Of course - a review of historical peer reviewed studies is more or less a refuge in the past ...
"Peer-reviewed" is good, but in historical studies the peers were equally historical. They had as much to go on as the contemporary researchers.
...and in a review of historical studies....
... my above point has to be taken into account. Beck doesn't do that.
... the modern era by definition is avoided.
Avoidance of the modern era is quite a feature in contrarianism, and particularly in Beck's case.
#2 and #4 makes no sense to me either ...
You could have mentioned that when you cut-and-pasted them.
...unless natural variation of CO2 on land where (let's suppose) these measurements were predominately taken varies by that much compared to the Mauna Loa data.
We don't have to suppose. CO2 measurements can be taken by hand-held devices, on land or sea, and they vary greatly in different parts of town and at different times of day. Something which historical researchers and their peers
suspected but weren't in a position to confirm. As Callender recognised (not alone, of course) samples taken where the prevailing wind is off an ocean are more likely to well-mixed. When you only take
those into account CO2-load is stable and rising.
Beck, of course, includes everything, which is why he gets the wild gyrations he was seeking. Bear in mind that everything Beck does is directed towards undermining the modern consensus, not towards seeking the truth. As I've pointed out before, he's not the messenger, he crafts a message and tries to beat the evidence into the right shape.
Beck didn't derive the message from the papers he claims as support, he
trawled for those papers after he'd constructed the message.
That has other consequences, by the way. You say at one point that the resolution of ices is 60-80 years and then you say that a 420ppm level would be showed in an ice core 60 years ago...
Well ... yes. That 420ppm in '42 would be represented across the 1902-1982 ice-core. It isn't.
This boils down to is (A) accept Keeling's throwing out of all historical CO2 data (B) independently review the data and determine if that decision was correct. (A) is what the IPCC did. I'm not totally opposed to (A), it just seems rather peculiar.
To me it seems
very peculiar that CO2-load went up and down by as much as 10ppm per annum until accurate and consistent measurement became established and only
then did it settle into a regular 0.5-2.5ppm per annum increase.
Suppose we said we need to throw out all 18th and 19th century thermometer measurements...
Thermometry and barometry are far simpler and more easily calibrated than the measurement of CO2-load (in parts per million). Nor do they claim to represent
global conditions (as Beck tries to claim from his dubious data). So it wouldn't make sense to throw them out. They measure temperature and pressure at particular places and times on a consistent scale (mercury or alcohol equivalent against metres).
As you'll have realised by now, your comment is fatuous. As is everything that issues from Beck. He's not actually a liar, like Pat Michaels, but he's an idiot.