science fraud is common place

Diseases are just trying to thrive and survive. ;)

As are other species, as are other tribes of Homo sapiens. justintime's most broken premise is the notion that without some segment of the human species, every organism on the planet would live in peace and harmony without aggression or harm. He identifies that segment as scientists, and science alone. That's just silly.
 
The diseases are still there, scientists just keep them out the door. Such inhospitable people, those scientists.
Poor diseases :rolleyes:
 
So what does all of this "EVIL PRODUCTS OF SCIENCE" business have to do with the supposed commonness of fraud in the scientific community?
 
Based on his posts above, I believe this is what justintime actually wants to have happen. If so, that would be completely unrealistic.

...and this would allow for a complete and unthinking re-acceptance of whatever version of religion he says he believes in.

It is that which I believe is the reason for his illogical rants against science.

Nuclear weapons have also ended the nightmare of large scale alliance warfare. Think of what Stalin would have done if NATO and the US had not had nuclear weapons in the later 40's and early 50's.
 
Last edited:
So what does all of this "EVIL PRODUCTS OF SCIENCE" business have to do with the supposed commonness of fraud in the scientific community?

Good question -- arguably nothing, since I've asked justintime to reconcile whether scientists are unsucessful because of fraud, or successful and evil and I get no answer.

The way I interpret it, he originally meant to argue that science was a fraud only as a proxy argument to the larger accusation that scientists were immoral. Fraudulently pursuing your profession would indeed be immoral. Faced with an inability to reconcile the fraudulence of science with its visible success in practical terms, he seems to have shifted gears to argue differently that scientists are immoral, in this case because they aim to destroy life with their creations.

A simpler way to say that is that maybe, given how justintime has evolved his claim, the thread is too narrowly titled.
 
There were no tools of mass destruction until scientists began to invent them.....their focus have always been on the destruction of life.

It is truly amazing how many more people are living longer and healthier lives since the tools of mass destruction were invented. It is a real shame that you cannot see that.
 
It is truly amazing how many more people are living longer and healthier lives since the tools of mass destruction were invented. It is a real shame that you cannot see that.

It appears that he considers every beneficial act of innovation to be mere unguided, inevitable "tinkering" or else a product of nature. Intentional innovation according to the scientific method, according to him, seems to produce only destruction.

Yeah, basically it's a Neo-Luddite argument taken to an extreme, taking everything beneficial for granted.
 
To equate mass extinction with weapons of mass destruction is ridiculous.

Why ? Both kill large number of beings.

Natural disasters are less likely to annihilate the planet than an all out nuclear war.

False. It's the opposite.

The world will be a better place without weapons of mass destruction and scientists that invented them.

You think the cold war would've remained cold if the USSR and USA didn't have a dreadful fear of nuclear fallout ?
 
Based on his posts above, I believe this is what justintime actually wants to have happen. If so, that would be completely unrealistic.

The return to an agrarian economy is the political goal of a handful of small Maoist communist groups in the Bengal area. They are a legacy (after receiving late 20th century support) from Maoist (return to agrarianism) movements in Burma and Cambodia.

Very similar arguments to those being made here, have been made on the Skeptic Society forum, by a member of such a group. The only unique thing appears to be Justintime's dislike for Carl Sagan.
 
The world will be a better place without weapons of mass destruction and scientists that invented them. Countries can revert to throwing stones and spears at each other or putting up with the common flu.

Where is the rationale funding research only to have the product be the destruction of mankind and the scientists no wiser for it.

Speaking about mass destruction. We are over 7 billion humans on the planet. You are dreaming about a society that can perhaps feed a few hundreds millions.... No it just stroke me. You are just sherry picking what scientific advances would remain. Or you have a very romantic picture about life before science. It seems to me that you do not have a beef with science. You really do have a beef with human nature. Scientists developed WMDs yes. But it is more fair to say humans did. Since scientists could not have done it on their own.
 
Some pages back JiT was rejecting claims that science could take credit for any inventions; now suddenly they've invented every source of evil in the world. Consistency is not his strong suit.
 
Some pages back JiT was rejecting claims that science could take credit for any inventions; now suddenly they've invented every source of evil in the world. Consistency is not his strong suit.

If the end result is that science cannot hold perception of reliably contradicting my favourite creation myths then all is good.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom