Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

Thich Naht Hanh teaches that nibbanna is much like the state that martial artists train for,

mindful, unreactionary, unfettered.

That's just silly. We train to be reactionary.

It can be called a state of nothingness, but it is also a state of detachment and freedom to live life as it is , without the fetters of the five skandhas and false beliefs.

The state of nothingness can only be achieved through death.
 
In what way (if any) is this distinguishable from the Christian concept of being born again?

As I understand it the Christian concept is the idea of a new start brought about by accepting Jesus into your life and as a result you are now "born again" without sin.

The Buddhist idea of rebirth is the opposite: you are reborn because of your actions in previous lives.

For Christians being "born again" is a good thing. For Buddhists being reborn is a bad thing - it is the very thing you are trying to escape.
 
As I understand it the Christian concept is the idea of a new start brought about by accepting Jesus into your life and as a result you are now "born again" without sin.

The Buddhist idea of rebirth is the opposite: you are reborn because of your actions in previous lives.

For Christians being "born again" is a good thing. For Buddhists being reborn is a bad thing - it is the very thing you are trying to escape.

Ah, but this conflicts with what was said earlier and to which I was responding, and I quote:

Yale Landsberg said:
Same goes for "re-birth". Anytime you break free of old habits of feelings, thoughts and actions, for example becoming an atheist, or finding God, or getting divorced or having sex for the first time (hopefully not after getting divorced, but probably a good reason to get a divorce), you are in a sense re-born.

Furthermore, the very notion of "previous lives" involves, necessarily, some form of reincarnation (literally "getting into some meat again"), and since pregnant women don't really stuff all that much meat into their vaginas, and most of it comes back out again, I have to conclude that babies are made of newly constructed meat (optimally, with some newly constructed bones, too).

Yet I see time and time again that rebirth is not reincarnation, though I have never seen those who say it come close to explaining it.
 
In what way (if any) is this distinguishable from the Christian concept of being born again?


I would suggest that nirvana is moment to moment and therefore beyond rebirth.

But it does illuminate some ideas of karma, acts and thoughts have consequence.

If one is conditioned and reactionary then one is 'reborn'.
 
That's just silly. We train to be reactionary.


Hmm, I use the idea differently most likely. When I practised aikido, just a baby practioner, the goals was to respond in the moment to what was presented. Strangely, the reactions of one's partner are integral to the practise of aikido. There is an interesting interplay of ploy, counter ploy and response.
So trained practise is good for the body to do as the mind instructs, but reactions are the core of falling.

Could be very different in your martial arts training, I would assume that you strive for the form beyond the form, and the like. But each uses words differently.
The state of nothingness can only be achieved through death.

I agree, but then I did not state that mirvana was the attainment of nothingness, given the fact that the buddha never denied the existance of reality, there is no nothingness.
 
Hmm, I use the idea differently most likely. When I practised aikido..

Maybe if you trained in something that had to do with fighting, you'd think different. My training doesn't consist of practicing choreographed motions and teaching choreography.

Could be very different in your martial arts training, I would assume that you strive for the form beyond the form, and the like. But each uses words differently.

No, I strive to be a better fighter, and thus, better at defending myself.
 
Ah, but this conflicts with what was said earlier and to which I was responding, and I quote:



Furthermore, the very notion of "previous lives" involves, necessarily, some form of reincarnation (literally "getting into some meat again"), and since pregnant women don't really stuff all that much meat into their vaginas, and most of it comes back out again, I have to conclude that babies are made of newly constructed meat (optimally, with some newly constructed bones, too).

Yet I see time and time again that rebirth is not reincarnation, though I have never seen those who say it come close to explaining it.

The conventional answer as to what is reborn is that it is the karmic effects of previous lives, playing out in an enormously complex way over time.

Thus if I have a particular craving for money then that burden will be passed on to a child born to a family connected or blighted by wealth (or the lack of it) in some way. In the same way my attachment to debate might pass on to a different person, born into circumstances that favour them becoming a skilled debator or a crashing bore. It is likely that the people my karma manifests in will be connected to my current life in some way and that, in time, the threads spawned from their actions and cravings will pass out again to others, weaving and interweaving across the whole human race.

I am not reborn because there really is no I but if I do not attain enlightment in this lifetime then my karma will pass on. When I achieve enlightment I will be able to see how the threads of the karma that have culminated in my current birth have passed down through the ages and I will be able to stop the onward flow of my karma and thus free humanity from its burden. I will be aware of my previous lives, but this is a side effect of my perfect understanding of karma, not an ability to see previous incarnations.

The more modern answer is that I am "reborn" each time something significant changes in my life. However, unless I am enlighted those rebirths are still moulded by the habits and cravings of my previous "lives". Once I achieve enlightment the notion of "birth" and "rebirth" becomes meaningless because I am no longer driven by the cravings and desires that shaped me before.
 
Nirvana

Nirvana has nothing to do with nothingness.

"Snuffing out" simply means that you have eliminated suffering by stopping the cause of suffering - the desires and habits that lead to it.
 
The conventional answer as to what is reborn is that it is the karmic effects of previous lives, playing out in an enormously complex way over time.

Thus if I have a particular craving for money then that burden will be passed on to a child born to a family connected or blighted by wealth (or the lack of it) in some way. In the same way my attachment to debate might pass on to a different person, born into circumstances that favour them becoming a skilled debator or a crashing bore. It is likely that the people my karma manifests in will be connected to my current life in some way and that, in time, the threads spawned from their actions and cravings will pass out again to others, weaving and interweaving across the whole human race.

OK, so getting back to the topic.

As a skeptic, I should consider this something more than smug, fantastic, moralistic, imaginary wish-fulfillment exactly how, except as a rather naive interpretation of psychology and social interaction?

Other than being the plot of practically every episode of The Twilight Zone, which was at least admittedly supernatural, what is it about this that isn't anti-science?

If it's natural, show me the boson. If it's supernatural, just admit it.
 
Extent of committal.

Ryokan #125 said:
Hotei is not Siddhartha Gautama, known as the Buddha. Gautama Buddha is always depicted as rather slim.

But that's okay, it's a very common mistake.
attachment.php

Fat and Laughing Buddha​

As a matter of fact I had always imagined previously that the fat laughing statuary of a Buddha which everyone in my place calls Buddha, refers to the historical Buddha or Gautama (I have to do some reading on the names of the historical Buddha or names attributed to him); thanks, now I know better, he is not actually the historical Buddha, founder of Buddhism, but a Chinese Buddhist monk who, what? attained buddhahood, i.e. becoming a Buddha.

I must congratulate you, Ryokan, you have apparently gone very deep into Buddhism, the religion, the philosophy, the folk culture, and that not as a hobbyist like some people would go into the Hollywood Matrix, spending time, effort, and money, and endless discussions on the celluloid Matrix world, as though it is the real world for them -- but of course they are just play-acting, exercising a script.

What about myself, what am I doing here? Play-acting also, enacting the script of a skeptical traveller in the land of Buddhism, keeping a very keen and probing eye to what I see, judging everything on the basis of my sense organs and sane reason, no illusions and no delusions.


Tell me, are you Ryokan, an uncompromisingly committed believer in Buddhism, your kind of course? as the Jim Jones people and the Heaven's Gate folks believed in their universe and took off into biological extinction.

Let's not bring to mind the Muslim bombers who expect to get straight to paradise. Buddhists don't bomb their way to Nirvana -- for they are non-violent people, but they can be indifferent as to be bombed to Nirvana or several rebirths on the way.

What about taking up a monk's life in a Buddhist community, what's that, a sangha? maybe in Thailand. At least to be logical in your committal to what, Theravada Buddhism? Because from reading in the web I understand that Theravadans are expected to assume sangha life in a community as their ideal, the fastest and surest way to attain Nirvana.


Yrreg
 

Attachments

  • fat and fat.jpg
    fat and fat.jpg
    10.9 KB · Views: 26
attachment.php

Fat and Laughing Buddha​

As a matter of fact I had always imagined previously that the fat laughing statuary of a Buddha which everyone in my place calls Buddha, refers to the historical Buddha or Gautama (I have to do some reading on the names of the historical Buddha or names attributed to him); thanks, now I know better, he is not actually the historical Buddha, founder of Buddhism, but a Chinese Buddhist monk who, what? attained buddhahood, i.e. becoming a Buddha.

He's a god, the god of contentment and happiness.

However, he's supposed to be based on a real person, a Zen priest who begged a lot. As you can tell by the belly, he was apparently pretty good at begging.
 
Violence, the lure of power.

Let's not bring to mind the Muslim bombers who expect to get straight to paradise. Buddhists don't bomb their way to Nirvana -- for they are non-violent people, but they can be indifferent as to be bombed to Nirvana or several rebirths on the way.

"...for they are non-violent people..."

No, Buddhism is not so massively and chronically associated with violence and atrocity, but given a chance and smug with power, Buddhists can also fall prey and relish inflicting agony and death on fellow humans, all in the name of their noble religious philosophy.

Here are excerpts from an article I found in the web of a Westerner who took up Buddhism, Zen, as the religion of peace unlike faiths originating from the Middle East. Please read the whole article.

ZEN'S HOLY WAR​
​
Christopher Stephens speaks with [Zen] priest and historian Brian Victoria

snip snip snip

Buddhism, wrote D.T. Suzuki, is unique among world religions in never having been part of a holy war. This was the idea that changed Brian Victoria's mind about Christianity and helped turn him into a Zen priest. It is also the idea that he has spent 30 years working to disprove.

In his controversial 1997 book, Zen at War (Weatherhill), and in greater detail in the newly published Zen War Stories (RoutledgeCurzon), Victoria has shown that a close relationship existed between Zen Buddhism and Japanese militarism as far back as the Russo-Japan War and, more significantly, during the Second World War.

The tone of Victoria's work is set by Harada Daiun, the head abbot for 40 years at Hosshin-ji, who in 1939 stated, "[If ordered to] march: tramp, tramp, or shoot: bang, bang. This is the manifestation of the highest Wisdom [of Enlightenment]. The unity of Zen and war of which I speak extends to the farthest reaches of the holy war [now under way]."

As both books make clear, Harada's views were not unique among Japanese Buddhist leaders. The Soto Zen priest Sawaki Kodo, for one, admitted that while fighting in Russia, he and his fellow soldiers had "gorged themselves on killing." Yet years later, in 1942, no contrition was apparent in Harada's belief that "it is just to punish those who disturb the social order."

snip snip snip

Victoria, currently a senior lecturer at the University of Adelaide, explains (snip snip snip) "... once you believe that discriminating thought is no longer important - in fact, that not only is it not important, but that it has to be discarded - then all ethical concerns disappear. I see that disappearance as a very self-serving development in Zen history in Japan that enabled Buddhists to work ( . . . ) to ensure that their privileged position in Japanese society would be maintained forever. In this way, Zen became the handmaiden of the warrior class...

snip snip snip

In 1961, Victoria arrived in Japan by way of Nebraska as a Methodist missionary... found that Buddhism made more sense to him... ordained as a Soto Zen priest in 1964. It was around this time that the American conflict in Vietnam began to escalate, leading Victoria to take an active role in anti-war protests in Tokyo - often in his clerical robes. Despite threats from his superiors at the temple, Victoria somehow managed to avoid being defrocked. He wasn't as lucky with the Japanese government. In 1975, Victoria was deported for anti-government activities. This was the first of six incidents in five Asian countries in which Victoria was forced to leave for his involvement in political causes.

However, Brian Victoria is still not disillusioned with Buddhism, he has adopted the NARB (not a real Buddhist) defense.

snip snip snip

"I will go so far as to say that institutional Zen Buddhism in Japan is not Buddhism. And therefore, what has passed as Zen has for a very long time been a distortion of Buddhist teachings."

snip snip snip

According to Christopher Stevens, the author of the article:

An encouraging hint of such a change came in 2001 following the publication of the Japanese edition of Zen at War. Myoshin-ji became the first Rinzai Zen temple to issue an official apology for its actions during World War II: "As we reflect on the recent events of [September 11] in the USA, ( . . . ) we recognize ... our sect, in the midst of wartime passions, was unable to maintain a resolute anti-war stance and ended up cooperating with the war effort. In light of this, we wish to confess our past transgressions and critically reflect on our conduct." ( . . . ) In a later statement in October of the same year, Myoshin-ji acknowledged that it was Victoria's book which had enabled them to begin to come to terms with the past.

I would earnestly recommend to Brian Victoria to instead take up with the Greenpeace activists for a lifetime advocacy, or with the folks at Amnesty International. One need not have to adopt any esoteric metaphysics to experience the impulse to adopt a noble existence.

So, what else is new?


Yrreg
 
"...for they are non-violent people..."

No, Buddhism is not so massively and chronically associated with violence and atrocity, but given a chance and smug with power, Buddhists can also fall prey and relish inflicting agony and death on fellow humans, all in the name of their noble religious philosophy.

First, allow me to introduce myself as I am not a frequent poster on this board (previously posted mainly on political forum). I am atheist (formerly fundy xian) and a skeptic (or I endeavor to be).

I am not buddhist, but I have been passingly interested in the topic while not really understanding it. It has been this thread, and Ryokan's posts that have resulted in my looking more closely at buddhism. So, I am not buddhist and really don't know what to say on the topic good or bad yet, but I wanted to join in the discussion if that is OK.

Now, on the topic of Buddhists becoming violent or power hungry if given the chance I would say this is true of all humans.

I, personally, think the Dali Lama is a complete waste of flesh. I think he is an abuser of humans and the only reason he is a benign figure now is that he has no political power. So, I do agree that claiming to be Buddhist is no guarantee against being a complete ass.

However, I also believe it is always a mistake to judge any religious, philosophical or psychological belief system by it's adherents or those who claim to be students of it. Rather any belief system should be judged on it's own merits.

It is very easy to point to an adherent of any viewpoint and find them to be jerks. If we are lazy minded we may then dismiss the belief out of hand. Is this likely to lead us to truth or a right understanding?

However, Brian Victoria is still not disillusioned with Buddhism, he has adopted the NARB (not a real Buddhist) defense.

Which is a very valid defense, in my view. Today I can go out and molest children, murder the elderly and commit other atrocities. When I am arrested and the news cameras are on me I can scream out "I did this for Jesus", or "I did this for Allah" or "I did this for Buddha". Am I a proper representative of any of these belief systems? Are my actions consistent with the teachings of any of them?

I would earnestly recommend to Brian Victoria to instead take up with the Greenpeace activists for a lifetime advocacy, or with the folks at Amnesty International. One need not have to adopt any esoteric metaphysics to experience the impulse to adopt a noble existence.

So, what else is new?

Yrreg

Well, as the bible says "There is nothing new under the sun." In my initial examination of buddhism I find absolutely nothing new, I just find things organized in a particular way that is unique to buddhism.

As I understand it buddhism is about happiness. Happiness would be the lack (or reduction) of suffering (stress, disappointment, disillusionment). As such if ones goal is to experience happiness and little to no suffering then buddhism is a potential "way" to achieve that. If one finds another way, then pursue that.

Now, as it relates to a skeptic forum like this one I can say that as of yet I have found nothing in my cursory examination of buddhism that requires me to accept anything on faith. As I read various sources I do see a religious buddhism that speaks of various "mini gods" and I do see some faith based stuff, but it is within a particular tradition of buddhism that appears to have been modified to fit in with the prevailing religious notions of the place/time it was accepted. As such this is not buddhism, but an adaption of it. A Christian can adapt buddhism to Christianity, so can a Jew, Muslim, or atheist.

The "flavor" imparted to buddhism by an adherent is not buddhism.
 
Does JREF harbor a sympathetic ear for Buddhism?

Originally Posted by Yrreg:
But there might be readers who think that you are a resident Buddhist designated as such by the owners/managers of JREF Forum. It seems like the title of moderator [or] of administrator after the names of users who do perform the task of moderator and administrator in a message board.​

My title used to be "Resident Greek." No one appeared to think that I was the Official JREF Greek Person.

Posted by Paul C. Anagnostopoulos:
Ryokan's title "Resident Buddhist" is perfectly fine.​

The way I see it, Resident Buddhist for a title seems to indicate that the JREF Forum is maintaining an office for Buddhist affairs; it's almost like, please forgive me, the person sporting that title is some kind of a Buddhist chaplain in this society of the JREF Forum, and that chaplaincy is maintained by the JREF Forum, or allowed as not contrary to the policy and spirit of the JREF as an institution advocating scientific skepticism.

So, am I against an office for Buddhist affairs in the JREF Forum?

Yes, certainly; and why?

Because the JREF website, the mother society or group or establishment is, the way I understand it, or the man himself, James Randi, is at least indifferent to any mystical metaphysics group, which I think Buddhism is one, if not distrusting of or even antipathetic to, i.e., not sympathetic to, any mystical metaphysics.

Or am I wrong? then James Randi is sympathetic to religion, and even an admirer of Buddhism, though not one calling himself a Buddhist?

What I know from reading the man's commentaries is that he is what I might say someone who will dismiss anything that is beyond what can be explained from our knowledge of nature as such nature is so far vouched for by our present state of scientific data -- dismiss in the sense that the only comment he will issue is that we don't know at present.

I think maybe I should bring this matter to a higher level, and even to continue with my quest, contact James Randi himself, asking him whether he will be convinced about the verity of Buddhist beliefs and practices on the basis of explanations by words alone without scientific demonstration.

And most importantly, what does he think about someone sporting the title of Resident Buddhist in the message board of his educational foundation, namely, is it not misleading to the effect that JREF has an at least sympathetic ear for Buddhism?


Yrreg
 
However, I also believe it is always a mistake to judge any religious, philosophical or psychological belief system by it's adherents or those who claim to be students of it. Rather any belief system should be judged on it's own merits.

I disagree.

If one of the claims of a religion is that adhering to it does something to those who adhere to it, then it is appropriate to see if it actually does. The only way I can think of to do this is to look at adherents.

It isn't a perfect test, of course. It may be that only people who are predisposed to behave a certain way are attracted to a particular belief system. So it isn't so good for verification. It's a bit better for falsification, because it's less likely that one would choose a belief system at odds with one's predisposition.
 
The way I see it, Resident Buddhist for a title seems to indicate that the JREF Forum is maintaining an office for Buddhist affairs;

I do not share that opinion.

Because the JREF website, the mother society or group or establishment is, the way I understand it, or the man himself, James Randi, is at least indifferent to any mystical metaphysics group, which I think Buddhism is one,

With the exception of religious buddhism which kind of deals with mini deities there is nothing metaphysical about buddhism. Throughout this thread you have been provided links to various sources of information on buddhism. I am unaware of any way you could have read them and concluded that buddhism is metaphysical in nature.

Or am I wrong?

I believe your understanding, at present, to be incorrect based upon my own understanding.

What I know from reading the man's commentaries is that he is what I might say someone who will dismiss anything that is beyond what can be explained from our knowledge of nature as such nature is so far vouched for by our present state of scientific data -- dismiss in the sense that the only comment he will issue is that we don't know at present.

I am unaware of anything in buddhism which requires anyone to accept anything on faith. As I understand it buddhism contains a set of teachings and these teachings are to be evaluated. The 'truths' are to be treated with skepticism, not accepted as truth because some authority said so. I have no idea what Randi thinks of Buddhism, but I don't see anything in buddhism for any skeptic to call 'woo-woo' since it doesn't require anyone to believe anything without proof.

I think maybe I should bring this matter to a higher level, and even to continue with my quest, contact James Randi himself, asking him whether he will be convinced about the verity of Buddhist beliefs and practices on the basis of explanations by words alone without scientific demonstration.

You can do so if you wish, but would difference would it make what his response to such a question was?

And most importantly, what does he think about someone sporting the title of Resident Buddhist in the message board of his educational foundation, namely, is it not misleading to the effect that JREF has an at least sympathetic ear for Buddhism?

I can't speak for Mr. Randi, but if you notice every user has a title. Some people choose a custom title, others leave the default title (based upon number of posts). Some of the JREF assigned titles are philosopher, muse, student, and scholar.

Is everyone who is system labeled a scholar really a scholar? Does it matter?

I would be surprised if user titles are taken with much seriousness by the owner or staff.

It appears to me you wish to object to buddhism, but have little understanding of it and seem to resist educating yourself to what it is that you object to.

Why do you wish to object to something you do not understand?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom