Peter Morris said:
It is a work of fiction. Moast of the items are invented by Randi fans.
This post is to document the quotes from Larsen’s article mentioned at the beginning of this thread. This is to counter to hysterical claims from Peter that few or none of these excuses have been used. As can be seen, almost all of these can be found, and some are so common that to claim otherwise required deliberate ignorance.
Some may ask, why didn’t we do this sooner. Well, again I would say that this is because these excuses are common enough that we really have no need to document them. It is like saying there is a traffic light down the road from you. If you say this on the newsgroup and some looney says that you are full of it and there is no traffic light, how much effort are you willing to spend countering such attacks on a very mundane thing? You could take a picture, but that might easily be rejected. You could get documents, but they might be considered faked. I have already expended far too much effort trying to prove that there are traffic lights.
A note before we start: Claus’ list is hardly new. Several lists of excuses can be found on USENET and the web. For example this one from a parapsychology site lists several:
http://www.parascope.com/articles/0197/randi.htm
But now on with the excuses:
James Randi makes money from this:
“randi has not made a legal challenge. randi has posted
loud and long that he has made a one million dollar challenge to any
one who can prove the existence of the paranormal. Legally what randi
is doing is committing a fraud upon the public for personal gain.†–Pete Stapleton
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
James Randi doesn’t have the money
This one is so common I am amazed that I have to prove it is used, but hey:
“Afterall, Sollog hasn't even said he wants Randi's million (which is
b*******, Randi doesn't have a million to give away, it's a lousy
promissory note)†–SollogRules
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
“Neither you or Randi have a pot to pee in..†Earl Curly
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
“What ever happened to Benneth? Maybe he became convinced (like me) that
Randi would never pay.†- Kim Birney
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
Randi is just a magician, what does he know?
This one is tad tricky, because the sentiment is usually dismissive of Randi, and not the challenge. But:
“Randi isn't a scientist and has no credible competence in the scientific community to analyze or make recommendations or inferences on experimental design and statistical inference.†- Brian Zeiler
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
“I've said it before, and I'll continue screaming it at the top of my lungs until the mainstream news media in this country takes notice: JAMES RANDI IS NOT A SCIENTIST. He has ZERO academic or scientific credentials. He is nothing but a former stage performer who, by today's standards, is a subpar magician…†Micheal GoodSpeed
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
I was tested by X and that proves it!
This one is often used by Geller regarding his ‘test’ at SRI. A close version comes from Benneth (via Kettler):
“...I'm claiming can be done HAS ALREADY BEEN DONE by others before me.â€
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
James Randi won’t let me take the challenge
Oh, please! Just look at latinrijil’s post on this forum where he tried to enter someone else’s video tape.
The variation on this is to bluster about the challenge and claim Randi is running away. There are too many examples to list. Ed Dames, Benneth are immediate examples. (see the link under “I was tested by X…†above).
Some things can’t be quantified by your limited scientific methods.
“People with these kinds of abilities don't need "scientific" approval or validation, because the reality is that modern science is extremely biased to begin with. It isn't about truth and hasn't been for a long time.†–M1thr0s
http://www.occultforums.com/showthread.php?t=8898&page=4&pp=20
Spiritual Powers and money don’t mix
“I wonder if Randi has considered that offering money in exchange for
demonstration of "psychic powers" is actually corrupting the process?
As a believer in the paranormal, I think the #1 problem is the profit
motivation of "psychics." -Wilma Schpamme
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
The money is tainted. It will only bring misery and pain
Claus already documented this one.
I don’t do this for personal gain
“Unfortunately the kabalists in Israel have not displayed the slightest
interest in earning some extra money, perhaps Mr. Randi could think up
of something to tempt them.â€
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
I can only perform if no sceptic is in any way involved in the testing
While not directly to the challenge, Uri Geller blamed Johnny Carson’s skepticism for his failure on the tonight show when he returned to Leno’s Tonight Show.
The entire “psi-missingâ€, a long staple in Parapsychology, also covers this.
I can only perform if a skeptic offers me large sums of money
I can only perform if no skeptic offers me large sums of money
I really don’t feel the need to repeat what is essentially covered by “not in this for personal gain†routine. Truth is, these are redundant.
I can only perform when no skeptic is present because their evil vibrations negate my powers
Pretty much the same as “I can only perform…†listed above. Psi-missing once again.
The Challenge is not worth taking
I need only point to Sylvia Brown’s excuses that she’s “too busy†to win a million dollars for this one.
I am not out to convince anyone
Peter had access to this one from the first. He would later claim that only one excuse was documented (not this one) . Gee, dishonest much Peter?
“Without sounding too skeptical of the skeptics, I'd be willing to bet that their "proper observing conditions" are rather limiting. Besides, I don;t have to prove myself to anyone.†Quidgyboo
http://www.occultforums.com/showthread.php?t=8898
I only heal/ do mediumship for those who really need it
“I think the problem with a challenge of this type is that it is not motivated by a desire to see a miracle…If we can perform miracles at all,it is only by the Spirit of God, who decides when and where He will give a miracle. It isn't up to any of us.†–John Seeks
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
If I do this in public, they will lock me up in the Pentagon or in a nuthouse
This was the hardest to find. There are variations on it, and the parascope article makes mention of it.
Randi won’t pay me the money even after I win
This one is fairly easy.
“I predict that no time within James Randi's lifetime will anyone win
the $10,000 prize. Do you really believe there is _anything_ that would cause him to state that one of the fundamental tenets of his and CSICOP's worldview is in error? He can always ask for better demonstrations, claim fraud, duplicate the demonstration using prestidigitation and dismiss it, claim hallucinogens in the air conditioning, etc.†Tim Scott
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
Randi sets the tests too high. The test is impossible
“With the information that I have acquired, I feel that the
odds are highly in James Randi's favor. In fact I believe
that they are a little TOO HIGH.†-Flagship of the Paranormal
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
The terms enable Randi to draw up specific rules that are unwinnable.
Really, this is the same as above.
The challenge is just a meaningless PR stunt.
There are TONS of examples of this one.
“This is just a big publicity stunt, and he is in complete control.†Newbie
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
Randi will just say that the effect can produced by trickery, then the effect must trickery
“I told you that Randi would arrange things in such a way that Kam will not be
able to preform,or if he succeeds that Randi will try to find an alternative
method of why he succeeded and if he finds one he will insist that this was how
it was done. He has no real interest in finding the truth. But to prove how
clever he is.†PQ Rada
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
Randi will just refuse to accept what I do as paranormal
Pretty much the same as above.
I will lose my power if I charge money for using my gift
Can’t say I’ve heard this one used. So I didn’t bother looking for it. It looks like a variation of an earlier excuse, however.
The JREF doesn’t release any readily available results from previous applicants, so I don’t know what to expect.
“4. Why won't JREF reveal records of previous applications?
We've asked, but indications are that they either don't exist or are
being withheld. Why aren't they kept for review by those who ask?†John Benneth, via Kettler
http://groups.google.com/[email protected]&output=gplain
So there you have it. I have wasted my time demonstrating stuff that was already encountered and expected. I will not waste more time chasing geese for a whiner.
Edited for coding mistakes