Show me that Science proves there is no god

Then tell me what he meant. If you can't or won't than these type of posts are not helpful and are going to dilute this thread and kill it.

I'm not sure, but what I think people mean is that it is usually expected that people start a thread because they want to discuss something, and that it is therefore expected that they also participate in their own threads.

Also, people generally think that there are no things that are supposed to be exempt from discussing, so if the original poster states that "I am not going to discuss this, this and this, only this" then people will want to know why.

Also, I think that many don't like when people start a thread that is basically giving a topic and asking people to discuss the topic among themselves, to then lean back to see what happens. I suspect this is not liked for the following reasons (could be more or other resons as well): 1) If the topic is not fully clear, people find it annoying that the OP has stated that he won't be there to answer questions about the topic or clarify things. 2) It reminds of a school teacher handing out assignments :). 3) And last, it is common troll beahviour to throw topics out and wait to see who bites, never intending to participate. Thus it's a sure way to arouse suspicion.

But now you are participating, so all is OK, I guess.

ETA:
So, if a thread dies out because the OP is not participating and he/she starts a new thread instead of "not taking responsibility" for the last one, so to speak, it arouses suspicion of intent and trolling even more.

ETA again:
I'm talking about "unwritten laws" here, you can do it in any way that you want to, of course. Just an attempt to explain a few reason to why it can be that some question your intentions.
 
Last edited:
Thanks Fran - makes perfect sense. These threads were meant to get your opinions and not debate and even in this thread the first response was "don't start fights" etc. I of course broke my own rules by responding - but that's nothing new to me. :) and neither of these posts were in reference to any specific god - just what you wanted to post about.
 
I did appreciate the Carl Sagan link although not directly related. I enjoy his writings and loved COSMOS.

You're welcome.
But I thought it was very related. Sagan's Dragon is not merely a good anecdote. It also illustrates what others were saying regarding what science can test.
 
If people stop posting a thread you start you can't start a new thread? I really don't understand what having an open mind and being a sceptic have anything to do with starting a new thread. I'm sorry - you lost me on what the issue is here.

I feel like noteing that your last post in that thread was #55, while there where 106 total posts. This seems to me like running away.
 
It also fails to refute Athena's existence. Athena is a limited goddess: She has only a defined portfolio and an amount of personal power. Neither evil nor turtles are under her aspect.

You're right.
Eat crow, Epicurus!
 
I feel like noteing that your last post in that thread was #55, while there where 106 total posts. This seems to me like running away.

OK - looking back I see that I stopped posting once I started debating about Sanata Claus with someone. :) I then moved to the Should Sceptics only be Athiests thread because I felt that was better than to go in tangents off what the original threads purpose was. But i've gone back to the original if anyone is interested.

Here's the thread for anyone interested:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3233434#post3233434
 
Last edited:
I'm aware of alot of this type of research. But isn't all this is showing is why I think it's beautiful or that I think it's beauriful.? How can it prove it's beautiful.

"The flower is beautiful" is a statement of subjective opinion, not objective fact.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure where you found the claims that some scientist disproved God, and I didn't read most of the responses after the OP, but I'm going to say science will (most likely) never be able to disprove the existence of God.

Assuming, unfortunately, that we're talking about the Christian God, it's easy to see how science cannot prove God doesn't exist (double negative?). Science and the Christian religion operate on separate methodical levels to come to conclusions. As where science is based on observations and testable hypothesis, which is constantly revamping theories, religion's conclusions are not based on the same methods as science. The Christian religion uses it's biggest weakness, the absence of evidence, as it greatest strength, faith.

Science cannot disprove God because science cannot disprove faith since religious faith is defined as believing in something without evidence.

On a personal note, I think it would be interesting if science were to prove that God did exist. Then, that which most defines and individual as a strong religious person, faith, would be destroyed, destroying the most important aspect of religion. I don't think what I just wrote come across clearly, but I think its a paradox or something.
 
On a personal note, I think it would be interesting if science were to prove that God did exist. Then, that which most defines and individual as a strong religious person, faith, would be destroyed, destroying the most important aspect of religion. I don't think what I just wrote come across clearly, but I think its a paradox or something.

Actally this is a point other known Atheists make as well. If god was "found" scientifically, he could be just another part of nature, open to scientific inquiry. This would destroy the faith, and most importantly "mystery", that many religions live by.
 
Why would confirming faith destroy it?

When it is proven, it is not taken on faith anymore.

How many proponents of "natural",herbal and homeopathic medicine do you see proclaiming the healing powers of certain products of fungus (penicillin/antibiotics)? All the ones I hear about see that as the big "enemy". They need the big mystery and "unknown" ways of working for the belief to comfort them. I think for a large part of the godly religious, it is the same.
 
I disagree. So does Dawkins. The hypothesis that a God exists is a scientific hypothesis that can be examined and tested.
Point me to those scientific investigations. Peer reviewed science publications, if you don't mind.

You know, my joke about Sokal's hoax paper wasn't just a joke. It should raise the point that there is no scientific paper about "hermeneutics":D.

Let me know if you find one. Good luck.

The scientific methodology that Dawkins applies to the "God Hypothesis" is in no way different from the scientific methodology he applies to the theory of evolution.
The God "hypothesis" is no hypothesis from a scientific pov. It's creationism.

Herzblut
 
Last edited:
From what I understand the expansion of the universe means that some parts of it are (and others will be) receding from us faster than the speed of light. So, at least those parts are impossible for us to ever reach.
Interesting point! My General Relativity savviness is too bad to even present justified guesses here, just gut feelings.

Moreover, if you're talking about a vehicle that could take live humans, I think that's pretty likely impossible for a number of reasons. Not least of which is the acceleration forces that would be required to get it up to such a high percentage of the speed of light before your 1 hour was up.
Yep. Nevertheless, robo, please read between the lines to get to the point I am making. Which is "there is no absolute space and time". Physically, given all engineering problems are resolved, a vehicle sufficiently close to speed of light could cross, say, our Milky Way in almost no time. Light crosses any distance in no time at all. Proper time, of course.

Herzblut
 
Last edited:
The fact that you would interpret it differently doesn't suggest, however, that your interpretation is valid. For instance, if you showed me a red sweater, I could say it was blue all I wanted, I might even beleive it to be blue (maybe I had some weird sort of brain damage, or colour-blindness, etc) but that wouldn't change the fact that it was red, and my conclusion was simply wrong.
That's interesting again. I'd say that an object "as is" has got no colour attribute. The object is emitting light of a certain frequency range. It's just our perception that makes up a colour like "blue". Without the vast majority of men having the same kind of perception, we wouldn't call it blue at all, e.g. if men had some kind of blue colour blindness.

An object "is" blue, simply because we make it so. BTW, an object having one colour in the morning would probably have another one in the evening. It's our "colour correction" which makes it constantly "blue" (or whatever) all the time, although it isn't so.

Herzblut
 
Last edited:
OK - looking back I see that I stopped posting once I started debating about Sanata Claus with someone. :) I then moved to the Should Sceptics only be Athiests thread because I felt that was better than to go in tangents off what the original threads purpose was. But i've gone back to the original if anyone is interested.

Here's the thread for anyone interested:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3233434#post3233434

Exactly you ran away and ignored many people who made legitimate points after that.
 
Assuming, unfortunately, that we're talking about the Christian God, it's easy to see how science cannot prove God doesn't exist (double negative?). Science and the Christian religion operate on separate methodical levels to come to conclusions. As where science is based on observations and testable hypothesis, which is constantly revamping theories, religion's conclusions are not based on the same methods as science. The Christian religion uses it's biggest weakness, the absence of evidence, as it greatest strength, faith.

That depends, the standard christian god has strong evidence against its existance because he is supposted to answer prayers and heal people. This lack of a strongly defined traits evidence can be viewed as evidence of non existance.
 
Point me to those scientific investigations. Peer reviewed science publications, if you don't mind.

"Science" is not limited to peer reviewed publications. It was The God Delusion that opened my mind to the possibility of studying the existence of God scientifically. I admit that I don't find all of Dawkins's arguments totally convincing, but I am certainly convinced of his central idea, that hypotheses about the possible existence of any sort of God are ideas that can be analysed and tested using scientific means, just as are hypotheses about what a particular dinosaur may have looked like or how the human mind functions. So, as a start on the scientific investigation of God, I recommend reading The God Delusion.

The God "hypothesis" is no hypothesis from a scientific pov. It's creationism.

Creationism is a belief, not a hypothesis. It is perfectly possible, however, to re-state the creationist idea as a hypothesis and to put it scientifically to the test against the available evidence.
 
Why would confirming faith destroy it?

Read the Hitchhiker's Guide To The Galaxy regarding the Babel fish:

"I refuse to prove that I exist", says God, "for proof denies faith, and without faith I am nothing."

"But", says Man, "the Babel fish is a dead giveaway isn't it? it could not have evolved by chance. it proves you exist, and so therefore, by your own arguments, you don't. QED."

"Oh dear", says God, "I hadn't thought of that," and promptly vanishes in a puff of logic.

"Oh that was easy" says Man, and for an encore goes on to prove that black is white and gets himself killed on the next zebra crossing.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom