So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Antique Hunter wins this thread. A bizarre read, for sure.

Best linked quote:
That's skeptics. Rational about everything except themselves, self-preservation, and manners.

I won't be at TAM, but I sincerely wish that all of you who go will have a great time.

I also hope that at some point at TAM, a crew of practical jokers will all walk out of a bank of elevators with the little coffee pots from their hotel rooms, and scurry about offering to fill people's cups .... or pull off a similar sort joke, but funny.

For SG: yes, Rebecca got banned for both Sock Puppetry and that escapade with access to areas she wasn't supposed to be in. Recall the FM discussion on that one, and also the company Watson's Knight's Errant rushing to defend her.

I expect R Dawkins will weather this modest storm.

EDIT: TraneWreck, EG is at least somewhat smart. He has remained anonymous. Rightly so.
 
Last edited:
I can only conclude that a lot of people that don't deserve to be called "men" are playing that role on the internet. If a friend of mine pulled a creep move like that douche on the elevator and I found out about it...that guy would be getting **** for quite a while..


So i was at work today and got invited to a project kickoff meeting. I was the only male in the room surrounded by 5 older women. They were all wearing blouses that exposed their ginormous cleavage. I felt creeped out, they made me uncomfortable and i couldn't leave..
 
So i was at work today and got invited to a project kickoff meeting. I was the only male in the room surrounded by 5 older women. They were all wearing blouses that exposed their ginormous cleavage. I felt creeped out, they made me uncomfortable and i couldn't leave..

That response has absolutely nothing to do with what I was talking about.

File a sexual harrassment complaint. Problem solved. You are welcome to feel how you feel, I was offering a comment on your responsibilities in your behavior towards others.
 
Yes, we should always be careful not to generalize from our own personal views.

Whew. Glad we cleared that up. SG has spoken!
Your attempt to sidestep the facts here is more than obvious. I didn't say Beth shouldn't generalize from her personal experience. I said a work related engineering conferences differed from non-work related atheist and skeptics conferences.
 
Jesus Christ I am so sick of this ********.
JC probably shares you sentiment on that one. :cool:
So i was at work today and got invited to a project kickoff meeting. I was the only male in the room surrounded by 5 older women. They were all wearing blouses that exposed their ginormous cleavage. I felt creeped out, they made me uncomfortable and i couldn't leave..
What, had you gone to work commando, and were thus unable to discretely conceal the tent polt? :confused:

Never go to work commando, it can lead to uncomfortable situations ...
 
EDIT: TraneWreck, EG is at least somewhat smart. He has remained anonymous. Rightly so.

Sure, a lot of really creepy people are smart. That's how they're able to be creepy for so long.

Then there are the dumb creeps, like Anthony Weiner...

Serious question not just directed at DR, if you found out that EG was your son, what would you tell him?

That answer would be interesting both from a male and female perspective. Anyone think they'd say, attaboy?
 
Last edited:
... I also hope that at some point at TAM, a crew of practical jokers will all walk out of a bank of elevators with the little coffee pots from their hotel rooms, and scurry about offering to fill people's cups .... or pull off a similar sort joke, but funny. ....
I'm pretty sure you can count on something related. :)
 
That being said, its a shame that of all the things to report about in the skeptical community, this is what gets reported in the main press. ETA: And a distorted overblown version at that.

Lets raise a toast to PZ and his "name and shame" irrational approach to being a complete dick!

Well, just to be clear here, I don't regret that this is being discussed within the skeptical community. My regret is that of all the topics and ideas that do get discussed within the community, that this is the one that spills over to mainstream media.

To be honest, I'm a little surprised that this has kicked up such a tempest in a coffee cup within the skeptical community -- but since it has, I think it should be discussed and discussed even to ad nauseum if necc.

Obviously there has been some serious disconnects and hopefully some people have now been able to see other people's perspectives as a result. Hopefully.
 
That response has absolutely nothing to do with what I was talking about.

File a sexual harrassment complaint. Problem solved. You are welcome to feel how you feel, I was offering a comment on your responsibilities in your behavior towards others.


Double standard much?
 
To be honest, I'm a little surprised that this has kicked up such a tempest in a coffee cup within the skeptical community -- but since it has, I think it should be discussed and discussed even to ad nauseum if necc.

Here's my opinion of why this has been such a big issue:

There are a lot (not all) of really pathetic men in the skeptical community that behave very similarly to EG. A woman calling out that type of behavior was seen as a broad condemnation of men at these conferences.

Being someone who doesn't behave that way, I laugh at that douche. Rebecca Watson just lifted up the rock and now we're seeing the bugs scurrying around.
 
Here's my opinion of why this has been such a big issue:

There are a lot (not all) of really pathetic men in the skeptical community that behave very similarly to EG. A woman calling out that type of behavior was seen as a broad condemnation of men at these conferences.

Being someone who doesn't behave that way, I laugh at that douche. Rebecca Watson just lifted up the rock and now we're seeing the bugs scurrying around.

Whats funny is that I could sit here and call you pathetic as well because you apparently feel the need to vocalize your superiority complex and judge a bunch of people you know absolutely nothing about.

Should we call this "Neo-Skepticism" or "Nu-Skepticism"???
 
Double standard much?

None at all. If you feel uncomfortable (and aren't just ********ting), then you have every right to ask women in your workplace to behave differently. You employer and maybe eventually the courts will decide the legitimacy of your request.

But what we have once again is a childish attempt at creating an equivalency. Notice that you are simpley concerned with the way the women looked. They did nothing to you, they just had low cut shirts. As we know from a certain geographical region of the planet, that sort of behavior is generally not compatable with an understanding of basic human rights. But whatever, there's a big gap there, and maybe they are dressed inappropriately. It's still not an act of aggression on their part (until you modify this ridiculous example to try and deal with this weakness).

Second, there is no threat of violence in that room, it's just you being upset about looking at breasts, which again, you have every right to feel that way. Of course, you think you're being clever right now, so there's really no way to take you seriously.

The issue in the elevator was one of isolation and the latent threat of something inappropriate happening. When Rebecca was in that elevator, she was at the mercy of that person propositioning her. There was no such threat in the air in your example.

It's just another silly, frivolous attempt at thinking your perception of the world gives you definitive insight into the perception of others. Again, this is the stuff boys do, not men.
 
Last edited:
Whats funny is that I could sit here and call you pathetic as well because you apparently feel the need to vocalize your superiority complex and judge a bunch of people you know absolutely nothing about.

Should we call this "Neo-Skepticism" or "Nu-Skepticism"???

Yeah, except I do know something about them. I know that anyone who behaves like EG or thinks the way he behaved was acceptable is not someone worthy of respect.

But yes, I am speculating on the reason for the hyper-emotional male reaction to this issue. I cannot see any reason why any man would care about EG being called out otherwise. He's a douche.

If you were my friend, my brother, my son, and I found out you were doing stuff like that, I would stage an intervention. I would hope the people close to me cared enough to do the same were I to behave in such a pathetic way. Setting aside Rebecca Watson's experience (the people who don't value her perception of the world never will, that's pretty clear), no self-respecting man should be arguing for the ability to pull BS moves like that without the fear of criticism.
 
Last edited:
But yes, I am speculating on the reason for the hyper-emotional male reaction to this issue. I cannot see any reason why any man would care about EG being called out otherwise. He's a douche.

Maybe because you're missing the point of what people are upset about?
 
...
Best linked quote:.....
Some of the related/adjacent comments are worth honorable mention:
And the best question: Have the world's self-professed rationalists really spent the last week arguing about a proposition in an elevator?

Jesus, they have. It's enough to make you wonder if anybody knows what the hell rationality's all about. Not incidentally, this isn't the first time skeptics have become so uselessly derailed. This is the movement that almost boarded up shop for a week last year while it tried to figure out if the "Skepticon" gathering had too many atheists on its speaker roster, and oughtn't therefore be called "Atheistcon." This is the movement in which a respected leader not long ago gave a talk entitled "Don't Be a Dick," and the suggestion was so novel that nobody shut up about it for weeks.

That's skeptics. Rational about everything except themselves, self-preservation, and manners.
I must need a life. I'm all too aware of all three "useless derails".
 
Last edited:
Here's my opinion of why this has been such a big issue:

There are a lot (not all) of really pathetic men in the skeptical community that behave very similarly to EG. A woman calling out that type of behavior was seen as a broad condemnation of men at these conferences.

Being someone who doesn't behave that way, I laugh at that douche. Rebecca Watson just lifted up the rock and now we're seeing the bugs scurrying around.

Well since you bring it up ... I have wondered how much of the blogwar is due to how this issue was expressed.

I mean if a guy had made a video blog where he discussed some very objectional behavior by a woman and than said "OK, to the atheist gals, don't be this gal." -- part of me would have been annoyed. If ONE woman had done something seriously objectionable -- why should ALL of the women in the community be given a talking to, so to speak?

I don't think Rebecca meant to do that to ALL of the men, but I can see how some people would feel like that is what she did and object to that.

As to the folks who can't see how creepy that guy was or who think that they have the right to approach everyone with innuendos for sex without taking even a few split seconds to size up the situation -- grow up. Really.

FWIW, I'm conservative in some ways and I agree with the poster upthread who said that he finds it offensive to be asked for sex by a stranger. But I also don't have a problem with telling people no and letting them know why I'm saying no.

"I don't do casual hook-ups", "My eyes are up here buddy", and pointed comments about wives are all statements that I've been very comfortable making when I needed to.
 
Sure, a lot of really creepy people are smart. That's how they're able to be creepy for so long.

Then there are the dumb creeps, like Anthony Weiner...

Serious question not just directed at DR, if you found out that EG was your son, what would you tell him?

That answer would be interesting both from a male and female perspective. Anyone think they'd say, attaboy?

Serious answer:

If my son told me about the incident at 0400, and the reaction of Ms Watson, I'd look at him and say something like:

"Son, that's not a great way to meet someone. It's a way to make someone wish not to meet you."

We'd then need to talk about people skills for a while. He'd probably blow me off, being my son, and a college freshman. :cool:
 
It's just another silly, frivolous attempt at thinking your perception of the world gives you definitive insight into the perception of others. Again, this is the stuff boys do, not men.

I certainly hope i fulfilled your internet macho needs! I could find someone else in another forum that would claim we're both dweebs hiding in our basements but does that solve anything?

HINT.. i have no problem with Watson calling out someone creepy for elevator macking.. where i got annoyed with the hole thing was when PZ Meyers escalated the issue WAYYYYY beyond blip of a blurb on what Watsons youtube video clip made..

But you could have asked that instead of calling people "not real men" if they're not 100% behind skeptchick

If there is a serious douche bag problem amongst TAM / skeptic conventions i wouldn't know.. I haven't attended any. I do however partake in CFI meetups and other organizations and more often than not, women outnumber the men.
 
Last edited:
Maybe because you're missing the point of what people are upset about?

No, I see the weak rationalizations and lame justifications surrounding the issue of EG's behavior.

There are a ton of related issues that Rebecca Watson brought up that I seriously disagree with, but her sensation of being threatened on that elevator by the pathetic, embarassing behavior of a cynical simulacrum of man is absolutely correct.

Do I take it that you're no longer trying to defend this idiot's behavior with absurd analogies?
 
I certainly hope i fulfilled your internet macho needs! I could find someone else in another forum that would claim we're both dweebs hiding in our basements but does that solve anything?

Yeah, I think you agree with me, but because of the rule of internet arguing*, you can't admit it.

You know as well as I do that this fellow behaved attrociously. I don't know why anyone tries to defend it, even in the most tepid of ways.

*Whatever position you intially take, you must defend to the death...or until the thread gets burried.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom