Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

For freak's sake Kimpatsu, find the quote or give it up. I'm on your side buddy, but don't make a dick of yourself.

jzs said:
So if someone is enthusiastic, deluded, brags, or is simply mistaken, and claims they can get 20 out of 20 everytime, they don't, but get 18 out of 20 or something still statistically significant, you are saying we just throw it out? Forget that it was significant? Seems like you are wanting to throw standard scientific method out the window.

It's a challenge. If the challenger can't do what they say they can do, then they lose. It's that simple.

If they find out after the challenge that they can do something remarkable (if slightly less remarkable than they thought) they should just challenge again in 12 months and win. There is nothing unscientific about delaying a test for a year.
 
Peter Morris said:
attempting to persude Rawlins into silence.


Try again. Depsite Rawlins' balwing the fact is that Randi was trying to preven the loose cannon nature from flying off the ship. Rawlins already got CSICOP in trouble by making very nasty insults about Gauquelin (you do know who that is, right?) and was overall acting like a jerk. He did have some good points, and in the long run they were addressed (See Abel's work from 1983 esp), but his manner of dealing with people and his "I'm right, surrender on all fronts" attitude was grating. Try reading cRYBABY somtime.

By concealing part of the results that didn't match their expectations.

And those results were testing what exactly? C'mon Peter, what were they testing? Make sure you get it right.

Quite literally, I do not think you even understand the difference between truth and lies.

QUite literally, I think you are a kook. I seem to have better support for my arguement around here.

You appear to define "lies" as being anything that tends to discredit Randi and his supoporters. The fact remains, I cited exact quotes from Larsen to show his deliberate misrepresentations.

Oh, yeah, right, like "Larsen said the money was cursed". That was a knee-slapper alright.

All I got in response was foul abuse from trolls. You have not shown one single thing I have said that is untrue.

BWHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! Dream faster! You were shown to be laughable with the Larsen comment, your claims about the quotes being total fabrications by my post. All uyou could do is froth and rant, and that'a ll you are doing now.

It's been all over. Its often quoted by Randi fans.

Evidence please. I think you'll find that I was probably the only one. Give us three sources where it is quoted.

You make the claim, you prove it.

You were the one claiming it's true.

Your words : " Now, of interest is that the post preceeding Mr. Hutchinson the allegation made is not that Randi was only partially quoted, but that the quote had nothing to do with the Randi challenge at all but was in reference to his stage act.

This is not a hard mistake to make, in fact the first issue of Jr. Skeptic (in the pages of SKEPTIC magazine) had a little comic of Randi discussing his "out" with regards to his stage act."

Don't confuse issues, Peter. I was quite clear that I was making a point about some people mistaking comments from Randi with others. This is you being deliberately obtuse. The fact that you can't seperate the issues even when Randi points out the difference is your ineptness, not a problem with Randi.

But again, even if your cry about the quote was 100% true (and it isn't), it doesn't mean diddly squat. The whole 'out' is nonsense.
 
princhester said:
For freak's sake Kimpatsu, find the quote or give it up. I'm on your side buddy, but don't make a dick of yourself.
Do you know how much material that requires wading through? Or are you claiming that Randi never said it?
 
Kimpatsu said:

As things stand, I'm going to find the source of the quote


Which is what I've requested all along, for you to find the evidence that supports your claim.


you can go shove it up the same orifice from which your statements emanate.

More personal attacks.

Please, find the evidence that you claimed existed. Until then,

*PLONK!*
 
Peter Morris said:
The problem with you, Princhester, is that you play these silly word games where you pick one word in someone's post, and argue the toss about the precise meaning of that particular word.

Let's see. You said this Peter Morris.

Now, tell me what evidence you have to support the excuse that the money is cursed.

Larsen says this.

Have you seen the Kofoed quote?

You choose to intepret this as Larsen believing that the money is cursed when you damn well know that in context, Larsen thought that you wanted evidence that his quote was representative of what a real claimant said. So you pick one word, "support", isolate it out of context from the point of the discussion, and believe Larsen said the money was cursed.

See this. There are obviously two ways to interpret your own words. There is one way as in asking for "support" that the excuse that the money is cursed exists. There is another way, which is you asking Larsen to provide evidence or "support" that the money is cursed out of context with the discussion. In other words you are the one playing word games. You are saying "If A then B" or since Larsen provides "support the excuse that the money is cursed exists" then "Larsen is a liar" when A is strictly ambigious. To resolve this ambiguity, you could have just used your eyes and read what Larsen posted in the past, or asked Larsen himself.

In other words,

Let A be your question, true representing you asking for evidence that the money is cursed, false representing you asking for evidence that evidence exists that the money is cursed.
Let B be whether or not Larsen believes the money is cursed.

A B
T T
T F
F T
F F

You pick only one of the possible outcomes of Larsen's reply, the first outcome, when you damn well know that Larsen thought you meant you wanted evidence that the excuse existed. In fact, you said this,

Actually, if you cannot find even one single instance of a person saying this, then including it on the list of "common" arguments would be a lie.

Therefore indicating earlier in the thread that you wanted evidence that Larsen's comments were based on actual claims..

In other words you decided to trap Larsen by saying you wanted evidence of the comments being based on real claims, and by using an ambigiously worded question later you would force Larsen to say he believed the money was cursed. Ridiculous, because in this case A does not imply B because there are many meanings of "support". However taken in context "support" must mean that you are asking Larsen for support that there is an "instance of a person saying this" in your own words because you asked him specifically for this evidence earlier.

Brian
 
jzs said:
Kimpatsu's personal attacks will be ignored, as I'm only interested in him finding the evidence that supports his claim.

How will you see his evidence, if you have him on ignore?
 
I can't believe Peter Morris is still going on about the cursed money. He is truly deluded, if he thinks he will convince anyone that he is right.

Well, he's deluded anyway, but...
 
Kimpatsu said:
Do you know how much material that requires wading through? Or are you claiming that Randi never said it?

I mean that giving a quote, then not giving a useable cite, then giving a vague reference, then giving a more concise reference that turns out to be wrong, makes you look pissweak. Find the quote or give it up. I don't say this as any sort of statement about the substance of the debate. I say it simply as a comment on the debate process.
 
jzs said:


Which is what I've requested all along, for you to find the evidence that supports your claim.
[/B]
So you do doubt that Randi ever said it? You think everyone on this board is a liar?!
 
princhester said:
I mean that giving a quote, then not giving a useable cite, then giving a vague reference, then giving a more concise reference that turns out to be wrong, makes you look pissweak. Find the quote or give it up. I don't say this as any sort of statement about the substance of the debate. I say it simply as a comment on the debate process.
Why don't you bloody well look for it too, instead of sitting on your high horse? You know it's there somewhere; do smething constructive for once.
 
Kimpatsu said:
So you do doubt that Randi ever said it? You think everyone on this board is a liar?!

Where do you come up with this stuff? Really.

As I've said, I'm skeptical.

Just provide the evidence you claimed existed. Or don't.
 
CFLarsen said:
No, someone claimed that Rawlings made the claim. You did.
And he provided a source which backed up his claim that '2) Randi has been reported to have allegedly said, in regards to his challenge, that “I always have an out”.'

I don't understand why jzs either doesn't believe that it is an incomplete quote, or that someone is going to put in the time to find it.

But, somehow you insist that he hasn't meant the standard of evidence on his claim. He has. You even seem to believe that Rawlins made the quote. Why can't you see this?

Given the title of the thread and that jzs provided the excuse and a reference, you have nothing to complain about on point 2) of his post.

Walt
 
jzs said:
I said I will be ignoring his personal attacks, Claus.

......how? You have to read something in order to decide whether it is a personal attack or not.

Oh, well.... :rolleyes:
 
Walt,

No, no. You misunderstand. I am not saying that Justin hasn't showed a source for his claim. It's a source, however less verifiable than Kimpatsu's.

I am saying that Justin made a claim that Rawlings said this. Justin doesn't want to admit that he made this claim.

Somehow, Justin never makes "claims". He just uses the claims of others to argue his point. That way, he never has to back up anything he says himself, while he insists that others back up their claims.

Justin thinks that "debating" is continuously lopping the ball back, without ever having to argue anything himself.
 
CFLarsen said:
Walt,

No, no. You misunderstand. I am not saying that Justin hasn't showed a source for his claim. It's a source, however less verifiable than Kimpatsu's.

I am saying that Justin made a claim that Rawlings said this. Justin doesn't want to admit that he made this claim.

Somehow, Justin never makes "claims". He just uses the claims of others to argue his point. That way, he never has to back up anything he says himself, while he insists that others back up their claims.

Justin thinks that "debating" is continuously lopping the ball back, without ever having to argue anything himself.
Do understand correctly that you don't think the FATE magazine article is entirely genuine, and that FATE put worlds into Rawlins mouth?

Walt
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom