Peter Morris said:
I quoted some guy's stated reason for not taking the test. I invited you to include that reason on your list.
Now your demand for "evidence" confuses me. See, here's the scenario:
Peter: Here's one for your list. A claimed dowser has rejected the test. His reason given was
"it is unacceptable to put a lump of sulfide mineralisation, or a gold ring, or any other substitute for an orebody under a cardboard box and ask me to detect that by dowsing. It won't work. It must be done under real field conditions over real sulfide mineralisation. I have had no response from the Australian Sketpics, other than to invite me to the next round of testing of water dowsers. Presumably, they are going to ask the dowsers to detect bottles of water or pipes of water. It won't work, because that's not how dowsing works. I will contact them again and try to get a better response out of them. I will let you know how I get on.
There, that's a common reason. Put that on your list.
Peter Morris, you should have read the whole thread about the conversation between KRAMER and the dowsers.
The dowser complains that Australian Skeptics, which have offer a price for dowsing for which one could apply without applying for JREFs, ask for a test, he can not pass with his abilities, because they work differently.
KRAMERs response:
Dear Carl,
Please suggest a test protocol that you feel can best and most easily verify your sulfide mineralization claim. - KRAMER, JREF
So KRAMER accepted in this case, that the dowser explecitely said that he can only dowse for natural sources of water and minerals and showed that he was willing to find a protocol.
The dowsers then gives some thoughts, how the test could be conducted( geologist check where something is, he does not know and gets blindfolded and tries to find it) and, now listen closely,
KRAMER does not reject any of his thoughts.
What will make you especially happy is that KRAMER realized, that he could not rely upon aussie sceptics to conduct the test ("As Australian Skeptics has already proven to be a bit resistant to testing this specific claim, JREF is looking forward to finding independent investigators to assist us in the testing of Carl Brauhart.") and only notices it might be difficult to find enough help to conduct the test
So sorry, though i know that the excuse you named, might well appear, here it was not used to avoid JREF challenge, only to avoid aussie challenge and KRAMER indirectly agreed with the dowser, that it was wrong of aussie sceptics, to insist of a test protocol, that was unacceptable for the dowser.
So please find another source for the excuse you named, i'm certain there is somewhere one.
Also this applicant withdrew, because he tested his abilities under conditions, which he thought might be those he has to deal with in a JREF test.
He failed and drew the logic consequence, that he needs more knowledge about how and under which conditions, he can perform, before negotiating any test protocol for his abilities.
Which i think was very clever, because obviously if you do not know when you can perform, it might happen that you agree to a test protocol, which you think you can manage, but then fail.
So please cite from anywhere else, in this case there was no lame excuse to avoid JREF challenge, it was very reasonable and honest:
"I was very confident that I could dowse sulfide mineralisation under all conditions but today I did an extensive blind-fold test with work colleagues and the results were all over the place.
Candour in this situation is probably the best approach.I am not ready to submit to a test and so I am forced to withdraw my challenge, or, at least, postpone it. I am, however, still intrigued by dowsing."
Carn
BTW, i would be still interested in your answer to my post over here
http://www.randi.org/vbulletin/showthread.php?threadid=44920&perpage=40&pagenumber=3 .