Re: Re: More of them
Source?
Kimpatsu said:What Randi actually said was: "I always have an out: I'm always right."
Source?
Kimpatsu said:What Randi actually said was: "I always have an out: I'm always right."
CFLarsen said:You can't say that the alpha value is "typically" set at 0.001. You have no real basis for this.
Either people can do it, or they can't. End of story.
The quote is incomplete.
The challenge is genuine and nobody is stopping anyone from applying.
Randi has made it blatantly clear several times (e.g. on Australian TV and at TAM3) that the money will be paid in such a case, simply because it would be such a fantastic new discovery.
Then go elsewhere and have someone else test it for you.
It doesn't matter whether JREF was fooled or not.
The JREF files are open to anyone who wants to inspect them.
The JREF Internet Show archive, somewhere around July 2003.jzs said:Source?
jzs said:
It would be assimilated into a the natural world. It would cease to be paranormal, and hence awarding a paranormal prize would make no sense for a natural event.
jzs said:http://www.randi.org/jr/08-24-01.html,
"As always, as described in the rules, a preliminary test for the JREF prize would be performed. That test would have odds of only 1 in 1,000 against the results being positive by chance alone."
is that "no real basis" to you?
Now please address the points.
jzs said:Answer the question. Does a baseball player hit every time at bat? Yes or no?
jzs said:Then complete it, with a source, please.
jzs said:Strawman.
jzs said:The issue is that if Randi really did say he always has an out, then he may indeed always have an out, so you do not know if the challenge is genuine as you claim. That is the problem.
jzs said:It would be assimilated into a the natural world. It would cease to be paranormal, and hence awarding a paranormal prize would make no sense for a natural event.
jzs said:Ah, the 'you don't like it, so go!!!' dodge.
jzs said:If you think about it, it would, because a paranormal event may not have occured, but rather the JREF and claim testers could have merely been fooled. In other words, passing the JREF challenge would convince no one, beacuse a more probable hypothesis than a paranormal event happening is that people are simply being fooled.
jzs said:So you cannot answer the question with an actual number. Noted.
Kimpatsu said:Claus is right; Justin's attacks are ludicrous. They amount to sticking his fingers in his ears and humming loudly, as opposed to possesing the desire to actually understand what the JREF challenge is, and how it is met. As there is no medicine for willful ignorance, I don't know what else we can do...![]()
jzs said:He assured me how cautious he was in the testing for his well-publicized $ 10,000 prize for proof of psychic abilities (for which he acts as policeman, judge and jury -- and thus never has supported my idea of neutral judgment of CSICOP tests. "I always have an out," he said."[/i]
Notice the number of errors the always arrogant Dennis Rawlins makes in this little paragraph? There is no judging (never was) so randi cannot be judge and jury. Policeman? Rather doubtful since no cop ever walked up to a mugger and challenged him at his own option to prove he was innocent in a court of law.
I had not noticed before that Rawlins' quote of Randi ends in a comma. Typical of Rawlins' behavior, leaving out a quote like that. Ranks up there with him considering a black man 'unreliable' as a witness to a major geographic event as far as scummy Rawlins antics go.
kookbreaker said:I had not noticed before that Rawlins' quote of Randi ends in a comma. Typical of Rawlins' behavior, leaving out a quote like that.
In a 1995 book saturated with piercing skepticism, the late Carl Sagan of Cornell University maintained his life-long mission of educating the public about science, in this case by debunking popular hysteria over alien abductions, channelers, faith-healers, the "face" on Mars, and practically everything else found in the New Age section of most bookstores. Then, in one paragraph amongst 450 pages, we find an astonishing admission:
The Conscious UniverseAt the time of writing there are three claims in the ESP field which, in my opinion, deserve serious study: (1) that by thought alone humans can (barely) affect random number generators in computers; (2) that people under mild sensory deprivation can receive thoughts or images "projected" at them; and (3) that young children sometimes report the details of a previous life, which upon checking turn out to be accurate and which they could not have known about in any other way than reincarnation.
"I pick these claims not because I think they're likely to be valid (I don't), but as examples of contentions that might be true." They "have at least some, although still dubious, experimental support. Of course, I could be wrong."
Bob Carroll, comments on Carl Sagan, The Demon-Haunted-World
In 1995, for example, no less an arch-skeptic than the late astronomer Carl Sagan rendered his lifelong opinion that all psi effects were impossible. But in one of his last books, The Demon-Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark, he wrote, "At the time of writing there are three claims in the ESP field which, in my opinion, deserve serious study: (1) that by thought alone humans can (barely) affect random number generators in computers; (2) that people under mild sensory deprivation can receive thoughts or images "projected" at them; and (3) that young children sometimes report the details of a previous life, which upon checking mm out to be accurate and which they could not have known about in any other way than reincarnation."
Source
kookbreaker said:Ranks up there with him considering a black man 'unreliable' as a witness to a major geographic event as far as scummy Rawlins antics go.
Come again?? [/B]
Rawlins sat shoulder to shoulder with junior college librarian Bryce, each vying for camera attention. And of course, they got in the key racist line; "Peary didn't take any credible witnesses with him." OH! A Negro is not a credible witness? Oh, really?
Easy answer here..because scientific settings want 100% accuracy even if a person had acheived 90/80 or even 70% of the time science still wouldn't recognise it, even those averages are well above guess work
ie. the ad hominem attacks disturb my 'chi' ?However they are as close minded as it gets and attack rather than objectively look at the situation
Fairly easy answer here too..He's been quoted saying 'I always have a way out'. Eg. the data recorded is OWNED by them, and can be manipulated any way they want. They tend to accuse the candidates of leaving information out, and when offered the data they refuse to view it.
ie. he ignores the genuine, sane guys?is only intrested in testing those bonkers individuals and not intrested in the more difficult task of proving psi in a correct scientific way [...AND...] The contest is bullsh*t. advanced [psychic?] people like **** have said that he tried to take the test and they never respond. [... AND... ] I'm going to start a contest to prove that James Randi doesn't exist. I will give anyone $500 million to prove to me that James Randi exists, and as long as I ignore all of you who present birth certificates and US census records, I will never have to worry about coming up with the money
Is that a possible excuse? Maybe not...Randi has no intrest in investigating psi phemonenon, he does have an intrest in exposing psi frauds. This is fine but its no where near saying that psi is untrue. Randi is a showman like many of the fakes he tests
Very easy answer...Even if someone levitated this Randi dude and he begun seeing a field of light around him in the mirror. He'd probably just start taking a nice powerful anti-psychotic pill every night and swear it was all a dream.
Perhaps this isn't useable as an excuse, but I thought it was a 'revealing' quote regarding their thinkingMy problem with James Randi isn't his skepticism, it's the idea of the Million Dollar Challenge. Let's play pretend again... say I'm a multi-billionaire athiest. I take several billion dollars and send out press releases and notifications to all religious organizations, saying that if they can prove conclusively that there is some sort of deity or deities they will recieve all that money. When no one is able to do it, I safely conclude there is no God(dess)(e(s)) and laugh maniacally as I roll around in a pile of gold coins. This isn't sound scientific method, or a sound philosophical method. Some may be saying, "Well psi abilities are different than God, they can be measured with fancy instruments and junk." Can they? How do you know? When did you measure one? Science isn't a bunch of big words in books that are written in stone, its a way of thinking. A search for answers, not waiting for answers to come to you
ie. Randi doesn't test for psi correctly and scientifically?Randi is unfortunately only lying when he says "of course I'd like to see paranormal powers proved," he comes from a point of skeptism where he is "actively" looking to debunk psi, when he does (or even if he doesn't) he uses ridecule to expose and embarass the idividual? Would a real scientist poke fun at someone involved in an objective scientific test? No thats cause he's a magician, not a scientist, not even close to one. This man is muddying the waters, he's gunning for fakers, let him test all the dolphin huggers, levitaters and psychic's he wants but he's actually making the majority of right thinking people believe psi phemonenon is false. If psi can be iron clad proved to be something observable in the universe it must be proved in the lab and there they are measuring deviations from chance produced by its effect [..goes on about princeton..]
Nice - we need to organise 10,000 (exactly) to prove itIf the Randi organisation allowed (funded) the testing of 10,000 people at once (non of whom need to claim psi skills) under the directorship of the psi skeptic Richard Wiseman in say a test to see if a person knew they were being watched in a closed room by remote camera, by monitoring physical subliminal cues like skin conductivity then I would be happy to take part. If you want me or others to levitate dolphins then I'm afraid I can't Randi only wants to see the aspects of psi demonstrated that he and everyone knows are not true, its the safest bet in history
ie. using examples of Randi's beligerent and insulting attitude as an example of how 'unfair' he isWhile searching for failed claimants, all I found was negative towards Mr Randi. [...exerpt of Randi's response to breatharian claim...] James Randi doesn't sound so fair after all
I don't honestly know about this incident, perhaps someone else does.Randi has been asked but will not agree to use proper scientific methods. [... quotes Randi/Schwartz incident...]
ie. Randi is too prejudiced?My point is that Randi's challenge is a test to uncover fakers and in itself this seems a good thing. The problem is that he has seriously prejudiced real research into psi, any scientist with any thought to their career with avoid psi research like the plague or be branded a nut. [...] Don't forget that lucid dreaming was here before Le Berge got his funding to do proper research If the net was as popular 20years ago you might be on a forum argueing with skeptics till your blue in the face that you wake in your dreams to a mind created reality. They would have laughed in your face. Infact to see how agressive skepics can be and how long they can hang onto their beleifs long after the facts have left them behind check this page out at the skeptics dictionary. http://skepdic.com/lucdream.html
He picks on people who are obviously too new age for their own good, because it's easy to make them seem flakey and unreasonable. These are the people who blame failures on negative energy caused by the disbelief of the audience. So he challenges them, and then if they don't respond within a couple of weeks he starts strutting around on his website talking about how they're just scared because they know they are fake.
Not too hard(Regarding the rule about data - #3So basically, the applicant will be selling themselves and their gifts to Randi. For one million dollars. And that's only if they succeed. [... AND...] emphasis on "freely by the JREF." Not any other independent body, but just JREF. They can do what they want the data.
Added more for it's humour, than its usefulnessHe probably is with the Government or Area 51 or something and is trying to get everyone to beleive that TK isn't real so that people don't try to learn it and don't become a threat
Also for it's humourYah but I mean deep down I think James Randi knows tk is real,the idea of it probably just scares him,so while he may act tough inside he's just a scared little man
Carn said:Irrelevant, since Randi in behalf of JREF and the applicant sign a treaty, where it is defined what the applicant has to do to get the million. If he does it, JREF has to pay or will be sued.
Carn
Kimpatsu said:The JREF Internet Show archive, somewhere around July 2003.
CFLarsen said:
Does he claim to be able to? It all depends on what the claimant says he can do.
Kimpatsu said:Claus is right; Justin's attacks are ludicrous.
They amount to sticking his fingers in his ears and humming loudly, as opposed to possesing the desire to actually understand what the JREF challenge is, and how it is met. As there is no medicine for willful ignorance, I don't know what else we can do...![]()
I'm not going to bloody well wade through them all again. Listen to them yourself; you might learn something.jzs said:An exact source, please, not this 'it is over there somewhere' stuff.
Kimpatsu said:I'm not going to bloody well wade through them all again. Listen to them yourself; you might learn something.
Yes, I do: The internet radio shows, circa July 2003. That is a source.jzs said:
So you don't have a source, then?
Kimpatsu said:Yes, I do: The internet radio shows, circa July 2003. That is a source.
![]()
Edit: Just read the quote given by jzs above. It appears to be a second hand report of a single sentence. And this is better than a reference to a radio show in what way?