Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Another zombie rises from the dead. There is no evidence from Mauna Loa and Cape Grim that such a thing ever happens. The maximum that is observed is nothing like 10ppm per year.

Then what one would do is look at the 135 peer reviewed studies in Beck's compilation, determine that modern science had shown it was impossible to have a 10ppm increase, check the studies to see how geographical siting may have affected the measurements, and on some reasonable basis with supporting calculations, toss out some of the studies.

You would not toss them all out, only a few.
 
Then what one would do is look at the 135 peer reviewed studies in Beck's compilation, determine that modern science had shown it was impossible to have a 10ppm increase, check the studies to see how geographical siting may have affected the measurements, and on some reasonable basis with supporting calculations, toss out some of the studies.

You would not toss them all out, only a few.

I'm tossing it all out. The ice cores, Mauna Loa and Cape Grim verses random tests with no awareness of the environment they are being taken in. As someone has already pointed out, it was realised that the only way to get a reliable CO2 reading was to take it in a remote place, where there were the atmosphere was well mixed. Once that was done, the true story was apparent, and Cape Grim confirms the accuracy of Mauna Loa. They both agree with the ice core record.
 
Then what one would do is look at the 135 peer reviewed studies in Beck's compilation, determine that modern science had shown it was impossible to have a 10ppm increase, check the studies to see how geographical siting may have affected the measurements, and on some reasonable basis with supporting calculations, toss out some of the studies.

You would not toss them all out, only a few.

The job of someone writing a review article is not to toss out peer reviewed articles but to enumerate and discuss them all. That is so readers of the review can see that tiny subset of science, with all of it's blunders and advances, and make their own judgements.
 
Your response simply indicates you have not read Beck's article. As such I don't feel obliged to point out where you are wrong. If you'd like to go read it, then I will discuss it further with you.

Mauna Loa and Cape Grim verses random tests with no awareness of the environment they are being taken in.

If I am incorrect and you have read it, then point out where in the article your comments are substantiated. That is to say, go beyond what your friends at Gristmill and Realclimate have to say (they don't give you page numbers for their claims, do they?)
 
I asked a question a while back that hasn't been answered. Is there no carbon dioxide reservoir that has been used to confirm ice core data? Is one available? If not, any results/ declarations that humanity is in peril are a bit premature (thanks to M. Twain).

Plant stomata definitely shows more of a variation than ice core data, and the articles often comment on the "smoothed" ice core data, referring to the issues we were discussing earlier about ice cores and data quilting.

What is the relevance of this? Well, the question was simply, can we rely on ice core CO2 approximations for 19th and earlier 20th century CO2 levels? Are you looking for a source other than Beck?
 
Originally Posted by a_unique_person
Downloadable spreadsheet of the data.

http://www.environment.gov.au/soe/20...dioxide_dl.xls

What it does show is that Beck is purely, and simply, wrong. Another Zombie beaten to death, but I know it will rise again.
​
Thanks for the link. I got a perfect correlation (r = 1.00) and k = 1.55 ppm CO2/ yr so that's really compelling. As I'm not knowledgeable, how does this rebut Beck? What was Beck's opinoin that said this would be wrong?

This is highly disingenuous and misleading.

Beck's study of historical CO2 levels did not cover the period of time that the Cape Grim and Mauna Loa data was taken. Cape Grim and Mauna Loa are accurate to each other and have nothing to do with prior historical Co2 concentrations.

Data series covered by Beck's study end in 1961, and includes work done by several Nobel prize winners (Krogh 1923, Warburg 1933) as well as Benedict, nominated for the Nobel prize in 1923.

There were more than 320 technical papers on air gas analysis from 1800 to 1961 containing verified data on atmospheric CO2 concentrations. Keeling and the IPCC discredit these techniques and data and in fact, the IPCC do not even mention them - historical revisionism at it's finest.

Beck shows in his review article that for every decade from 1857 to the 1950s there are several measurement series with hundreds of precise data points.

Page 5, Beck's abbreviated paper.

It is easily seen that -
1. Atmospheric carbon dioxide fluctuates through 19th and 20th century contradicting the ice core reconstructions.
2. In 20th century we notice one big maximum around 1942 with more than 420 ppm...
3. CO2 Concentrations rise from 1880 to 1930 by some 20 ppm as Callender speculated in 1938
4. Big maximas with an amplitude of 100 ppm like the one in the 40s should be easily reproduced with chemical means. (3%) This is not mentioned in modern literature.
​
If Beck is simply making obvious conclusions from over 130 published, peer reviewed studies, why fault the messenger? He provides all the data series for review. You are able then to look at the actual data and draw your own conclusions.

Here is the spreadsheet of the historical CO2 data.
 
IMHO, the reason a lot of qualified physicists would avoid these threads is that they are startlingly similar to debates about evolution of bigfoot, that is, a debate not worth wasting their time on, when the other side offers so much rubbish as evidence. Beck, Jaworoski, Chrichton, the list of non entities in science never ends.

Frankly, I wish I'd never stumbled on this thread. It's fairly sacrosanct that, if a scientist has a question they can answer themselves, they're beholden to do that. I read only a little and ran up against those four assumptions which, to me, are unreasonable. So, now I have to dig up the original report and "do the numbers".

My experience is that good science isn't pretty. You get a bunch of scientists in a room to discuss a nebulous point and you may as well order dinner. I can't tell you for sure that the mudslining you're watching is the process of discovery but a good scientific debate would look very similar. Sad, huh? :)
 
There're two problems:
1. Where the samples are taken, and
2. Which of several techniques is used to determine the CO2 concentration in those samples.
The issue isn't with Beck. It's with the source papers he got his data from.

In many cases, it's impossible to determine precisely where the sample came from, or the sample was stated as taken from a location close to a city or other source of CO2; the CO2 count can be 100ppm higher in a city than the country a hundred miles away, but if the wind blows the right (wrong?) direction, the country location will suddenly gain 50ppm. You can't even put sensible error bars on that. All you can do is throw it out.

In most of the papers, the method is specified, but isn't the one that is used today, and those results therefore are unusable; the reason we use the one we use is because it's the most accurate. Furthermore, chemical tests to determine CO2 concentration are notoriously finicky, not least due to the possibility of contamination by the tester's breath. So, again, there's no good way to even assign error bars.

The 10ppm/yr delta is just a symptom of those problems. It's the clearest possible signal that there is something wrong with the data Beck used; the things that are wrong are above.
 


The method measuring CO2 today is much more accurate, but accuracy to 3% sounds good also. Beck (and his sources) discusses methods of chemical analysis, plus siting issues at length. From just one of the papers he cites is the analysis in the above picture.

I've seen nothing that adequately explains why all the "pre Mauna Loa" data should be thrown out, let alone why the ice core data should at the same time be thrown in...

Further, assume for a moment that you are absolutely correct - still, then, if one wished to validate 18th, 19th and early 20th century ice core data with "something"..... wouldn't it be the chemical atmospheric tests of CO2 per Beck? That is, after careful examination of them for relevance and with judicious discarding of ones that by the view of today's science, were invalidated.

Suppose that we thought the Mauna Loa data was "correct", and then go looking for historical data that "matches up" with it. We find some, use it, and toss out the other data.

Do you see a little problem there?
 
Plant stomata definitely shows more of a variation than ice core data, and the articles often comment on the "smoothed" ice core data, referring to the issues we were discussing earlier about ice cores and data quilting.

What is the relevance of this? Well, the question was simply, can we rely on ice core CO2 approximations for 19th and earlier 20th century CO2 levels? Are you looking for a source other than Beck?

No, I'm just asking the question because the ice core data could be experimentally biased. It makes no logical sense to make sweeping prediction in the face of contradictory data. From the speculation I've heard regarding GW, you'd think that the hypothesis would have reams of confirmatory data from various different sources.
 
Frankly, I wish I'd never stumbled on this thread. It's fairly sacrosanct that, if a scientist has a question they can answer themselves, they're beholden to do that. I read only a little and ran up against those four assumptions which, to me, are unreasonable. So, now I have to dig up the original report and "do the numbers".

My experience is that good science isn't pretty. You get a bunch of scientists in a room to discuss a nebulous point and you may as well order dinner. I can't tell you for sure that the mudslining you're watching is the process of discovery but a good scientific debate would look very similar. Sad, huh? :)
On the off chance I've misjudged you due to a combination of misstatements on your part, misunderstandings on mine, and our apparently mutually abrasive natures, and because a reasonable person never forgets the possibility they might be wrong, I'll make you an offer.

Just stop with all the ad homs and rhetorical tricks, and state the four assumptions you're having trouble with, clearly and concisely. I'll answer, clearly and in reasonable detail. If you have more questions, ask them. I'll answer as best I can. We'll forget all this BS, and move forward.

The ball's in your court. I doubt you have the stones for this, but I could be wrong. So here's your chance.
 
This is highly disingenuous and misleading.

Beck's study of historical CO2 levels did not cover the period of time that the Cape Grim and Mauna Loa data was taken. Cape Grim and Mauna Loa are accurate to each other and have nothing to do with prior historical Co2 concentrations.

I've drawn no conclusion from the linked data, only that it is remarkably coherent. Data from 1976-2004 is insufficient to make dramatic claims about anything but, say, ten years on either side. Also, the data don't disprove that atmospheric gases can change quickly as one would have to presuppose that such a change should be happening at the time. I've got to note that the slow increase of carbon dioxide concentration would be a factor against carbn dioxide being the driver of GW, wouldn't it?

There were more than 320 technical papers on air gas analysis from 1800 to 1961 containing verified data on atmospheric CO2 concentrations. Keeling and the IPCC discredit these techniques and data and in fact, the IPCC do not even mention them - historical revisionism at it's finest.

Hmm. 320 technical papers ignored? But that could be thousands to tens of thousands of contributors and researchers! :rolleyes: It's almost as if the number of people involved is not evidence of truth! Oh, woes!

Beck shows in his review article that for every decade from 1857 to the 1950s there are several measurement series with hundreds of precise data points.

Page 5, Beck's abbreviated paper.


It is easily seen that -
1. Atmospheric carbon dioxide fluctuates through 19th and 20th century contradicting the ice core reconstructions.​

2. In 20th century we notice one big maximum around 1942 with more than 420 ppm...​

3. CO2 Concentrations rise from 1880 to 1930 by some 20 ppm as Callender speculated in 1938​

4. Big maximas with an amplitude of 100 ppm like the one in the 40s should be easily reproduced with chemical means. (3%) This is not mentioned in modern literature.​

Keeping in mind the "sine-wave" ice core data that someone posted a while back, the comparatively slow rate of accumulation in the stats I just reported would signal that CO2 concentration is beginning to plateau, right? That is, if one would accept my data stitching here (which I don't).


If Beck is simply making obvious conclusions from over 130 published, peer reviewed studies, why fault the messenger? He provides all the data series for review. You are able then to look at the actual data and draw your own conclusions.

Here is the spreadsheet of the historical CO2 data.

Thanks. Something to play with tonight!
 
Becks paper isn't really that good is it?

Ignoring that it doesn't read like any journal paper I have read before. "I did this, then I did this..." etc. it just isn't very convincing.

He says this

The overall validity of the pattern of CO2 fluctuations is supported by the following considerations.

• Broad geographic coverage, with measuring stations spread throughout middleand northern Europe, USA, Atlantic ocean, Alaska, India and Antarctica.
• High data density: the 41 CO2 series used include about 70,000 discrete measurements, with the highest data density in the peak area between 1939 and 1942.
• The application of different accurate standard measuring systems with high accuracy of 2–3%, as designed by Krogh, Schuftan, van Slyke, Haldane, Scholander.
• Measurements were made by several different, highly competent experts: Buch [32], Haldane [70], Duerst [37], Kreutz [38], Scholander [40], Lockhart [84].
• Verified suitable locations of the measuring stations: no contamination is known from human or natural sources, e.g. conurbation, war, soil degassing, volcanic emissions.
• The Second World War cannot be responsible for the high values, because a rise in CO2 is exhibited from 1925 and culminating in 1942, and the second part of the maxima was recorded at places with no war activity (Alaska, India].
I think the one I have bolded is really the main point at issue here and it isn't a case he makes very well in his paper at all. Consider from his paper where he talks about modern methods of data capture.

CO2 measuring stations are distributed across the globe. Most, however, are located in coastal or island areas in order to obtain air without contamination from vegetation, organisms and industrial activity, i.e. to establish the so-called background level of CO2.
Now consider the location of one the sampling stations he highlights.

Giessen

http://www.biokurs.de/treibhaus/literatur/kreutz/Kreutz_english.pdf

Dubious as I am about anything that starts off with a title like, "Who was W. Kreutz in Gießen? or what’s wrong with atmospheric CO2?" and includes such gems as "In the conclusion the vague possible correlations are summed up," when it purports to be a translation of a journal paper, it does include a map of the site in question.

It doesn't seem to me to like it would be possible to "obtain air without contamination from vegetation, organisms and industrial activity, i.e. to establish the so-called background level of CO2."

The method of testing can be as accurate a way of assessing CO2 concentrations as you like. If your sample is contaminated it really doesn't matter. The data will be flawed and so analysis deriving from the data will also be flawed.

I don't think his paper demonstrates that "no contamination is known from human or natural sources, e.g. conurbation, war, soil degassing, volcanic emissions."

He goes on to say

The close relationship between temperature change and CO2 level exhibited by these results is consistent with a cause-effect relationship, but does not of itself indicate which of the two parameters is the cause and which the effect. The greenhouse hypothesis of IPCC argues for CO2 being the cause (through radiative feedback) of the temperature rise. My results are equally if not more consistent with temperature being the forcing that controls the level of CO2 in the atmospheric system. In support of this causality, ice-core data consistently shows that over climatic time scales, changes in temperature precede their parallel changes in carbon dioxide by several hundred to more than a thousand years [91].
So he thinks he has found a cause effect relationship between CO2 and temperature. But, of course CO2 can not drive temperature so he decides that it must be the other way around, he doesn't say why his conclusion is "equally or more consistent" than that of the alternative, but he does then bring up data from ice cores to support his view, even though he has been trying to discredit ice cores for the last 20 odd pages. So we see that ice cores are good enough when you can use them to make your own case look stronger, but otherwise they are fraught with problems and inaccuracies.

I might be missing some finer point here, or perhaps he is talking nonsense and hoping people don't realise.

In his conclusion he states that

The historical data that I have considered to be reliable can, of course, be challenged on the grounds that they represent local measurements only, and are therefore not representative on a global scale. Strong evidence that this is not the case, and that the composite historical CO2 curve is globally meaningful, comes from the correspondence between the curve and other global phenomena, including both sunspot cycles and the moon phases, the latter presented here probably first time in literature and the average global temperature statistic. Furthermore, that the historical data are reliable in themselves is supported by the credible seasonal, monthly and daily variations that they display, the pattern of which corresponds with modern measurements. It is indeed surprising that the quality and accuracy of these historic CO2 measurements has escaped the attention of other researchers.
Here he argues that his curve is globally meaningful. His argument doesn't really make much sense to me. I'm not convinced I followed how he made his curve that well, but...The accuracy of the data taken at those locations could be as high as he likes but it doesn't follow that he can then say that those values are then globally significant.

I could probably take temperature measurements of the air surrounding the gas hob in my kitchen. I would be able to see cycles that correspond to other activities in the house, but to then say that the temperature of the air around the hob can be thought of as a proxy for the air temperature inside my house is nonsense. I think that is the kind of thing that he is trying to do. If he isn't doing that then I am willing to be corrected.
 
The method measuring CO2 today is much more accurate, but accuracy to 3% sounds good also.
Does it? That's 10ppm.

Beck (and his sources) discusses methods of chemical analysis, plus siting issues at length. From just one of the papers he cites is the analysis in the above picture.

I've seen nothing that adequately explains why all the "pre Mauna Loa" data should be thrown out, let alone why the ice core data should at the same time be thrown in...
Have a look at this, from 1985. Then take a look at this image, which was of an apparatus used, if you can imagine it, in 1955 (that is not a typo, nineteen fifty-five) to take air samples. Do you notice any problems with it?

As for the ice core data, the methods used are impeccable, and are treated here. A gas chromatograph was used, and was calibrated before and after each measurement. The dating was equally careful.

I hate to be the one to break it to you, but Beck asserts that CO2 varies with the phase of the Moon. Oops.

Further, assume for a moment that you are absolutely correct - still, then, if one wished to validate 18th, 19th and early 20th century ice core data with "something"..... wouldn't it be the chemical atmospheric tests of CO2 per Beck? That is, after careful examination of them for relevance and with judicious discarding of ones that by the view of today's science, were invalidated.
Careful examination of the sources Callendar used (and you'll note, if you read the paper I linked above, that From and Keeling were given access to Callendar's notebooks, and made extensive use of the data there) yielded one series that, after being vetted using wind speed and direction criteria, just barely showed the seasonal variations we know CO2 has in the atmosphere due to plant growth during the spring and summer, and dormancy during the fall and winter. One. And Callendar looked far afield, and even then he was able to find only five sources he believed; and it looks like he was not skeptical enough on four of them.

I don't think you're quite clear on how precise modern methods are compared to older ones. It's literally night and day.

Suppose that we thought the Mauna Loa data was "correct", and then go looking for historical data that "matches up" with it. We find some, use it, and toss out the other data.

Do you see a little problem there?
Are you saying that's what From and Keeler did? In 1985? And what reputable source do you cite that says that there is a problem with the Mauna Loa Observatory data?
 
I don't think you're quite clear on how precise modern methods are compared to older ones. It's literally night and day.

What we're expected to accept, if we go by Beck (people really do that?) is that CO2 used to fluctuate wildly until we could measure it accurately and then settled down. From 10ppm/yr up or down to a few ppm/yr upwards. This despite the increasing consumption of fossil-fuels year-on-year and resulting injections of CO2 into the atmosphere - more CO2 than is represented in those few ppm.

It's all rather silly, isn't it? Ludicrous. Incredible, even. Of course, when credulity meets the incredible, credulity always wins out.

Beck. This is what they've come to. In comparison even Singer has some substance.
 
From 10ppm/yr up or down to a few ppm/yr upwards. This despite the increasing consumption of fossil-fuels year-on-year and resulting injections of CO2 into the atmosphere - more CO2 than is represented in those few ppm.

Please elaborate. I'm not getting your argument.
 
I got it, CD.

Here's the deal, ST: if you believe Beck, then you believe that CO2 was fluctuating all the time, up and down, 10ppm/yr, up until we started accurately measuring it, at which point it magically settled down and started increasing by a couple ppm per year, steadily, with no major fluctuations.

Now, how likely is that?
 
This is highly disingenuous and misleading.

Beck's study of historical CO2 levels did not cover the period of time that the Cape Grim and Mauna Loa data was taken.

Indeed not, Beck takes refuge in history before accuracy and consistency were well-established.

Cape Grim and Mauna Loa are accurate to each other and have nothing to do with prior historical Co2 concentrations.

Nor do they, but they do tell us a lot about the rate of variation in CO2-load when measured accurately and consistently. Upshot is, they don't vary wildly.

Data series covered by Beck's study end in 1961, and includes work done by several Nobel prize winners (Krogh 1923, Warburg 1933) as well as Benedict, nominated for the Nobel prize in 1923.

Krogh got a Nobel Prize in Physiology and Medicine. Or are we talking about a different Krogh?

Argument from authority or what? Weaselling is what it is - not yours, Beck's, you just report it.

There were more than 320 technical papers on air gas analysis from 1800 to 1961 containing verified ...

Verified? Can anything really be said to be verified?

... data on atmospheric CO2 concentrations. Keeling and the IPCC discredit these techniques and data and in fact, the IPCC do not even mention them - historical revisionism at it's finest.

How does the IPCC both discredit and not mention this data? As to "historical revisionism" - have you been talking to Diamond recently? He was always well keen on that phrase.

Beck shows in his review article that for every decade from 1857 to the 1950s there are several measurement series with hundreds of precise data points.

No he doesn't. Unless he defines his own "precision". What is that, 3%? Compared to what?

You're an easy mark for precision when it says precisely what you want to hear.




It is easily seen that -
1. Atmospheric carbon dioxide fluctuates through 19th and 20th century contradicting the ice core reconstructions.​
2. In 20th century we notice one big maximum around 1942 with more than 420 ppm...​
3. CO2 Concentrations rise from 1880 to 1930 by some 20 ppm as Callender speculated in 1938​
4. Big maximas with an amplitude of 100 ppm like the one in the 40s should be easily reproduced with chemical means. (3%) This is not mentioned in modern literature.​

As to 1, I wouldn't make much of ice-cores for the last century myself. Gases can percolate through snow; it's only when snow gets deep enough to be compacted into ice that trapped gasses are immobilised. Thus the time-resolution of ice-cores is about 60-80 years. That said, the percolation is very slow so there's something to learnt from 20thCE ice-cores. Just not too much.

As to 2, 420ppm sixty years ago is laughable. That would be represented in modern ice-cores, for one thing, and for another : where did it come from, where did it go, and why? If Beck's data shows this it shows Beck's data for what it is. Self-serving BS.

As to 3, I have to ask, why does Callender speculate while Beck shows? I fear you've spent so much time amongst them that you've become (all unknowingly) infected with weaselism.

As to 4, it makes no sense to me. What chemical means, except the burning of fossil-fuels at an even more alarming rate than currently? What the heck was going on back in the 40's that nobody noticed? Admittedly there was a lot of anthropogenetic stuff that demanded attention but all the same somebody would surely have noticed whatever was behind it. Beck doesn't even speculate on what it was. It just happened.

If Beck is simply making obvious conclusions from over 130 published, peer reviewed studies, why fault the messenger?

Beck's not the messenger, nor are his conclusions obvious. His message is of his own manufacture and he calls in evidence 130 studies to try and give it some substance. Just as he calls in evidence the number of Nobel Prize winners involved.

You believe this guy? You believe that those 130 studies are what Beck searched out before he made his message, rather than searched out afterwards to give spurious substance to his nonsense?

He provides all the data series for review. You are able then to look at the actual data and draw your own conclusions.

Here is the spreadsheet of the historical CO2 data.

Well there's a thing.

The data series have been reviewed, Callender did that as best he could. Beck just takes everything from before the modern measurement era unquestioningly. The modern era he ... avoids. You may call it scientiofic diligence. Taking refuge in the past, I calls it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom