Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

Kimpatsu said:
I have already told you; July 2003.

Kimpatsu... you previously said
(bold mine)

"The JREF Internet Show archive, somewhere around July 2003"

and

"The internet radio shows, circa July 2003"

not that it was specifically July 2003.

Moreover, there are four July 2003 files. It would be helpful if you knew which one specifically it was.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

jzs said:
Kimpatsu... you previously said
(bold mine)

"The JREF Internet Show archive, somewhere around July 2003"

and

"The internet radio shows, circa July 2003"

not that it was specifically July 2003.

Moreover, there are four July 2003 files. It would be helpful if you knew which one specifically it was.
Well, it can't be the one where Randi is absent, so try the others.
You should listen to them all, anyway.
 
kookbreaker said:
Fair enough. But this does not preclude another part of the quote.

The burden of proof is yours. I don't have to proove it wasn't said, it's up to you to prove it was. You make the claim, you prove it.


Yes, and as is pointed out by Mr. Hutchinson:
Doesn't speak well of Rawlins.

Randi & co hate Rawlins because Rawlins chose to tell an embarrasing truth rather than a comfortable lie. The CSICOP people tried to fake the falsify the results of their botched test. Rawlins exposed their dishonesty. So the vilify him. It doesn't alter the fact that he is the only one that acted with honour.

Shall we go back a few pages in the very thread? The one you abandoned after your humilation?

The one I abandoned after proving my case beyond any doubt, and receiving tons of hate in response. I abandonded it when it became plain that you, and Dr Adequate and Larsen had no interest in logical debate, and had nothing to offer but filthy abuse and outright lies.

Simply because you've never heard him explain it before is not reason that he has not.

The first excuse is widely published, yet nobody ever heard of the second one. If Randi had made it before, it would have been given the same publicity.

Now, of interest is that the post preceeding Mr. Hutchinson the allegation made is not that Randi was only partially quoted, but that the quote had nothing to do with the Randi challenge at all but was in reference to his stage act.

So, according to Randi, the quote:

1) Means that he doesn't allow people to cheat on the $10,000 challenge.

2) Doesn't refer to the challenge, but actually means his stage act.

3) Isn't an accurate quote anyway.


And you believe ALL of these? :confused:
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

Kimpatsu said:
Well, it can't be the one where Randi is absent, so try the others.


The page you linked to shows Randi being at all of the July ones.

Jul 31, 2003
James Randi, Andrew Harter, Jack Latona

Jul 24, 2003
James Randi, Andrew Harter, Jack Latona

Jul 10, 2003
James Randi, Andrew Harter, Jack Latona

Jul 3, 2003
James Randi, Andrew Harter, Jack Latona


You should listen to them all, anyway.

I guess one has to since you don't know which one it is.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

jzs said:
I guess one has to since you don't know which one it is.
You're right; I don't. There are no transcripts of these audio transmissions. So what?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

Kimpatsu said:
You're right; I don't. There are no transcripts of these audio transmissions. So what?

Your reference isn't directly to the specific source you are claiming exists. One has to spend ~5hrs just to see if it even exists.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

jzs said:
Your reference isn't directly to the specific source you are claiming exists. One has to spend ~5hrs just to see if it even exists.
You bloody well know it exists; you're just being bolshey. If there were a transcript of the broadcasts available I'd direct you to them, but as there isn't, you'll have to make do with listening, like the rest of us.
 
Peter Morris said:
Randi & co hate Rawlins because Rawlins chose to tell an embarrasing truth rather than a comfortable lie. The CSICOP people tried to fake the falsify the results of their botched test. Rawlins exposed their dishonesty. So the vilify him. It doesn't alter the fact that he is the only one that acted with honour.

Since you know so much:

Which test was falsified? What was Randi doing with the test that was dishonest? How did CSICOP 'fake' results? How do you feel about Abell's work in this matter post-1980. Why exaclty was Rawlins honourable. The answers are not what you think they are.

The answers are not your simplistic tales. Quite frankly you show that you know nothing about the entire affair.

The one I abandoned after proving my case beyond any doubt, and receiving tons of hate in response. I abandonded it when it became plain that you, and Dr Adequate and Larsen had no interest in logical debate, and had nothing to offer but filthy abuse and outright lies.

Pwah! Oh that is rich. This is why you get no respect, Peter. None. This is fantasy beyond all telling. You were taken to task for this fable before, it still won't work. The only lies were told by you, and they were very, very incompetent lies.

The first excuse is widely published, yet nobody ever heard of the second one. If Randi had made it before, it would have been given the same publicity.

First excuse is widely published? Where is you evidence of that, please? Mr. Hutchinson relating words from Randi's email hardly qualifies as 'widely published.

So, according to Randi, the quote:

1) Means that he doesn't allow people to cheat on the $10,000 challenge.

Yes. But that does not preclude that the quote was only partial.

2) Doesn't refer to the challenge, but actually means his stage act.

No, that was an error in assumption by the person Mr. Hutcinson was replying to. Can't you pay attention?

Randi has said comments similar to 'out' with regards to his magic act. He makes it clear to Mr. Hutchinson that in this case he most certainly was not.

"The skeptic, no matter how well-meaning, is confusing this with the fact -- which I've often stated -- that we magicians always have an "out" from not saying in advance what we're going to do in the act, thus not having to do something which may turn out to be impossible because of unexpected events or conditions."

3) Isn't an accurate quote anyway.

He states that it is a partial quote. There is a difference.

And you believe ALL of these? :confused: [/B]

False dichotomy. Your presentation is inept.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

Kimpatsu said:
You bloody well know it exists;


How do I know that, you haven't provided an exact reference. Just because you say so?

You cannot point out specifically which one it is in July. Why do you keep going on and on?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

jzs said:


How do I know that, you haven't provided an exact reference. Just because you say so?

You cannot point out specifically which one it is in July. Why do you keep going on and on? [/B]
Because you keep bloody well insisting here, rather than listening to the broadcasts for yourself! What do you want? For me to transcribe all the broadcasts for you until the quote is found? I heard it during the b/cast in question. Now you go and listen to them yourself. I can't provide an exact reference as there is no transcript of the show, which you know, and are merely using as an excuse to avoid listening to the broadcast yourself, which would disprove your contention that Randi never said the full quote.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

Kimpatsu said:

I heard it during the b/cast in question.


Which one, Kimpatsu? There are many. Even in July 2003 there are 4 of them. You don't know, I know that.


, which would disprove your contention that Randi never said the full quote.

That's absurd, Kimpatsu. I never claimed Randi didn't say that. Quit inventing things, please.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

jzs said:


Which one, Kimpatsu? There are many. Even in July 2003 there are 4 of them. You don't know, I know that.[/B]
I don't knwo which one, which is why you'll have to listen to them all!
jzs said:
That's absurd, Kimpatsu. I never claimed Randi didn't say that. Quit inventing things, please.
Then what exactly is your problem? Why won't you bite the bullet and listen tot he b/casts? You are very determinedly avoiding listening to them, and you claimed earlier that you doubted the source existed. Look at all the time you've wasted dancing around here rather than actually listening to the b/casts. This speaks of a hidden agenda; most probably, having made the claim that the source is spurious, you are now pointedly avoiding listening to the b/casts as a way of saving your monstrous ego, for once heard, you will no longer be able to deny to yourself that the source exists.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

Kimpatsu said:
I don't knwo which one, which is why you'll have to listen to them all!


Please, don't recommend a source unless you know, for certain, the specific source. "circa July 2003", and "I don't know" is not knowing the specific source. That's all.


You are very determinedly avoiding listening to them, and you claimed earlier that you doubted the source existed.


Please, show me my exact quote.


Look at all the time you've wasted dancing around here rather than actually listening to the b/casts. This speaks of a hidden agenda;
[/quopte]


Opportunity cost is irrelevant, Kimpatsu. You have not provided the specific source as requested, to back up your claim, as I've been saying. Actually, it wouldn't even back up your claim. It would just show Randi's 28 years after the fact recollection of the event, right?


as a way of saving your monstrous ego,


Personal attack.

Please, you also have no idea if I am, or am not, listening to these broadcasts. If you do, you should apply for the challenge.

