kookbreaker
Evil Fokker
- Joined
- Aug 23, 2001
- Messages
- 16,546
Allow me to summarize a bit:
Claus decides to write an article giving answers to excuses for not taking the challenge. The purpose of the article is mostly to give answers to existing and potential comments. The important part of the article is the answers, not the questions themselves. This article is not a quotation documentation, it is not a historical accounting of excuses used, it does not use exact wording of every variation on an excuse. Claus makes this clear early on when he points out that several excuses are covered by other ones.
Peter, in his second post in the thread (the first being a typical Peter cheap-shot insult), declares that the excuses are straw men, and demands evidence for each one, despite the nature of the article.
Evidence is provided for some of them, Peter ignores most of it. One person gives a personal account of an excuse being used and Peter rejects it. This becomes important soon.
Peter soon insists that his own excuse be put on the list. By this point, what Peter says is really not to be taken on faith for obvious reasons. This is made clear by Claus, saying he;d like more evidence. Is it an unfair standard for Peter? Maybe, but Peter is the one responsible for his own reputation. Nobody made Peter write all those hysterics and rantings.
Peter claims to provide evidence for his 'excuse', but when examined it turns out to a person who withdrew during negotiations, a person who applied on bad faith and Peter Morris's own experience. Peter seems to now expect people to accept the standards he himself rejected. This 'excuse' is effectively rejected since it really has nothing behind it besides Peter's prejudice against Randi.
It gets more ugly from there. The original purpose of the article is somehow twisted to Peter's standards, a feeling only Peter subscribes to.
So Peter calls everyone liars.
Claus decides to write an article giving answers to excuses for not taking the challenge. The purpose of the article is mostly to give answers to existing and potential comments. The important part of the article is the answers, not the questions themselves. This article is not a quotation documentation, it is not a historical accounting of excuses used, it does not use exact wording of every variation on an excuse. Claus makes this clear early on when he points out that several excuses are covered by other ones.
Peter, in his second post in the thread (the first being a typical Peter cheap-shot insult), declares that the excuses are straw men, and demands evidence for each one, despite the nature of the article.
Evidence is provided for some of them, Peter ignores most of it. One person gives a personal account of an excuse being used and Peter rejects it. This becomes important soon.
Peter soon insists that his own excuse be put on the list. By this point, what Peter says is really not to be taken on faith for obvious reasons. This is made clear by Claus, saying he;d like more evidence. Is it an unfair standard for Peter? Maybe, but Peter is the one responsible for his own reputation. Nobody made Peter write all those hysterics and rantings.
Peter claims to provide evidence for his 'excuse', but when examined it turns out to a person who withdrew during negotiations, a person who applied on bad faith and Peter Morris's own experience. Peter seems to now expect people to accept the standards he himself rejected. This 'excuse' is effectively rejected since it really has nothing behind it besides Peter's prejudice against Randi.
It gets more ugly from there. The original purpose of the article is somehow twisted to Peter's standards, a feeling only Peter subscribes to.
So Peter calls everyone liars.
