So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
OK, but look. I'm sure it's possible to collect comments from Evil Male Sexists. I'm also sure it's possible to collect comments from Evil Female Sexists. Ultimately, you can prove anything you like.

Is that what this is about? Is it a given that all the Evil Male Sexist comments represent a trend that is Really Important?

She has a right to respond to it, just as you have a right to respond to females making sexist comments. Unfortunately, the roles in our society have it that when a woman makes a complaint about being mistreated by a man, she's a raving feminist and when a man makes a comment about being mistreated by a woman, he's told to tuck his string in. They both suck and they both need to be addressed because they are both incredibly sexist.
 
What is it about "it's the basis for the conclusion, not the number of people affected" do you not understand?


The problem is that the dismissals come even when the basis for the conclusion isn't known. For instance, boo shared what seems to be a description of how repeated unwelcome attentions at a TAM caused her to seriously think about whether to attend another one. Rather than acknowledge or even explore why those experiences made her feel the way she did, all she got was people criticizing her judgment and implying that it's wrong of her to not consider the "fun" of such conventions worth enduring the discomfort she experienced. The people who argued with her just completely invalidated her personal experience without even bothering to ask for the 'basis of her conclusions'. So no, I'm sorry, but I don't buy that. I don't buy the "I'm not telling you to just suck it up, but...really, just suck it up" lines of argument I'm seeing here, and I'm not buying that a simple request to respect the fact that some people don't want to be prepositioned when cornered, is some kind of 'attack on the fact that men are sexual beings'.
 
Last edited:
The problem is that the dismissals come even when the basis for the conclusion isn't known. For instance, boo shared what seems to be a description of how repeated unwelcome attentions at a TAM caused her to seriously think about whether to attend another one. Rather than acknowledge or even explore why those experiences made her feel the way she did, all she got was people criticizing her judgment and implying that it's wrong of her to not consider the "fun" of such conventions worth enduring the discomfort she experienced. The people who argued with her just completely invalidated her personal experience without even bothering to ask for the 'basis of her conclusions'. So no, I'm sorry, but I don't buy that. I don't buy the "I'm not telling you to just suck it up, but...really, just suck it up" lines of argument I'm seeing here, and I'm not buying that a simple request to respect the fact that some people don't want to be prepositioned when cornered, is some kind of 'attack on the fact that men are sexual beings'.

Are you reading the same thread?

All I mentioned to her was that I felt that we needed to consider more than one person's response. And that perhaps this was indication we should consider a broad survey to gauge these feelings. I also proposed that a format change might make things a bit more 'normal' since the TAM meeting structure is a bit different to most conventions.

I don't know how that turned into 'just suck it up'
 
I happen to agree with the point he was making, but I felt that his tactic was one that has the effect of suppressing dissent.
But that's because you prefer the nice guy approach. ;)

No more so than the other POV.
The vilification of the other POV is because that side is baselessly vilifying others.

Sure, but only when everyone is in agreement. Allow dissent and it stops being so neat. I don't think these are the core issues. At least not for me. I happen to agree with you that it isn't necessarily sexism, objectification or misogyny. I think the behaviors that have been reported and discussed are the core issues. However you label them, I think they do have the effect of driving women away from atheist and skeptical events.
Actually, Rebecca specifically said that some of them were from guys who identified as atheists and/or skeptic.
I still fail to see that "driving women away" is a valid assertion.

...OTOH, if the place where the jerk behavior is occurring is something you do voluntarily like going to an atheist/skeptic conference, the equation regarding whether to speak up, tolerate, or just avoid the situations is much difference. I find it easy to understand that for women who are bothered by such behavior, it's a better use of their time and money to choose to go somewhere where it isn't happening and they don't have to decide how to deal with it.
No doubt individuals might not enjoy themselves at a skeptic or atheist event and choose not to go again for any number of reasons including obnoxious behavior of other participants. How does that translate into the kind of problem Rebecca claims it is?

One of my co-workers who is young and attractive has requested not to go for exactly that sort of reason - unwanted attention from a male. In this case, it was a man who was in a position of power and he started requesting her specifically for projects aside from the conference, which made it problematic but things were worked out.
Not analogous. Like I said, there could easily be individuals with individual experiences, I've had a few. But they were not specifically inherent in an atheist or skeptic gathering.

So yes, these things happen and yes, they do drive women away from attending conferences. These things happen at professional conferences and I suspect they happen even more frequently at atheist/skeptical conferences which are not usually work related for attendees. I suspect that many people are freer with such behavior than my engineering colleagues because they don't have to worry about repercussions to their career if their boss hears about their bad behavior afterwards.
I'm certainly not arguing there are no such events where sexist behavior is excessive. I'm arguing it's not at skeptic or atheist events in the excess that Rebecca seems to be describing.
 
She has a right to respond to it, just as you have a right to respond to females making sexist comments.

I'm not denying anybody their rights.

Unfortunately, the roles in our society have it that when a woman makes a complaint about being mistreated by a man, she's a raving feminist and when a man makes a comment about being mistreated by a woman, he's told to tuck his string in. They both suck and they both need to be addressed because they are both incredibly sexist.

That at least I can agree with. Yes, they both suck.

However, I've said this before, and I'll say it again. There are lots of collected stories about men being mean to women and what it says about Male Nature and the Patriarchy and so on and so forth. Hell, there was even a television channel (Lifetime) that did this all the time, though they have toned it down a bit since they were bought by Disney.

Since feminism isn't the subject of this particular thread, what we ultimately have is one particular bad experience that a woman had, comparable to bad experiences that I personally have every week or so (unless they are worse). And so, ultimately, what?

If there weren't an effort (which, again, I do not ascribe to Watson but rather, at least mostly, to third parties) to make this emblematic of some Big Fat Hairy Feminist Deal, there would be much reason to comment about it.
 
The problem is that the dismissals come even when the basis for the conclusion isn't known. For instance, boo shared what seems to be a description of how repeated unwelcome attentions at a TAM caused her to seriously think about whether to attend another one. Rather than acknowledge or even explore why those experiences made her feel the way she did, all she got was people criticizing her judgment and implying that it's wrong of her to not consider the "fun" of such conventions worth enduring the discomfort she experienced. The people who argued with her just completely invalidated her personal experience without even bothering to ask for the 'basis of her conclusions'. So no, I'm sorry, but I don't buy that. I don't buy the "I'm not telling you to just suck it up, but...really, just suck it up" lines of argument I'm seeing here, and I'm not buying that a simple request to respect the fact that some people don't want to be prepositioned when cornered, is some kind of 'attack on the fact that men are sexual beings'.
Neither Rebecca's nor Boo's personal experiences are the issue here. It's the attempt to generalize from those individual experiences to the whole group.
 
I wouldn't hold the skeptical community to a higher or lower standard than what the broad 'tradeshow' world deals with.

I would. If I'm going to a conference for work, I'll just hang out in my room when I'm not at conference meetings. If I'm picking a conference to go to just because I want to be there, I'm not going to pick one where I have to tolerate a lot of behavior I don't like. If I'm someone who doesn't care for the treatment I'm getting from fellow conference attendees, I'm not going back.

At this point, I'm not talking about the elevator proposition, which I have to tell you is beyond the pale for a huge percentage of women, at least in the U.S. I'm talking about more subtle, common types of things. The types of things I'm seeing women complaining about on the blogs are things like getting propositioned an average of every 45 minutes at social events. Reports of having men talk to their boobs all day. (That's one that always bugged me back when my boobs were perky enough to attract interest.) Lots of men *accidently* brushing up against them was another one mentioned.

These are things that happen everywhere all the time to women in our society. We are fortunate enough to like in a free country and few are the women in it who haven't received an inappropriate proposition or unwanted unexpected grope. Women can and do handle these types of annoyances on a regular basis. As long as it doesn't escalate, we can deal with it. We all have our own tolerance levels for such behavior and we make individual decisions to avoid places where the background level of such occurrences is higher than we are willing to tolerate.

What I gather from reading these blogs and their comments and listening to the women talk about their experiences is that these things happen often enough at atheist and skeptics (and comic book, sci fi, etc.) conferences that it exceeds their tolerance level for those petty annoyances and they don't go back.

The elevator incident, which I find perfectly understandable as the natural progression of such behaviors, goes beyond petty annoyance and into, as the article you linked to put it "behaving in a way that's indistinguishable from creepiness". I think it's likely that for a great many women in America, knowing that the men who attend such conferences think that behavior is perfectly socially acceptable is enough to put us off from voluntarily attending such a conference.


Thanks. Nice to know how others are viewing us.
 
I would. If I'm going to a conference for work, I'll just hang out in my room when I'm not at conference meetings. If I'm picking a conference to go to just because I want to be there, I'm not going to pick one where I have to tolerate a lot of behavior I don't like. If I'm someone who doesn't care for the treatment I'm getting from fellow conference attendees, I'm not going back.

At this point, I'm not talking about the elevator proposition, which I have to tell you is beyond the pale for a huge percentage of women, at least in the U.S. I'm talking about more subtle, common types of things. The types of things I'm seeing women complaining about on the blogs are things like getting propositioned an average of every 45 minutes at social events. Reports of having men talk to their boobs all day. (That's one that always bugged me back when my boobs were perky enough to attract interest.) Lots of men *accidently* brushing up against them was another one mentioned.

These are things that happen everywhere all the time to women in our society. We are fortunate enough to like in a free country and few are the women in it who haven't received an inappropriate proposition or unwanted unexpected grope. Women can and do handle these types of annoyances on a regular basis. As long as it doesn't escalate, we can deal with it. We all have our own tolerance levels for such behavior and we make individual decisions to avoid places where the background level of such occurrences is higher than we are willing to tolerate.

What I gather from reading these blogs and their comments and listening to the women talk about their experiences is that these things happen often enough at atheist and skeptics (and comic book, sci fi, etc.) conferences that it exceeds their tolerance level for those petty annoyances and they don't go back.

The elevator incident, which I find perfectly understandable as the natural progression of such behaviors, goes beyond petty annoyance and into, as the article you linked to put it "behaving in a way that's indistinguishable from creepiness". I think it's likely that for a great many women in America, knowing that the men who attend such conferences think that behavior is perfectly socially acceptable is enough to put us off from voluntarily attending such a conference.



Thanks. Nice to know how others are viewing us.

A lot of your comment saddens me, and if what you express genuinely is how the majority of American women feel today, then aren't we coming up against a much larger issue than this little forum.

Perhaps I have rose-tinted glasses on. I'm older, I'm in a relationship, I'm homosexual. I wouldn't talk to someone's breasts, as frankly - not interested - at least, not in that way.

If you're already limiting social contact in your work setting (by staying in your room) then obviously a lot happens in your day to day life that bothers you. If making the decision to attend a TAM (or similar) is a holiday decision for you (as I'm sure it is to a degree for lots of us) then I can understand why you may hope for a better experience than 'usual' - but is that fair? It is after all, primarily a conference attended by Americans, in America, and will have a pretty typical cross-section of (largely) American attendees. Maybe if things are that bad, you're better off choosing to go to a conference that caters only to women - or to gay men. Or going on a trip to a foreign country who have a better way of dealing with inter-gender relations?

I hope this doesn't sound flippant in any way - it saddens me that people feel inclined to lead their lives in this fashion.
 
Neither Rebecca's nor Boo's personal experiences are the issue here. It's the attempt to generalize from those individual experiences to the whole group.

No, you can't generalize from those individual experiences to the whole group, but they are valid data points that I can consider when I trying to match their experiences to what you've described and what I, myself, have experienced at other conferences, like professional engineering conferences and local sci-fi conventions.

I gave a synopsis of the comments I've read from women how have attended such conferences and posted about them in my previous post. I can't conclude anything about what percentage they might be of women who have attended such conferences, but I can conclude the such experiences happen regularly and some women decide not to attend those events because of it.
 


AFAICT, this is part of Dawkins last response in the comments war:

Dawkins said:
<snip>

But not everybody sees it as end of story. OK, let's ask why not? The main reason seems to be that an elevator is a confined space from which there is no escape. This point has been made again and again in this thread, and the other one.

No escape? I am now really puzzled. Here's how you escape from an elevator. You press any one of the buttons conveniently provided. The elevator will obligingly stop at a floor, the door will open and you will no longer be in a confined space but in a well-lit corridor in a crowded hotel in the centre of Dublin.

No, I obviously don't get it.

<snip>

Further down the page, plenty of other commenters explained it to him. And as its already been explained, explained and explained yet again in this thread I won't repeat the reasons why he is in error -- but he has not chosen to continue the conversation. I guess he still doesn't get it or perhaps he doesn't like to admit when he's wrong.

That being said, its a shame that of all the things to report about in the skeptical community, this is what gets reported in the main press. ETA: And a distorted overblown version at that.
 
Last edited:
That being said, its a shame that of all the things to report about in the skeptical community, this is what gets reported in the main press. ETA: And a distorted overblown version at that.

Lets raise a toast to PZ and his "name and shame" irrational approach to being a complete dick!
 
No, you can't generalize from those individual experiences to the whole group, but they are valid data points that I can consider when I trying to match their experiences to what you've described and what I, myself, have experienced at other conferences, like professional engineering conferences and local sci-fi conventions.

I gave a synopsis of the comments I've read from women how have attended such conferences and posted about them in my previous post. I can't conclude anything about what percentage they might be of women who have attended such conferences, but I can conclude the such experiences happen regularly and some women decide not to attend those events because of it.
I would be careful generalizing from your work related male dominated engineering conference experience and personal interest atheist or skeptical conferences.

I've been to one TAM, went on a cruise with 100 skeptics and meet once a month, sometimes more with both atheist and skeptic groups in this area. The atheist group is a long standing group of very good people and our skeptic group is growing by leaps and bounds. We've added numerous additional events and we had to move from our first skeptics at the pub location to one that could accomodate a larger crowd.

At TAM, people were flirting on both sides of the gender isle and it was clearly mutual. The success of the Skepchick party and for that matter the Skepchick calendar are evidence the behavior was what people were expecting. But it in no way dominated the rest of the event. Female speakers were clearly welcomed and valued. What nonsense if someone thinks their views were seen as less important. Just where is this "problem"? I'm sorry, but it definitely wasn't evident at TAM 5 or in the Seattle area groups.
 
Last edited:
AFAICT, this is part of Dawkins last response in the comments war:



Further down the page, plenty of other commenters explained it to him. And as its already been explained, explained and explained yet again in this thread I won't repeat the reasons why he is in error -- but he has not chosen to continue the conversation. I guess he still doesn't get it or perhaps he doesn't like to admit when he's wrong.

.....
Or perhaps not everyone agrees he is wrong.
 
I would be careful generalizing from your work related male dominated engineering conference experience and personal interest atheist or skeptical conferences.

Yes, we should always be careful not to generalize from our own personal views.

Female speakers were clearly welcomed and valued. What nonsense if someone thinks their views were seen as less important. Just where is this "problem"? I'm sorry, but it definitely wasn't evident at TAM 5 or in the Seattle area groups.

Whew. Glad we cleared that up. SG has spoken!
 
Let's take the conversation in a different direction:

Reading these threads I was initially disgusted with posters' inability to understand what was concerning about the confrontation in the elevator from Rebecca Watson's perspective.

Reading these comments I'm now more amused by the consternation posters have in distinguishing between appropriate ways of expressing interest in women and those that will be found offensive.

I can only conclude that a lot of people that don't deserve to be called "men" are playing that role on the internet. If a friend of mine pulled a creep move like that douche on the elevator and I found out about it...that guy would be getting **** for quite a while.

But sorry, I played sports and talked to girls in high school*, so maybe I can't empathize with the early development trauma necessary to create such an utterly piteous nature. Yes, I am directly questioning the manhood of anyone on this thread that believes that Elevator Guy acted remotely appropriately for a man. If he was 15 I'd let it slide. He, and anyone with a Y chromosome that handles their business as he does, cannot be given the title, "man," they're just boys. And that stands whether you're attracted to men or women.

*Unfortunately, they didn't really want to talk to me back then...
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom