Kimpatsu said:
you just claim that because I can't give you chapter and verse, it doesn't exist!
That is not correct, Kimpatsu. I have NOT claimed that it doesn't exist. Please, cease repeating this embarassing falsehood of yours.
No, it is not a false dichotomy. Either you have some doubts that the quote exists, or you have NO doubt. Which is it?
You changed what you previously said. Now you included "some". Before, you just typed that either I doubt it exists or I don't, which was indeed a false dichotomy. In any case, doubt is not the same as denial, as I have already pointed out to you.
I don't know the specirfic file or time because I listened to them all one after the other, many moons ago.
So you are going based on your recollection here, right? It could be flawed, right?
You haven't even listened to them once.
By what basis do you make that outlandish claim, Kimpatsu?
In fact, I've listened to all of the July 2003 ones. Nope, no such quote there. Oh maybe it was elsewhere...

So what is your story now?
For the last time: "...I doubt that it exists" is sayign that you believe that it doesn't exist.
I am skeptical of it. Now, I know it doesn't exist in the July audio, despite you claiming so vocally otherwise. Again, I doubt, not deny. Evidence is always, and still, welcome, Kimpatsu. If you are able to find where it actually is, not send us on a wild goose chase of where you believe it could be, let us know.
I can figure it out. If you'd been listening since you started your tirade, you would have found the source by now.
I listened to all of the July 2003 ones, and nope, not there. Again, you had no basis to say that I wasn't listening to the audios, but don't let that stop your personal agenda.
Ergo, you haven't been listening.
See above.
Your first post, however, was made this morning (my time), which is at least six hours ago! And you keep coming back every 10 minutes with a reply. Consequently, you have clearly expended more time reading my posts and replying to them than you have listening to the recordings. QED.
And you keep coming back too. What is your point? Your mistake is that you assumed that I hadn't been listening to the audios, Kimpatsu. You assumed, and you were wrong. You were also wrong in thinking that the July audios contained the quote which you were so sure existed there.
So you DO think the claim is flase; i.e., that Randi never made the statement?
I am skeptical of it. I am open to seeing the actual evidence... still.
And that's a wild exaggeration. I'm pointing to one of four books on the shelves; now it's up to you to do the rest, and actually listen!
Newsflash, it was
always up to you to find it, because you made the claim. However, I listened to all the July ones. Nope, it wasn't there.
Now what, Kimpatsu?