princhester
Critical Thinker
- Joined
- May 13, 2003
- Messages
- 321
For freak's sake Kimpatsu, find the quote or give it up. I'm on your side buddy, but don't make a dick of yourself.
It's a challenge. If the challenger can't do what they say they can do, then they lose. It's that simple.
If they find out after the challenge that they can do something remarkable (if slightly less remarkable than they thought) they should just challenge again in 12 months and win. There is nothing unscientific about delaying a test for a year.
jzs said:So if someone is enthusiastic, deluded, brags, or is simply mistaken, and claims they can get 20 out of 20 everytime, they don't, but get 18 out of 20 or something still statistically significant, you are saying we just throw it out? Forget that it was significant? Seems like you are wanting to throw standard scientific method out the window.
It's a challenge. If the challenger can't do what they say they can do, then they lose. It's that simple.
If they find out after the challenge that they can do something remarkable (if slightly less remarkable than they thought) they should just challenge again in 12 months and win. There is nothing unscientific about delaying a test for a year.