Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

jzs said:
Kimpatsu, specifically, which audio file is it? You do not know this. Therefore, you have not "found it" for me. You just pointed out the general area where you believe it might be located. Do you believe this is providing an actual reference? You'd get marked down if you put that in any paper in the 'References' section.
But this isn't a bloody essay! You're not even prepared to try to find the file; you just claim that because I can't give you chapter and verse, it doesn't exist!
jzs said:
I cannot have some doubt? I have to have all or none? That is a false dichotomy, Kimpatsu. I have some doubts, based on your lack of evidence and avoidal to provide a specific reference. I don't deny it exists, which is what you incorrectly claimed.
No, it is not a false dichotomy. Either you have some doubts that the quote exists, or you have NO doubt. Which is it?
jzs said:
That is a strawman. Why would you need a transcript to know which one it was in? You mean you don't remember which one it was in? So all this time you've just been guessing where it is?
Yes; an educated guess. I KNOW the general area; I don't know the specirfic file or time because I listened to them all one after the other, many moons ago. You haven't even listened to them once. If I had a transcript, however, say in PDF format, I'd search and find the exact quote immediately. So, how is that a strawman?
jzs said:
Kimpatsu, you are still mistaken. I never claimed Randi didn't make that statement. You claimed he did, however. If I claimed that Randi didn't make the statement, please, show me my exact quote (not what you believe I supposedly implied, etc).
For the last time: "...I doubt that it exists" is sayign that you believe that it doesn't exist. It means that you entertain virtually no doubnt of the subject.
jzs said:
Please, show me these quantities
a) time I've spent typing here
and
b) time I've spent listening to the recordings
You'd have to know both of those, somehow, to make the (another!) claim you did. Unless.... you were making another claim without actual evidence.
I can figure it out. If you'd been listening since you started your tirade, you would have found the source by now. Ergo, you haven't been listening. Your first post, however, was made this morning (my time), which is at least six hours ago! And you keep coming back every 10 minutes with a reply. Consequently, you have clearly expended more time reading my posts and replying to them than you have listening to the recordings. QED.
jzs said:
Regardless of my opportunity cost, that doesn't have anything to do with you providing evidence for your claim.
So you DO think the claim is flase; i.e., that Randi never made the statement?
jzs said:
Exactly, which is why you have not provided a direct reference, just a vague area where you believe it might be located.
Yes; so go listen. You might even learn something! You would certainly find the quote.
jzs said:
All that implies is that I wanted to hear him say that. YOU made the claim he said that. I want to see the evidence (which you can't seem to actually specifically find).
Not CAN'T find; I would have to listen to the recordings over again. Why don't you try listening to them for the first time?! Your refusal to listen is tantamount to sticking your fingers in your ears and humming loudly, in an effort to avoid actually finding the source. It's bloody childish.
jzs said:
You don't know which one specifically, so you aren't really pointing anywhere (or rather you are pointing everywhere, like to all books in a library).
And that's a wild exaggeration. I'm pointing to one of four books on the shelves; now it's up to you to do the rest, and actually listen!
 
Kimpatsu said:
you just claim that because I can't give you chapter and verse, it doesn't exist!


That is not correct, Kimpatsu. I have NOT claimed that it doesn't exist. Please, cease repeating this embarassing falsehood of yours.


No, it is not a false dichotomy. Either you have some doubts that the quote exists, or you have NO doubt. Which is it?


You changed what you previously said. Now you included "some". Before, you just typed that either I doubt it exists or I don't, which was indeed a false dichotomy. In any case, doubt is not the same as denial, as I have already pointed out to you.


I don't know the specirfic file or time because I listened to them all one after the other, many moons ago.


So you are going based on your recollection here, right? It could be flawed, right?


You haven't even listened to them once.


By what basis do you make that outlandish claim, Kimpatsu? In fact, I've listened to all of the July 2003 ones. Nope, no such quote there. Oh maybe it was elsewhere... :rolleyes: So what is your story now?


For the last time: "...I doubt that it exists" is sayign that you believe that it doesn't exist.


I am skeptical of it. Now, I know it doesn't exist in the July audio, despite you claiming so vocally otherwise. Again, I doubt, not deny. Evidence is always, and still, welcome, Kimpatsu. If you are able to find where it actually is, not send us on a wild goose chase of where you believe it could be, let us know.


I can figure it out. If you'd been listening since you started your tirade, you would have found the source by now.


I listened to all of the July 2003 ones, and nope, not there. Again, you had no basis to say that I wasn't listening to the audios, but don't let that stop your personal agenda.


Ergo, you haven't been listening.


See above.


Your first post, however, was made this morning (my time), which is at least six hours ago! And you keep coming back every 10 minutes with a reply. Consequently, you have clearly expended more time reading my posts and replying to them than you have listening to the recordings. QED.


And you keep coming back too. What is your point? Your mistake is that you assumed that I hadn't been listening to the audios, Kimpatsu. You assumed, and you were wrong. You were also wrong in thinking that the July audios contained the quote which you were so sure existed there.


So you DO think the claim is flase; i.e., that Randi never made the statement?


I am skeptical of it. I am open to seeing the actual evidence... still.


And that's a wild exaggeration. I'm pointing to one of four books on the shelves; now it's up to you to do the rest, and actually listen!

Newsflash, it was always up to you to find it, because you made the claim. However, I listened to all the July ones. Nope, it wasn't there.

Now what, Kimpatsu?
 
jzs said:
So if someone is enthusiastic, deluded, brags, or is simply mistaken, and claims they can get 20 out of 20 everytime, they don't, but get 18 out of 20 or something still statistically significant, you are saying we just throw it out? Forget that it was significant? Seems like you are wanting to throw standard scientific method out the window.

You seem intent on misunderstanding people. I did not say anything like that. Read what I say.

jzs said:
Incredible. I didn't make any claim. I reported what Rawlings claimed. You still fail to admit the difference.

Oh, I understand the difference perfectly: Whenever you have to back something up, it's not a claim anymore.

jzs said:
Please, try to remember what you wrote just a little while ago.

...

You basically avoided a real life discussion with an intelligent person whose ideas differ from yours, then made up some excuse. The other people at TAM didn't seem worried about shanek..

That's not why I didn't want to engage with shanek at TAM3. You know the reason, but you prefer to ignore it.
 
CFLarsen said:
You seem intent on misunderstanding people. I did not say anything like that. Read what I say.


I did read what you wrote. In reponse to me writing

"I am saying that your claim of 'it depends on what they claim they can do' is completely bogus. What someone says they can do in no way affects their actual performance. I'm also saying that no one is perfect all the time, and the actual baseball data verifies this. Even the 'best' players had nowhere near hits/(at bats) = 1."

you wrote

"Bogus?? Justin, we have to go with what people claim they can do. We can't enforce some statistics on e.g. Sylvia Browne - we have to go with what she really claims to be able to do."

Claus, she could claim 100%, 80%, whatever %. Her performance and if it is significantly beyond chance expectation in a decent experiment(s), not her anitcipated % she believes she will get, is the real issue here.


Oh, I understand the difference perfectly: Whenever you have to back something up, it's not a claim anymore.


You are incorrect. Rawlings made the claim. I posted a link to what Rawlings wrote. I didn't make the claim. Do you understand?


That's not why I didn't want to engage with shanek at TAM3. You know the reason, but you prefer to ignore it.

You were afraid of some rage he would supposedly get in (because he posts all caps on here for emphasis). Yes, we all know the reason, Claus..
 
jzs said:

That is not correct, Kimpatsu. I have NOT claimed that it doesn't exist. Please, cease repeating this embarassing falsehood of yours.
Let's make this really simple for you: Do you believe Randi said it on the b/cast, or don't you?
jzs said:
You changed what you previously said. Now you included "some". Before, you just typed that either I doubt it exists or I don't, which was indeed a false dichotomy. In any case, doubt is not the same as denial, as I have already pointed out to you.
No, it was always there. Do you doubt Randi said it, or do you beleive that he did? Yes or no?
jzs said:
So you are going based on your recollection here, right? It could be flawed, right?
That Randi actually said it? No.
jzs said:
By what basis do you make that outlandish claim, Kimpatsu? In fact, I've listened to all of the July 2003 ones. Nope, no such quote there. Oh maybe it was elsewhere... :rolleyes: So what is your story now?
Then it must be in August. It's there somewhere; keep looking.
jzs said:
I am skeptical of it. Now, I know it doesn't exist in the July audio, despite you claiming so vocally otherwise. Again, I doubt, not deny. Evidence is always, and still, welcome, Kimpatsu. If you are able to find where it actually is, not send us on a wild goose chase of where you believe it could be, let us know.
Remember, I said "circa".
jzs said:
I listened to all of the July 2003 ones, and nope, not there. Again, you had no basis to say that I wasn't listening to the audios, but don't let that stop your personal agenda.
I don't have a "personal agenda". Why didn't you admit to listening to them? Seems like you're trying to play a petty game of oneupmanship rather than locating the actual quote.
jzs said:
See above.
Ditto.
jzs said:
And you keep coming back too. What is your point? Your mistake is that you assumed that I hadn't been listening to the audios, Kimpatsu. You assumed, and you were wrong. You were also wrong in thinking that the July audios contained the quote which you were so sure existed there.
I'm sure it exists somewhere around the July mark. I'll find it, then, and shut you up permanently.
jzs said:
I am skeptical of it. I am open to seeing the actual evidence... still.
Then go listen to all the August b/casts.
jzs said:
Newsflash, it was always up to you to find it, because you made the claim. However, I listened to all the July ones. Nope, it wasn't there.
Then listen to the August b/casts.
You're claiming you don't believe the quote is there I.e., Randi never said it); I'll find it, but I bet you won't recant.
[/B][/QUOTE] Now what, Kimpatsu? [/B][/QUOTE]
Are you listening to the August b/casts yet?
 
jzs said:
Claus, she could claim 100%, 80%, whatever %. Her performance and if it is significantly beyond chance expectation in a decent experiment(s), not her anitcipated % she believes she will get, is the real issue here.

You don't get it, do you? You can't decide in advance what an applicant can do or can't do. I suspect it has something to do with this desire of yours to dictate how the world around you should be.

jzs said:
You are incorrect. Rawlings made the claim. I posted a link to what Rawlings wrote. I didn't make the claim. Do you understand?

No, someone claimed that Rawlings made the claim. You did.

jzs said:
You were afraid of some rage he would supposedly get in (because he posts all caps on here for emphasis). Yes, we all know the reason, Claus..

Not just "rage", Justin. Not just "all caps". Go back and check. Yes, that means: YOU do the work.
 
Kimpatsu said:
Let's make this really simple for you: Do you believe Randi said it on the b/cast, or don't you?


I have some doubts. Don't try to make this a false dichotomy, Kimpatsu.


then it must be in August. It's there somewhere; keep looking.


Moving the posts I see. First, you were so sure it was in July, now it is in August, etc. This is the reason you must provide an exact source for your claim.


Remember, I said "circa".


Yes, originally. Then you clarified what you wrote, and said

"I have already told you; July 2003"

No "circa" in that clarification, Kimpatsu. Oops again!

Now Kimpatsu, care to explain your embarassing blunder, of how you were so sure I wasn't listening to the July 2003 audios? I didn't think so. It does, however, demonstrate uncontrollable preconceived notions on your part.


I'll find it, then,


Good for you! That is what I've been asking you to do from the start; to provide the required evidence for your claim!


and shut you up permanently.
/b]

I am for inquiry, you are, judging from your emotional attack above, for stopping inquiry.


Then go listen to all the August b/casts.

Then listen to the August b/casts.


Before you said ""I have already told you; July 2003"", but now it is August? What will it be after that? Seems like you don't really know for certain.


I'll find it, but I bet you won't recant.

I'm glad you are certain you will find it. That is what I've been asking you to do all along, since you made the claim. As far as recanting, I've never denied it existing, just skeptical of it, based on lack of an exact reference, so there won't be anything to recant. It really is that simple, Kimpatsu.


Are you listening to the August b/casts yet?

At the rate your goalpsots are moving, maybe I should start at the first year and month the broadcasts started?

Please let me know when you actually find it.
 
Kimpatsu said:
I don't have a "personal agenda". Why didn't you admit to listening to them? Seems like you're trying to play a petty game of oneupmanship rather than locating the actual quote.

Justin is petty. He has admitted this.
 
CFLarsen said:
Justin is petty. He has admitted this.

Claus, you sure seem to be obsessed with this 'piece of fly excrement'. Why do you suppose that is?
 
CFLarsen said:
Ask him about the content, and he will disappear...

Irrelevant. All that is needed is that the July 2003 audios did not contain what Kimpatsu believed they did.

Or do you seriosuly expect me to recall the details of over 5 hours of audio, Claus?
 
jzs said:
Irrelevant. All that is needed is that the July 2003 audios did not contain what Kimpatsu believed they did.

It is highly relevant: It will prove whether you actually listened to it or not.

jzs said:
Or do you seriosuly expect me to recall the details of over 5 hours of audio, Claus?

Interesting how you always seem to go to extremes: Nobody said anything about details. Only content. Of which you remember nothing of.

Go figure.
 
jzs said:
I have some doubts. Don't try to make this a false dichotomy, Kimpatsu.
No, it isn't. Either you believe it, or you don't. Which is it?
jzs said:
the posts I see. First, you were so sure it was in July, now it is in August, etc. This is the reason you must provide an exact source for your claim.
I told you "circa July". In case you don't know, that means "around July".
jzs said:
Yes, originally. Then you clarified what you wrote, and said

"I have already told you; July 2003"

No "circa" in that clarification, Kimpatsu. Oops again!
Hardly; that was my best guess. I'm now checking the August b/casts.
jzs said:
Now Kimpatsu, care to explain your embarassing blunder, of how you were so sure I wasn't listening to the July 2003 audios? I didn't think so. It does, however, demonstrate uncontrollable preconceived notions on your part.
What's embarrassing about it? Being wrong on this is only embarrassing to petty egomaniacs like you. I'll tell you what's really embarrassing, though: misspelling "embarrassment".
jzs said:
Good for you! That is what I've been asking you to do from the start; to provide the required evidence for your claim!
So you DON'T believe Randi said it?
Besides, I'm only doing this because you're too pigging lazy to do any legwork yourself.
jzs said:
I am for inquiry, you are, judging from your emotional attack above, for stopping inquiry.
That's yet another error on your part.
jzs said:
Before you said ""I have already told you; July 2003"", but now it is August? What will it be after that? Seems like you don't really know for certain.
I don't know for certain when Randi said it; I only know ballpark. I do know for certain, however, that he said it.
jzs said:
I'm glad you are certain you will find it. That is what I've been asking you to do all along, since you made the claim. As far as recanting, I've never denied it existing, just skeptical of it, based on lack of an exact reference, so there won't be anything to recant. It really is that simple, Kimpatsu.
Bollocks. Now you're backpeddling from your original position. Do you beleive Randi said it? Yes or No?
jzs said:
At the rate your goalpsots are moving, maybe I should start at the first year and month the broadcasts started?
I haven't moved any goalposts. And it's definitely closer to the end than the beginning. If you bother to do some legwork, you'll find it.
jzs said:
Please let me know when you actually find it.
So you're going to give up searching are you? Why am I not surprised that you're a quitter?
 
CFLarsen said:
It is highly relevant: It will prove whether you actually listened to it or not.


The July 2003 didn't contain the audio Kimpatsu claimed. That is all that is relevant, Claus.

Keep denying..
 
CFLarsen said:
What am I "denying"?

Reality. My recollection of 5+ hours of audio is irrelevant to the fact that any impartial skeptic can verify that the 2003 July audios did not contain Kimpatsu's quote as claimed.
 
Kimpatsu said:
No, it isn't. Either you believe it, or you don't. Which is it?


Yes it is. You attempt it again, and again, I point it out and reject the attempt. I have some doubts.


I told you "circa July". In case you don't know, that means "around July".


Later, you clarified and said "July 2003". There was no circa there, Kimpatsu.


I'll tell you what's really embarrassing, though: misspelling "embarrassment".


Can't be embarassing as over 250 errors after calling yourself an editor, though.


So you DON'T believe Randi said it?


I am skeptical, but I am not denying he said it.


Besides, I'm only doing this because you're too pigging lazy to do any legwork yourself.


I listened to 5+ hours, Kimpatsu. This is for YOUR claim, something which you should have worked to find the evidence to support.


Do you beleive Randi said it? Yes or No?


I am skeptical, but I am not denying he said it. In fact, I am asking you for evidence.


If you bother to do some legwork, you'll find it.


It is your claim, you find the evidence, Kimpatsu. It is not up to me to find evidence to support your claim, Kimpatsu.


Why am I not surprised that you're a quitter?

It is your claim, you find the evidence. I've already searched 5+ hours of audio, for something you were sure was there, but it wasn't. Please, find the specific audio to support your claim, then just post it. It is quite simple.
 
Justin, you clearly have no interest in pursuing the truth or determining whereabouts in the audio record the quote exists. You keep changing your mind over whether Randi actually said the quote in question or not. If you'd actually say something sensible on which we could pin you down, I would call you on it. As things stand, I'm going to find the source of the quote for my own purposes, and you can go shove it up the same orifice from which your statements emanate.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom