science fraud is common place

Language can be used to harass, bully, and defame. On the one hand, why isn't justintime decrying that? And on the other hand, it demonstrates that knowledge per se and the willingness to use knowledge immorally are two separate concepts that justintime insists on conflating.


We're keeping track of them for him. We've been constantly reminding him of the blatant contradictions in his own posts, but so far no reconciliation has appeared.

Exactly right Jay but we differ on one point; you hold that he is doing so by error and mis-judgment while I hold he is doing so deliberately.

I really think he should give up language as it is obviously scientist tainted.....
 
Last edited:
Exactly right Jay but we differ on one point; you hold that he is doing so by error and mis-judgment while I hold he is doing so deliberately.

I really think he should give up language as it is obviously scientist tainted.....

I'm still trying to figure out how those scientists bumbling around aimlessly in their dirty labs doing the same thing over and over managed to come up with all these world destroying devices.
 
That's just the same sort of devoid-of-fact rant you've been writing here yourself, only this-time penned by someone else and linked to by you. It doesn't address a single point in my post, especially the part where your own line of reasoning refutes itself. No link can save you from logical contradiction.

Please try again.



That doesn't mean those concerns are correct, fairly considered and stated, or have any fact to support them.

Now please address my actual points, not just randomly link to people who agree with you.

You point has been addressed. Science is affecting every aspect of our lives and what appears as benefits of science are short term benefits because they all end up poisoning our food, air and planet. Scientists are engineers of death.
Read the link again.
Human race being terminated by 'scientific suicide'
http://www.naturalnews.com/035790_scientific_suicide_humans.html#
 
I'm still trying to figure out how those scientists bumbling around aimlessly in their dirty labs doing the same thing over and over managed to come up with all these world destroying devices.

Hey, when you're good, you're good. ;)

justintime said:
Science is affecting every aspect of our lives and what appears as benefits of science are short term benefits because they all end up poisoning our food, air and planet. Scientists are engineers of death.
First, this has been repeatedly shown to be wrong. Second, even if this were true the solution wouldn't be "abandon science", it would be for science to explore how to mitigate the impacts of these unintended consequences.
 
I'm still trying to figure out how those scientists bumbling around aimlessly in their dirty labs doing the same thing over and over managed to come up with all these world destroying devices.

They got a little help from engineers.
 
To sit in a modern house, with electricity and modern plumbing, never having starved in once life, not needing to fear epidemics and writing on once computer on the internet that science is bad is a bit rich imo. (That sentence should be shot. :))

But to play the game. I think science have been a very bad thing. For almost all other species than humans that is. Our success have been a disaster for most other species.
 
You point has been addressed.

No, it hasn't. I pointed out how your "wrong hands" line of reasoning contradicts your "scientists are the evil party" claim.

You have not reconciled that line of reasoning. Please do so now.

Read the link again.

I have already addressed the content of this link. Either address my rebuttal of it or concede the point. Do not simply repeat rebutted claims unaltered.
 
They got a little help from engineers.

Nope.

Although I disagree, you argue strenuously that scientists and engineers are not the same thing. But now you're placing the blame for "destructive" ends on the engineers, not the scientists. So which is it?

In any case, you missed your critic's point; he's asking you how and undirected "tinkering" approach to innovation, as opposed to a systematic scientific approach, could ever have resulted in the tools you seem so destructive on a wide scale. In your argument, scientists are simultaneously evil genius and fraudulent bumpkins. You can't have it both ways.
 
Exactly right Jay but we differ on one point; you hold that he is doing so by error and mis-judgment while I hold he is doing so deliberately.

Well, I don't really "hold" anything since the rules compel us not to speculate on the person or motives of the claimants. While I may have personal beliefs on those points, the only acceptable approach on JREF is to assume the claimant is sincere. Hence that's the basis from which I try to write my responses.
 
But to play the game. I think science have been a very bad thing. For almost all other species than humans that is. Our success have been a disaster for most other species.

Not really. Some have lost out, sure, but others have thrived (and not just the domesticated ones--rodents, snakes, insects, and weads are doing quite well). It's all part of a mass extinction event that began 10,000 years ago; to blame it all on science is to deny the data.
 
justintime, I am also anxious to hear your answer to my question regarding your categorical argument that scientists focus only on the destruction of life.

I asked if you would be willing to make that accusation directly to those of us here who fit the category of "scientist," and stand by it. If you accept me, or Dinwar, or both of us as practicing scientists of one ilk or another, then you should be able to provide specific evidence particular to either of us that we have focused our careers on destruction.

I consider this a reasonable request because a categorical argument must, by definition, touch all the members of the category. If it cannot be shown to hold for all members, then it cannot be a categorical argument. And if it is not a categorical argument, then you must concede that science may be composed of proportions of well-intentioned and ill-intentioned people. Then, if you argue they are mostly ill-intentioned, you bear the burden to show this demographically.

I agree that talk is cheap when making categorical claims. Therefore I'm "calling out" your categorical argument and asking you to substantiate it.
 
Not really. Some have lost out, sure, but others have thrived (and not just the domesticated ones--rodents, snakes, insects, and weads are doing quite well). It's all part of a mass extinction event that began 10,000 years ago; to blame it all on science is to deny the data.

Oh I do not blame anything on science, science is a very good method to find better ways to do what one want to do. What I am implying is that humans are so successful that the habitat for most other species are a lot smaller. We where successful before we invented the scientific method but it certainly have helped us immensely in conquering the planet, and as a result our competitors suffer.
 
It's all part of a mass extinction event that began 10,000 years ago; to blame it all on science is to deny the data.

And if my recollection of prehistory serves me, this isn't the only mass extinction event for which we have evidence. The point being, you can't lay all ill at the hands of Homo sapiens, and especially at a professionally-identified subset of them.

Nor, if I recall modern history correctly, can you lay even H. sapiens-caused catastrophe at the feet of science. I recall hearing how some parties of aboriginal American Indians would run entire herds of buffalo off cliffs etc. to obtain only a fraction of the produce. The rest were left to rot. Not something we'd approve of today, and no science required to accomplish it. I don't intend this as a racist argument, obviously, but as an illustration of human nature. We are not by nature a kind, benevolent race led only to the depravity of destruction by the wiles of "science."

justintime constantly conflates broader issues of human nature with the comparatively narrow concept of systematic scientific inquiry.
 
Last edited:
No, it hasn't. I pointed out how your "wrong hands" line of reasoning contradicts your "scientists are the evil party" claim.

You have not reconciled that line of reasoning. Please do so now.



I have already addressed the content of this link. Either address my rebuttal of it or concede the point. Do not simply repeat rebutted claims unaltered.

There were no weapons of mass destruction before scientists invented them. Einstein was the first to suggest nuclear chain reaction could be used to construct a bomb, a very powerful bomb.

It is not the weapons of mass destruction ending in the wrong hands that is the only problem. It is scientists using science to invent weapons of mass destruction to give their government an edge in the rush to dominate. It is also scientists using the science for profit and ignoring the harmful side effects of their inventions.

Scientists are also involved in the proliferation of the technology that creates weapons of mass destruction. Countries like N`Kores, Iran, Pakistan etc have scientists that are actively engaged in developing weapons of mass destruction for their government. It is the scientists that should be held accountable for unleashing such destructive technology and making the world a less safer place for all.
 
I think we are dealing with a Luddite here, folks............

Most of his arguments seem to be those commonly made by the Neo-Luddites. The original Luddites feared technology because they feared it would displace them and wreck their livelihoods. Neo-Luddites, in contrast, have a far broader fear of modern technology, and for reasons that aren't purely economical or selfish. However, most Neo-Luddite claims are not as dogmatic as justintimes'.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom