Disagreeing with you isn't telling you to shut up.
Still, the only way for this whole **** storm to never have happened is if the incident had never been mentioned.
There's no way for it to be discussed neatly. It's not a tidy subject.
No people aren't saying shut up. I'm not worth bothering about. But clearly that wasn't the case with Dawkins. He used sarcasm to illustrate how minor he viewed the elevator incident. I happen to agree with him. And this point of view is being vilified.
I do think the subject
can be discussed neatly. But of course it isn't. I've tried to bring the discussion back to the core issues. Is there really evidence of this sexism driving women from the atheist and skeptical events? I sure haven't seen any evidence of it. And is hitting on a woman evidence of objectifying? As Linda noted, what are the cues to the difference?
Is it really a surprise that name calling includes sexual references to Rebecca when people reply to her blogs? Have you read many of PZ's "I get EMail" blog entries? That's evidence people say really nasty things when you threaten their god and other woo beliefs. Those are not atheists and/or skeptics, those are nut-jobs.
It appears to me that PZ and Phil as skeptical/atheist spokespersons are taking Rebecca's word for it that she experiences the sexism she claims to experience. If you're a guy, how can you challenge that? But I'm a woman. And I've moved about in the world relatively uninhibited by people's expectations of what feminine behavior should be. It has cost me but it has also rewarded me. I think I have a pretty good idea of what real sexism is and some guy hitting on you as was described in this case is not it.
If it only took as little as unwanted male attention for women to be offended, I'd need therapy for chronic affrontedness. It's my opinion that such annoyances pale in comparison to the real issues women face. Why waste energy whining about such things when there are so many more important hurdles in the world for women.
If I want equality, shouldn't I be confident enough about myself to ignore such tripe? Maybe that's what bothers me about this and why I had the exchange I did with TraneWreck about hotel elevators not being particularly dangerous places.
How can I be equal if I don't take some personal responsibility for that equality? TraneWreck has the expectation that women should fear men, that we should fear walking alone, that we should fear all the dangerous things in the world. If I did that, I would surely be the loser and I would be the one responsible for much of my inequality.
And I can say with confidence that fear of everything TraneWreck thinks I should fear because men are on average stronger than women, wasn't justified. I went out in the night alone and guess what? Nothing bad happened. I know from your thoughtful posts that you understand the concept of having control of your responses.
People can do things, but I choose to respond, they cannot make me respond. I choose not to let the things I can control, my response in this case, be the things which result in my loss.
If I let sexist men keep me from doing anything, be it attending an event or getting on an elevator in a hotel alone, I'm the one who loses. If I let some action of a sexist man get under my skin, I'm the one who loses. I can control my reaction to these things and I chose not to be bothered by such trivial issues. There are real issues out there worth my energy. Reacting to a jerk isn't one of them.
Speaking up so other women can hear this point of view
is a real issue worth my energy.
Don't let sexist men, jerks or otherwise, affect your life. If you recognize they have no power over you, problem solved.