ZEN'S HOLY WAR
Christopher Stephens speaks with [Zen] priest and historian Brian Victoria
snip snip snip
Buddhism, wrote D.T. Suzuki, is unique among world religions in never having been part of a holy war. This was the idea that changed Brian Victoria's mind about Christianity and helped turn him into a Zen priest. It is also the idea that he has spent 30 years working to disprove.
In his controversial 1997 book, Zen at War (Weatherhill), and in greater detail in the newly published Zen War Stories (RoutledgeCurzon), Victoria has shown that a close relationship existed between Zen Buddhism and Japanese militarism as far back as the Russo-Japan War and, more significantly, during the Second World War.
The tone of Victoria's work is set by Harada Daiun, the head abbot for 40 years at Hosshin-ji, who in 1939 stated, "[If ordered to] march: tramp, tramp, or shoot: bang, bang. This is the manifestation of the highest Wisdom [of Enlightenment]. The unity of Zen and war of which I speak extends to the farthest reaches of the holy war [now under way]."
As both books make clear, Harada's views were not unique among Japanese Buddhist leaders. The Soto Zen priest Sawaki Kodo, for one, admitted that while fighting in Russia, he and his fellow soldiers had "gorged themselves on killing." Yet years later, in 1942, no contrition was apparent in Harada's belief that "it is just to punish those who disturb the social order."
snip snip snip
Victoria, currently a senior lecturer at the University of Adelaide, explains (snip snip snip) "... once you believe that discriminating thought is no longer important - in fact, that not only is it not important, but that it has to be discarded - then all ethical concerns disappear. I see that disappearance as a very self-serving development in Zen history in Japan that enabled Buddhists to work ( . . . ) to ensure that their privileged position in Japanese society would be maintained forever. In this way, Zen became the handmaiden of the warrior class...
snip snip snip
In 1961, Victoria arrived in Japan by way of Nebraska as a Methodist missionary... found that Buddhism made more sense to him... ordained as a Soto Zen priest in 1964. It was around this time that the American conflict in Vietnam began to escalate, leading Victoria to take an active role in anti-war protests in Tokyo - often in his clerical robes. Despite threats from his superiors at the temple, Victoria somehow managed to avoid being defrocked. He wasn't as lucky with the Japanese government. In 1975, Victoria was deported for anti-government activities. This was the first of six incidents in five Asian countries in which Victoria was forced to leave for his involvement in political causes.