Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

TheBoyPaj said:
Edit: Just read the quote given by jzs above. It appears to be a second hand report of a single sentence.

From an extremely bitter and angry person lashing out at a bunch of folks he convinced himself betrayed him. Oh, and said person is prone to giving all sorts of quotes out of context.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

jzs said:
Specifically...where is it? A pointer to the specific source. Is that too difficult for you?


Certainly it seems to hard for you. Are you always this Luci-esque in your intellectual laziness?

TheBoyPaj wrote
This isn't about comparing the 'goodness' of sources. I freely admit that the source of the 'I always have an out,' is from a paper I read that Rawlings wrote. Kimpatsu cited a source, but has yet to show it. And for the record, I am neither a "Randi-basher" nor am I suggesting fraud. [/B]

Yet, you are going well out of your way to avoid seeing anything that might counter your precious quote.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

kookbreaker said:
Certainly it seems to hard for you. Are you always this Luci-esque in your intellectual laziness?


Do you always defend people who say there is a source, but then are too lazy to be bothered to provide it?


Yet, you are going well out of your way to avoid seeing anything that might counter your precious quote.

I am not aware of any specific source. Whomever mentioned the source has all the burden of showing it to others.
 
The thing is, your source is just Rawlings' anecdote, in which he says "I heard Randi say this".
Then we have Kimpatsu saying "I heard Randi say this".

Rawlings' claim is unverifiable, since it was a personal meeting and unrecorded.
Kimpatsu's claim can be verified, though it will take some hours to do so. So why aren't you badgering Rawlings for more evidence?

Anyway, I plan to listen to those radio archives soon. If I come across the phrase, I'll help you narrow your search.
 
TheBoyPaj said:
The thing is, your source is just Rawlings' anecdote, in which he says "I heard Randi say this".
Then we have Kimpatsu saying "I heard Randi say this".

Rawlings' claim is unverifiable, since it was a personal meeting and unrecorded.
Kimpatsu's claim can be verified, though it will take some hours to do so. So why aren't you badgering Rawlings for more evidence?

1) Because Rawlings is critical of skeptics. Justin can use any such criticism, regardless of it is true or not.

2) Justin doesn't do his own homework. He insists that others do it for him.
 
TheBoyPaj said:
The thing is, your source is just Rawlings' anecdote, in which he says "I heard Randi say this".
Then we have Kimpatsu saying "I heard Randi say this".


Look, you're getting off topic again. This isn't about comparing the 'goodness' of sources. I made my source directly identifiable. Kimpatsu has not. That is the issue here.


Kimpatsu's claim can be verified, though it will take some hours to do so.


So how is a radio show of Randi saying what occured any different than Rawlings writing what occured?


So why aren't you badgering Rawlings for more evidence?


Pardon me, but you have no idea of my attempts. I've searched for some contact information, but cannot find any. I'd love to get more info.


Anyway, I plan to listen to those radio archives soon. If I come across the phrase, I'll help you narrow your search.

The burden is on Kimpatsu. He mentioned the reference, but when asked for it specifically, he, as of the current time and date I am writing this, couldn't produce it. Again, even if he does, how is a radio show of Randi saying what occured any different than Rawlings writing what occured?
 
CFLarsen said:

2) Justin doesn't do his own homework. He insists that others do it for him.

Did my own homework for all of my years in school.

Kimpatsu cited some source, but couldn't provide a direct path to it when asked. The work here is Kimpatsu's I'm sorry to say.
 
jzs said:
Did my own homework for all of my years in school.

So, you feel you've done enough for the rest of your life. Gotcha.

jzs said:
Kimpatsu cited some source, but couldn't provide a direct path to it when asked. The work here is Kimpatsu's I'm sorry to say.

Is the Rawlings quote a complete one? Is it correct, with no selective quoting?
 
CFLarsen said:
So, you feel you've done enough for the rest of your life. Gotcha.


Well that is a pretty silly belief of yours. I do your homework for example..catching things like obvious typos that an "editor" should catch, and that your "thousands" of "peer reviewers" apparently overlook. Gotcha.

If you know how I feel, you should apply for the challenge!


Is the Rawlings quote a complete one? Is it correct, with no selective quoting?

Who knows. I've certainly never said it is or isn't, just that it is out there. I'm still waiting for Kimpatsu's source, and for an explanation of how Randi verbally saying a quote is a different level of 'evidence' than Rawlings writing about it. I'll note that Randi's audio source, if it exists, would be about 28 years after the event, while Rawlings written source, which does exist, is written only 5 or so years after.
 
jzs said:
Who knows.

*DING!* Thank you for calling.

jzs said:
I've certainly never said it is or isn't, just that it is out there. I'm still waiting for Kimpatsu's source, and for an explanation of how Randi verbally saying a quote is a different level of 'evidence' than Rawlings writing about it. I'll note that Randi's audio source, if it exists, would be about 28 years after the event, while Rawlings written source, which does exist, is written only 5 or so years after.

It doesn't matter, Justin. You are pointing to an unverifiable source.
 
Claus,

BS. Does a baseball player hit every time at bat? Yes or no?

What the player claims has nothing to do with performance.
 
CFLarsen said:

It doesn't matter, Justin. You are pointing to an unverifiable source.

So is Kimpatsu though, right? You don't care about him though. Could have something to do with pointing out your errors..

Kimpatsu claimed that "What Randi actually said was: "I always have an out: I'm always right."", and everyone is still waiting for his amazing verification of this, and an explanation how that would be a higher level of evidence than Rawling's paper. I'd like to see Randi's evidence of him "always" being right, or even what that means!

Claus. I originally said

"2) Randi has been reported to have allegedly said, in regards to his challenge, that “I always have an out”. This discourages people from thinking the challenge is genuine."

so I am not saying Randi did or did not say that. I am bringing up the topic for discussion, showing that the hinting at always having an out would discourage many people from wanting to participate in the Challenge. Do you finally understand?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

jzs said:

Do you always defend people who say there is a source, but then are too lazy to be bothered to provide it?

Are you always this dense? It was stated that it was on the webcast.

http://www.randi.org/shopping/index.html#

I am not aware of any specific source. Whomever mentioned the source has all the burden of showing it to others. [/B]

This was done. You chose to ignore it.
 
jzs said:
So is Kimpatsu though, right? You don't care about him though. Could have something to do with pointing out your errors..

Kimpatsu claimed that "What Randi actually said was: "I always have an out: I'm always right."", and everyone is still waiting for his amazing verification of this, and an explanation how that would be a higher level of evidence than Rawling's paper. I'd like to see Randi's evidence of him "always" being right, or even what that means!

Claus. I originally said

"2) Randi has been reported to have allegedly said, in regards to his challenge, that “I always have an out”. This discourages people from thinking the challenge is genuine."

so I am not saying Randi did or did not say that. I am bringing up the topic for discussion, showing that the hinting at always having an out would discourage many people from wanting to participate in the Challenge. Do you finally understand?

So, once again, you start off with a claim, but later claim that it isn't (really) a claim, but still want other people to back up their claims?

Can you tell us when you are making a claim, and when you are not making a claim? It would be most helpful, Justin.
 
Kimpatsu, the only CD of the webcasts I can see for sale are the 2002 ones. You said it was in July (ish) 2003.

Still, even if it could have been in the range June-August, that's still only 9 shows to listen through. That's about 10 hours of educational and entertaining radio!

And if you compare that to how long it would take to verify a reference to an academic publication, I imagine it would take longer than 10 hours for me to go to the library, order the book, wait for it to arrive and read it. :D
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: More of them

kookbreaker said:
Are you always this dense? It was stated that it was on the webcast.

http://www.randi.org/shopping/index.html#


If you were following the conversation, you'd find that I am not looking for vague references. Please get me exactly to it. That is what to provide a reference means. The page you linked to does not do that.

Once you or anyone find the claimed source, then explain to everyone that a 28 years after the fact verbal recollection somehow means something more than a 6 year after the fact written recollection. Randi and Rawlings were both there, that much is agreed upon at least. :)


This was done. You chose to ignore it.

It certainly has not been done yet.
 
CFLarsen said:
So, once again, you start off with a claim,


Which was what exactly? What was my claim, Claus?


, but still want other people to back up their claims?


Well Kimpatsu did indeed make a claim. He said that "What Randi actually said was: "I always have an out: I'm always right."". I didn't make any claim of what Randi said, but only said "2) Randi has been reported to have allegedly said, in regards to his challenge, that “I always have an out”. This discourages people from thinking the challenge is genuine". If you actually read what I wrote, you would have seen the difference.

Claus,

Does a baseball player hit every time at bat? Yes or no?

What the player claims has nothing to do with performance. Will you provide a direct Yes or No answer to this?
 
TheBoyPaj said:
Kimpatsu, the only CD of the webcasts I can see for sale are the 2002 ones. You said it was in July (ish) 2003.

Still, even if it could have been in the range June-August, that's still only 9 shows to listen through. That's about 10 hours of educational and entertaining radio!

And if you compare that to how long it would take to verify a reference to an academic publication, I imagine it would take longer than 10 hours for me to go to the library, order the book, wait for it to arrive and read it. :D

What, like saying 'i remember it being out there, somewhere, I think' is not providing a good reference?! You're just being lazy and wanting people to do your homework! ;)
 
jzs said:
Which was what exactly? What was my claim, Claus?

Recently, that Rawlings said what he said. You can, of course, now claim that it wasn't a claim after all. Which makes it hard to tell when you make claims. I am sure you are keen on clarifying that to us.

jzs said:
Well Kimpatsu did indeed make a claim. He said that "What Randi actually said was: "I always have an out: I'm always right."". I didn't make any claim of what Randi said, but only said "2) Randi has been reported to have allegedly said, in regards to his challenge, that “I always have an out”. This discourages people from thinking the challenge is genuine". If you actually read what I wrote, you would have seen the difference.

You have been given a source. Check it out.

jzs said:
Does a baseball player hit every time at bat? Yes or no?

I have no idea. That would depend on the baseball player.

jzs said:
What the player claims has nothing to do with performance. Will you provide a direct Yes or No answer to this?

Again, it would depend on the baseball player.

Now, I have answered your questions. Please answer mine. You can start with this one:

Can you tell us when you are making a claim, and when you are not making a claim?

Answer that, or hang you head in shame.
 
CFLarsen said:
Recently, that Rawlings said what he said. You can, of course, now claim that it wasn't a claim after all.


You need to read a dictionary and see what "claim" means. Me reporting what someone else said is not me making a claim.


You have been given a source. Check it out.


No, I have not. Saying something like 'archives, somewhere, I think it may be this year' is not providing a source, that is providing a recollection of perhaps where the source may be. Kimpatsu did make a claim of what Randi supposedly said, and we're all waiting for the actual source. And once we get that source, if it exists, we're waiting for the explanation of why a 28 year after the fact verbal recollections means something more than a 6 year after the fact written recollection.


I have no idea. That would depend on the baseball player.


Now you have no idea, but before you said it depends on what the player claims he/she can hit, which is absurd. The performance of a player has nothing to do with their claim of performance. The facts are, Claus, that no known baseball players have hit everytime at bat in their career. Actual data (try looking at it sometime) from the MLB association in USA, for example, support this.


Can you tell us when you are making a claim, and when you are not making a claim?


It is obvious. If I make the claim, I have made the claim. Me reporting what someone else said is not me making a claim. Do you finally understand?


Answer that, or hang you head in shame.

Don't you have some typo correcting to do? Like about 250 or more?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom