So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Society has given you a do not call registry, gated communities, fences and trespassing laws because we respect that people and property have boundaries. These are examples that while you might be perfectly fine with being interrupted at dinner and having your rose bushes trampled, your view is not universal. People who disagree have done something about it and that has lead to solutions a bit more civilized then "Let them be jerks! I can take it!"
If only those means were effective keeping the sales minions away... sigh, that would be nice.

Touching would have crossed a boundary. I don't recall any social rule that says talking to a person after waiting until you are alone but still in a public place crosses a boundary. I get it my assessment with the rules differs from others in the discussion. I agree to disagree with you as I see no way to resolve our conflicting views.
 
That wasn't sarcasm that was a stupid attempt at trying to pass one of the most common logical fallacies around as an attempt as an argument. Seriously people. You are skeptics. Stop trying to excuse someone who evoked the same level of intellectual discourse that he rails against.
Eye of the beholder:

Because I agree with Dawkins, my view was he cited an example illustrating real sexism vs a minor minute of awkward discomfort.

For those in the discussion who don't agree with Dawkins, they are claiming he intended the extreme example to be the minimum threshold for a complaint to be justified.
 
You are talking about a man who was suggested by multiple people that the JREF ban from ever attending another TAM. That tells me right off the bat that something is seriously wrong with him and that you shouldn't just deal with him.
We had a guy a while back that I believe our fearless leader asked not to come to any more of our skeptic meetups. He scared people.

When you have a social group like the JREF community, membership is open to the public. People who might never be asked to come to the picnic show up. It's the nature of the beast, part social, part public.
 
Well, I can see how a skeptical conference would attract a larger percentage of socially awkward/nerdy/geeky/shy attendees than other conferences, but still don't see how the group in general would be more sexist or disrespectful to women than any other group of 800 people.
And so far, no convincing evidence this is the case has been presented either.
 
Stop lumping me in with these creepy people. I am socially awkward. I have done things that most normal people would not even consider doing. Harmless but awkward as all hell. I would never think of doing something this stupid unless I was really out of my mind.

Don't get mad at me. Get mad at the people who seem to think "socially awkward" is an all-purpose excuse for poor behavior.
 
I heard Rebecca hacked the phones at the News of the World...

Meanwhile, back at Rumour Control Headquarters...

Given most women probably don't stay away from sceptic conferences because of homoelevophobia - and assuming it's true the attendance at such things is still male biased, is it pertinent to ask why are there so many more men than women in sceptical circles?
Or would that be off topic? Damned if I can remember.
 
Don't get mad at me. Get mad at the people who seem to think "socially awkward" is an all-purpose excuse for poor behavior.

I'll get ******* mad at whoever the **** I want to. You can't ******* tell me what to do. You are not the ******* boss of me.

Sorry, I am a bit socially awkward and have trouble controlling my temper.
 
I'll get ******* mad at whoever the **** I want to. You can't ******* tell me what to do. You are not the ******* boss of me.

Sorry, I am a bit socially awkward and have trouble controlling my temper.

Well played.
 
All of the above? I enjoy the social aspects of skepticism as a movement because it's a bit intellectual. I'm 45, married and plain. In my 20's, I was proud that I had a scathing comeback for every occasion and of my ability to tackle the battle of the sexes with energy and wit. But I'm tired of it now. I gave as good as I got for 20 years, can't I go to one measly conference on science and rationality without having to revisit those days? Especially now that time has given me cover.

Thanks. It sounds like we really need that TAM survey, then.

I have social phobias so, like many people, I hide it with overly-energetic interaction as soon as I am uncomfortable. Before I found my TAM buddy (a truly wonderful gentleman who stuck by my side for days.) I was in constant frantic smiley chatty mode. Which makes me look like an idiot (leading to more social phobia stuff. yay me.) and is utterly exhausting after just a few hours.

Fortunately, I don't have that. I'm just very quiet, which makes me look calm or aloof, depending upon your perspective. :) But I do find attention (even just knowing someone is observing me) draining.

Linda
 
Full quotes are sometime more informative

I have no doubt that the topic was on Rebecca's mind throughout the day, but I have to question how much it really was the topic of conversation when it wasn't mentioned by someone who was there (under circumstances where it would have been relevant).

Linda
 
I ask, in all seriousness and completely devoid of sarcasm, what evidence could possibly convince you?
For starters, how about an explanation supporting the hypothesis? Some evidence this sexism among skeptics and atheists made sense?

I can support the hypothesis that many Christians and right wingers are of the sexist demographic. Maybe the older scientific and academic communities have a history of ignoring women's accomplishments. The younger academic and scientific communities, not so much.

But the larger demographic of our own community, both atheists and skeptics, tend to be more forward thinking rationalists, not the type to just follow traditions because they are comfortable with them. We tend to have many more people who look at evidence and reassess established beliefs, more flexible, in essence, more liberal. It is not the demographic of a sexist community.

Can you even propose an etiology of this supposed sexism?


And what is your criteria? Because there are a few jerks in every large group the whole group should be condemned? I was called a skeptic bimbo by Darth Rotor when we met in the forum. That was clearly sexist. And there are a few more worse personalities in the politics forum especially. But Darth and I have changed our views of each other (I have, I think he has anyway), and the rest tend to be a very small but prolific posting minorities. They are by no means representative of the group as a whole. If you took a slice of society even in the Western cultures, just as bias against blacks is still there, of course sexism is as well. But neither attitude dominates the forward thinking groups such as atheists and skeptics. It just doesn't.


Disclosure: I live on the liberated West Coast. Perhaps the skeptic and atheist communities of the Bible Belt, Texas and the South have a different demographic. I doubt it, but I'm willing to consider my personal experience is non-random.
 
Don't get mad at me. Get mad at the people who seem to think "socially awkward" is an all-purpose excuse for poor behavior.

I don't think many (if any) people are defending EG's jerkish behavior. The issue is claiming the behavior represented sexism and is common enough among skeptics and atheists as to affect a significant number of women's experience at formal events.
 
Last edited:
The issue is claiming the behavior represented sexism and is common enough among skeptics and atheists as to affect a significant number of women's experience at formal events.

How many affected women would you say constitutes an insignificant number?
 
How many affected women would you say constitutes an insignificant number?
A group of people viewing the world through cause-based distorted glasses. This is the exact opposite of skepticism (unless the cause is increasing the collective critical thinking skills of the human race, of course).
 
Last edited:
I've had women invite me back to their place at the bar. Sometimes we've only known eachother for less than an hour. Sometimes I'm interested, which is fortunate, sometimes I'm not, which is unfortunate. But I can't fathom finding it "sexist," or calling them "creepy" just for asking. Though I wince at that word creepy, since it seems like identical gestures go from romantic to endearing to creepy based on the attractiveness of the guy or girl in question...

She wasnt interested in him, I get it, but that doesn't make him sexist.
 
Passing thought : After this I for one certainly wouldn't feel comfortable getting into an elevator alone with Ms Watson, or indeed being any place alone with her. And if I found myself so, I'd be quite concerned about it and want to get out as fast as I could.

Ironic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom