So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nods. But of course I need to know to whom I should be addressing my 'Dude, seriously' comment. I don't in the case of RW vs EG. I can pretty much assure you I will probably say 'Dude, seriously' to DRBuzz0 at some point in TAM9 about something.



I'm not quite sure I grok this. You're saying that people should be aware of who would be welcoming of a pass, and therefore the ones that can't figure it out will stand out even more?

That assumes that a) someone knows ahead of time who would be welcoming of an approach.

For me (who is not dating anyways, being in a 17 year long committed & monogamous relationship) I have always thought looking for a wedding ring was a logical starting point. But that of course is not conclusive - so I would say having a conversation and getting to know someone first is the next step. If no vibe then move on. If 'vibe' then a more direct question may follow (back in the day.)

Do you think there is some other way to achieve a) in a different way that I describe?

And it sounds like you're also saying b) that if 90% of people behave more responsibly / better, then the 10% who don't get it will be more obvious.

But is the problem REALLY that bad, and is it REALLY that much worse at a skeptical/atheist event? That would be a really fascinating question to examine. Is attendee behaviour at a TAM more disconcerting to women than say... at a COMIC-CON or at the Consumer Electronic Show?

I've been to the SD Comicon about a dozen times. Once dressed as Emma Frost (it was a dare) in a sparkly vinyl corset, miniskirt, white mink shrug, and huge boots, carrying a riding crop that I had carefully painted white. I had far less unfortunate male attention there than I did at TAM in a maxi-dress, flip-flops and an old lady shawl.
 
I obviously can't speak to this from the female perspective, but I can say that I attended a couple of TAMs back in 2006 and 2007 and stopped going in part because the socially awkward quotient of the attendees (at least at the time-- it was only ~800 back in those days) was significantly higher than the norm. The thought of being a target of sexual attention from that group-- yeah, I can see how that would be uncomfortable.


Well, I can see how a skeptical conference would attract a larger percentage of socially awkward/nerdy/geeky/shy attendees than other conferences, but still don't see how the group in general would be more sexist or disrespectful to women than any other group of 800 people.
 
Bloody hell this is getting ridiculous, singling out someone who some people find creepy and weird - why does he have to change, why can't people deal with him as he is, if you don't like him because you find him creepy then don't interact with him! If he was actually dangerous fair enough but for goodness sake live and let live!
You are talking about a man who was suggested by multiple people that the JREF ban from ever attending another TAM. That tells me right off the bat that something is seriously wrong with him and that you shouldn't just deal with him.
 
Last edited:
Disagreeing with you isn't telling you to shut up.

Still, the only way for this whole **** storm to never have happened is if the incident had never been mentioned.

There's no way for it to be discussed neatly. It's not a tidy subject.
No people aren't saying shut up. I'm not worth bothering about. But clearly that wasn't the case with Dawkins. He used sarcasm to illustrate how minor he viewed the elevator incident. I happen to agree with him. And this point of view is being vilified.

I do think the subject can be discussed neatly. But of course it isn't. I've tried to bring the discussion back to the core issues. Is there really evidence of this sexism driving women from the atheist and skeptical events? I sure haven't seen any evidence of it. And is hitting on a woman evidence of objectifying? As Linda noted, what are the cues to the difference?

Is it really a surprise that name calling includes sexual references to Rebecca when people reply to her blogs? Have you read many of PZ's "I get EMail" blog entries? That's evidence people say really nasty things when you threaten their god and other woo beliefs. Those are not atheists and/or skeptics, those are nut-jobs.


It appears to me that PZ and Phil as skeptical/atheist spokespersons are taking Rebecca's word for it that she experiences the sexism she claims to experience. If you're a guy, how can you challenge that? But I'm a woman. And I've moved about in the world relatively uninhibited by people's expectations of what feminine behavior should be. It has cost me but it has also rewarded me. I think I have a pretty good idea of what real sexism is and some guy hitting on you as was described in this case is not it.

If it only took as little as unwanted male attention for women to be offended, I'd need therapy for chronic affrontedness. It's my opinion that such annoyances pale in comparison to the real issues women face. Why waste energy whining about such things when there are so many more important hurdles in the world for women.

If I want equality, shouldn't I be confident enough about myself to ignore such tripe? Maybe that's what bothers me about this and why I had the exchange I did with TraneWreck about hotel elevators not being particularly dangerous places. How can I be equal if I don't take some personal responsibility for that equality? TraneWreck has the expectation that women should fear men, that we should fear walking alone, that we should fear all the dangerous things in the world. If I did that, I would surely be the loser and I would be the one responsible for much of my inequality.

And I can say with confidence that fear of everything TraneWreck thinks I should fear because men are on average stronger than women, wasn't justified. I went out in the night alone and guess what? Nothing bad happened. I know from your thoughtful posts that you understand the concept of having control of your responses. People can do things, but I choose to respond, they cannot make me respond. I choose not to let the things I can control, my response in this case, be the things which result in my loss.

If I let sexist men keep me from doing anything, be it attending an event or getting on an elevator in a hotel alone, I'm the one who loses. If I let some action of a sexist man get under my skin, I'm the one who loses. I can control my reaction to these things and I chose not to be bothered by such trivial issues. There are real issues out there worth my energy. Reacting to a jerk isn't one of them.

Speaking up so other women can hear this point of view is a real issue worth my energy. Don't let sexist men, jerks or otherwise, affect your life. If you recognize they have no power over you, problem solved.
 
Last edited:
No people aren't saying shut up. I'm not worth bothering about. But clearly that wasn't the case with Dawkins. He used sarcasm to illustrate how minor he viewed the elevator incident. I happen to agree with him. And this point of view is being vilified.
That wasn't sarcasm that was a stupid attempt at trying to pass one of the most common logical fallacies around as an attempt as an argument. Seriously people. You are skeptics. Stop trying to excuse someone who evoked the same level of intellectual discourse that he rails against.
 
Last edited:
Well, I can see how a skeptical conference would attract a larger percentage of socially awkward/nerdy/geeky/shy attendees than other conferences, but still don't see how the group in general would be more sexist or disrespectful to women than any other group of 800 people.

I tend to agree with those who have said that this is more an issue of tact and empathy than outright sexism. Based on my encounters with the skeptical community, I suspect that EG's problem was a general social awkwardness that manifested in this context in behavior that Rebecca perfectly reasonably interpreted as creepy or vaguely threatening. I further suspect, again based only on my own observations, that a lot of the behavior that women at TAM find disrespectful or annoying stems from the same source of general awkwardness rather than overt misogyny.
 
Oh, people have tried to be helpful...

I recall one memorable discussion involving him, Hal, and GeekGoddess. It started out with him being unresponsive and surly, and ended up with him in tears (not just a little bit, but full-on uncontrollable sobbing) when the conversation went to companionship, and it brought back memories of a dog of his that died accidentally a few years before.

If they didn't back off at "unresponsive and surly" then, to me, it's not Dr. B. that comes across as creepy in this anecdote.
 
I've been to the SD Comicon about a dozen times. Once dressed as Emma Frost (it was a dare) in a sparkly vinyl corset, miniskirt, white mink shrug, and huge boots, carrying a riding crop that I had carefully painted white. I had far less unfortunate male attention there than I did at TAM in a maxi-dress, flip-flops and an old lady shawl.

Certainly an interesting take. Of course, (and I don't mean this in a disrespectful way) one persons' experience does not an analysis make.

Should the JREF consider if there is some way to make this determination? Based on the amount of crap flying around the internet at the moment, it would seem so.

To be honest, a more 'freeform' sort of event may be a logical next step anyways. As we grow in size beyond what can realistically be housed in one auditorium, perhaps the format of TAM should change into that more of a trade show, with a lot more smaller break-out sessions - having repeat sessions for the more popular 'heavy-hitting' speakers.

That way, there wouldn't be as much forced 'huge' group dynamic, no forced shared dining etc... The garrolous crowds will find each other and socialize, the shy / awkward ones will have more room to move freely between events, and it might normalize somewhat the overall event.

Stretch it out for a couple more days, change up the format, and see if people prefer it.

Just throwing it out there.
 
No people aren't saying shut up. I'm not worth bothering about. But clearly that wasn't the case with Dawkins. He used sarcasm to illustrate how minor he viewed the elevator incident. I happen to agree with him. And this point of view is being vilified.

I do think the subject can be discussed neatly. But of course it isn't. I've tried to bring the discussion back to the core issues. Is there really evidence of this sexism driving women from the atheist and skeptical events? I sure haven't seen any evidence of it. And is hitting on a woman evidence of objectifying? As Linda noted, what are the cues to the difference?

Is it really a surprise that name calling includes sexual references to Rebecca when people reply to her blogs? Have you read many of PZ's "I get EMail" blog entries? That's evidence people say really nasty things when you threaten their god and other woo beliefs. Those are not atheists and/or skeptics, those are nut-jobs.


It appears to me that PZ and Phil as skeptical/atheist spokespersons are taking Rebecca's word for it that she experiences the sexism she claims to experience. If you're a guy, how can you challenge that? But I'm a woman. And I've moved about in the world relatively uninhibited by people's expectations of what feminine behavior should be. It has cost me but it has also rewarded me. I think I have a pretty good idea of what real sexism is and some guy hitting on you as was described in this case is not it.

If it only took as little as unwanted male attention for women to be offended, I'd need therapy for chronic affrontedness. It's my opinion that such annoyances pale in comparison to the real issues women face. Why waste energy whining about such things when there are so many more important hurdles in the world for women.

If I want equality, shouldn't I be confident enough about myself to ignore such tripe? Maybe that's what bothers me about this and why I had the exchange I did with TraneWreck about hotel elevators not being particularly dangerous places. How can I be equal if I don't take some personal responsibility for that equality? TraneWreck has the expectation that women should fear men, that we should fear walking alone, that we should fear all the dangerous things in the world. If I did that, I would surely be the loser and I would be the one responsible for much of my inequality.

And I can say with confidence that fear of everything TraneWreck thinks I should fear because men are on average stronger than women, wasn't justified. I went out in the night alone and guess what? Nothing bad happened. I know from your thoughtful posts that you understand the concept of having control of your responses. People can do things, but I choose to respond, they cannot make me respond. I choose not to let the things I can control, my response in this case, be the things which result in my loss.

If I let sexist men keep me from doing anything, be it attending an event or getting on an elevator in a hotel alone, I'm the one who loses. If I let some action of a sexist man get under my skin, I'm the one who loses. I can control my reaction to these things and I chose not to be bothered by such trivial issues. There are real issues out there worth my energy. Reacting to a jerk isn't one of them.

Speaking up so other women can hear this point of view is a real issue worth my energy. Don't let sexist men, jerks or otherwise, affect your life. If you recognize they have no power over you, the problem goes away.

One of these days, that pat on the head for being the "good kind" of feminist won't be as satisfying. I'm not judging, I was there myself many years ago. Dump it all on me! Hear me roar!

Then one day, I started saying "Hey guys, I've been sorta taking your side in this. Boys will be boys and all that. I get it, really. And you've been really nice about it, telling me how great my ass is and stuff. But um, maybe just tone it down a little? Not a lot, just a tiny bit. maybe just the worst of it? please."

yadda, yadda - I don't do that anymore.
 
So they weren't talking about feminism and sexual objectification after all? (He says "atheist proselytizing".)

Linda

Full quotes are sometime more informative
Among them were yours truly, various Irish atheists, and some foreign dignitaries like PZ Myers, AronRa, and Rebecca Watson. There was a formal dinner until about 10pm, and then the Hotel bar was used for atheist proselytising way into the wee hours of the morning.
 
Is this on all these other sites that are discussing this because I've not seen that idea being expressed here? (I have enough trouble keeping up with this thread!)

I've definitely seen it expressed elsewhere, and I suspect it's here. I'm not going to pour back over this 600+ post thread and the other one, mainly because I expect you would just quibble with my examples anyway.

But yes, all over these discussions is the notion that "I have the right to proposition women in elevators at 4 am," "if she has a problem with that it's her problem not mine," and my personal favorite "the human race would die out if you had it your way."

I obviously can't speak to this from the female perspective, but I can say that I attended a couple of TAMs back in 2006 and 2007 and stopped going in part because the socially awkward quotient of the attendees (at least at the time-- it was only ~800 back in those days) was significantly higher than the norm. The thought of being a target of sexual attention from that group-- yeah, I can see how that would be uncomfortable.

My impression is similar to yours. I would also point to the large number of people in this and the other venues who are claiming to be "socially awkward," "on the autism spectrum," or otherwise struggling to discern generally acceptable social behavior.
 
My impression is similar to yours. I would also point to the large number of people in this and the other venues who are claiming to be "socially awkward," "on the autism spectrum," or otherwise struggling to discern generally acceptable social behavior.
Stop lumping me in with these creepy people. I am socially awkward. I have done things that most normal people would not even consider doing. Harmless but awkward as all hell. I would never think of doing something this stupid unless I was really out of my mind.
 
Last edited:
One of these days, that pat on the head for being the "good kind" of feminist won't be as satisfying. I'm not judging, I was there myself many years ago. Dump it all on me! Hear me roar!

Then one day, I started saying "Hey guys, I've been sorta taking your side in this. Boys will be boys and all that. I get it, really. And you've been really nice about it, telling me how great my ass is and stuff. But um, maybe just tone it down a little? Not a lot, just a tiny bit. maybe just the worst of it? please."

yadda, yadda - I don't do that anymore.
I'm pretty sure I'm older than you. I assure you I'm still very satisfied. And my point was, that you seemed to have missed, I pat myself on the head, I don't need other people's approval.
 
Last edited:
I've definitely seen it expressed elsewhere, and I suspect it's here. I'm not going to pour back over this 600+ post thread and the other one, mainly because I expect you would just quibble with my examples anyway.

But yes, all over these discussions is the notion that "I have the right to proposition women in elevators at 4 am," "if she has a problem with that it's her problem not mine," ....
....
So Rebecca owns the elevator?

I hate it when I get unsolicited sales calls either at my door or on my phone. And I do own the phone and the property in front of my door. But apparently society determines these sales people have a right to approach me whether I like it or not.

Yet you are saying people don't have a right to speak to a person in a hotel elevator. It is Rebecca's problem. She made that clear. We haven't heard from the man involved.
 
As I said I used a bit of hyperbole, that means I exaggerated a response to make a point.
Funny, I saw it more as an outright strawman...
I am saying we don't know, we have no way of knowing what actually happened or was actually said and so on.
Quick, someone make a "We just can't know!" caption/pic...

And I don't, but for some reason I don't feel a need to place a label on you because I don't agree with you....
What label is that now?

Then how can you hold apparently firm conclusions about what happened and what it means?
What firm conclusions are those now?
 
So Rebecca owns the elevator?

I hate it when I get unsolicited sales calls either at my door or on my phone. And I do own the phone and the property in front of my door. But apparently society determines these sales people have a right to approach me whether I like it or not.

Yet you are saying people don't have a right to speak to a person in a hotel elevator. It is Rebecca's problem. She made that clear. We haven't heard from the man involved.

Society has given you a do not call registry, gated communities, fences and trespassing laws because we respect that people and property have boundaries. These are examples that while you might be perfectly fine with being interrupted at dinner and having your rose bushes trampled, your view is not universal. People who disagree have done something about it and that has lead to solutions a bit more civilized then "Let them be jerks! I can take it!"
 
So they weren't talking about feminism and sexual objectification after all? (He says "atheist proselytizing".)

Linda
I think the reference was to Rebecca's lecture, not the bar chat, but I am sometimes recall-challenged when it comes to such a busy discussion as this one.


From the good doctor from Oz who was there at the bar:
If you really want social equality for women, which is what feminism is, why not apply the same standards to men and women, and stop demonizing men for being sexual beings?

Stef, a hint, for future reference : “Being a sexual being” does not equal proposing to have coffee sex to a woman in an elevator at 4am, a woman you had access to for hours on end beforehand, and a woman who you did not exchange a single word with prior to your “coffee” invitation, although you had a whole weekend to do so.
If I wanted to register to reply on his blog, which I don't, I would reply, "Dear Dr from Oz, who says?"

One can comment the elevator guy was a jerk, and that would be an opinion everyone is within their rights to have. But judging what is "being a sexual being" and what is not requires a bit more substantive supporting documentation in my book.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom