Show me that Science proves there is no god

"Science" is not limited to peer reviewed publications. It was The God Delusion that opened my mind to the possibility of studying the existence of God scientifically. I admit that I don't find all of Dawkins's arguments totally convincing, but I am certainly convinced of his central idea, that hypotheses about the possible existence of any sort of God are ideas that can be analysed and tested using scientific means, just as are hypotheses about what a particular dinosaur may have looked like or how the human mind functions.
So you say, you belief the "God Hypothesis" about God's existence is subject to serious scientific investigation, although you're not aware of any corresponding literature, correct?

Let me tell you, I know for a fact that your are wrong. You shouldn't accept anything just because somebody has written it in his pamphlet and you happen to like it.

You should at least try to verify if it's reasonable at all. Where are all those scientific investigations? Name some! You cannot? Well, you should start accepting the fact, there aren't any. Why not? Maybe the pamphlet is wrong? Or what? Explain to me, I am curious.

So, as a start on the scientific investigation of God, I recommend reading The God Delusion.
Why? That's not scientific literature.

Creationism is a belief, not a hypothesis.
Right. The statement "God created all" is a belief, not a scientific hypothesis. That's what I said.

It is perfectly possible, however, to re-state the creationist idea as a hypothesis and to put it scientifically to the test against the available evidence.
Why don't you just do it? Did somebody else do it so far? Who?

Herzblut
 
Last edited:
I've never once said all I have is scientific evidence only. But what would be the point of posting anything else if scientific evidence is all people will consider?
Who said that's the only thing we'll consider? I'd consider any sort of evidence. If it turns out to be valid, I would value having been shown it.

Especially since my only purpose here is to learn - not prove or convert or anything.
Sure, but if your evidence isn't valid, exposing it to criticism is a good way to find that out. If you're interested in learning whether or not your viewpoint is correct you should be excited about telling us what leads you to it.

Mind you, that doesn't mean you have to accept whatever criticism is presented - there are plenty of bad arguments posted on these forums, and it might turn out that while many posters here disagree with you, you're still right. But at least having the opportunity to see their arguments should be worthwhile. I don't know...

Like I posted somewhere else since I've posting here I've had more people tell me that what I believe is wrong. I've never once posted that anyone here or elsewhere has to believe anything. I have simply been responding to peoples questions and requests of me.
This is a little defensive - I can understand that. A few people have called you a "troll" and I don't really know why - the fact that you disagree with many people here and want to have a discussion about that doesn't make you a troll. In my opinion it makes you valuable to these forums.
But some of us really are interested in a genuine discussion.

But one example just off the top of my head (so for all I know it might not be a great example): Beauty of a flower. Science can never prove to me the beauty of a flower. But I have plenty of evidence in my life that there are beautiful flowers.
I think Dr Kitten answered this very well, so I'll leave it with her response. :)

Science has limitations. I've accepted that. And really - what would someone whose only measurement on things was science really be like? I can't really imagine since I don't know anyone like that.
It's true that science has limitations. I just don't know if there is anything that uses a method other than that of science to find truth that doesn't have the same limitations.



I agree. I've never said anything against that. I understand that.[/quote]
 
Originally Posted by A Christian Sceptic
I've never once said all I have is scientific evidence only. But what would be the point of posting anything else if scientific evidence is all people will consider?
Who said that's the only thing we'll consider? I'd consider any sort of evidence. If it turns out to be valid, I would value having been shown it.

That statement was made in reference to the circumstances I posted stuff I take as evidence and was a reply to someone's request for elaboration. At which point I pointed out that any evidence I show isn't going to be considered evidence for God's existence anymore than any evidence anyone shows against will be accepted as being against.

And I've stated in many posts that I think God's existence can't be proven to others one way or another. But that said, many people used the reason of not believing as "lack of evidence" so I'm curious on what that specifically it is. In this thread I limited it to scientific evidence and the posts confirmed what I already know - science can't prove or disprove his existence. From some people's response it seems Richard Dawkins is claiming this, which I hope is not the case. I hope what he means is "Science might be used to investigate whether he left any traces of him existing." Him existing and him leaving traces would be two seperate things.

So far my conclusion in this aspect of believing or not believing: "God may or may not exist, it can't be proven one way or another, and people come to a conclusion on his existence based on the evidence (however they want to define it) that they receive throughout their life."

I know this next part wasn't asked for (I've been trying to limit what I state to responses to people posting to me). But I think every person's belief in God is like a pendulum. It swings back and forth between belief and non-belief based on circumstances and personal experience, previous beliefs, new knowledge gained, and basically whatever they consider evidence, etc. To me an Athiest who says they will never believe in God is the exact same as a religious person saying they will never not believe in God. Neither of these cases is obviously true since it happens both ways.
 
Last edited:
So you say, you belief the "God Hypothesis" about God's existence is subject to serious scientific investigation, although you're not aware of any corresponding literature, correct?

Let me tell you, I know for a fact that your are wrong. You shouldn't accept anything just because somebody has written it in his pamphlet and you happen to like it.
Why don't you just do it? Did somebody else do it so far? Who?

The God Delusion is not a pamphlet, it's a book full of serious reasoning backed up by solid evidence. Have you read it?
 
The God Delusion is not a pamphlet, it's a book full of serious reasoning backed up by solid evidence. Have you read it?
I couldn't find it in the "Science" section of my local bookstore.

Seriously, it doesn't matter what I've read.

You are saying there's an exciting scientific hypothesis out there, but no scientific research about it. How can you seriously think so?

Herzblut
 
I couldn't find it in the "Science" section of my local bookstore.

Come, now. We're hardly responsible for the incompetence of your local bookshop owner.

You are saying there's an exciting scientific hypothesis out there, but no scientific research about it. How can you seriously think so?

In my experience, anyone begins a statement with "you are saying,.... but," then they're not only misrepresenting what someone else is saying, but they are generally even aware of their dishonesty. I find it's one of the markers that distinguishes the liar from the honestly ignorant.

But on the off-chance that you are honestly ignorant, I recommend you check out The God Delusion. It has a references section in the back that will point you to quite a bit of scientific research.
 
I don't think science "disproves" God. It just makes it harder to believe what people say about Him/Her/Them/It/That/What?/Me/You/Us/Not/More/All/Some/None.
 
Last edited:
Tricky found some scientific evidence to disprove God -- the concept of God that Tricky believed in, anyway:

I was fortunate enough that my experience with religion was not as horrible as Slingblades, but I too was a former believer. I gradually stopped believing in God because not one thing that God was supposed to do ever happened. In fact, the world behaved exactly as you would expect it to behave if there weren't any sort of loving Father.

That was possible because, according to Tricky's former belief, the world would be different depending on whether God existed.

And, yes, the evidence offered is scientific.
The belief depended on observation, not whim.
 
In my experience, anyone begins a statement with "you are saying,.... but," then they're not only misrepresenting what someone else is saying, but they are generally even aware of their dishonesty. I find it's one of the markers that distinguishes the liar from the honestly ignorant.
What a cozy anecdote. You tell us more about your life?

But on the off-chance that you are honestly ignorant, I recommend you check out The God Delusion. It has a references section in the back that will point you to quite a bit of scientific research.
Just name the most convincing scientific results about whether god exists or not.
 
Depends on how you define "god". If you define god as the one in each individual religion, you can debunk most of them with science. Though there is no reason to prove the negative in these cases. Instead, you need to look at what the evidence supports and how overwhelmingly it supports the no god conclusion.

You can address religions such as the Biblical religion and present some pretty powerful logic arguments against the existence of that particular god. Many contradictions in particular are simply incompatible. Or you can show the lack of logical possibility of an omnipotent god since he couldn't make a rock which was too big to be moved. Those are not the most useful ways of addressing the evidence against god beliefs but they have been proposed.

But when you change the definition of god to one which science cannot test for, a god defined in that unnatural** way is then outside of the boundary of scientific inquiry.

**Unnatural in the sense this definition is not used by any traditional religion and only came about as the evidence for gods became less and less likely to be found. Things gods supposedly did such as answering prayers were not supported by evidence, so change your god belief to one who doesn't answer prayers, and so on.
 
Last edited:
I couldn't find it in the "Science" section of my local bookstore.

Seriously, it doesn't matter what I've read.

You are saying there's an exciting scientific hypothesis out there, but no scientific research about it. How can you seriously think so?

OK, here's just one publication on one of the aspects of the God hypothesis: Study of the Therapeutic Effects of Intercessory Prayer (STEP) in cardiac bypass patients. If you're really interested in more information on the scientific investigation of the existence of God, just pick up a copy of The God Delusion.
 
Or you can show the lack of logical possibility of an omnipotent god since he couldn't make a rock which was too big to be moved.

I've been around Christians who have had discussions about this subject - could God make a rock he couldn't move? None of their answered worked for me. But since then I've thought of many ways he could do this but I'd have to first think he had certain attributes such as he's honest, can't lie, in essence won't disobey himself, etc. But, that's neither here nor there. :)
 
Last edited:
I've been around Christians who have had discussions about this subject - could God make a rock he couldn't move? None of their answered worked for me. But since then I've thought of many ways he could do this but I'd have to first think he had certain attributes such as he's honest, can't lie, in essence won't disobey himself, etc. But, that's neither here nor there. :)

Look, here you're doing exactly what Sagan does in regards to his dragon. Of course it's "here or there", because it's at the very core of your belief system, and why it is untenable and ultimately wrong.

As Firegarden points out in that thread,

I think Sagan has been clever in illustrating the chain of thoughts you'd have to go through. So it's invisible, "Does it leave footprints?" So it floats, "what about the draft from its wings beating?" It doesn't fly, it just floats. And so on.

All methods of finding evidence for the dragon are attempts to answer: "what's the difference between an invisible, incorporeal, floating dragon who spits heatless fire and no dragon at all?"

You're moving the goalposts, making excuses, ad infinitum. Your God is the dragon in the garage.
 
Last edited:
You're moving the goalposts, making excuses, ad infinitum. Your God is the dragon in the garage.

I don't know what goalposts you're talking about. If you're telling me that the dragon in the garage is the god of all, then I wouldn't let science alone stop me from trying to find out if that's true. I may never come to a conclusion, or may not even be able to, but I wouldn't simply stop until I was satisfied. But that's just me, I understand that other people would not even bother. I'm fine with that.
 
I don't know what goalposts you're talking about. If you're telling me that the dragon in the garage is the god of all, then I wouldn't let science alone stop me from trying to find out if that's true. I may never come to a conclusion, or may not even be able to, but I wouldn't simply stop until I was satisfied. But that's just me, I understand that other people would not even bother. I'm fine with that.

You - "God is omnipotent"

Sceptic - "What about the immovable rock?"

You - "Oh, but God's, ummm, honest"

Compare:

Sagan - "I have a dragon in my garage"

Sceptic - "Why can't I see it?"

Sagan - "It's, ummm, invisible".


You see, it's moving the goalposts.

Of course God is honest; he has to be to iron out that particular illogical crease. But how about God tricking Abraham into nearly killing his Isaac?

No need to answer. That's just an illustration that you'll need to move the goalposts again in order for this whole fantasy to continue making sense.
 
You - "God is omnipotent"

Sceptic - "What about the immovable rock?"

You - "Oh, but God's, ummm, honest"

Compare:

Sagan - "I have a dragon in my garage"

Sceptic - "Why can't I see it?"

Sagan - "It's, ummm, invisible".


You see, it's moving the goalposts.

Of course God is honest; he has to be to iron out that particular illogical crease. But how about God tricking Abraham into nearly killing his Isaac?

No need to answer. That's just an illustration that you'll need to move the goalposts again in order for this whole fantasy to continue making sense.

I think your misunderstanding growth in your beliefs with trying to prove something to someone. If I am trying to prove to you something it would be accurate to say I'm moving the goalpasts. But I'm perfectly willing to alter my belief in God if I find out I misunderstood something about him. I guess if that means he's bigger than I thought - well I guess you're right - the goalposts were moved.
 
I've been around Christians who have had discussions about this subject - could God make a rock he couldn't move? None of their answered worked for me. But since then I've thought of many ways he could do this but I'd have to first think he had certain attributes such as he's honest, can't lie, in essence won't disobey himself, etc. But, that's neither here nor there. :)
Are you really not clear what this dilemma is about? If he succeeds he fails. Either way he fails. If he can do anything then he can make big rocks. If he can lift anything then he can lift big rocks. You CANNOT have it both ways. C A N N O T
 
I don't know what goalposts you're talking about. If you're telling me that the dragon in the garage is the god of all, then I wouldn't let science alone stop me from trying to find out if that's true.

Really?

In that case, there really is a dragon in my garage and he really is the god of all.

Now, you wouldn't want to miss out on this opportunity to worship the one true god, would you? Are you going to start praying to the dragon god in my garage?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom