Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

These claims are puzzling. The planet would not get more humid if the warming were natural? A warmer Earth will be more humid, regardless of the cause.

Absolutely. Water-vapour is a feedback to any forcing.

Also, if water vapor is THE major greenhouse gas, why are we worrying about carbon dioxide?

You're confusing the greenhouse effect and a forcing. Increased CO2- load is a positive forcing (via the greenhouse effect) which is amplified by water-vapour (which amplifies any forcing).

Humidity varies by percents; carbon dioxide in parts per million. :confused:

So what? Dioxin can screw you up in parts per billion. (Analogy)

There's no disagreement that water-vapour dances to the climate's tune, but that's all. Climate doesn't change because the atmosphere suddenly gets wetter. Climate changes for other reasons, and water-vapour reacts. Due to its greenhouse effect it serves as a positive feedback, but it doesn't drive anything.

Cranking up CO2-load is a forcing. As is reducing it. Water-vapour responds, and acts as a positive feedback.
 
There's no disagreement that water-vapour dances to the climate's tune, but that's all. Climate doesn't change because the atmosphere suddenly gets wetter. Climate changes for other reasons, and water-vapour reacts. Due to its greenhouse effect it serves as a positive feedback, but it doesn't drive anything.

Cranking up CO2-load is a forcing. As is reducing it. Water-vapour responds, and acts as a positive feedback.

At the risk of sounding like a broken record, it's all in the IPCC report.
 
Of course - a review of historical peer reviewed studies is more or less a refuge in the past ...

"Peer-reviewed" is good, but in historical studies the peers were equally historical. They had as much to go on as the contemporary researchers.

...and in a review of historical studies....

... my above point has to be taken into account. Beck doesn't do that.

... the modern era by definition is avoided.

Avoidance of the modern era is quite a feature in contrarianism, and particularly in Beck's case.



#2 and #4 makes no sense to me either ...

You could have mentioned that when you cut-and-pasted them.

...unless natural variation of CO2 on land where (let's suppose) these measurements were predominately taken varies by that much compared to the Mauna Loa data.

We don't have to suppose. CO2 measurements can be taken by hand-held devices, on land or sea, and they vary greatly in different parts of town and at different times of day. Something which historical researchers and their peers suspected but weren't in a position to confirm. As Callender recognised (not alone, of course) samples taken where the prevailing wind is off an ocean are more likely to well-mixed. When you only take those into account CO2-load is stable and rising.

Beck, of course, includes everything, which is why he gets the wild gyrations he was seeking. Bear in mind that everything Beck does is directed towards undermining the modern consensus, not towards seeking the truth. As I've pointed out before, he's not the messenger, he crafts a message and tries to beat the evidence into the right shape.

Beck didn't derive the message from the papers he claims as support, he trawled for those papers after he'd constructed the message.

That has other consequences, by the way. You say at one point that the resolution of ices is 60-80 years and then you say that a 420ppm level would be showed in an ice core 60 years ago...

Well ... yes. That 420ppm in '42 would be represented across the 1902-1982 ice-core. It isn't.

This boils down to is (A) accept Keeling's throwing out of all historical CO2 data (B) independently review the data and determine if that decision was correct. (A) is what the IPCC did. I'm not totally opposed to (A), it just seems rather peculiar.

To me it seems very peculiar that CO2-load went up and down by as much as 10ppm per annum until accurate and consistent measurement became established and only then did it settle into a regular 0.5-2.5ppm per annum increase.

Suppose we said we need to throw out all 18th and 19th century thermometer measurements...

Thermometry and barometry are far simpler and more easily calibrated than the measurement of CO2-load (in parts per million). Nor do they claim to represent global conditions (as Beck tries to claim from his dubious data). So it wouldn't make sense to throw them out. They measure temperature and pressure at particular places and times on a consistent scale (mercury or alcohol equivalent against metres).

As you'll have realised by now, your comment is fatuous. As is everything that issues from Beck. He's not actually a liar, like Pat Michaels, but he's an idiot.
 
Last edited:
At the risk of sounding like a broken record, it's all in the IPCC report.

We're at constant risk of sounding like a broken record when the same old crap - "CO2-change follows temperature-change at inter-glacials so what about that, eh? Eh? Gotcha there!" - turns up on the same old new threads.

And, of course, when it takes a lot of repetiton to get simple points across to some even simpler people.

At least Beck's contribution is relatively new nonsense.
 
That's the whole point of the AGW argument. Positive feedback effects, like this one. You bump up CO2, which only directly causes a small rise in temperature, feedback effects multiply that rise in temperature.

Have you read the IPCC reports yet? It's all in there.

I"ve read some of it. It's huge.

However, if that's what AGW is all about, then it's qualitatively indistinguishable from natural GW. My comment had to do with the reporter's sloppy writing. It's getting more humid, so it's going to rain more (duh) and that makes it AGW (:confused:). That's pretty much why don't get my science reporting from news services.
 
You're confusing the greenhouse effect and a forcing. Increased CO2- load is a positive forcing (via the greenhouse effect) which is amplified by water-vapour (which amplifies any forcing).

I misread the statement then. The stress was on water vapor being the primary greenhouse gas. So what you're saying is that it's just a cascade effect. (I've never noticed before just how punny this topic is.) That is fairly obvious though so I don't get the shock and horror in the reporter's tone.

So what? Dioxin can screw you up in parts per billion. (Analogy)

That's not true. There was a badly done paper once that a cow flopped over dead from eating one blade of grass with one molecule of the "bad" dioxin (a dioxin is a type of molecule and there are many variants). That's been debunked. It was another eco-scare that NGOs used to fill their coffers. That once came right after the scare that grilled foods would kill us all, IIRC. Really, the deadliest substances are natural. But, we digress.

There's no disagreement that water-vapour dances to the climate's tune, but that's all. Climate doesn't change because the atmosphere suddenly gets wetter. Climate changes for other reasons, and water-vapour reacts. Due to its greenhouse effect it serves as a positive feedback, but it doesn't drive anything.

I have no problem with this. Thanks for the explanation.
 
Last edited:
Well ... yes. That 420ppm in '42 would be represented across the 1902-1982 ice-core. It isn't.

To me it seems very peculiar that CO2-load went up and down by as much as 10ppm per annum until accurate and consistent measurement became established and only then did it settle into a regular 0.5-2.5ppm per annum increase.

CD, but it's just going to boil down to what do you do? You didn't like the shallow ice core data and noted age could easily be 60-80 years off. So to try to summarize it...

A. Use shallow ice core data, quilt it to the Mauna Loa data and make it fit by using an arbitrary 83 year offset.
B. Use shallow ice core data, assign errors to CO2 values based on ice age possible ranges, fit it to the Mauna Loa data and present resulting graph with error bounds.
C. Throw out shallow ice core data because variation in age is close to or in excess of the range of time under consideration.
D. Look further into relations between historical CO2 analysis and ice core data and so forth ("D" is actually our recent discussion here).

What I'd do in a case like this would be to carefully note the problems and areas of uncertainty, discuss problems with the historical CO2 data and problems with the ice core data, and draw the graph of historical values patching in with Mauna Loa with error bounds only.

What would you do, and why?
 
Beware new measurements

At the risk of reigniting this thread, yet adding even more carbon dioxide to the atmosphere ;), I will write my conclusiong.

Stated briefly, I find that the contention that the Earth is warming is unsupported by a fixed metric. Therefore, any attempt to ascribe assumed warming any factor is conjecture. Therefore, the scientific evidence that humans are responsible for global warming is insufficient to carry the premise from hypothesis to fact.

The basis of my conclusion are that there is no recognized method of measuring the temperature of the planet. Records do exist which can be combined to synthesize an approximate global temperature but the methodology used in attaining the temperatures and statistically combine them is unsettled. Frankly, with all the work that has been poured into this topic, I find it very troubling that a standard method of stating the temperature of the planet has not been established.

I have read substantial portions of the IPCC report, specifically Chapter 2 as I am an analytical chemist and am most experienced in reading quantitative-type reports. The number of assumptions contained in that report is highly unusual (search engine found 67 instances of "assum"). Most of the assumptions have direct and important effects on the findings, making them ill-advised. My planned trip to the library was, thankfully, obviated by the stated assumptions as that was the purpose of the trip. However, the assumptions in that Chapter went well beyond those that originally troubled me.

Having written the above, I must also point out that facts that are established are troubling. Carbon dioxide is indeed increasing although it has not been proven in any way to be the potent forcing agent that it is assumed to be. Atmospheric pollution, as well as other types of pollution, are worth worrying about. Worry and fear equal panic, though, and that is something that isn't worth the time.

So, that's what I've found. Let the hate mail begin.
 
At the risk of reigniting this thread, yet adding even more carbon dioxide to the atmosphere ;), I will write my conclusiong.

Stated briefly, I find that the contention that the Earth is warming is unsupported by a fixed metric. Therefore, any attempt to ascribe assumed warming any factor is conjecture. Therefore, the scientific evidence that humans are responsible for global warming is insufficient to carry the premise from hypothesis to fact.

Hence the use of deviations from the average for each measuring station, or 'anomolies'. Then you don't need to have a global 'average', you just look at the changes for each site.
 
Stated briefly, I find that the contention that the Earth is warming is unsupported by a fixed metric. Therefore, any attempt to ascribe assumed warming any factor is conjecture. Therefore, the scientific evidence that humans are responsible for global warming is insufficient to carry the premise from hypothesis to fact.

<snip>

I have read substantial portions of the IPCC report, specifically Chapter 2 as I am an analytical chemist and am most experienced in reading quantitative-type reports.
Chapter 2 isn't on global temperature. It's on radiative forcings. Chapter 3 gives the calculations of global temperature.

Also, you're posing as a chemist again.
 
Hence the use of deviations from the average for each measuring station, or 'anomolies'. Then you don't need to have a global 'average', you just look at the changes for each site.

We've covered this before. You yourself wrote that, yes, there are temperature records, albeit regional ones. One must have some concept of normality to consider anything to be an anomaly.

That underscores my observation that there is no accepted metric for global temperature. For global warming to be demonstrable, such a system must be devised.
 
We've covered this before. You yourself wrote that, yes, there are temperature records, albeit regional ones. One must have some concept of normality to consider anything to be an anomaly.

That underscores my observation that there is no accepted metric for global temperature. For global warming to be demonstrable, such a system must be devised.

Integrating thermometers two feet in the ground, two feet in the snow, and two feet down in the ocean at about 300 carefully picked locations?
 
Integrating thermometers two feet in the ground, two feet in the snow, and two feet down in the ocean at about 300 carefully picked locations?

I'm not sure how I would approach this problem. Compared to defining the mean temperature of a planet, setting the exact measurement of a second, a meter, etc is child's play. But, whatever way it's done, it's important for three reasons:

1. Establish that the planet is warming or not and, if so, to establish the rate. To paraphrase, a fact is worth a thousand arguments.

2. To provide a fairly quick touchstone for model validation. That is, instead of waiting for secondary effects of climate change to evidence themselves, modelers could avail themselves of accurate measurements to determine if their predictions are out of kilter.

3. To allow management and efficient remediation of the problem. This one is the most crucial, in my opinion. If indeed, we have a problem with the planet that we can ameliorate, embarking on activities meant to do so would be a blind effort if the effects on the problem cannot be measured.

The last one is, to me, the most frustrating aspect of listening to claims of assumed crises, and I'm not limiting this to global warming. Whenever I'm convinced that the other party might have a point, I ask them what I should do. For AGW/GW, the remedies vary from walking/planting a tree to shutting down whole industries. Well, I'm more than happy to walk or plant a tree but I'll be damned if I'm going to happily watch other people being deprived of their jobs or property on sheer speculation.
 
I'm not sure how I would approach this problem. Compared to defining the mean temperature of a planet, setting the exact measurement of a second, a meter, etc is child's play. But, whatever way it's done, it's important for three reasons:

1. Establish that the planet is warming or not and, if so, to establish the rate. To paraphrase, a fact is worth a thousand arguments.

2. To provide a fairly quick touchstone for model validation. That is, instead of waiting for secondary effects of climate change to evidence themselves, modelers could avail themselves of accurate measurements to determine if their predictions are out of kilter.

3. To allow management and efficient remediation of the problem. This one is the most crucial, in my opinion. If indeed, we have a problem with the planet that we can ameliorate, embarking on activities meant to do so would be a blind effort if the effects on the problem cannot be measured.

The last one is, to me, the most frustrating aspect of listening to claims of assumed crises, and I'm not limiting this to global warming. Whenever I'm convinced that the other party might have a point, I ask them what I should do. For AGW/GW, the remedies vary from walking/planting a tree to shutting down whole industries. Well, I'm more than happy to walk or plant a tree but I'll be damned if I'm going to happily watch other people being deprived of their jobs or property on sheer speculation.

The problem is determining a "global" temperature using the surface station records. There is much controversy surrounding the accuracy, precision and factors such as UHI, land use change etc. Naturally some will simply link to IPCC and claim UHI has been accounted for, but it has not. The IPCC ignored all studies reflecting negatively on the surface station network.

Those that claim the surface station network is reliable (logical fallacy coming, be forewarned), have no idea what they're talking about. This was fully exposed by Steve McIntyre, Pielke and many others.

T1-T2/2 to determine "average" daily temperature is absurd. The entire methodology is a subjective "adjustment", based on.......nothing they are willing to explain. Hansen (NASA) and Jones (Hadley) do not give any justification to their "adjustments", which is a perpetual process. For instance, Hansen made the following "adjustments" in 2001:



The AGW folks don't appear to want to discuss the quality of the surface station data because it happens to support the dogma after the data is massaged; they'd rather just "move on". When confronted with examples of the "high quality" network at http://surfacestations.org/ , they with a straight face, contend there are no problems; it doesn't matter they say. This is why ClimateAudit does what it does; audit.

Now Steve McIntyre is auditing the tree ring data by doing his own study using accredited dendrochronology labs, letting the chips fall where they may, which is the way it should be.

We do have satellite records going back to 1979, but that contradicts the AGW hypothesis, so there must be something wrong with it.

If there is any real fraud going on, it's the IPCC.
 
Last edited:
We've covered this before. You yourself wrote that, yes, there are temperature records, albeit regional ones. One must have some concept of normality to consider anything to be an anomaly.

That underscores my observation that there is no accepted metric for global temperature. For global warming to be demonstrable, such a system must be devised.

And those records are compiled from individual recording stations, for which records exist. Get an average of those temperatures, call that the 0. Then calculate the deviations, is it warming, or cooling?
 
And those records are compiled from individual recording stations, for which records exist. Get an average of those temperatures, call that the 0. Then calculate the deviations, is it warming, or cooling?

AUP, I know that argument and I'm not dismissing it. That is why I didn't write that there was no evidence of warming. I wrote that there is no standard metric to prove the point.

I've seen enough reports on warmer weather at various localities to alarm me. Based on the current controversy over AGW or GW, that could very well be selective reporting. I must say that I've also read reports by the anti-GW crowd of colder-than-normal weather. So, who knows for sure? What's the rate? Which ameliorative scenario would be more effective: A or B? How would we know for sure?

That's a serious problem, not with the existence or non-existence of GW but with verification. A lot of work has gone into global climate research, don't get me wrong. I'm impressed with the IPCC report but also impressed with the rebuttal of dissidents. If I ruled the universe, I would burden the UN to come up with a realistic measurement system instead of forming a commission to guess at what might be happening.
 
Yes but warming or cooling this instant is meaningless without comparing to ancient ranges. One thing is constant in climate, that is variability. Yes, Capeldoger, I know you think that is taking refuse in the past. But without past records to compare to, we just don't know whether this warm period is abnormal or not.

But, like the above discussion of inherent averaging within ice cores, we have a problem with tree rings. They just don't have the acuity to tell us if 1-2 degrees per century is a normal historical range. In a system that varies by 80 degrees some days, some places.
 
The problem is determining a "global" temperature using the surface station records. There is much controversy surrounding the accuracy, precision and factors such as UHI, land use change etc. Naturally some will simply link to IPCC and claim UHI has been accounted for, but it has not.

I agree. I don't know how one would take the temperature of a planet other than in an astronomical sense. We can determine the temperature of distant objects but we're the ant on the rock, so to speak. So, how do we measure the temperature of said rock? Should it be atmospheric only? solid and liquid phases included? A really natty problem but I believe that the effort should start there. Any uncertainty in the temperature we're discussing injects too much interpretive freedom.

The AGW folks don't appear to want to discuss the quality of the surface station data because it happens to support the dogma after the data is massaged; they'd rather just "move on". When confronted with examples of the "high quality" network at http://surfacestations.org/ , they with a straight face, contend there are no problems; it doesn't matter they say. This is why ClimateAudit does what it does; audit.

Now Steve McIntyre is auditing the tree ring data by doing his own study using accredited dendrochronology labs, letting the chips fall where they may, which is the way it should be.

We do have satellite records going back to 1979, but that contradicts the AGW hypothesis, so there must be something wrong with it.

I don't like speculation based on assumptions. When I begin a project I make a list of my assumptions. When I reach a dead end, I look at that list and, more often than not, I've made an assumption that has sunk its teeth into my rear end.

However, I found the IPCC Chapter full of assumptions. Some of them were basically assumptions that the previous assumptions were correct! I've seen many assumptions on this thread and the one that most troubles me is that carbon dioxide must be the agent of global warming. Whenever I've asked how they're certain, the champions of this idea tell me that it must be so. It must be so because it's the only gas that shows the propensity to reradiate heat in anywhere near the necessary flux to warm the planet. When I ask how a gas in ppm quantities can do this, I get nothing but a look of incredulity as to how truly stupid I must be because it's the only possible cause of global warming. Certainly none of the other gases will do this but that doesn't mean that carbon dioxide has that capability either.

My qualms about how sampling for gases by dredging up compressed strata to ambient pressure has also not been addressed. Nor have the assumptions behind the "age of air" assumption. That is, I understand that statement and agree with its reasoning (except for the 12C/13C ratio bit) and but I see no way one could possibly use it as a corrective factor without actually measuring the effect on site which has not been done.

If there is any real fraud going on, it's the IPCC.

I'm not sure whether or not this assertion is correct. Many people have posted that the IPCC does not generate its data but is strictly an interpretive body. I have no doubt that most of the scientists contributing to the work of the IPCC are honest, above-board professonals. That being said I am troubled by the apparent cherry-picking of data done by some of the leadership there. They've dismissed data that I don't think can be dismissed without explaining why. Yes, irrelevant data can be ignored but only after you've explained that it is irrelevant. For example, there's a study of variation of carbon dioxide in a room over time that is apparently not considered because it was not an environmental measurement. So what? The magnitude of CO2 would still have validity, yes? And so it goes.

I know many people cast a jaundiced eye at the IPCC because its parent, the UN, is as wildly political as any deliberative body. So, does the policy taint the IPCC? One has to wonder as the AGW hypothesis fits in perfectly with the aims of many countries that comprise the Third World and are memebers of the UN. However, that is beyond the scope of our present discussion. I'm only mentioning it because I don't want to accuse anyone of fraud...yet.
 
AUP, I know that argument and I'm not dismissing it. That is why I didn't write that there was no evidence of warming. I wrote that there is no standard metric to prove the point.

As it happens, there is, we are living in it. Ecosystems are so finely balanced in terms of temperature in Kelvin, that even a 1% change in their climate can cause huge changes, destabilising and then destroying them. In their bid to optimise the advantages they can gain, they become highly specialised and susceptible to what are, relatively speaking, the slightest changes. The bacteria will be fine, so will the rocks.

Already the slightest change is causing an acceleration in the melting of glaciers, and changes in albedo.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom