Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

Peter Morris said:
Well, for some of them you have produced cites that are similar to Larsen's quotes, but even with these it is plain that Larsen's article takes liberties. If Larsen uses the actual quotes, I will have no complaint about that.


Larsen made it quite clear that they were not exact quotes.

Of course, there are quite a few that you were unable to find, save for your claim that they are the same as others.

And very often they were, this would be my primary complaint about Larsen's article. But at least such a complaint is a legitimate criticism

And the fact that Larsen has refused to include certain excuses offered, because they make Randi look bad, and because he can't answer them.

There's only one such alleged excuse, and it has no support. Its sole proponent is you. This complaint is empty now as it was when you first demanded that Larsen put it in.
 
Two filthy and abusive liars who twist truth in support of another liar. They hate the paranormal, and think that any attack on the paranormal is a good thing. They are perfectly happy to let Larsen lie, as long as his lies support Randi and attack the paranormal. They justify Larsen's lies, and attack me with utter hate because I don't support him.
Oh, so now Kookbreaker and Dr Adequate are liars too? Is anyone who disagrees with Peter Morris instantly branded a liar? Am I a liar Peter?

If you think that's abuse, just take a look at some of the filth they produce.
I have read many posts by Kookbreaker and Dr Adequate. Not one would be described as 'filth'.
I am actually slightly worried about your mental health - you seem to have a severe persecution complex and seem paranoid that everyone is ganging up to get you.
Logic should tell you that maybe it is not everyone else's behaviour that is at fault here. But you do not seem to be reasoning in an intelligent and logical way.
Your repeated inability to admit mistakes is also strange.

If you would stop letting blind devotion to Randi get in the way of sensible discussion....
Where did I even mention Randi? You're the one obsesseed by him.
'A sensible discussion'? I am rather in shock that you would have the gall to use those words. Your debates with Larsen stopped being a 'sensible discussion' a very, very long time ago.

That's annoyance and disgust. I leave venom and hate to people like the Kook.
Your posts are far more filled with anger and venom than anyone else's here. Again I am slightly concerned you cannot see this.
And they seem to be getting worse - if you continue in this vein you might run the risk of being banned, so I'd suggest you tone it down a little.
 
They are perfectly happy to let Larsen lie, as long as his lies support Randi and attack the paranormal.
Of course, the lie the halfwit Morris claims Larsen told was that the JREF money had a curse on it, and this would be a claim of the paranormal and an attack on Randi. But hey, who says Morris's lunatic ravings have to make sense? So long as he's drivelling out some lie, he doesn't care how stupid it is.
 
Peter Morris said:
Well, in your case, it's because you know that the Kook & Inadequate will keep spewing out their filth in supoport of you.
Baby's learning some brand new words!
 
Kramer The Millionaire -

If I pray to god that PM goes away and stays away, and then he does, do I get the Million Dollars?

Hmmm....what a grand idea!

Kramer's Claim Letter: I can make a slimey growth masquerading as a rational, inquisitive human being disappear via prayer.

Hey, PM! Can you suggest a test protocol that would conclusively verify this claim?

We know it just wouldn't be fair to the applicant unless you yourself personally approved it in advance, since you are the self-proclaimed arbiter of all that is fair and right as regards JREF's testing of Paranormal Challenge applicants.

Take your time. In fact, please feel free to take all the time in the world. We can wait. Personally, I can wait forever.

Oh and by the way...

If you do decide to design a protocol for this claim, we'd love it if you could do so without being an obnoxious, pig-headed, rude, nasty, deliberately discourteous, spitefully hostile, unrefined, culture-less, intensely bitter, malicious, primitive, virulent, hateful, noxious, unrelentingly poisonous, mashed-potatoes-for-brains caveman.

Did I say "caveman"? Sorry. I wanted to say Neanderthal, but I just wasn't sure how to spell it. So I looked it up, which is more than you would do.

You are a malignancy in the forum, PM.

Cut it out.
 
Re: Kramer The Millionaire -

How the world sees the world's stupidest liar:
princhester said:
By the way, over on the SDMB I have got thoroughly pissed off with Peter and I can now confirm a change in my opinion. He is a flat out deliberate liar.
Nex said:
Holy crizzap, Peter Morris. Do you not know how stupid you look?
kookbreaker said:
Beating up strawmen and putting words in people's mouths is not 'sarcasm'. Given your pedantry, this level of deliberate deception is quite telling about your own honestly.

And for the record, "deliberate dishonesty: and "severe incompetence" are very bad things, however you have failed to prove your accusations. You have had to act in a deliberately dishonest manner to make it seem as if there was a smidgeon of evidence.
CFLarsen said:
You are one seriously disturbed person, Peter.
BillHoyt said:
So, Morris shouldn't be held accountable for his dishonesty?
Dr Adequate said:
You set me off again! Normally I'd feel guilty about laughing at people who are nuts in the head, but you also have such a singularly hideous personality, and are such a revolting liar and charlatan, that I can do so without shame.
Nex said:
Oh, stop it Peter. You're being ludicrous and you know it. No one claimed there actually was cursed money jokingly or otherwise, and for you to say that is a lie.

Peter, stop lying. Repetition does not make it true.

I would find this funny if it weren't so sad...
Dr Adequate said:
Just find it funny. You are not required to sympathise with loathsome people.

Why is he doing this? Well, if a vicious, violent, half-witted lunatic is strait-jacketed and strapped down so that he can't physically assault his keepers, there is still one thing he can do to get at them, if his hatred and lunacy are sufficiently intense.

He can deliberately soil himself.

By doing so, of course, he degrades and debases himself and makes of himself an vile, sickening object of contempt and disgust. But one of his hated keepers will have the loathsome job of coming into contact with the dirty animal and cleaning up its stinking mess. This is the lunatic's one revenge.

In the same way, we have to keep on cleaning up after Peter Morris and his filthy lies. If you let it sadden or sicken you, then he's won, but, as I said, you don't have to feel sorry for him. If on the other hand you find it amusing, as I do, to watch a hideously unpleasant man smear himself with his own filth, then stick around and... enjoy.
Prolix said:
Thank you for this wonderful insight. It gives me "the everlasting peace" of cognitive closure. And lets me accept my human brother Peter Morris, soilage and all. ( But I will keep my distance from him, thank you.)
kookbreaker said:
Right now, you are just a pathetic worm digging deeper. You invite this abuse, if I weren't so certain that your hatred is real, I'd call you a troll.
Nex said:
Peter, you're not only wrong, you're a LIAR. Why are you wasting bandwidth here?

No, don't answer that. Just stop.
KRAMER said:
Peter Morris couldn't recognize a FACT if it was tied to his own butt, with cowbells on it.

This is like trying to play baseball with a parapalegic.

I mean, really; what's the point?

OK, it's entertaining (laughable, in fact), but just how many times can you watch the same old reruns?
princhester said:
The problem with you Peter is and always has been one of having no sense of proportion, and no self awareness when it comes to your own hypocrisy.
Darat said:
All we are left with is your word, and I'll use the evidence of your posts here and elsewhere to assign the appropriate value to that.
Kimpatsu said:
Look, guys (and elegant ladies), Peter Morris is clearly off his goddamn rocker. No matter what we say will never make a blind bit of difference. I have read every singl;e post to this thread, and can objectively state the following: Mr. Larsen never lied at any point.
I also believe, but cannot state objectively, that Peter Morris is off his rocker.
Why don't we all just put this troll on ignore, and get on with the serious business of this forum.
Oh, wait, debunking woo-woos is the serious business of this forum, and Peter certainly qualifies.... :p
kookbreaker said:
In an above post, Dr. Adequate quotes both Peter and Larsen. The post is simple: Peter tantrums for evidence, and Larsen provides it.

Yet, down the page a bit Peter claims that Dr. Adequate has print a Larsen lie and thanks him? This is beyond chutzpah, this is some kind of insanity.
Dr Adequate said:
You are a compulsive liar, Peter. In a whole lifetime, you are the most hideous halfwitted pathetic incompetent implausible obsessive insane liar I have ever encountered. I find it alternately funny and disgusting to watch you drivelling out this filth.
rppa said:
You keep having to add new lies to try to keep your story self-consistent, and eventually it all breaks down in contradiction anyway.
Ashles said:
I just don't get this at all.

Peter Morris is claiming over and over that Larsen has said there is a curse on the money.

Larsen has never done this.

Knowing Larsen and his posting history it would be idiotic to even claim such a thing.
You'd have to be an utter moron and someone who has a desperate need to try and twist any phrase to try and back up their own untenable arguments.
You'd have to be a half-wit to lie so blatantly and to continue to lie even in the face of unanimous mockery of your bare faced lie.

Oh, now maybe I get it...
CFLarsen said:
You poor sod.
rppa said:
One of your recent "recaps" motivated me to go back and read the whole thread. Now I'd like to know if you are still sticking to the other distortions and deliberate misinterpretations you injected. It's really hard to keep track of what you claim to believe...

Oh, and by the way, your "recap" bore no resemblance to the actual. As anybody with a browser can easily verify.
rppa said:
Perhaps readers will find this quote relevant:
've obviously been lied to a lot by campaign operatives, but the striking thing about the way she lied was she knew I knew she was lying, and she did it anyway. There is no word in English that captures that. It almost crosses over from bravado into mental illness.
-said by Tucker Carlson of GW Bush advisor Karen Hughes
KRAMER said:
If you do decide to design a protocol for this claim, we'd love it if you could do so without being an obnoxious, pig-headed, rude, nasty, deliberately discourteous, spitefully hostile, unrefined, culture-less, intensely bitter, malicious, primitive, virulent, hateful, noxious, unrelentingly poisonous, mashed-potatoes-for-brains caveman...

You are a malignancy in the forum, PM.

Cut it out.

How the world's stupidest liar would like to be seen:
Peter Morris said:
As for me, I post because I can't abide dishonesty. I endeavour to expose lies when I see them.
Seek help for your mental condition, Peter. There is something terribly, and I mean terribly wrong with you. You are a ridiculous, pathetic, nauseating excuse for a human being. Do you want to spend the rest of your life this way?
 
PM are you sure your definition of Lie, Liar, and Lying is the same as ours. Note: Ignore the one that involves beds, I don't think it applies.
 
Re: Kramer The Millionaire -

KRAMER said:
You are a malignancy in the forum, PM.

I see him as a great help to skepticism. He exemplifies what a belief in the paranormal can lead to. Perhaps that will make some believers stop and think.
 
Re: Re: Kramer The Millionaire -

CFLarsen said:
I see him as a great help to skepticism. He exemplifies what a belief in the paranormal can lead to. Perhaps that will make some believers stop and think.

You certain, that PM believes in paranormal things, it might be that he just believes, Randi, everybody ever working directly or indirectly for JREF and everybody on this forum, who claims to be sceptic, but does not agree fully with PM, are a bunch of wicked evil lying sceptic believers, who would not believe in paranormal, if combusted to ashes and revived a few years later.

Such a conspiracy of hard core sceptics of course could as most conspiracy theories, be somewhat unrealistic and therefore paranormal, but not in the sense of JREF challenge.

Carn
 
I have never known PM to say anything to suggest that he believes in the paranormal as such. He participates regularly in SDMB threads on logic puzzles etc in a way that shows he is logical, clever and has a clear ability to comprehend English.

This of course makes it all the more stark that his vendetta against Randi is just that: he is not stupid.
 
He's not trolled on here since the twenty-fifth.

I wonder if it was something I said?

Sometimes silence is the most beautiful sound.
 
More of them

Here are some more. Debunking is quite welcome. :)

1) It is often brought up that no applicant has even passed the preliminary test. Once the number of applicants gets over 1000, and keep in mind that alpha is typically set at .001, and if no one has passed the prelim at that point, will skeptics get skeptical, since a person passing is expected just by chance alone? And that point will alpha for the prelim be decreased even further?

2) Randi has been reported to have allegedly said, in regards to his challenge, that “I always have an out”. This discourages people from thinking the challenge is genuine.

3) If a paranormal or supernatural thing were to be demonstrated, it would no longer be paranormal or supernatural, but natural, hence the paranormal challenge would no longer apply, regardless of Randi’s claimed intentions of saying he’ll pay for the demonstration.

4) Science is not getting someone to agree on a long list of conditions and then coming back saying 'this is what you signed, the challenge goes to us!' (to paraphrase Josephson) And if it is not science, why should anyone pay any attention to the results as anything but entertainment?

5) If someone won the JREF Challenge, wouldn’t it be more probable (ie invoking Ockam’s razor) to say the JREF, or their chosen panel of experts, was fooled? Would someone winning the prize convince everyone that paranormal stuff really exists? One demonstration means nothing, as replication is needed in science.

6) In all the ‘experiments’ JREF has conducted, what is the largest sample size out of all of them? Are the tests even large enough to detect a small effect?
 
Re: More of them

jzs said:
Here are some more. Debunking is quite welcome. :)

1) It is often brought up that no applicant has even passed the preliminary test. Once the number of applicants gets over 1000, and keep in mind that alpha is typically set at .001, and if no one has passed the prelim at that point, will skeptics get skeptical, since a person passing is expected just by chance alone? And that point will alpha for the prelim be decreased even further?

As I understand it, the 1:1000 chance of passing only applies if each and every applicant does exactly the same test only once. This is equivalent of one applicant doing the same test 1000 times. It also presupposes every preliminary test conducted is a "chance" test. If it is a do-it-or-fail test, chance has nothing to do with it.

2) Randi has been reported to have allegedly said, in regards to his challenge, that “I always have an out”. This discourages people from thinking the challenge is genuine.

Will you please put that remark in accurate context?

3) If a paranormal or supernatural thing were to be demonstrated, it would no longer be paranormal or supernatural, but natural, hence the paranormal challenge would no longer apply, regardless of Randi’s claimed intentions of saying he’ll pay for the demonstration.

So? It needs to be demonstrated properly in order to make that transition. That's the Challenge.

4) Science is not getting someone to agree on a long list of conditions and then coming back saying 'this is what you signed, the challenge goes to us!' (to paraphrase Josephson) And if it is not science, why should anyone pay any attention to the results as anything but entertainment?

Get your thoughts in order... What particularly are you saying here?

5) If someone won the JREF Challenge, wouldn’t it be more probable (ie invoking Ockam’s razor) to say the JREF, or their chosen panel of experts, was fooled? Would someone winning the prize convince everyone that paranormal stuff really exists? One demonstration means nothing, as replication is needed in science.

True. But think of the kudos of pulling a fast one on Randi and running off with his $1M! Thing is, you need to get up VERY early in the morning to fool the examiners, Randi included. And if it IS demonstrated, wouldn't you think scientists would beat a path to your door to get ahold of the latest "gee-wizz technology"? And if they find it is a fake, guess who's going to look mighty foolish real quick...

6) In all the ‘experiments’ JREF has conducted, what is the largest sample size out of all of them? Are the tests even large enough to detect a small effect?

How small an effect? If you pick up rocks about the place and hold them over your head, getting bigger and bigger rocks each time, is the last giant rock you lift a paranormal phenomenon because it stands out statistically, or just the result of all that previous weightlifting practice?
 

If it is a do-it-or-fail test, chance has nothing to do with it.


Does a baseball player hit every time at bat? Yes or no?


Will you please put that remark in accurate context?


From http://cura.free.fr/xv/14starbb.html:

"During this period Randi would occasionally phone up for a friendly "just-happened-to-be-thinking-of-you" chat. l suspected he was trying to draw out of me statements of anger or of dissatisfaction. Despite his private rages Randi wished to make no public waves. When I asked him why, he repeated the tired old alibi that the occultist kooks would whoop it up if Kurtz fell. But he claimed that he had dressed down Kurtz (privately) in Washington in December. He stated without qualification that Gardner Hyman and he all supported my scientific position on the sTARBABY mess. (I knew, however, that he was telling all inquiring Fellows that a little old nonstatistician like himself just couldn't understand the problem.)
Next Randi (and soon afterwards Bob Sheaffer) tried to get me involved in new projects, i.e., diversions. As part of this effort Randi asked my advice on the Helmut Schmidt parapsychology experiment which some CSICOPs had been investigating. I simply urged that it be approached with all the caution KZA had thrown to the winds in 1975 and 1976. He assured me how cautious he was in the testing for his well-publicized $ 10,000 prize for proof of psychic abilities (for which he acts as policeman, judge and jury -- and thus never has supported my idea of neutral judgment of CSICOP tests. "I always have an out," he said."



So? It needs to be demonstrated properly in order to make that transition. That's the Challenge.


So then it is not a paranormal or supernatural thing anymore, so why would ANY rules of a paranoramal challenge even apply anymore?


Get your thoughts in order... What particularly are you saying here?


Ad hom.

If the challenge is not science, why should anyone pay attention to it? As opposed to reading articles in scientific journals where strange things are scientifically studied, for example.



Ok, so you admitted that winning the JREF challenge would convince no one of the reality of any claimed paranormal or supernatural thing. People could always say most likely the JREF or there chosen panel of experts were really fooled, and again, no paranormal thing was really demonstrated.
 
Re: More of them

jzs said:
Randi has been reported to have allegedly said, in regards to his challenge, that “I always have an out”.
Isn't it wonderful how quoting only half the sentence changes the meaning? What Randi actually said was: "I always have an out: I'm always right."
 
Re: More of them

jzs said:
1) It is often brought up that no applicant has even passed the preliminary test. Once the number of applicants gets over 1000, and keep in mind that alpha is typically set at .001, and if no one has passed the prelim at that point, will skeptics get skeptical, since a person passing is expected just by chance alone? And that point will alpha for the prelim be decreased even further?

You can't say that the alpha value is "typically" set at 0.001. You have no real basis for this.

Since claims vary greatly in character and scope, specific rules must be formulated for each applicant.
Rules

Either people can do it, or they can't. End of story.

jzs said:
2) Randi has been reported to have allegedly said, in regards to his challenge, that “I always have an out”. This discourages people from thinking the challenge is genuine.

Same old, same old. The quote is incomplete. The challenge is genuine and nobody is stopping anyone from applying.

jzs said:
3) If a paranormal or supernatural thing were to be demonstrated, it would no longer be paranormal or supernatural, but natural, hence the paranormal challenge would no longer apply, regardless of Randi’s claimed intentions of saying he’ll pay for the demonstration.

Randi has made it blatantly clear several times (e.g. on Australian TV and at TAM3) that the money will be paid in such a case, simply because it would be such a fantastic new discovery.

jzs said:
4) Science is not getting someone to agree on a long list of conditions and then coming back saying 'this is what you signed, the challenge goes to us!' (to paraphrase Josephson) And if it is not science, why should anyone pay any attention to the results as anything but entertainment?

Then go elsewhere and have someone else test it for you. However, the JREF challenge is far less rigorous than a real scientific test would be.

jzs said:
5) If someone won the JREF Challenge, wouldn’t it be more probable (ie invoking Ockam’s razor) to say the JREF, or their chosen panel of experts, was fooled? Would someone winning the prize convince everyone that paranormal stuff really exists? One demonstration means nothing, as replication is needed in science.

It doesn't matter whether JREF was fooled or not.

jzs said:
6) In all the ‘experiments’ JREF has conducted, what is the largest sample size out of all of them? Are the tests even large enough to detect a small effect?

The JREF files are open to anyone who wants to inspect them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom