science fraud is common place

JayUtah said:
And if my recollection of prehistory serves me, this isn't the only mass extinction event for which we have evidence.
Nope. This is the latest in 5, 6, or 7 mass extinctions (depending on how you count them). And whether this one started with humans is an open question. I've seen evidence for the Overkill Hypothesis, but I've also seen evidence against it. Personally, I don't think the data are sufficient to draw conclusions at this point.

justintime said:
There were no weapons of mass destruction before scientists invented them.
Never the less, the K/Pg event involved the death of a huge portion of life on Earth. As an aside, it was also an order of magnitude or so greater than human destructive potential at this time.

It is not the weapons of mass destruction ending in the wrong hands that is the only problem. It is scientists using science to invent weapons of mass destruction to give their government an edge in the rush to dominate.
The nuclear bomb was developed by the USA in large part to PREVENT domination. You'll note that Germany and Japan are independent countries (Germany was working on a nuclear bomb).

Scientists are also involved in the proliferation of the technology that creates weapons of mass destruction.
As well as those involved in life-saving technologies. These are often the same thing. Abuse does not negate use, and you are ignoring the benefits of science for idiological reasons.
 
It is the scientists that should be held accountable for unleashing such destructive technology and making the world a less safer place for all.
Why are you doing complaining about it here? Get on the stick. Make a megaphone out of some cardboard and get to a highway median and shout it out loud.

You can take donations in a pencil cup.
 
Not really. Some have lost out, sure, but others have thrived (and not just the domesticated ones--rodents, snakes, insects, and weads are doing quite well). It's all part of a mass extinction event that began 10,000 years ago; to blame it all on science is to deny the data.

To equate mass extinction with weapons of mass destruction is ridiculous. Natural disasters are less likely to annihilate the planet than an all out nuclear war.
 
To equate mass extinction with weapons of mass destruction is ridiculous. Natural disasters are less more likely to annihilate the planet than an all out nuclear war.
Fixed that for you. As I said, the K/Pg event was more destructive than anything humans today can do, by an order of magnitude. That's not getting into things like gama ray bursts and the like.
 
Nope. This is the latest in 5, 6, or 7 mass extinctions (depending on how you count them). And whether this one started with humans is an open question. I've seen evidence for the Overkill Hypothesis, but I've also seen evidence against it. Personally, I don't think the data are sufficient to draw conclusions at this point.

Never the less, the K/Pg event involved the death of a huge portion of life on Earth. As an aside, it was also an order of magnitude or so greater than human destructive potential at this time.

The nuclear bomb was developed by the USA in large part to PREVENT domination. You'll note that Germany and Japan are independent countries (Germany was working on a nuclear bomb).

As well as those involved in life-saving technologies. These are often the same thing. Abuse does not negate use, and you are ignoring the benefits of science for idiological reasons.

The world will be a better place without weapons of mass destruction and scientists that invented them. Countries can revert to throwing stones and spears at each other or putting up with the common flu.

Where is the rationale funding research only to have the product be the destruction of mankind and the scientists no wiser for it.
 
Last edited:
To equate mass extinction with weapons of mass destruction is ridiculous.

Why? You're laying the blame for the potential extinction of all life solely at the feet of some small group of humans, and saying that this huge unrealized potential alone makes them worthy of your contempt. But you are unable to place those hypothetical effects alongside similar actual effects that aren't caused by your chosen whipping-boy and talk about the risk.

Basically what we do with this rebuttal is look past your hysterical doomsaying and put it in a more appropriate and less sensationalist context.

Natural disasters are less likely to annihilate the planet than an all out nuclear war.

Nonsense. Go study up on the NNSA; there is simply not enough nuclear weaponry out there to "annihilate the planet."

Further, nuclear war comes with the option not to do it, which is why -- although there are many countries with nuclear weapons -- it has not occurred for the better part of a century despite widespread aggression and military action.

In contrast, go stand on a beach and try to reason with the tsunami that killed 250,000 people.
 
The world will be a better place without weapons of mass destruction and scientists that invented them. Countries can revert to throwing stones and spears at each other or putting up with the common flu.

Where is the rationale funding research only to have the product be the destruction of mankind and the scientists no wise for it.

We could do all that, but then we'd be less efficient at it.

As a gunner, I appreciate the accuracy of precision guided munitions, that allow me to bring 45kg high explosive shells down on targets 40km away with a PER smaller than the size of the average minivan.

And I thank the scientists and engineers that make that possible.
 
The world will be a better place without weapons of mass destruction and scientists that invented them. Countries can revert to throwing stones and spears at each other or putting up with the common flu.

Where is the rationale funding research only to have the product be the destruction of mankind and the scientists no wiser for it.

Except that that's not what would happen. What would happen is that all of these principles and bombs would still exist--only no one would know how they work. The idea that the worst diseae we'd suffer is the common flu is nonsense; lepors have existed for as long as humanity has, and it's only science that allows them to live today. Same with the Plague.

What is the sense of denying reality? You have all the risks, but none of the benefits. If you study reality you run some risks, but the benefits are absolutely awe-inspiring.
 
The world will be a better place without weapons of mass destruction and scientists that invented them.

Apples and oranges. I agree the world would be better off without weapons of mass destruction. I do not agree that the world would be better off without scientists, for the reasons abundantly mentioned in this thread. Nor do I agree that the only function of scientists is to facilitate destruction -- a claim you have made but absolutely refuse to support with anything other that tedious accusation.

Countries can revert to throwing stones and spears at each other or putting up with the common flu.

The "common flu" of 1918 was a huge pandemic that was so severe it ended a world war. In fact it killed more people than the war it ended, which war also included weapons of "mass destruction" such as chemical and biological warfare. Science fervently aims to do away with such detrimental natural occurrences, but this absolutely does not factor into your one-sided thinking.

Where is the rationale funding research only to have the product be the destruction of mankind and the scientists no wiser for it.

Asked and answered. You already conceded that science is amoral, and that the moral agency instead lies elsewhere, in "the wrong hands." You apparently have no plans to reconcile that glaring contradiction in your condemnation instead of scientists.

"Only to have," is not how the facts actually work out, but rather only your completely myopic and hypocritical way of looking at what science does.
 
Except that that's not what would happen. What would happen is that all of these principles and bombs would still exist--only no one would know how they work. The idea that the worst diseae we'd suffer is the common flu is nonsense; lepors have existed for as long as humanity has, and it's only science that allows them to live today. Same with the Plague.

What is the sense of denying reality? You have all the risks, but none of the benefits. If you study reality you run some risks, but the benefits are absolutely awe-inspiring.

That is why natural remedies are gaining popularity. It has all the benefits and none of the risks.

It is not denying reality. The world being created according to science and scientists is very real but unacceptable and the disastrous ending must be averted..
 
Except that that's not what would happen.

Nor is justintime's suggestion even remotely achievable. You cannot simply will the world to revert, or even to materially change itself. A "pie-in-the-sky" suggestion as an alternative to the "evil" technological world we live in isn't a tenable argument.

Further, an abolishment of science and technology would return us to subsistence farming, with its attendant starvation. It would renew all the diseases and maladies presently under medical control, allowing them once again to decimate the planet. We would get to enjoy plagues and pestilences, only this time starting with orders of magnitude more population. Without modern chemistry, our cities would soon choke in the toxicity of their own natural waste products -- poop kills too, you know.

Alternatives like, "Why can't we all just get along?" or "Why can't we just lead the simple life our forebears did?" are naive proposals. Humans don't naturally get along; we're tribal people and no amount of wishing otherwise changes that. And our forebears didn't think their lives were so great -- that's why they (like us) were constantly trying to improve it, through science.
 
That is why natural remedies are gaining popularity. It has all the benefits and none of the risks.

No, natural remedies do not have all the benefits and do not avoid all the risks. How many purveyors of "natural remedies" have been convicted as frauds? There are particular cases. Yet you let this fraud pass, and search for imaginary fraud on someone else's part.

The world being created according to science and scientists is very real but unacceptable and the disastrous ending must be averted..

You accept it. Unless you're living in a cave somewhere and not posting this on a computer, you hypocritically accept the benefits science gives you. If you want to avert a disaster, go after the people you identify as "the wrong hands." They're the ones who are misusing whatever is at their disposal for immoral ends. They have always been around, and they're the real enemy.

Again, what argument of yours, if any, amounts to anything more than, "I hate scientists"?
 
That is why natural remedies are gaining popularity. It has all the benefits and none of the risks.

It is not denying reality. The world being created according to science and scientists is very real but unacceptable and the disastrous ending must be averted..

Natural remedies do work, but very often not as well as the synthetic remedies that we make. Why? Consistency. We know the concentration of the chemicals that go into our synthetic remedies and the concentration of those similar chemicals in naturally occuring herbs, etc. is wildly variable from plant to plant, and often within the plant itself. This why my gruits (a style of beer that does not use hops) taste different from batch to batch, even with using the same ingredients and herbs - the concentrations of some of the chemicals in the plants are different than those picked just a few metres away, or at a different time of year and that yields different tastes.
 
If it was not for science we would be still living in a precarious totally agrarian society with all its attendant backwardness and early death because of malnutrition and lack of modern medicines to combat disease.
 
If it was not for science we would be still living in a precarious totally agrarian society with all its attendant backwardness and early death because of malnutrition and lack of modern medicines to combat disease.

Based on his posts above, I believe this is what justintime actually wants to have happen. If so, that would be completely unrealistic.
 
There were no weapons of mass destruction before scientists invented them. Einstein was the first to suggest nuclear chain reaction could be used to construct a bomb, a very powerful bomb.

It is not the weapons of mass destruction ending in the wrong hands that is the only problem. It is scientists using science to invent weapons of mass destruction to give their government an edge in the rush to dominate. It is also scientists using the science for profit and ignoring the harmful side effects of their inventions.

Scientists are also involved in the proliferation of the technology that creates weapons of mass destruction. Countries like N`Kores, Iran, Pakistan etc have scientists that are actively engaged in developing weapons of mass destruction for their government. It is the scientists that should be held accountable for unleashing such destructive technology and making the world a less safer place for all.

So the scientists should be held responsible for developing WMDs. Then it follows that politicians should be responsible for ordering them. The engineers for designing them. The workers for building them. And the taxpayers for paying for them. It is time to face fact. We are a violent species. If we as a species where not, we would not put so much effort in developing ways to kill and destroy. But to blame that human trait on a single profession is childish.
 
But to blame that human trait on a single profession is childish.

Indeed, that's the spine of my dispute with justintime's new moralist bent. Argue, if you will, that humankind is at times self-destructive, petty, vindictive, competitive, ruthless, territorial, and immoral. I won't contest that. Pin that on only one segment of the species, and I'll dispute that. Pin it on the one that I inhabit, and I'll contest it vigorously.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom