Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

But, umm, the man wasn't a Buddhist. No matter how much you praise Buddhism, that doesn't make you a Buddhist.

So what makes someone a Buddhist? It's a perfectly reasonable question. You've said that if someone self-identifies as a Buddhist then he and/or she is probably a Buddhist. You haven't said before now that if someone does not self-identify as a Buddhist then he and/or she is not a Buddhist, though I think it's reasonable to infer this from your statement here.

So, how exactly does it work? I know someone on another forum who self-identifies as a Buddhist and claims to have experienced Nirvana. Is he a Buddhist or not? And would you be able to say anything about the claims that he makes?

Note that I am only going on your functional definition of a Buddhist. So, if they're accurate and to-the-point, you should be able to answer the questions in the previous post. (For the sake of argument, let's assume that I'm not lying or misrepresenting.)

And if you can't, would you like to elaborate?
 
So what makes someone a Buddhist? It's a perfectly reasonable question. You've said that if someone self-identifies as a Buddhist then he and/or she is probably a Buddhist. You haven't said before now that if someone does not self-identify as a Buddhist then he and/or she is not a Buddhist, though I think it's reasonable to infer this from your statement here.

If someone does not identify himself as a Buddhist, it's reasonable to believe he's not a Buddhist. Wouldn't you also agree that it's reasonable that I don't have to answer for what non-Buddhists claim Buddhism is about, no matter how much he praises it?

As we saw earlier, even Carl Sagan had nice things to say about Buddhism. Albert Einstein did the same. This does not make these two men a Buddhism, and no Buddhist has to defend statements made by these two men.

Isn't this reasonable?

So, how exactly does it work? I know someone on another forum who self-identifies as a Buddhist and claims to have experienced Nirvana. Is he a Buddhist or not? And would you be able to say anything about the claims that he makes?

Hard for me to say something about this specific case, but if he identifies himself as a Buddhist, it's reasonable to assume he is.

Does he claim to have experienced nirvana? Or to have attained it? Those are two different things. Everyone has had their moments of zen.

Note that I am only going on your functional definition of a Buddhist. So, if they're accurate and to-the-point, you should be able to answer the questions in the previous post. (For the sake of argument, let's assume that I'm not lying or misrepresenting.)

And if you can't, would you like to elaborate?

If you're not happy with the answers, specify what parts and I'll try to be clearer.
 
Two Einstein's texts, and on Nirvana encounter.

Here are two texts supposedly from Einstein on some kind of endorsement of Buddhism, but I never found who brought them up originally, and from what collections of Einstein's published or still unpublished records.

1. "If there is any religion that would cope with modern scientific needs it would be Buddhism." Albert Einstein

2. "Buddhism has the characteristics of what would be expected in a cosmic religion for the future: it transcends a personal God, avoids dogmas and theology; it covers both the natural & spiritual, and it is based on a religious sense aspiring from the experience of all things, natural and spiritual, as a meaningful unity." Albert Einstein

​
They have been repeatedly cited by Buddhists online, but as I said without any links to authoritative sources.

---------------

About the experience or the attainment or the arrival in regard to Nirvana, what is it? an experience in the last neurological analysis I would imagine; but good Ryokan, maybe you can be more enlightening.

I mean it's all in the mind if a person should experience it while still in time and in space; now, if he is not longer in time and in space as when he is beyond the grave, how is anyone much less himself now gone from time/space, from his body, to say about his experience of or attainment of or arrival at Nirvana?

Yrreg
 
epepke - Please read more carefully.

yyreg - Get off of your high horse and think for a bit.

I hate to see quality tools used by people who can't or won't use them well.

I have no interest in looking into any religion for any purpose.

There are aspects of the philosophy behind Buddhism that I find interesting.

A person is a Buddhist if he or she says she is a Buddhist.

yrreg has repeatedly said that he does not want to read Buddhist texts but would rather talk with Buddhists. He has engaged in discussions with at least one Buddhist on this forum. He does not appear to listen or to learn during this discussions.

I would enjoy eavesdropping on, and possibly participating in, a discussion that is a real skeptical probing and analysis of what I have called philosophical Buddhism. Unfortunately, yrreg has yet to demonstrate that he is able or willing to enter into that discussion.
 
Why reach Nirvana, "a state of nothingness", during life when it is evident that this state happens in death without even trying?
 
Dear Epepke, thanks; you are the only skeptic here critical of Buddhism; at least I have not seen others here with your kind of critical approach, but I still have to read all the posts here very carefully and see whether another one or two entertain the same kind of rigorous skepticism you show here in re Buddhism.

What do you say? I think there is a radical fault in the attitude of our Buddhist brethren here, namely, they do not seem to be acquainted with the distinction between fiction and fact.

Well, what have you addressed to be sceptical of?

I am sceptical that the buddha lived on a grain of rise a day for six months, I am sceptical that the buddha's mother was inseminated in a dream by a white elephant, I am sceptical that the buddha caused a mango tree to grow in a single day, I am sceptical that the buddha ate the finger of a leper that fell into his begging bowl. I am sceptical that the buddha was a perfect egalitarian, his mother and his wife had to fight with him to convince him to let women into the sngha.

Give me a specific practise and belief and I will tell you what I am sceptical of.

I find merit is the teachings of the buddha that are handed down, in the Mahayana tradition there thousands of stories about the many lives of the buddha.

Do I believe that the buddha was a monkey, donkey, tiger, tec. NO.

You are making such broad and terrubly vausge accusations that it is hard to agree to be sceptical or not.

Do I believe that monks in meditative trances float up in the iar?
No.

Do I believe that monks might preform stage magic to tell the wise from the unside, you bet I do!
I am trying to distill the facts from the fictions in Buddhism but they are to all appearances getting them all mixed up.
Perhaps you should bring up the beliefs you don't like and we can discuss them.

Do I believe that reincarnation happens , no.

Do I believe that kamma as the perpetuation of negative thoughts and actions carries on to the future. You bet!

Do I believe in raja yoga , as a way of tapping into astral images, no.

Do I believe that mindfullness meditation is a good practise, yes.

Do I believe that spirits and , diva, and asura exist. No.

Are they useful intuitive concepts, maybe.
Addressing skeptics here who are not Buddhists, please join in and also give me some critical assessment of Buddhism. There is no better way to get to know a religion than to do a skeptical criticism of it and read the explanations, defenses, emotional reactions from the religion's adherents.

Give me a belief, if it is irrational I will critique it!
Ryokan here is a softspoken and mild Buddhist, but he has shall we call them, fans who tend to see any critical regards as insults to their in effect, master.

Uh dude, you are so lacking in following your own precepts.

The buddha is not my master. he may not have ven existed, although there is more veidence for the buddha than for Ceaser.

have you cited your proof that the eightfold path pre-existed the buddha.

You aren't critical of buddhism except in very vauge terms.

Do I believe that a mytic seer saw the thousand spoked wheel in the footprint of the buddha, maybe, but then they were probably high or whacked out.

Do I believe that the buddha sat unedr a particular tree and came to his realization that the self does not exist while sitting under the bodhi tree. Maybe, it might not have been at that spot, it might not have been that type of tree. We can't know, is it very likely that others did the same things , you bet.

Do I believe that he was gazing upon Venus when he had his 'enlightenment, maybe.

Do Ibelieve that Jesus went to India and studies buddhism, no.

Do I believe that taoism and buddhism are related, yes.
But Taoism allows for the eating of meat and has other magical practise associated with it.

Do i believe that the Pale canon comes close to the teachings of the buddha, yes.

Do I believe that it is a word for word transfixiation of the teachings , no.

Do I believe that arhats have seminal emmissions at night, yes.

Do I feel that after the buddha was gone and during his life , the sangha did some whacked out stuff, yes.

There is another koan:

A student feels that there master is too harsh and critical of them they journey and find another master and ask if they may study with them.

The new master asks if they have had instruction before, the student states that they had but they left to find another master.

The master asks why they left.

The student replies: he hit me when I asked a question.

The master askes: What was the question?

The student answers :What is the buddha nature?

The master strikes the student and states : Return to your master and thank them fr thier grandmotherly kindness!
 
Why reach Nirvana, "a state of nothingness", during life when it is evident that this state happens in death without even trying?

Thich Naht Hanh teaches that nibbanna is much like the state that martial artists train for,

mindful, unreactionary, unfettered.

It can be called a state of nothingness, but it is also a state of detachment and freedom to live life as it is , without the fetters of the five skandhas and false beliefs.
 
Last edited:
So what makes someone a Buddhist? It's a perfectly reasonable question. You've said that if someone self-identifies as a Buddhist then he and/or she is probably a Buddhist. You haven't said before now that if someone does not self-identify as a Buddhist then he and/or she is not a Buddhist, though I think it's reasonable to infer this from your statement here.

So, how exactly does it work? I know someone on another forum who self-identifies as a Buddhist and claims to have experienced Nirvana. Is he a Buddhist or not? And would you be able to say anything about the claims that he makes?

Being a buddhist is like being a witch, if you practise buddhism then you are a buddhist.

I would be sceptical of anyone claiming the state of nibbanna.

Tich Naht Hanh and the Dali Lamma and many teachers have written on the subject.

It is a state of mindfullness that is 'unconditioned'.
 
About the experience or the attainment or the arrival in regard to Nirvana, what is it? an experience in the last neurological analysis I would imagine; but good Ryokan, maybe you can be more enlightening.

I mean it's all in the mind if a person should experience it while still in time and in space; now, if he is not longer in time and in space as when he is beyond the grave, how is anyone much less himself now gone from time/space, from his body, to say about his experience of or attainment of or arrival at Nirvana?

Yrreg
I recomend The Heart of the Teachings of the Buddha by Thich Naht Hanh

The state of nibbanna is one that is not beyond time and space according to this teacher.

It is a state of mindfullness that is unfettered and unconditioned. the indivdual is in life and living life as it is. No thoughts or habits that lead to further suffering.

That is a modern interpretaion by a very wise teacher, is it what the buddha taught, I don't know.

More from here:

http://www.plumvillage.org/teaching...28 The Island Of Self_Three Dharma Seals.htm
Nirvana means extinction. Extinction of what? Extinction of notions such as being and non-being, birth and death, one and many. We have created all these notions that become the ground of all our suffering and our fear. Because we have not been able to touch the true nature of our being, we are caught by these pairs of opposites. To die, what does it mean? In our minds it means that you are someone, and then suddenly you become no one. You are something, suddenly you become nothing—that is our idea of death. But if we observe things deeply, we see nothing like that in reality. There is nothing that can be reduced to nothing, or to nothingness. Can you reduce a cloud into nothingness? No, you can only help the cloud to become rain. You can help the rain to become snow. But you cannot make a cloud into nothingness. A sheet of paper—can you reduce it into nothingness? No. You may burn it, and it is transformed in many ways. Part of it will become a cloud, the smoke rising. Part of it will become the heat, penetrating into the cosmos. Part of it will become ash, that can be reborn as a flower or a blade of grass, sometime later. So everything is on their way, on their journey of manifestation of being. You are also like that. If you don’t manifest yourself in this form, then you manifest yourself in another form. Please don’t be afraid of being nothing. Nothingness is just an idea. Non-being is just an idea. The Buddha said not only is non-being an idea, but being is also an idea. Reality transcends both being and non-being.
 
Last edited:
If someone does not identify himself as a Buddhist, it's reasonable to believe he's not a Buddhist. Wouldn't you also agree that it's reasonable that I don't have to answer for what non-Buddhists claim Buddhism is about, no matter how much he praises it?

I'm not passing judgement about what is reasonable or not. I'm simply trying to get a handle on the ground rules. Even that is difficult enough for me. We can examine whether it's reasonable or not later.

Please think about this before replying: If I combined what I understood about Buddhism with what I though was reasonable, then there's no guarantee that it would be an accurate representation of Buddhism, is there? It would be an amalgam, which would be of the same kind as those people that have nice things to say about Buddhism make. So I can't do that without getting a skewed view. What I can do is ask questions and present challenges and listen to the answers.

Does he claim to have experienced nirvana? Or to have attained it? Those are two different things. Everyone has had their moments of zen.

Good question. He claims to have experienced Nirvana (past tense). As a result, he claims to know with certainty the true nature of being, reality, and existence (present tense).

He also has a serious distrust of Zen, thinking it to be an unstable contamination of Buddhism with Taoism and other things.

I'll give you another example of a Buddhist to chew on. My friend Eugene was a Nichiren Buddhist. He used to come to Stammtisch, which was an informal meeting of German students on Friday. He used to go to Nichiren Buddhist meetings every couple of weeks in Albany, Georgia.

He and my roommate Chris got into some discussions, and Chris asked Eugene for a test. The details were worked out over some engaging discussion, but it worked out like this. Eugene said that if Chris chanted "Nam myoho renge kyo" for ten minutes in the morning and fifteen minutes at night for one week, that he would get anything he wanted.

Now, remember, Chris was my roommate, so I can attest to the fact that he did the chanting.

Next week, another Stammtisch, and the following exchange:

Eugene: Did you do the chanting?
Chris: Yes.
Eugene: Did you get what you wanted?
Chris: No.
Eugene: Then you must have done something wrong, because I know for a fact that it works.

I found this just classic and laughed quite a lot.
 
epepke - Please read more carefully.

I'm reading as carefully as I can, and I read this as a put-down. What purpose does it serve?

A person is a Buddhist if he or she says she is a Buddhist.

Does this describe a sufficient or a necessary condition?

In the normal usage of "if" (which is different from "iff," which is shorthand for "if and only if"), it would describe a sufficent but not necessary condition.

I know you think I'm not reading carefully enough, but I didn't invent the English language with its ambiguities. I just use it.
 
I'm not passing judgement about what is reasonable or not. I'm simply trying to get a handle on the ground rules. Even that is difficult enough for me. We can examine whether it's reasonable or not later.

Please think about this before replying: If I combined what I understood about Buddhism with what I though was reasonable, then there's no guarantee that it would be an accurate representation of Buddhism, is there? It would be an amalgam, which would be of the same kind as those people that have nice things to say about Buddhism make. So I can't do that without getting a skewed view. What I can do is ask questions and present challenges and listen to the answers.

Sounds reasonable ;)

There are dozens and dozens of Buddhism amalgams out there, though, all with different views and beliefs. That's why the self-labeling is often the only way to seperate a Buddhist from a non-Buddhist.



Good question. He claims to have experienced Nirvana (past tense). As a result, he claims to know with certainty the true nature of being, reality, and existence (present tense).

He also has a serious distrust of Zen, thinking it to be an unstable contamination of Buddhism with Taoism and other things.

Sounds bogus, to be honest.

Zen is a mix of (Mahayana) Buddhism, Taoism and other things, really. It was founded by Bodhidharma, an Indian Buddhist, at the Shaolin temple in China. He is also credited as the father of Kung Fu.

I'll give you another example of a Buddhist to chew on. My friend Eugene was a Nichiren Buddhist. He used to come to Stammtisch, which was an informal meeting of German students on Friday. He used to go to Nichiren Buddhist meetings every couple of weeks in Albany, Georgia.

He and my roommate Chris got into some discussions, and Chris asked Eugene for a test. The details were worked out over some engaging discussion, but it worked out like this. Eugene said that if Chris chanted "Nam myoho renge kyo" for ten minutes in the morning and fifteen minutes at night for one week, that he would get anything he wanted.

Now, remember, Chris was my roommate, so I can attest to the fact that he did the chanting.

Next week, another Stammtisch, and the following exchange:

Eugene: Did you do the chanting?
Chris: Yes.
Eugene: Did you get what you wanted?
Chris: No.
Eugene: Then you must have done something wrong, because I know for a fact that it works.

I found this just classic and laughed quite a lot.

Hehe. That sounds like the words of a True Believer, and that's not a Good Thing.

Nichiren Buddhism seems very weird to me. It's one of those 'easy' Buddhisms, created to be popular among the masses, like Pure Land. Just chant some bits, and presto! Enlightenment!

Needless to say, this is not the teachings of Gautama Buddha.

ETA : But your point, I guess, was maybe asking me if Eugene is a Buddhist? Yes, he is.
 
Last edited:
I like to meet with skeptics here who can tell me how Buddhist doctrines like rebirths and Nirvana cannot stand up to skeptical criticism.

And also the usefulness of meditation, specially that of the Zen school.

yrreg

Religous ideas do not have to be taken literally, although they usually are by both practioners and critics. For example, "nirvana" is literally a Sanscrit word meaning "to extinguish", which could quite usefully be stated in the sense of "It is 'nirvana' when you finally cross off (and thus extinguish) a 'Honey-Do' list -- or deliver all requisite projects in time to get a yearly performance bonus."

Same goes for "re-birth". Anytime you break free of old habits of feelings, thoughts and actions, for example becoming an atheist, or finding God, or getting divorced or having sex for the first time (hopefully not after getting divorced, but probably a good reason to get a divorce), you are in a sense re-born.
 
So what makes someone a Buddhist? It's a perfectly reasonable question. You've said that if someone self-identifies as a Buddhist then he and/or she is probably a Buddhist. You haven't said before now that if someone does not self-identify as a Buddhist then he and/or she is not a Buddhist, though I think it's reasonable to infer this from your statement here.

So, how exactly does it work? I know someone on another forum who self-identifies as a Buddhist and claims to have experienced Nirvana. Is he a Buddhist or not? And would you be able to say anything about the claims that he makes?

Note that I am only going on your functional definition of a Buddhist. So, if they're accurate and to-the-point, you should be able to answer the questions in the previous post. (For the sake of argument, let's assume that I'm not lying or misrepresenting.)

And if you can't, would you like to elaborate?

Technically to become a Buddhist, as opposed to someone who is attracted to the philosophy, you have to take refuge in the Triple Gem.

That is you have to explicitly state that you are "Going" to the Buddha, the Dharma and the Sangha in order to try to reach nirvana.

In other words you accept that (i) the Buddha existed and achieved enlightment, (ii) his teachings are correct and (iii) that a community of teachers exists to help you.

Most schools have a ceremony of sorts but you don't have to go through it, you can simply state that you are going for refuge and the job is done.

It's as formal or informal as you wish to make it.
 
Same goes for "re-birth". Anytime you break free of old habits of feelings, thoughts and actions, for example becoming an atheist, or finding God, or getting divorced or having sex for the first time (hopefully not after getting divorced, but probably a good reason to get a divorce), you are in a sense re-born.

In what way (if any) is this distinguishable from the Christian concept of being born again?
 
Technically to become a Buddhist, as opposed to someone who is attracted to the philosophy, you have to take refuge in the Triple Gem.

That is you have to explicitly state that you are "Going" to the Buddha, the Dharma and the Sangha in order to try to reach nirvana.

In other words you accept that (i) the Buddha existed and achieved enlightment, (ii) his teachings are correct and (iii) that a community of teachers exists to help you.

Most schools have a ceremony of sorts but you don't have to go through it, you can simply state that you are going for refuge and the job is done.

It's as formal or informal as you wish to make it.

The Three Gems of Buddhism.

I seek refuge in the Buddha
I seek refuge in the Dharma
I seek refuge in the Sangha


Many denominations do indeed have these 'gems'. My denomination, Theravada, for example. However, not all denominations do (I don't think Mahayana does, but I may be wrong), and they mostly apply to monks, not laymen.
 
Sounds bogus, to be honest.

Well, speaking only personally, mind you, to me it sounds like bald arrogance. I don't have any personal objection to arrogance as long as it can be backed up.

I went back and forth with him for a while, and he couldn't really describe it, except that it had something to do with Mind, as well as something to do with experiences of reality, being, and that other word. Well, I've had experiences of reality, being, and that other word, too, so I asked how I could distinguish them from Nirvana (if I could)? This seemed to result in his getting, to my way of thinking, rather histrionic and using straw men. This doesn't seem to me like how I use the words "unattached" and "wise," let along "loving kindness," another term he used a lot to describe himself. However, there's always the possibility that I use words in a different way from the way Buddhists use the same words.

This relates to the second of the classes of skepticism I mentioned. Namely, does an adherence to Buddhism actually result in the effects on the person that are claimed by Buddhists?

Also, another guy said that maybe some of the people who I thought were Buddhists weren't Real Buddhists, which I interpreted as an indirect way of talking about that person (that board has a rule against making statements about other posters), which is why I'm asking the NARB question here.

Zen is a mix of (Mahayana) Buddhism, Taoism and other things, really. It was founded by Bodhidharma, an Indian Buddhist, at the Shaolin temple in China. He is also credited as the father of Kung Fu.

That's always confused me, because there was a guy named Kung Fu Tsu (or some approximation) almost a millennium earlier, who wrote a lot of good stuff. Was the one named after the other, or what?

Nichiren Buddhism seems very weird to me. It's one of those 'easy' Buddhisms, created to be popular among the masses, like Pure Land. Just chant some bits, and presto! Enlightenment!

Needless to say, this is not the teachings of Gautama Buddha.

ETA : But your point, I guess, was maybe asking me if Eugene is a Buddhist? Yes, he is.

Nice to have some sort of informal ruling, anywyay.

And it isn't really needless to say. It isn't obvious to me what the teachings of Gautama Buddha are (even though I've read Die Lehre Buddhas in German. It's a freebie book in a lot of hotels in California. I'm not sure why). I can read the Bible, too, with a level of understanding that seems good to me, yet I am told by Christians that my understanding is wrong.

Nor am I really convinced that the teachings of Gautama Buddha are the be-all and end-all in Buddhism. Isn't there something about not trusting teachers, but rather finding out for yourself?
 
The Three Gems of Buddhism.

I seek refuge in the Buddha
I seek refuge in the Dharma
I seek refuge in the Sangha


Many denominations do indeed have these 'gems'. My denomination, Theravada, for example. However, not all denominations do (I don't think Mahayana does, but I may be wrong), and they mostly apply to monks, not laymen.

Going for Refuge is universal, although in the Mahayana tradition it often incorporates the bodhisattva vow as well.

I have to say I always thought of it as a lay ceremony, mainly because it's usually followed by taking the Five Vows, and I've never seen it mentioned in descriptions of ordination ceremonies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom