Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

And you continue to weasel out.

I've given you several quotes for your list, specific people who have stated their reasons for not taking Randi's challenge.

Why are you unwilling to include them on your list?

could it be because the complaints are reasonable, and you have no answer for them?
 
Peter Morris said:
And you continue to weasel out.

I've given you several quotes for your list, specific people who have stated their reasons for not taking Randi's challenge.

Why are you unwilling to include them on your list?

could it be because the complaints are reasonable, and you have no answer for them?

No.

Why are you unwilling to acknowledge that Anett Kofoed's quote is evidence of my claim?
 
CFLarsen said:
No.

Why are you unwilling to acknowledge that Anett Kofoed's quote is evidence of my claim?

Well, Larsen, it's because I don't understand what you mean by "evidence" That is why I keep asking you to explain. And you keep refusing to explain.

Now, here's the situation as I see it.
CARL BRAUHART, a claimed dowser, won't take the test offered by Randi's Australian chums, because he claims it's unfair and unacceptable.

Anett Kofoedd, a claimed psychic, won't take the test because she claims that the money has bad energy.

Now, you say that :
- You WILL include Kofoedd's excuse because you HAVE evidence for it.
- You WONT include the dowser's excuse, because you LACK evidence for it.

Now, I've invited you to say what "evidence" you are referring to, and you refuse to answer. What can you possibly mean?

Possibility 1 : You want a cite for the quote.

But I have given you the cite. Kramer reports the dowser saying this.

Possibility 2 : You want evidence that dowsing works.

Maybe that's what you are saying. The man says he can dowse. Perhaps you won't include his excuse without evidence that he really can dowse.

But, you will list the psychics excuse. And you say that you have evidence. So, are you saying that you have evidence of her psychic powers?

Possibility 3 : you want evidence of unfairness.

This could be it. The dowser has said the test is unfair. Perhaps you want evidence of that?

But the psychic has said the money has bad energy. And you say you have evidence . So, you accept as true that the money has bad energy?


Of course, you may mean something else entirely.


Once again, I invite you to say what you mean.
 
Peter Morris said:
So, sarcasm is worse than deliberate dishionesty and severe incompitence?

Beating up strawmen and putting words in people's mouths is not 'sarcasm'. Given your pedantry, this level of deliberate deception is quite telling about your own honestly.

And for the record, "deliberate dishonesty: and "severe incompetence" are very bad things, however you have failed to prove your accusations. You have had to act in a deliberately dishonest manner to make it seem as if there was a smidgeon of evidence.
 
Peter Morris said:
Well, Larsen, it's because I don't understand what you mean by "evidence" That is why I keep asking you to explain. And you keep refusing to explain.

No, I do not. Stop telling people what they say or mean.

Peter Morris said:
Now, here's the situation as I see it.
CARL BRAUHART, a claimed dowser, won't take the test offered by Randi's Australian chums, because he claims it's unfair and unacceptable.

But it is not unfair and it is not unacceptable.

Peter Morris said:
You WONT include the dowser's excuse, because you LACK evidence for it.

No, I don't exclude the dowser's excuse because I lack evidence of that he said it.

Let me get this straight, OK? Do you want me to include Brauhart's excuses, because you think they are valid or not valid?

Valid or not valid?
 
Peter Morris said:
I quoted some guy's stated reason for not taking the test. I invited you to include that reason on your list.

Now your demand for "evidence" confuses me. See, here's the scenario:


Peter: Here's one for your list. A claimed dowser has rejected the test. His reason given was

"it is unacceptable to put a lump of sulfide mineralisation, or a gold ring, or any other substitute for an orebody under a cardboard box and ask me to detect that by dowsing. It won't work. It must be done under real field conditions over real sulfide mineralisation. I have had no response from the Australian Sketpics, other than to invite me to the next round of testing of water dowsers. Presumably, they are going to ask the dowsers to detect bottles of water or pipes of water. It won't work, because that's not how dowsing works. I will contact them again and try to get a better response out of them. I will let you know how I get on.

There, that's a common reason. Put that on your list.


Peter Morris, you should have read the whole thread about the conversation between KRAMER and the dowsers.

The dowser complains that Australian Skeptics, which have offer a price for dowsing for which one could apply without applying for JREFs, ask for a test, he can not pass with his abilities, because they work differently.

KRAMERs response: Dear Carl,
Please suggest a test protocol that you feel can best and most easily verify your sulfide mineralization claim. - KRAMER, JREF


So KRAMER accepted in this case, that the dowser explecitely said that he can only dowse for natural sources of water and minerals and showed that he was willing to find a protocol.

The dowsers then gives some thoughts, how the test could be conducted( geologist check where something is, he does not know and gets blindfolded and tries to find it) and, now listen closely, KRAMER does not reject any of his thoughts.

What will make you especially happy is that KRAMER realized, that he could not rely upon aussie sceptics to conduct the test ("As Australian Skeptics has already proven to be a bit resistant to testing this specific claim, JREF is looking forward to finding independent investigators to assist us in the testing of Carl Brauhart.") and only notices it might be difficult to find enough help to conduct the test

So sorry, though i know that the excuse you named, might well appear, here it was not used to avoid JREF challenge, only to avoid aussie challenge and KRAMER indirectly agreed with the dowser, that it was wrong of aussie sceptics, to insist of a test protocol, that was unacceptable for the dowser.

So please find another source for the excuse you named, i'm certain there is somewhere one.

Also this applicant withdrew, because he tested his abilities under conditions, which he thought might be those he has to deal with in a JREF test.
He failed and drew the logic consequence, that he needs more knowledge about how and under which conditions, he can perform, before negotiating any test protocol for his abilities.
Which i think was very clever, because obviously if you do not know when you can perform, it might happen that you agree to a test protocol, which you think you can manage, but then fail.

So please cite from anywhere else, in this case there was no lame excuse to avoid JREF challenge, it was very reasonable and honest:

"I was very confident that I could dowse sulfide mineralisation under all conditions but today I did an extensive blind-fold test with work colleagues and the results were all over the place.

Candour in this situation is probably the best approach.I am not ready to submit to a test and so I am forced to withdraw my challenge, or, at least, postpone it. I am, however, still intrigued by dowsing."



Carn

BTW, i would be still interested in your answer to my post over here http://www.randi.org/vbulletin/showthread.php?threadid=44920&perpage=40&pagenumber=3 .
 
CFLarsen said:
No, I do not. Stop telling people what they say or mean.

But it is not unfair and it is not unacceptable.


Ah, now we're getting somewhere. You've finally said what you mean. I'm glad of that.


So, someone says the test is unfair. And you won't includen that on list because there's no evidence that it's unfair.

Another person says the money is cursed. And you will include that on the list, because you have evidence that its cursed.

A very strang attitude for a skeptic to take, frankly.


Let me get this straight, OK? Do you want me to include Brauhart's excuses, because you think they are valid or not valid?

Valid or not valid?

Hey, YOU are the one claiming that you have "evidence," Larsen.
 
Peter Morris said:
Ah, now we're getting somewhere. You've finally said what you mean. I'm glad of that.


So, someone says the test is unfair. And you won't includen that on list because there's no evidence that it's unfair.

Another person says the money is cursed. And you will include that on the list, because you have evidence that its cursed.

A very strang attitude for a skeptic to take, frankly.

You are one seriously disturbed person, Peter. How can you possibly claim that I think that the money is cursed??

Peter Morris said:
Hey, YOU are the one claiming that you have "evidence," Larsen.

Whatever.

Do you want me to include Brauhart's excuses, because you think they are valid or not valid?

Valid or not valid?
 
Carn said:
Peter Morris, you should have read the whole thread about the conversation between KRAMER and the dowsers.

The dowser complains that Australian Skeptics, which have offer a price for dowsing for which one could apply without applying for JREFs, ask for a test, he can not pass with his abilities, because they work differently.

So KRAMER accepted in this case ....

So sorry, though i know that the excuse you named, might well appear, here it was not used to avoid JREF challenge, only to avoid aussie challenge and KRAMER indirectly

So please find another source for the excuse you named, i'm certain there is somewhere one., but then fail.

So please cite from anywhere else, in this case there was no lame excuse to avoid JREF challenge, it was very reasonable and honest:

"I was very confident that I could dowse sulfide mineralisation under all conditions but today I did an extensive blind-fold test with work colleagues and the results were all over the place.

Thank you for your politeness. Very rare on this forum.

I underastand what you're saying, but still this withdrawal is a good example of what I'm saying.

At the end of the discussion, the man's position was : I believe dowsing works. I believe that I have some dowsing skills. But I have tried the specific test you offer, and it doesn't work under those precise conditions. I can dowse, but not in the exact way you want me to. So I'm not taking the test, for the moment. I might try again at a later date.

So, really, this withdrawal was because he found the test protocol to be unacceptable. And there was no other protocol on offer.

I suspect that this is the most common reason for not taking the test.
 
CFLarsen said:
You are one seriously disturbed person, Peter. How can you possibly claim that I think that the money is cursed??


Its what you said, Larsen. Your claim, not mine.

You demanded evidence for the dowser's claim, but said that you already had evidence for hers.

Do you want me to include Brauhart's excuses, because you think they are valid or not valid?

Valid or not valid?

Larsen, lets be serious.

You said you had evidence for Brauharts excuses, but it's pretty obvious that you said a stupid thing that you didn't mean, then refused to withdraw it. In fact, you don't have evidence for her claim.

Now, look at your list.

"James Randi makes a lot of money from this."

Did you demand evidence of this, Larsen? Are you only willing to put this on your list if it is true?

"James Randi doesn't have the money."

Did you demand evidence of this, Larsen? Are you only willing to put this on your list if it is true?

"Randi will never pay, because he depends on the income."

Did you demand evidence of this, Larsen? Are you only willing to put this on your list if it is true?

The money is tainted. It will only bring misery and pain.


Did you demand evidence of this, Larsen? Are you only willing to put this on your list if it is true?

I can only perform if no sceptic is in any way involved in the experimental design/testing process"

Did you demand evidence of this, Larsen? Are you only willing to put this on your list if it is true?

"If I do this in public, they will lock me up in the Pentagon or in a nuthouse."

Did you demand evidence of this, Larsen? Are you only willing to put this on your list if it is true?

I tried contacting Randi to discuss a test protocol. I received nothing but a stream of ad hominem abuse in response.

Did you demand evidence of this, Larsen? Are you only willing to put this on your list if it is true?

The test protocol offered by Randi isn't a fair test of my abilities

Did you demand evidence of this, Larsen? Are you only willing to put this on your list if it is true?

I'm really puzzled by your rather hypocritical attitude.

Why are the ones I suggested the only ones that require "evidence?"
 
Peter Morris said:
Its what you said, Larsen. Your claim, not mine.

You demanded evidence for the dowser's claim, but said that you already had evidence for hers.

Stop right here. Let's get this out of the way, before we move any further.

Where have I claimed that the money is cursed?

And let's get this one out of the way, too:

Do you want me to include Brauhart's excuses, because you think they are valid or not valid?

Valid or not valid?
 
CFLarsen said:
Stop right here. Let's get this out of the way, before we move any further.

Where have I claimed that the money is cursed?

And let's get this one out of the way, too:

Do you want me to include Brauhart's excuses, because you think they are valid or not valid?

Valid or not valid?

You're dodging the question, Larsen

You repeatedly claimed that you had evidence for her claim.

And I answered your question in my last post.

Now, answer my question.
 
Peter Morris said:
You're dodging the question, Larsen

You repeatedly claimed that you had evidence for her claim.

And I answered your question in my last post.

Now, answer my question.

Sorry, but there is absolutely no doubt: You are a woo.
 
CFLarsen said:
Sorry, but there is absolutely no doubt: You are a woo.


Definition of woo : someone who exposes the lies of a fraud.

Larsen, you are a coward who dare not answer the question I asked.

You are a liar and a fraud, Larsen. Your list is a work of fiction. Most of the items you and your cronies have simply made up. I've shown you real reasons given for not taking Randi's test. You cannot answer those, so you refuse to include them on your list. That's cowardice, Larsen.

Now, coward, answer my question.

Why does my example require "evidence" when none of the others do?
 
Folks, Larsen claimed that he has "evidence" of the cursed money claim. Now he denies saying it. For everyone's benefit, I'll just remind you of the stupid things he came out with. Note his repeated insistence that he has evidence in the quote he supplied, and that his evidence supports the cursed money claim.

Note that he rejects my suggestions, because he wants evidence, but includes the cursed money because he already has evidence. Watch as he repeatedly claims he has evidence of cursed money .... then desperately backtracks away from his statements.

Peter : Kookbreaker provided us with one of the actual common excuses : I tried negotiating a test protocol with him, I only received abusive language in response to my attempts, Randi's childish misbehaviour made it impossible to continue.

The person may or may not be telling the truth, but that is about the most common reason given that I've seen.

Or then there's : I don't trust Randi. I consider him dishonest. I'm willing to be tested independently, but I will not be tested by that particular man, or his close assosiates. Randi has refused an independant tester.
example

Or then there's : I don't like the test Randi is offereing me. My dowsing skill enables me to find minerals or water in large quantities in the ground. Randi's test design insists that I find small quantities underneath a cup. That's a different thing, which I can't do..

Put those in your list, Larsen.


Larsen : I'm most willing to. All I need is evidence.

Peter : Evidence of what, Larsen? .... However, and this is the point that confuses me, your list already contains the claim that some people refuse the test because the money is cursed.

So, I presume that you already have evidence of that? Since you need evidence before you include an item on your list.

Larsen : Here you go:
Re the "dirty money" that Danish numerologist Annet Kofoed says, on that same Boesen site, that she doesn't want from the JREF, reader William Rentfrow suggests:

If the physical money is somehow "cursed," couldn't she just exchange it? "Hello, I'd like to exchange this for some non-cursed money, please." It's a practical approach.

Or give it away to an enemy...?

Peter : First of all, congrats for providing the cite. Now repeat for all items on your list.

You see my dilemma, Larsen? You consider evidence missing when someone complains that Randi's design for a protocol is unfair, yet evidence present when someone says the money is cursed. So I ask again. What evidence would that be? Evidence of what?

Larsen : Whoa....just a second. Do you admit that there was evidence? Yes or no?

Peter : What is the "evidence" that you want. Some evidence that
- is missing from the dowsers statement
- yet present in the claim that the money is cursed.

You refuse to include the dowsers statement because you say there is no evidence.

You include the cursed money because there IS evidence.

Where is the evidence of the cursed money, Larsen?

Larsen : It's in my post. "Annet Kofoed". Now, where is the evidence of dowsing you spoke of?

Peter : It is a proven fact that someone claimed to have evidence, offered to show it to Randi, and Randi refused to look. Randi refused to look at the evidence. That does not mean I believe the evidence is true. Only that Randi is a proven liar, just like you.

Now, tell me what evidence you have to support the excuse that the money is cursed.

Larsen : Have you seen the Kofoed quote?

Peter : What is your evidence, Larsen? You say that there is some evidence you have that is :
- missing from the dowsers quote
- present in the claim that the money is cursed.

I'm still wondering what that evidence might be.

Larsen : Why are you unwilling to acknowledge that Anett Kofoed's quote is evidence of my claim?

Peter : Now, here's the situation as I see it.
CARL BRAUHART, a claimed dowser, won't take the test offered by Randi's Australian chums, because he claims it's unfair and unacceptable.

Anett Kofoedd, a claimed psychic, won't take the test because she claims that the money has bad energy.

Now, you say that :
- You WILL include Kofoedd's excuse because you HAVE evidence for it.
- You WONT include the dowser's excuse, because you LACK evidence for it.

Now, I've invited you to say what "evidence" you are referring to, and you refuse to answer. What can you possibly mean?

Possibility 1 : You want a cite for the quote.
Possibility 2 : You want evidence that dowsing works.
Possibility 3 : you want evidence of unfairness.

Larsen : But it is not unfair and it is not unacceptable.

Peter : Ah, now we're getting somewhere. You've finally said what you mean. I'm glad of that. So, someone says the test is unfair. And you won't includen that on list because there's no evidence that it's unfair. Another person says the money is cursed. And you will include that on the list, because you have evidence that its cursed.

Larsen : You are one seriously disturbed person, Peter. How can you possibly claim that I think that the money is cursed?? .

Peter : You demanded evidence for the dowser's claim, but said that you already had evidence for hers..

Larsen : Sorry, but there is absolutely no doubt: You are a woo.
 
Holy crizzap, Peter Morris. Do you not know how stupid you look?

He has evidence of the claim being made-- it doesn't matter if it's true or not BECAUSE it's an excuse that was actually made by an actual person.

Really, it's a list of stupid excuses for why people don't want to go for the million. Come on.

Your blowing it out of proportion to the point of inane absurdity makes my head hurt. For the love of the great IPU, man, just stop.
 
Nex said:
Holy crizzap, Peter Morris. Do you not know how stupid you look?

He has evidence of the claim being made-- it doesn't matter if it's true or not BECAUSE it's an excuse that was actually made by an actual person.

Actually no. Read what he wrote.

Here's a summary.

1) I provided links to a dowser protesting that the test on offer was unfair and unsuitable. I invited Larsen to put it on his list.

2) Larsen replied saying that he requires evidence before it goes on the list.

3) I pointed out to him that one of the items on the list was "the money is cursed" and he didn't require evidence for that.

At this point a sensible person would have replied "hey, good point, it doesn't have to be true to go on the list. None of the others are true, yours goes on the list too. I don't need proof"

Sadly, Larsen is not sensible. so ...

4) Larsen claimed that he DOES have evidence for the curse on the money.

5) Hijinks ensue. Larsen repeatedly demanding that I prove the dowser's claim, while claiming that he has proved the money is cursed.

Pretty dumb thing for him to say, really. He shot himself in the foot with his double standards.
 
Your blowing it out of proportion to the point of inane absurdity makes my head hurt. For the love of the great IPU, man, just stop.

AGREED!

The thread is "Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge", not "Rock Solid Arguments for refuting Extensively Documented Claims".

If the list of "lame excuses" isn't good enough for you, then by all means you have the right to maintain your skepticism about this subject.
 
So, Larsen shouldn't be held accountable for his dishonesty?

One of the common reasons for not taking the challenge (possibly the most common) is : I tried to negotiate a protocol, but wasn't able to agree on a fair test with him. The test he is offerring isn't a fair test of my skills.

Larsen has point blank refused to include that on his list.
 
Peter Morris said:
One of the common reasons for not taking the challenge (possibly the most common) is : I tried to negotiate a protocol, but wasn't able to agree on a fair test with him. The test he is offerring isn't a fair test of my skills.

Larsen has point blank refused to include that on his list.
False. This excuse is listed on the first page:
"Randi sets the bar too high. The test is impossible."

We cannot relax the conditions to an extent where it is possible for you to cheat.
There are other entries on the list that could arguably be applied, like
"James Randi won't let me take the challenge."
listed in the first post and certainly
"Some things just can't be quantified by your limited scientific methods"

1. Then how do you distinguish between a real phenomenon and one that is not?

2. We don't even need scientific methods. If it can be shown to exist, then you win the money.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom