Slimething
Illuminator
- Joined
- Nov 14, 2006
- Messages
- 3,790
Argument from authority or what? Weaselling is what it is - not yours, Beck's, you just report it.
I really don't agree with this attitude. We're skeptics, right? We argue the idea, not the person.
Verified? Can anything really be said to be verified?
Yup. It's called independent confirmation in science. A different and independent lab or team will run the experiment exactly as reported and confirm the finding or fail to confirm. It's a crucial step in the acceptance of an hypothesis. Fleischman and Pons sure wish they had waited for this step now.
On a more relevant note, this is why I've been asking if there is an alternative carbon dioxide sink that could be used to confirm ice core data. The answer so far is no, am I correct? Is it that there is none or that the candidate formations don't confirm the core findings and the consensus is that the ice cores are more accurate?
No he doesn't. Unless he defines his own "precision". What is that, 3%? Compared to what?
Precision has a precise definition in analytical chemistry and you'll find it precisely here.
You're an easy mark for precision when it says precisely what you want to hear.
Really, the term you want to use is "accuracy", not "precision". A measurement can be precise but not very inaccurate.
As to 1, I wouldn't make much of ice-cores for the last century myself. Gases can percolate through snow; it's only when snow gets deep enough to be compacted into ice that trapped gasses are immobilised. Thus the time-resolution of ice-cores is about 60-80 years. That said, the percolation is very slow so there's something to learnt from 20thCE ice-cores. Just not too much.
This is one of the assumptions I really find to be wildly speculative. How do you know that gas in ice is immobilized? That's a huge assumption and I can't say offhand that I agree with it at all, especially given that carbon dioxide especially is water soluble and could flow quite easily through ice by processes other than diffusion. I agree that the rate of loss may be significantly reduced but I can't agree that gases are immobilized without proof.
As to 2, 420ppm sixty years ago is laughable. That would be represented in modern ice-cores, for one thing, and for another : where did it come from, where did it go, and why? If Beck's data shows this it shows Beck's data for what it is. Self-serving BS.
I'm not defending the precise figure but don't make the assumption that all carbon dioxide produced by industry stays in the atmosphere. That's another assumption that I find difficult to swallow.
As to 4, it makes no sense to me. What chemical means, except the burning of fossil-fuels at an even more alarming rate than currently? What the heck was going on back in the 40's that nobody noticed? Admittedly there was a lot of anthropogenetic stuff that demanded attention but all the same somebody would surely have noticed whatever was behind it. Beck doesn't even speculate on what it was. It just happened.
Now that's a fascinating question. Someone posted a "sine-wave" type graph of ice-core carbon dioxide data the other day that clearly showed the same cyclical pattern has been occuring even before the Industrial Revolution. I have no idea whether or not those data are accurate (not precise, accurate) but, if they are, a mechanism is at play on this planet that no one has explained yet. Really, this is pretty cool in that we might be discovering a new phenomenon about this planet. Pretty exciting stuff, really.
The data series have been reviewed, Callender did that as best he could. Beck just takes everything from before the modern measurement era unquestioningly. The modern era he ... avoids. You may call it scientiofic diligence. Taking refuge in the past, I calls it.
I really don't see your point here. Say there is a set of modern data that we all agree was collected using proven, standardized techniques that we are all overjoyed with and are unquestionable. Whether you believe record A, B, or C of ancient data not collected with the moder method, you are still constrained by science from plopping the modern data on top of it without regard to accurace and precision. Any way you argue it, you lose. It doesn't really matter who's version of past measurements are correct, they're unusable. For that matter, I see ice core data as unusable too because quality assurance has not been done to insure accuracy of results. Precision may not be a problem but accuracy sure is.
Last edited:





