This is highly disingenuous and misleading.
Beck's study of historical CO2 levels did not cover the period of time that the Cape Grim and Mauna Loa data was taken.
Indeed not, Beck takes refuge in history
before accuracy and consistency were well-established.
Cape Grim and Mauna Loa are accurate to each other and have nothing to do with prior historical Co2 concentrations.
Nor do they, but they do tell us a lot about the rate of variation in CO2-load when measured accurately and consistently. Upshot is, they don't vary wildly.
Data series covered by Beck's study end in 1961, and includes work done by several Nobel prize winners (Krogh 1923, Warburg 1933) as well as Benedict, nominated for the Nobel prize in 1923.
Krogh got a Nobel Prize in Physiology and Medicine. Or are we talking about a different Krogh?
Argument from authority or what? Weaselling is what it is - not yours, Beck's, you just report it.
There were more than 320 technical papers on air gas analysis from 1800 to 1961 containing verified ...
Verified? Can anything really be said to be verified?
... data on atmospheric CO2 concentrations. Keeling and the IPCC discredit these techniques and data and in fact, the IPCC do not even mention them - historical revisionism at it's finest.
How does the IPCC both discredit
and not mention this data? As to "historical revisionism" - have you been talking to Diamond recently? He was always well keen on that phrase.
Beck shows in his review article that for every decade from 1857 to the 1950s there are several measurement series with hundreds of precise data points.
No he doesn't. Unless he defines his own "precision". What is that, 3%? Compared to what?
You're an easy mark for precision when it says precisely what you want to hear.
It is easily seen that -
1. Atmospheric carbon dioxide fluctuates through 19th and 20th century contradicting the ice core reconstructions.
2. In 20th century we notice one big maximum around 1942 with more than 420 ppm...
3. CO2 Concentrations rise from 1880 to 1930 by some 20 ppm as Callender speculated in 1938
4. Big maximas with an amplitude of 100 ppm like the one in the 40s should be easily reproduced with chemical means. (3%) This is not mentioned in modern literature.
As to 1, I wouldn't make much of ice-cores for the last century myself. Gases can percolate through snow; it's only when snow gets deep enough to be compacted into ice that trapped gasses are immobilised. Thus the time-resolution of ice-cores is about 60-80 years. That said, the percolation is very slow so there's
something to learnt from 20thCE ice-cores. Just not too much.
As to 2, 420ppm sixty years ago is laughable. That
would be represented in modern ice-cores, for one thing, and for another : where did it come from, where did it go, and why? If Beck's data shows this it shows Beck's data for what it is. Self-serving BS.
As to 3, I have to ask, why does Callender
speculate while Beck
shows? I fear you've spent so much time amongst them that you've become (all unknowingly) infected with weaselism.
As to 4, it makes no sense to me. What chemical means, except the burning of fossil-fuels at an even more alarming rate than currently? What the heck was going on back in the 40's that nobody noticed? Admittedly there was a lot of anthropogenetic stuff that demanded attention but all the same somebody would surely have noticed whatever was behind it. Beck doesn't even speculate on what it was. It just happened.
If Beck is simply making obvious conclusions from over 130 published, peer reviewed studies, why fault the messenger?
Beck's not the messenger, nor are his conclusions obvious. His message is of his own manufacture and he calls in evidence 130 studies to try and give it some substance. Just as he calls in evidence the number of Nobel Prize winners involved.
You
believe this guy? You believe that those 130 studies are what Beck searched out
before he made his message, rather than searched out
afterwards to give spurious substance to his nonsense?
He provides all the data series for review. You are able then to look at the actual data and draw your own conclusions.
Here is
the spreadsheet of the historical CO2 data.
Well there's a thing.
The data series have been reviewed, Callender did that as best he could. Beck just takes everything from
before the modern measurement era unquestioningly. The modern era he ... avoids. You may call it scientiofic diligence. Taking refuge in the past, I calls it.