[b[
for once heard, you will no longer be able to deny to yourself that the source exists.

As mentioned, Kimpatsu, I have never, ever, denied that such a thing exists. I've just pointed out that you have not provided a direct link to the broadcast in question. Please, don't invent a position for me. Thanks.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

jzs said:
Please, show me my exact quote.
Your reference isn't directly to the specific source you are claiming exists. One has to spend ~5hrs just to see if it even exists.
There, you see? You started this nonsense over five hours ago. You would have found the quote by now if you weren't fatarsing around.
jzs said:
Please, you also have no idea if I am, or am not, listening to these broadcasts. If you do, you should apply for the challenge.
It doesn't take any psychic powers to see through you.
jzs said:
As mentioned, Kimpatsu, I have never, ever, denied that such a thing exists.
Liar. Look at your own quote above: "...Just to see if it even exists". That's denail, pure and simple.
jzs said:
I've just pointed out that you have not provided a direct link to the broadcast in question. Please, don't invent a position for me. Thanks.
Because i don't have a direct link! (Which you have known since you started this.) You're just fatarsing around to avoid having to actually listen to the b/casts, and the only possible reason for that is to avoid being forced to admit that the quote does indeed exist, which position is an ego one, and nothing to do with the search for truth.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

Kimpatsu said:
There, you see? You started this nonsense over five hours ago. You would have found the quote by now if you weren't fatarsing around.


You could have had the direct link to it before talking about it, Kimpatsu.


Liar. Look at your own quote above: "...Just to see if it even exists". That's denail, pure and simple.


You are incorrect, Kimpatsu. I doubt, I don't deny. I doubt it exists because you have not provided a direct link to the evidence, nor are you able to specify exactly where it is (ie. "circa", one of the four files, and so on). I am not denying such a quote can exist. Do you understand?

As I've mentioned numerous times, if the verbal recollection exists, how is Randi's 28 year after the fact verbal recollection different than Rawling's 6 year after the fact written recollection? Care to address this?


that is to avoid being forced to admit that the quote does indeed exist, which position is an ego one, and nothing to do with the search for truth.

I freely admit the audio may exist. I never claimed otherwise, despite your claims. I have mentioned, however, that you have not provided a specific link to it, despite being so vocal about the source. Moreover, the audio file wouldn't be evidence for your actual claim, which was not the audio existing, but being so certain that Randi said what said.
 
kookbreaker said:
Since you know so much:

Which test was falsified?
[/qu8ote]

The results were falsified, because they only published the control group, and hid the rest.


What was Randi doing with the test that was dishonest?

attempting to persude Rawlins into silence.

How did CSICOP 'fake' results?

By concealing part of the results that didn't match their expectations.

How do you feel about Abell's work in this matter post-1980. Why exaclty was Rawlins honourable. The answers are not what you think they are.



Pwah! Oh that is rich. This is why you get no respect, Peter. None. This is fantasy beyond all telling. You were taken to task for this fable before, it still won't work. The only lies were told by you, and they were very, very incompetent lies.

Quite literally, I do not think you even understand the difference between truth and lies. You appear to define "lies" as being anything that tends to discredit Randi and his supoporters. The fact remains, I cited exact quotes from Larsen to show his deliberate misrepresentations. All I got in response was foul abuse from trolls. You have not shown one single thing I have said that is untrue.


First excuse is widely published? Where is you evidence of that, please? Mr. Hutchinson relating words from Randi's email hardly qualifies as 'widely published.

It's been all over. Its often quoted by Randi fans.



Yes. But that does not preclude that the quote was only partial.

You make the claim, you prove it.



No, that was an error in assumption by the person Mr. Hutcinson was replying to. Can't you pay attention?

You were the one claiming it's true.

Your words : " Now, of interest is that the post preceeding Mr. Hutchinson the allegation made is not that Randi was only partially quoted, but that the quote had nothing to do with the Randi challenge at all but was in reference to his stage act.

This is not a hard mistake to make, in fact the first issue of Jr. Skeptic (in the pages of SKEPTIC magazine) had a little comic of Randi discussing his "out" with regards to his stage act."



Randi has said comments similar to 'out' with regards to his magic act. He makes it clear to Mr. Hutchinson that in this case he most certainly was not.

But you claimed he was.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of

jzs said:
You could have had the direct link to it before talking about it, Kimpatsu.
For the Nth time: I can't supply a direct link, as I don't know which b/cast it was. You seem to want me to do the work for you.
jzs said:
You are incorrect, Kimpatsu. I doubt, I don't deny. I doubt it exists because you have not provided a direct link to the evidence, nor are you able to specify exactly where it is (ie. "circa", one of the four files, and so on). I am not denying such a quote can exist. Do you understand?
If you doubt it exists, then you are denying that our claims that it exists are true. I can't specify the exact file, because I don't know on which file the quote is located. If you'd actually bothered to listen to them rather than fatarsing about here, you would have found it by now. Your continued avoidance of the audio tapes implies that you are avoiding facing the truth.
jzs said:
As I've mentioned numerous times, if the verbal recollection exists, how is Randi's 28 year after the fact verbal recollection different than Rawling's 6 year after the fact written recollection? Care to address this?
I don't know what you're talking about. You asked where Randi had made the statement, implying that you didn't believe he had ever said such a think. I gave you the ballpark where I know the quote to be located, but you keep avoiding it, which behaviour is an indictment of your snottiness, not of our (Claus's and my) veracity in stating that Randi did indeed make the statement.
jzs said:
I freely admit the audio may exist. I never claimed otherwise, despite your claims.
Liar. Yo usaid specifically: "IF it exists", which is very much an admission of doubt.
Or maybe you don't understand the conditional?
jzs said:
I have mentioned, however, that you have not provided a specific link to it, despite being so vocal about the source. Moreover, the audio file wouldn't be evidence for your actual claim, which was not the audio existing, but being so certain that Randi said what said.
If you actually bother to play the recordings, you will hear Randi make the statement yourself. Instead, you are expending vast amounts of energy in not listening to them. I wonder why...?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More

Kimpatsu said:
as I don't know which b/cast it was. You seem to want me to do the work for you.


I know you don't know which broadcast it was, that is my point. You should know before making such a claim. If you claim it exists, it is your work to find the source for others. The direct source (that is, if you actually want others to find it), not a "circa", etc. It is not up to me to search to verify the claim that you made.


If you doubt it exists, then you are denying that our claims that it exists are true.


That is absurd. I doubt it exists, I am skeptical of it existing, I am not denying that such a thing exists. Do you understand?


If you'd actually bothered to listen to them rather than fatarsing about here, you would have found it by now.


The same goes for you. Moreover, when you mention a source, you should know the exact, specific source. You, apparently, desire people to wade through over 5 hours of audio to find a snippet. That is not providing a direct, specific source.


You asked where Randi had made the statement, implying that you didn't believe he had ever said such a think.


Inquiring where he made a statement is saying I don't believe he made it? Are you serious?!


Liar. Yo usaid specifically: "IF it exists", which is very much an admission of doubt.


Doubt, skepticism, not denial, as you previously claimed.


If you actually bother to play the recordings, you will hear Randi make the statement yourself.


If you actually knew where it was, that would be helpful. I'll give you a reference where you can learn about how to provide references correctly. It is one page 23-something of some book that was written sometime in 2003, I think.


Instead, you are expending vast amounts of energy in not listening to them. I wonder why...?

Because you have not provided a direct reference to the exact source you claimed existed. "Vast amounts", oh, typing expends so much energy!

Again, you avoided addressing this: if the audio exists, it won't even be evidence for your orginal claim of Randi saying something. It would only be evidence of the audio existing of Randi's 28 years after the fact recollection of what he said. Agree?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:

jzs said:
I know you don't know which broadcast it was, that is my point. You should know before making such a claim. If you claim it exists, it is your work to find the source for others. The direct source (that is, if you actually want others to find it), not a "circa", etc. It is not up to me to search to verify the claim that you made.
I have found it for you; you are simply refusing to listen to the b/casts.
jzs said:
That is absurd. I doubt it exists, I am skeptical of it existing, I am not denying that such a thing exists. Do you understand?
Either you doubt that it exists (which means you think it probably doesn't), or you have NO doubt that it exists. Yo ucannot have it both ways.
jzs said:
The same goes for you. Moreover, when you mention a source, you should know the exact, specific source. You, apparently, desire people to wade through over 5 hours of audio to find a snippet. That is not providing a direct, specific source.
So, in other words, you just want an excuse to avoid listening to the b/casts. :rolleyes:
I can't be more precise, because I don't have a transcript of the b/casts!
jzs said:
Inquiring where he made a statement is saying I don't believe he made it? Are you serious?!
Your attempts at sustained innuendo are obnoxious. You weren't inquiring as to where Randi made the statement; you were claiming that he never made it. If you were seriously interested in finding the source, you would have listened to the tapes by now, instead of going out of your way to avoid doing so. You have wasted more time typing here than you have spent listening to the recordings. Why?
jzs said:
Doubt, skepticism, not denial, as you previously claimed.
More false innuendo.
jzs said:
If you actually knew where it was, that would be helpful. I'll give you a reference where you can learn about how to provide references correctly. It is one page 23-something of some book that was written sometime in 2003, I think.
First, what am I supposed to be looking for?
Besides, I wasn't that general. Your example should be, "it's on or around p. 23 of (name of book), version, which came out in July 2003", thereby reducing my search to pp. 20 to 40 of four volumes.
jzs said:
Because you have not provided a direct reference to the exact source you claimed existed. "Vast amounts", oh, typing expends so much energy!
Less energy than it takes to listen? As I keep saying, I can't provide a direct reference to which b/cast, because I don't know. I only know the approximate area. Why is this so hard to grasp?!
jzs said:
Again, you avoided addressing this: if the audio exists, it won't even be evidence for your orginal claim of Randi saying something. It would only be evidence of the audio existing of Randi's 28 years after the fact recollection of what he said. Agree?
WTF are you talking about? You wanted to know where Randi said, "I always have an out--I'm always right", implying that you doubt he ever said such a thing. I'm pointing you to the internet broadcasts, where he did indeed say such a thing. What's that got to do with 28 years ago?!
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:

Kimpatsu said:
I have found it for you; you are simply refusing to listen to the b/casts.


Kimpatsu, specifically, which audio file is it? You do not know this. Therefore, you have not "found it" for me. You just pointed out the general area where you believe it might be located. Do you believe this is providing an actual reference? You'd get marked down if you put that in any paper in the 'References' section.


Either you doubt that it exists (which means you think it probably doesn't), or you have NO doubt that it exists. Yo ucannot have it both ways.


I cannot have some doubt? I have to have all or none? That is a false dichotomy, Kimpatsu. I have some doubts, based on your lack of evidence and avoidal to provide a specific reference. I don't deny it exists, which is what you incorrectly claimed.


I can't be more precise, because I don't have a transcript of the b/casts!


That is a strawman. Why would you need a transcript to know which one it was in? You mean you don't remember which one it was in? So all this time you've just been guessing where it is?


You weren't inquiring as to where Randi made the statement; you were claiming that he never made it.


Kimpatsu, you are still mistaken. I never claimed Randi didn't make that statement. You claimed he did, however. If I claimed that Randi didn't make the statement, please, show me my exact quote (not what you believe I supposedly implied, etc).


You have wasted more time typing here than you have spent listening to the recordings. Why?


Please, show me these quantities

a) time I've spent typing here

and

b) time I've spent listening to the recordings

You'd have to know both of those, somehow, to make the (another!) claim you did. Unless.... you were making another claim without actual evidence.

Regardless of my opportunity cost, that doesn't have anything to do with you providing evidence for your claim.


I can't provide a direct reference to which b/cast, because I don't know. I only know the approximate area.


Exactly, which is why you have not provided a direct reference, just a vague area where you believe it might be located.


WTF are you talking about? You wanted to know where Randi said, "I always have an out--I'm always right", implying that you doubt he ever said such a thing.


All that implies is that I wanted to hear him say that. YOU made the claim he said that. I want to see the evidence (which you can't seem to actually specifically find).


I'm pointing you to the internet broadcasts

You don't know which one specifically, so you aren't really pointing anywhere (or rather you are pointing everywhere, like to all books in a library).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom