Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

jzs said:
Now you have no idea, but before you said it depends on what the player claims he/she can hit, which is absurd. The performance of a player has nothing to do with their claim of performance. The facts are, Claus, that no known baseball players have hit everytime at bat in their career. Actual data (try looking at it sometime) from the MLB association in USA, for example, support this.

So, you are saying that, since no baseball player has ever hit a perfect score, we cannot expect anyone to do something unexpectedly?

jzs said:
It is obvious. If I make the claim, I have made the claim. Me reporting what someone else said is not me making a claim. Do you finally understand?

No, I don't understand. Because if this is so, then you cannot possibly claim (yes, claim) that Kimpatsu also made a claim. He - like you did - referred to someone else making a claim: Randi, on an Internet radio show. Only, his claim is verifiable. Yours is not.

You can't have both. So, which is it? Did you make a claim, or are you a hypocrite?

jzs said:
Don't you have some typo correcting to do? Like about 250 or more?

You are not the boss of me. Or anyone else.

Tell me something, Justin: Do you, in real life, like to order people around? Or do you merely think you can get away with it on the Internet, because here, nobody can slap you, if you try it?
 
CFLarsen said:
So, you are saying that, since no baseball player has ever hit a perfect score, we cannot expect anyone to do something unexpectedly?


No, unexpected things can and do occur. I am saying that your claim of 'it depends on what they claim they can do' is completely bogus. What someone says they can do in no way affects their actual performance. I'm also saying that no one is perfect all the time, and the actual baseball data verifies this. Even the 'best' players had nowhere near hits/(at bats) = 1. So when you say something like "Either people can do it, or they can't. End of story." that is, again, irrelevant, as the issue is more a statistical one than a deterministic one.


No, I don't understand. Because if this is so, then you cannot possibly claim (yes, claim) that Kimpatsu also made a claim. He - like you did - referred to someone else making a claim:


Kimpatsu said "What Randi actually said was"... That is a claim from Kimpatsu. I just said something like 'This is what Rawlings wrote about what Randi allegedly said'. I didn't make any claim to what Randi said like Kimpatsu did. I referenced Rawlings, who did make a claim do what Randi said. Moreover, I provided an actual direct link to the source. Kimpatsu did nothing as specific. Additionally, since Rawlings and Randi were both there, I'm interested in leanring how a 28 year after the fact verbal recollection compares to a 6 year after the fact written recollection. Do you understand yet?


Tell me something, Justin: Do you, in real life, like to order people around? Or do you merely think you can get away with it on the Internet, because here, nobody can slap you, if you try it?

Claus, please try to refrain from the personal attacks and mentionings of physical violence. It doesn't do you any favors. Thaiboxerken and I agreed to meet a while back. He didn't show. I guess I'm not afraid of getting 'slapped' in real life after all.

Now, speaking of real life stuff, seems like you didn't care to be as pseudo-imposing to shanek in real life when he reportedly attempted to approach you at the recent TAM to discuss things. One can only speculate why. Maybe you were too busy with the cash register. That's it..
 
jzs said:
No, unexpected things can and do occur. I am saying that your claim of 'it depends on what they claim they can do' is completely bogus. What someone says they can do in no way affects their actual performance. I'm also saying that no one is perfect all the time, and the actual baseball data verifies this. Even the 'best' players had nowhere near hits/(at bats) = 1.

Bogus?? Justin, we have to go with what people claim they can do. We can't enforce some statistics on e.g. Sylvia Browne - we have to go with what she really claims to be able to do. Not how cold readers statistically do.

Check out the JREF Challenge: That's as fair as it gets. How can we demand a 100% score from a dowser that only claims 80%?

jzs said:
Kimpatsu said "What Randi actually said was"... That is a claim from Kimpatsu. I just said something like 'This is what Rawlings wrote about what Randi allegedly said'. I didn't make any claim to what Randi said like Kimpatsu did. I referenced Rawlings, who did make a claim do what Randi said. Moreover, I provided an actual direct link to the source. Kimpatsu did nothing as specific. Additionally, since Rawlings and Randi were both there, I'm interested in leanring how a 28 year after the fact verbal recollection compares to a 6 year after the fact written recollection. Do you understand yet?

I don't give a ◊◊◊◊ about what Kimpatsu said. I point to your own claim, even though you afterwards put your tail behind your legs and claim(!) that you never made any claim at all. Geesh, Justin, for once in your life, stand up for yourself!

jzs said:
Claus, please try to refrain from the personal attacks and mentionings of physical violence. It doesn't do you any favors. Thaiboxerken and I agreed to meet a while back. He didn't show. I guess I'm not afraid of getting 'slapped' in real life after all.

No, really, Justin. Address this. If nothing else, then for your own sake.

Because it seems to me that you really enjoy telling people what they should do - and not do. You simply love telling people to find evidence, yet you never provide any yourself. No, you don't make "claims", you merely parrot the claims of others. No, you never find facts, you merely want others to find facts for you. And no, you cannot be bothered to do any real work, despite your proclamations of Great Websites Designed To Tell The Truth. You want to order people around, so they can do your work for you.

Only, I cannot see this happening in real life, without people telling you off in so many words, some of which would be four-letter ones. Nobody would stand for that kind of snooty behavior in real life, without kicking your arse. Literally.

If you tried this at work, you would find yourself out on the street in no time. No boss would accept that kind of behavior, regardless of how indispensable you may think you are.

If you tried this at your mom's, I'm certain she would tan your hide. Unless, of course, she is the kind of mom that thinks her little Justin can do no wrong.

So, tell me, Justin: Why do you think you would succeed here?

jzs said:
Now, speaking of real life stuff, seems like you didn't care to be as pseudo-imposing to shanek in real life when he attempted to approach you at the recent TAM to discuss things. One can only speculate why. Maybe you were too busy with the cash register.

What on Earth are you talking about???
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

jzs said:


If you were following the conversation, you'd find that I am not looking for vague references. Please get me exactly to it. That is what to provide a reference means. The page you linked to does not do that. [/B]

If you are to lazy to examine the material, then you must go to the source.

I believe the email [email protected] works. I suggest a polite inquiry noting what you have heard from both sides.

Oh! I'm sorry? Would that mean you wouldn't be able to whine if you got an answer?
 
CFLarsen said:
, we have to go with what people claim they can do.


So if someone is enthusiastic, deluded, brags, or is simply mistaken, and claims they can get 20 out of 20 everytime, they don't, but get 18 out of 20 or something still statistically significant, you are saying we just throw it out? Forget that it was significant? Seems like you are wanting to throw standard scientific method out the window.


I don't give a ◊◊◊◊ about what Kimpatsu said.


Well that is already known to me, since you don't ask him for actual evidence, but you do ask me (even though I already provided a direct link to the article where Rawlings makes his claim).


I point to your own claim, even though you afterwards put your tail behind your legs and claim(!) that you never made any claim


Incredible. I didn't make any claim. I reported what Rawlings claimed. You still fail to admit the difference.


Because it seems to me that you really enjoy telling people what they should do - and not do. You simply love telling people


Please answer me this: am I still "nothing but a piece of fly excrement", Claus?


No, you don't make "claims", you merely parrot the claims of others.


Me saying what Rawlings claimed is not me making a claim. That is a fact, one which you fail to agree with.


Nobody would stand for that kind of snooty behavior in real life, without kicking your arse. Literally.


Do you have a point with all of this? Again, mentioning physical violence. Please, get in control of yourself.


If you tried this at work, you would find yourself out on the street in no time. No boss would accept that kind of behavior, regardless of how indispensable you may think you are.


Please, explain how your behavior is any different. You could call your boss or mom a piece of fly excrement, a fool, and ask her 20 questions in a row, folliwng her from job to job or around the neighborhood, demanding her to answer Yes or No? Really?


What on Earth are you talking about???

Please, try to remember what you wrote just a little while ago. From http://www.randi.org/vbulletin/showthread.php?s=&threadid=52584&perpage=40 here,

"I made several attempts to approach him at TAM3 just to talk with him and he always walked the other way. Wouldn't even look me in the eye. I have no idea what his malfunction is."

You even respond to that, in that very thread.

"There is only one reason why I kept away from shanek at TAM3: I did not trust him to keep his calm. If his real-life behavior is anywhere similar to his online ditto, then I thought it best to avoid him altogether. I could not be sure that he would not blow up in my face, especially not after his previously stated intentions."

You basically avoided a real life discussion with an intelligent person whose ideas differ from yours, then made up some excuse. The other people at TAM didn't seem worried about shanek..
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

kookbreaker said:
If you are to lazy to examine the material, then you must go to the source.


Again, you don't care a lick about what Kimpatsu claimed and what his supposed source is, and holding him accountable. I can't say I'm surprised.

kookbreaker, since Rawlings and Randi were both there, I'm interested in learning how a 28 year after the fact verbal or written recollection compares to a 6 year after the fact written recollection.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

jzs said:

Again, you don't care a lick about what Kimpatsu claimed and what his supposed source is, and holding him accountable. I can't say I'm surprised.

Kimpatsu only confirms what I have effectively heard from other, personal sources. Ergo I have not need to track down what I already am aware of. Kimpatuse said where it is, its just not convenient for your laziness.

kookbreaker, since Rawlings and Randi were both there, I'm interested in learning how a 28 year after the fact verbal or written recollection compares to a 6 year after the fact written recollection. [/B]

Look at the quote. Even in Rawlins' account it is a sentence fraction. Rawlins' uses partial quotes and comments out of context all the time to suit his viscous agenda. I have little doubt he heard that comment from Randi, it is merely how he purposely chose to use (part of) it.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

kookbreaker said:
Kimpatsu only confirms what I have effectively heard from other, personal sources. Ergo I have not need to track down what I already am aware of. Kimpatuse said where it is, its just not convenient for your laziness.


I see, because it fits your beliefs already, no need to inquire about Kimpatsu's source. Kimpatsu did not say where it specifically was located. He said

"The JREF Internet Show archive, somewhere around July 2003"

and

"The internet radio shows, circa July 2003"

"somewhere around" and "circa". That is very specific!

On the other hand I provided a direct link. See the difference?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

jzs said:

On the other hand I provided a direct link. See the difference? [/B]

How was Kimpatsu supposed to provide a direct link to a section of a video that is 1 hour long?

You're still whining becuase the world wasn't delivered to you on a silver plate.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

kookbreaker said:
How was Kimpatsu supposed to provide a direct link to a section of a video that is 1 hour long?


Link to the file. Give the exact month the radio show was. Just some suggestions. This is something Kimpatsu should think of. It is not my duty to show him how to reference the source he claimed existed.


You're still whining becuase the world wasn't delivered to you on a silver plate.

No, but I still am asking for Kimpatsu to provide a direct pointer to the source he claims exists.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

jzs said:


Link to the file.

Its not online anymore. JREF sells the show on DVD. Not everything is on the net.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

kookbreaker said:
Look at the quote. Even in Rawlins' account it is a sentence fraction.[/B]

What's your evidence for this, exactly? What precisely indicates in Rawlin's account that it is a sentence fraction? You made the claim, you back it up.

I also find it strange that Randi has changed his story on this.

Story #1 "the quote "refers to the fact that my tests are designed in such a way that no one can cheat. "

Story #2 : What I really said was "I always have an out: I'm always right"
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

Peter Morris said:
What's your evidence for this, exactly? What precisely indicates in Rawlin's account that it is a sentence fraction? You made the claim, you back it up.

Look at the quote:

He assured me how cautious he was in the testing for his well-publicized $ 10,000 prize for proof of psychic abilities (for which he acts as policeman, judge and jury -- and thus never has supported my idea of neutral judgment of CSICOP tests. "I always have an out," he said."

Note how Randi's comment ends with a comma, not a period. Last I checked, the use of a comma in the English language denotes that there will be another part of the sentence. Rawlins' did not inlcude that part.

Given Rawlins' nature, I do not trust him to have properly edited the comment.

Your link goes nowhere, but I know what your are talking about.

The two stories are not mutually exclusive. You might think so, but you are a hateful idiot.
 
kookbreaker said:
Note how Randi's comment ends with a comma, not a period. Last I checked, the use of a comma in the English language denotes that there will be another part of the sentence. Rawlins' did not inlcude that part.

You checked wrongly. Let's refer to people who know better than you.

Arthur Conan Doyle
"There are three hundred pounds in gold and seven hundred in notes," he said.

Victor Hugo
"I am paying my tithes," he said.

Robert Louis Stevenson
"Bill," said the stranger in a voice that I thought he had tried to make bold and big.

"Come, Bill, you know me; you know an old shipmate, Bill, surely," said the stranger.

Jack London
"Twist it, an' you'll choke 'm plentee," said Manuel, and the
stranger grunted a ready affirmative.

Thomas Hardy
"Good night t'ee," said the man with the basket.
"Good night, Sir John," said the parson.

etc, etc, etc

Your quote goes nowhere.

Sorry. here

The two stories are not mutually exclusive. You might think so, but you are a hateful idiot.

Excuse me? Which one of us just resorted to insults?

And don't you find it sloghly suspicious that Randi never claimed he was misquoted before? Why explain what he actuually meant by a sentence, if he was wrongly quoted?

No, he certainly changed his story.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

kookbreaker said:
Its not online anymore. JREF sells the show on DVD. Not everything is on the net.

You left out the other suggestion I made. I also said

"Give the exact month the radio show was."
 
Peter Morris said:
You checked wrongly. Let's refer to people who know better than you.

Fair enough. But this does not preclude another part of the quote.

Especially in light of the fact that it is Rawlins quoting.


Yes, and as is pointed out by Mr. Hutchinson:

am perfectly willing to accept that Dennis had recalled it as meaning
the challenge. I have no idea why he didn't either clarify it at the
time Randi said it, or write a little more on the quote in 'Fate'.
Whatever. It is something that believers have jumped on over the years
as meaning something which it doesn't. But there's nothing new there.

>Rawlins did this a *lot* in sTARBABY. He would give direct quotes from
>other people to put them in the worst light, then would only give the
>vaugest outline of what he himself was saying in the same conversations.
>These were emotional issues that I ended up avoiding outright when writing
>the sTARBABY FAQ.

Knowing many of the people involved I can agree with you. [I was going
to write that I know many of the 'players' but I know how that will be
spun by the pro-paranormal spin doctors. ;-) ]

Doesn't speak well of Rawlins.

Excuse me? Which one of us just resorted to insults?

Shall we go back a few pages in the very thread? The one you abandoned after your humilation?

[QUOTE[
And don't you find it sloghly suspicious that Randi never claimed he was misquoted before? Why explain what he actuually meant by a sentence, if he was wrongly quoted?
[/QUOTE]

Simply because you've never heard him explain it before is not reason that he has not.

In Mr. Hutchinson's post we are seeing part of his correspondance with Randi, with whom he is very familiar.

Now, of interest is that the post preceeding Mr. Hutchinson the allegation made is not that Randi was only partially quoted, but that the quote had nothing to do with the Randi challenge at all but was in reference to his stage act.

This is not a hard mistake to make, in fact the first issue of Jr. Skeptic (in the pages of SKEPTIC magazine) had a little comic of Randi discussing his "out" with regards to his stage act.

Most of Randi's comments were in answer to that erronious assumption, and that is the relevant part quoted by Mr. Hutchinson.

No, he certainly changed his story. [/B]

Not proven. You have a part of one story answering a different question.

Also, more importantly, this just does not matter. There is no 'out' for Randi. This is another tempest in a teapot. Get over it.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

jzs said:
You left out the other suggestion I made. I also said

"Give the exact month the radio show was."

Ah, so you expect him to have every show memorized.

Gotcha.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

kookbreaker said:
Ah, so you expect him to have every show memorized.

Gotcha.

That's absurd kookbreaker. Nowhere did I say he had to have "every show" or any show memorized; that is your invention.

My suggestion was for him to provide the exact source, especially if he mentions that such a source exists, not to give a vague description of it. The idea is that the source can be quickly found by those interested.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

jzs said:
Specifically...where is it? A pointer to the specific source. Is that too difficult for you?
I have already told you; July 2003. Randi says it on-air in response to the charge that you are making. How is that not specific?
jzs said:
This isn't about comparing the 'goodness' of sources. I freely admit that the source of the 'I always have an out,' is from a paper I read that Rawlings wrote. Kimpatsu cited a source, but has yet to show it. And for the record, I am neither a "Randi-basher" nor am I suggesting fraud.
How am I not showing it? Here:
http://clear-light.msspro.com/radio-randi.html
Go listen yourself.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom