Observation 1.
Buddhists seem to make much of nothingness, and one here gives the example of nothingness being great for doors and windows. That is what I see time and again with some Buddhists, making play on words.
The nothingness quote is attributted to Lao Tzu in the Dao De Ching. The play on words is just irrascable human nature. It is the nothingness of the door that makes a house useful. And there is in the buddhist tradition, the symbol of the empty house to represent the five skanhas as the dwelling of non-self.
The only message in such plays on words is to my evaluation, that the human mind cannot see into the intricacies of reality. So? so better just to accept the teachings of Buddhist masters: about self or no-self, rebirth, Nirvana, and depend on meditation to see light at the end of the tunnel?
Again, the buddha did not teach this, although there are schools which teach faith as the path to enlightenment.
Tye buddha taught that the student should criticaly examine the teaching of the buddha, but there are those who stray from the path that the buddha taught and use faith as a tool/crutch.
There is another buddhist image of the old man who is blind with a stick.
On the contrary in fact there are innumerable minds who do see into the intricacies of reality, starting with those plays on words from Buddhist masters of quibble.
I have heard that the koans of Chan and zen are meant to teach the student that words and concepts are fetters that need to be evaluated as a carpenter does thier tools.
Observation 2.
Do all Buddhists believe in recurring rebirths? or only religious Buddhists, but not philosophic Buddhists? Anyway, unlike in Hinduism its mother religion and philosophy (or step-mother or mother-in-law), where there is some soul that is being 'rebirthed' again and again, Buddhism is novel in this regard that it rejects the existence of the soul or self.
The issue of reincarnation is really tough one for buddhists, in the Mahayan traditions there are teachings that the soulkd is re-ncarnated multiple times often just like the progenitor of hindus. So there are buddhist schools which hold to some very metaphysical beliefs, in tibet there is the belief in the reincarnation of former master, who should have attained nibbanna, and is therefore a paradox.
And this is where honest Buddhists confess to difficulties in explaining how nothing is the identically same intermediary thing (pun not intended) between rebirths.
This is an essential teaching of the buddha, he often made reference to lamps.
And then would ask then student to ponder if the flame on the lamp was the same flame after it had been extinguished and then relit.
Or if the room was the same or not when lit by a different lamp. As a modern interpretation I take it to mean that the continuity of consciousness is n illusion of memory habits.
When you read their attempts at explanation you will realize that they are trying to drown you in a tsunami of words, hoping that you will accept the no-self for an intermediary nothingness between rebirths, or be amenable to sweep all the difficulties under the rug.
I agree, that is why I interpret the teachings in a non-metaphysical sense, I am a materialist in many ways.
There is not continutiy between the events of the perception of the self. Can a person who reads the words of Plato truely relive Plato?
In the wuote that I gave by Thich Naht Hahn, he states clearly the the vehicles which provide form are transformed and that the nature of being changes. I could be wrong, but I do not feel that he means the form of the cloud continues into the rain in some sort of rebirth, I take it to mean that the stuff of being changes and that we should accept it.
--------------
Observation 3.
There is now here in this thread noticeably more volume of words in the direction of my kind of skeptical criticism in regard to Buddhism; so, this thread is picking up, getting more enjoyable to read and to write for, and thereby more educational as intended by the founder of this foundation called James Randi Educational Foundation, understanding education as learning to be scientifically skeptical.
So, that is new.
Yrreg
If you offer beliefs that you are sceptical of then we can agree or diagree.
Here is a great big one that may interest you,
I worked for three years in a domestic violence shelter for women and thier children. Domestic violence is a huge issue around the world and quite an evil in all societies. I haven't studied amnesty internationals reprots to determine if the rates of domestic violence are lower in buddhist societies, because the reports state that womens rights are an issue in all nations and places.
It does bother me that societies that are grown in the precense of the teachings of the buddha are as rife with domestic violence as those that are not.
As I stated earlier, I do not believe that the buddha was a modern elgaltarian, his mother and wife had to browbeat him into allowing women into the sangha, from the tales.