Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

Walter Wayne said:
Do understand correctly that you don't think the FATE magazine article is entirely genuine, and that FATE put worlds into Rawlins mouth?

Well, the article is there, and I haven't seen anything from Rawlins where he complains about being misquoted.

I do know, however, that Rawlins misquotes Randi.
 
"I do know, however, that Rawlins misquotes Randi."

That pretty much sums up Claus's "approach" to skepticism...

Claus disregards my source flat out, and doesn't even care that Kimpatsu can't find his evidence.
 
jzs said:
"I do know, however, that Rawlins misquotes Randi."

That pretty much sums up Claus's "approach" to skepticism...

Claus disregards my source flat out, and doesn't even care that Kimpatsu can't find his evidence.

You need to work on your reading comprehension skills. I don't discard it, I say that Rawlins is wrong.

You see, it's not just the radio shows which you refuse to listen to. This also came up at TAM3, when we were setting up the conference. Randi explained to me how it went - Rawlins is misquoting Randi, pure and simple.
 
jzs said:
Where do you come up with this stuff? Really.

As I've said, I'm skeptical.

Just provide the evidence you claimed existed. Or don't.
Either you believe Randi said it, or you think he didn't and are being bolshey. Either way, if you really believed Randi said it and wanted the evidence for some higher purpose, such as woo-woo rebuttal, you'd have bothered to search for it yourself by now. As things stand, I'm the only one going back through all the 2003 b/casts to find it. That says more about my commitment to truth than yours.
 
CFLarsen said:
Well, the article is there, and I haven't seen anything from Rawlins where he complains about being misquoted.

I do know, however, that Rawlins misquotes Randi.
Which is a valid. But saying that jzs didn't backup that it had been alleged that Randi said that isn't.

When you said "No, someone claimed that Rawlings made the claim. [jzs] did." you seem to fail to note that jzs backed his claim theat Rawlins made the claim up. When you say jzs didn't back his claim you are wrong.

jzs has made the case for his statement, and the point left is the accuracy and importance of Rawlins claim.

Walt
 
CFLarsen said:

You see, it's not just the radio shows which you refuse to listen to.


I listened to ~5hrs. Kimpatsu should cite his source specifically ie. the exact audio file. He made the claim it existed, Claus. The burden is on him, not on me to search for hours for something I didn't even claim existed.


This also came up at TAM3, when we were setting up the conference. Randi explained to me how it went - Rawlins is misquoting Randi, pure and simple.

Can you look anyone in the face and say, in all seriousness and honesty, that the verbal recollection 28 years after an event is more accurate than a written recollection 6 years after the same event?

But for what it is worth, I'm not saying Randi did or did not. I just provided the Rawlings article, and am asking Kimpatsu to back up his claim.
 
jzs said:
Just provide the evidence you claimed existed. Or don't.
I will find it, but there's a lot of material to wade through. Then you'll have to eat humble pie and admit Randi did say it, after all.
 
jzs said:
I listened to ~5hrs. Kimpatsu should cite his source specifically ie. the exact audio file. He made the claim it existed, Claus. The burden is on him, not on me to search for hours for something I didn't even claim existed.

So, you have no interest in finding out whether Randi said it.

jzs said:
Can you look anyone in the face and say, in all seriousness and honesty, that the verbal recollection 28 years after an event is more accurate than a written recollection 6 years after the same event?

But for what it is worth, I'm not saying Randi did or did not. I just provided the Rawlings article, and am asking Kimpatsu to back up his claim.

It's worth nothing, then. Again, you merely take perverse joy in making other people work.
 
Kimpatsu said:
I will find it, but there's a lot of material to wade through. Then you'll have to eat humble pie and admit Randi did say it, after all.

I never said he didn't say it, Kimpatsu.
 
CFLarsen said:
So, you have no interest in finding out whether Randi said it.

ME showing a paper where Rawlings claimed what Randi said is me making a claim? REALLY??

Kimpatsu made the claim of a source, it is up to him to provide evidence for his claim.
 
jzs said:
I never said he didn't say it, Kimpatsu.
Then why don't you dearch through all the audio files yourself? Your antagonistic attitude means you don't beleive he said it, and are challenging Claus and me to prove that he did, whereas if you do genuinely believe he said it, you will make the effotr yourself.
Of course, it could just be that your bolshiness is because you're a petty-minded little prick.
 
jzs said:
ME showing a paper where Rawlings claimed what Randi said is me making a claim? REALLY??

Kimpatsu made the claim of a source, it is up to him to provide evidence for his claim.
OK, Randi never said it, arsehole. Everyone who heard him say it on air was suffering from mass auditory hallucination.
:rolleyes:
 
CFLarsen said:
Walt,

Has Justin admitted that he has made a claim?
Not that I am aware of.

However, whether he admitted it or not is irrelevant to our exchange. He made the claim and backed it up, which is entirely relevant to your asking him to back it up.

Given that:
- his claim was '2) Randi has been reported to have allegedly said, in regards to his challenge, that “I always have an out”'
- he provided a link to that source on page 12 of this thread where Rawlins alleged that Randi said that

Do you then admit that jzs backed up his claim back on page 12?


Walt
 
Kimpatsu said:
Then why don't you dearch through all the audio files yourself?


Beacuse you made the claim of it existing. I didn't. The burden of evidence is on you, my friend. I've already listened to 5+ hours as a courtesy.


Your antagonistic attitude means you don't beleive he said it,


That is flawed reasoning.


and are challenging Claus and me to prove that he did,


You should provide the evidence when requested since you made the claim.
 
Walter Wayne said:
Do you then admit that jzs backed up his claim back on page 12?

No, because he is not making a claim. He has referred to a source.

When you back up a claim, then you provide evidence that your claim is correct. At least, that's how I understand the term.

If it merely means "pointing to someone who said something", then we have to say that John Edward has backed up his claim that he talks to the dead.

I don't think that's what you mean, is it?
 
CFLarsen said:
No, because he is not making a claim. He has referred to a source.


I'm glad and surprised to see you finally conceed that I didn't make a claim. There is hope for you yet.
 
jzs said:


I'm glad and surprised to see you finally conceed that I didn't make a claim. There is hope for you yet. [/B]
You really are a sloppy little jerk, aren't you?! :rolleyes:
Have you listened to all the b/casts yet?
 
Kimpatsu said:
You really are a sloppy little jerk, aren't you?! :rolleyes:
Have you listened to all the b/casts yet?

I've listened to 5+ hours, of where you originally were convinced it was.

Kimpatsu, will you back up your claim and provide the data you claimed existed?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom