I'm married, over 50, not hawt and I don't socialize much when I'm there. If I looked like Rebecca and hung out at the hotel bar at the end of the day, I think it would be an entirely different story.

One of my co-workers who is young and attractive has requested not to go for exactly that sort of reason - unwanted attention from a male. In this case, it was a man who was in a position of power and he started requesting her specifically for projects aside from the conference, which made it problematic but things were worked out.

So yes, these things happen and yes, they do drive women away from attending conferences. These things happen at professional conferences and I suspect they happen even more frequently at atheist/skeptical conferences which are not usually work related for attendees. I suspect that many people are freer with such behavior than my engineering colleagues because they don't have to worry about repercussions to their career if their boss hears about their bad behavior afterwards.
 
I beg to differ. In this thread alone:
Sorry you had to go through all that work. That's not what I meant by jerkish. This is hard to explain and I apologize for not being more clear before you went to all that trouble. .

I am also of the side that doesn't think there was anything 'wrong' with EG's request. He made a pass at someone who wasn't interested, that's what I meant by a jerk and really it was based solely on Rebecca's distaste for the request, not the pass itself.

I'll just retract what I said as it wasn't clear.

Had Rebecca merely said she personally found the guy to be a jerk, she would of course have the right to such a reaction. It was claiming the guy was "objectifying" her where her conclusion is being challenged.
 
I know you're not posing the question to me, but I'll chime in. I would say any number that is greater than the number of similar reports at a 'typical' event. If for example, at a CES (Consumer Electronics) show in Vegas, they expect to see 5 in 100 women say that they had an 'uncomfortable' encounter (to phrase it in Rebecca's terms), then that would be the sort of baseline I would expect.

I don't know what that number is (I use 5 out of 100 as a guess). But I wouldn't hold the skeptical community to a higher or lower standard than what the broad 'tradeshow' world deals with.

We are not the only organization with creepy / sexist guys roaming the halls & elevators.
That too.
 
Well put, and I was wondering about this as well. What I'm getting from some of the posters is that TAM is worse in this regard than some other conference that brings together 1500 people from all over the world. I don't understand why that would be the case.

Maybe you don't understand it because it isn't true.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom