science fraud is common place

justintime said:
Dinwar, your view and opinion of scientists support the stereo type that scientists are self absolved in their research and may know very little outside of their chosen field and have an even poorer understanding of science itself.
As I have demonstrated, it only does this if you dishonestly remove my statements from their context and distort their intended meaning.

That is why the number of retractions are increasing.
You've yet to show this is the case.

It also helps the public to understand why peer-review oversight fails
You have yet to demonstrate that this is the case. To be clear, the errors in knowledge of history I was discussing were highly technical, and not the type of stuff you'd expect to come into play in day-to-day scientific activity. The explanation I provided was intended to demonstrate that. This has NOTHING AT ALL to do with any percieved failures of peer review.

So how can they expose fraudulent papers when scientific knowledge is so limited/restrictive for each individual scientist.
Trivially easily. They can expose errors in reasoning, errors in experimental design, contradictions with other papers, other papers that the author has not considered, etc. You don't need to know about de Vrise' primrose experiments to do genetic studies; it only becomes a factor when you attempt to evaluate the strength of various theories, because that DOES involve deep knowledge of the history of the evidence for each.

You also highlight the flawed trust in the self correcting obligation researchers have in the pursuit of knowledge.
I did no such thing.

But the limitations of the peer review process becomes apparent because it still ends up a small handful of people making these determinations.
That's such an egregious misrepresentation of what I've said that it cannot be a simple misinterpretation; it's a lie. I said if a proposed method for evaluating the strength of support for theories was adopted a small number of people would have too much control over that process. I was saying that specifically to argue in favor of the current method, where each researcher acts as an independent (essentially) check for each theory they encounter.

And finally the public will agree most of the science fraud that is so common is because what the scientists are practicing is not science, it is politics.
Again, this is such an egregious misrepresentation that it's a flat-out lie. I said that if a proposed method for evaluating the strength of support for theories was adopted the results would be a politica, not scientific process. I said that specifically in support of the current paradigm, which consists of scientific debate with each researcher reaching their own conclusions.

No one is disagreeing with your analysis.
Not true; obviously the person proposing the evaluation method does, as I was criticizing their method. That said, you have not represented what I've said. You've lied about it, pure and simple.
 
Dinwar, your view and opinion of scientists support the stereo type that scientists are self absolved in their research and may know very little outside of their chosen field and have an even poorer understanding of science itself.

He repudiated this interpretation of his post. Do not simply repeat the same misrepresentations.

That is why the number of retractions are increasing.

Assumes facts not in evidence.

It also helps the public to understand why peer-review oversight fails...

You have not shown that peer review fails in a way that dismisses it as a valuable tool in the furtherance of science. You have merely posted a popular article showing one person who has given anecdotal evidence of peer review failure, then speculated on how that might extrapolate to the entire field.

...because those on the board according to you "are generally ignorant of the history of their fields, let alone anyone else's."

None of this is required in order to perform an effective peer review. Do not simply attempt to rewrite the practice of science to be the caricature of it that you need in order for your beliefs to hold. Deal with science as it is actually taught and practiced, not how you fervently wish it to be.

So how can they expose fraudulent papers when scientific knowledge is so limited/restrictive for each individual scientist.

Knowledge of the philosophy of science is not required in order to perform an effective peer review. Knowledge of the history of the specific field is not required. What is required is knowledge of the current practices and methods used in the specific field in which one is a peer. None of that is contradicted by Dinwar's post, which you are increasingly having to stretch to fit your arguments.

But the limitations of the peer review process becomes apparent because it still ends up a small handful of people making these determinations.

No. Peer review is merely the gateway to publication. After publication, each individual treatise is forever subject to review and revision by the entire scientific community. That's how science works. Peer review does not guarantee that the science is correct, only that it is suitable for publication where it will likely be seen and tested by other competent practitioners.

And finally the public will agree most of the science fraud that is so common is...

You are not empowered to speak on behalf of the public. You have not proven that scientific fraud is "common," or even occurs in a noteworthy rate.

...because what the scientists are practicing is not science, it is politics.

No. You are desperately trying to style science as a political pursuit, likely because your objection to it and arguments against it are political in nature -- or at best ideological and not factual. You have deployed a number of dissimilar arguments having as their only common point some emotionally-laden reason to dismiss science and besmirch scientists. Just because you mount a political attack doesn't mean the defense against it must presume your political premise.

No one is disagreeing with your analysis.

Nice try. This is you attempting to spin his post to serve your needs. He has said on a number of occasions that he does not support your view. He has gone further to show in sufficient detail how you warped his meaning and misrepresented his statements. Do not continue to pretend Dinwar agrees with you or endorses your claims -- he patently does not.

It is your analysis with which there is broad disagreement here, and you are doing a fairly effective job of ignoring almost all that disagreement.
 
Dinwar, your view and opinion of scientists support the stereo type that scientists are self absolved in their research and may know very little outside of their chosen field and have an even poorer understanding of science itself.

Only if you completely misunderstand everything that other posters tell you.
 
Most scientists who develop chemicals are very careful to delineate safe handling procedures for those chemicals.

I guess if we're going down the rathole of the moralist argument, we might as well do it right. We've gone from "scientists are frauds" to "scientists are immoral," which isn't quite the same thing. The general argument I'm seeing, then, is "scientists are bad people" -- which entails proving that they're any number of types of bad people.

Those of us who use science to develop useful things are bound by an obligation to protect the public from harm arising out of their use or misuse. Especially in the United States, the law goes to great lengths to hold us accountable, even often for things that aren't strictly our fault.

But the bottom line is that the ability to use scientific methods to gain knowledge and to produce novel things that work is only slightly connected to the ethics of how others may eventually use them. Nearly everything I contemplate has a possible beneficial use and a possible nefarious use. A shovel can be a useful garden tool, or a weapon in the hands of a murderer. It is irresponsible to hold the inventor of the shovel responsible for how others use it outside his control.

"Scientists are immoral because they commit fraud," would be an on-topic argument. "Scientists are immoral because they produce harmful things," is a wholly different argument. Earlier, the line of reasoning was that scientists can't be praised for doing great things with their science because scientists don't actually produce anything of consequence. That's an allusion to the "ivory tower" dismissal of science as a useful pursuit. But now, if one argues that scientists harm the world (and are thus immoral), that argument contains the premise that what scientists do actually has material consequence. Scientists are either inconsequential or harmful -- they can't be both.

So I see this as a pretty hefty flip-flop in the argument.
 
JayUtah said:
A shovel can be a useful garden tool, or a weapon in the hands of a murderer. It is irresponsible to hold the inventor of the shovel responsible for how others use it outside his control.
This is a fantastic example. In WWI, many countries contemplated giving their soldiers shovels instead of daggers as bayonettes, because shovels had more mass and were therefore more effective killing tools--and they could be used to dig/improve trenches.

So I see this as a pretty hefty flip-flop in the argument.
Yeah, justintime is flailing, trying to find any excuse to reject science. He can't prove that science is based on fraud, so he's trying a different tactic. Once he realizes we won't fall for that one, he'll try something else. For people like justintime the reasoning isn't important--the conclusion that scientists are evil is sacred, not to be questioned, and his "logic" is merely justifications intended to support that a priori conclusion. The way these arguments interconnect is irrelevant to people making these sorts of arguments; they're looking for some chain of reasoning to support their conclusions, and don't care if one proposed chain destroys a different one they proposed. This is true of trolls and True Believers.
 
Yeah, justintime is flailing, trying to find any excuse to reject science. He can't prove that science is based on fraud, so he's trying a different tactic. Once he realizes we won't fall for that one, he'll try something else.


Or just go back the the "fraud" claim.
 
No, human behaviour is the primary cause for cyber fraud, cyber bulling, etc. Without a computer, fraud, bullying and crime would still exist.



And?

Clubs, axes, knives and spears are still responsible for most of the violent deaths in human history, but I'm sure you simply blame those on the application of newtonian physics right? Your beef is more properly directed at human behaviour again which has a strong tendency to violence.



And to act as pesticides and weedkillers allowing better and more productive agriculture.



Destroying - no.

Changing - yes.

They are also the reason that we are not limited to only local agricultural products to feed ourselves.



Your evidence for this assertion - derived from non-scientific means of course.



You've not been able to assert that "science fraud" is common with any degree of accuracy, in fact the sources YOU'VE PROVIDED point to it being insignificant.



The "true criminals" behind the "global crisis" are people - nothing more or less.
Scientists using science developed weapons, chemicals and technology capable of mass destruction without which the threat of global annihilation would not be possible. The scientific method lacks the safeguards to control scientists who are irresponsible in their research and short sighted in their inventions totally oblivious to the extent of damage their inventions can cause when put in the wrong hands. Even here safeguards cannot prevent proliferation of the technologies of mass destruction. Scientists should be held accountable for their application of science.

'I've Created a Monster!' On the Regrets of Inventors
http://www.theatlantic.com/technolo...a-monster-on-the-regrets-of-inventors/249044/
 

Fallacy of limited depth.

1. Computers/internet are the primary cause for cyber fraud, cyber bullying and cyber crime.

Crime, fraud, and bullying existed before there were computers. Before computers were widely used in commerce, mail fraud was common. Does that mean mail is inherently evil? Should all postmasters be jailed? Before commerce by mail, fraud was an in-person activity.

Generalize this to other forms of cyber crime such as stealing private, proprietary information. Before the time when data was kept and exchanged over computer networks, this type of crime took the form of "social engineering," or the (less technical) "Dumpster diving." Ultimately it's just eavesdropping, which requires no more equipment or technology than an ear and an eave. Should carpenters be jailed now too?

Cyber bullying has become a thing because social interactions rely more heavily on computer networks. Before then, you had to do your bullying in person -- ostensibly on the school playground. Shall we now jail all the makers of playground equipment?

The practices you decry and the moral decay underlying them are not the products of the tools now used to carry out those practices, nor the instigation of the moral phenomenon. That immoral people use whatever tools are at their disposal toward immoral ends is not proof that the tools are themselves immoral, that their creators intended (or even envisioned) them, nor that the creators bear ultimate moral responsibility for them.

2. Bombs are destructive and nuclear bombs are even more destructive.

Munitions (nuclear or conventional) are merely the military application of high-energy chemistry and physics, which serve mankind in other ways. There is nothing inherently wrong with high-energy processes; they have become the backbone of our modern world. Highways cannot be constructed through difficult terrain, for example, without the use of efficient explosives.

Knives are also destructive, and are merely the product of tinkering with metal. As with high-energy physics, metal-sharpening has a variety of applications of varying degree of moral approbation.

3. Biochemical agents are used to destroy innocent populations.

Same as above. Chemistry sometimes produces substances that are inimical to life, either by design or as an accidental property. Cyanide, for example, is very useful in the production of electronics, and as a pigment. It is also highly poisonous to organisms. A pesticide is a good thing in one context, where one wishes to set aside some land for growing his own food, or to make it possible to feed many more people on the same acreage -- a benefit from science. In another context it may be a weapon of war, whatever its original intent. That scientists know about properties of the physical world that can achieve vast destruction does not make them responsible for the actions of others who choose to use them as such.

These two points make it sound like you're arguing that scientists are immoral because they are not pacifists. That's a pretty big change of horses.

Warfare is a fact of human life. For whatever fault of the species, we feel the need to protect our interests and our lives. As one would expect, we turn to the tools we think will best suit that end. Would you not pick up a hefty stick to defend yourself if you were attacked, or felt you would be? I'm not going to debate the morality of war, except to point out that warfare and conflict occur in the absence of science, hence science is not to blame.

4. Chemicals and fossil fuels are destroying the planet by polluting and creating a greenhouse effect.

Chemical and fossil fuels are naturally-occurring substances that have been used for centuries to provide heat and run thermodynamic engines. Science makes them less polluting and hazardous, since people insist on using them. This is actually an example of science's favorable moral direction, not its alleged immorality.

Science is also vigorously pursuing alternative forms of energy that are more sustainable, safe, clean, and cheap. This requires considerable effort and brains. Can you deny that it is happening? Can you explain how it would possibly happen without science?

5. Industrial waste and radioactive material are major cause of cancer and birth deformities.

Where are you talking about? Here in the United States the major causes of cancer are genetic factors, tobacco, the Sun, and diet -- purely natural and/or voluntary factors. While isolated industrial pollutants are linked to some causes of cancer, they are not as major a factor here in the U.S. as they are elsewhere, such as in China where there are fewer environmental restrictions. Here in the U.S., industries are required to develop and maintain effective pollution controls. That requires science.

Only about half the causes of birth defects are known, so laying it vaguely at the feet of "science" is disingenuous.

Radiation is a notable cause of birth defects and cancer, but you have warped this into the notion of artificial, science-produced sources of radiation. The radiation in question, in terms of its biological effect, is the Sun and background radiation, not artificial sources used in nuclear science or nuclear engineering.

So not only is science fraud common place the adverse effects of scientific inventions are even more common place.

No. Your attempt at proving that science is fraudulent has been soundly refuted. You're now trying to change horses and show that science's inventions are harmful. But you have to silently abandon your fraud claim because you can't simultaneously say that science is ineffective and also that it has adverse effects -- the latter presupposes an effect.

Much of the science fraud is the concealment of the detrimental effects of short sighted solutions by scientists that leave long term devastation behind.

That's you making a political argument against, not science being political. Science is happy moving at its own pace. It's only when advocates on either side of some issue decide to draft scientists into their fight that you get the conditions you describe.

Companies get sued for contaminating the environment. But the scientists who created the toxic chemicals are not penalized. They are the true criminals contributing to our global crisis.

No, this is just more "I hate science." As we have outlined patiently over the past several pages -- but you continue to ignore -- the users of scientific findings are responsible for their use of it, not the creators of it. Malice occurs in the user, regardless of what tools he chooses to carry it out.
 
Scientists using science developed weapons, chemicals and technology capable of mass destruction without which the threat of global annihilation would not be possible. The scientific method lacks the safeguards to control scientists who are irresponsible in their research and short sighted in their inventions totally oblivious to the extent of damage their inventions can cause when put in the wrong hands. Even here safeguards cannot prevent proliferation of the technologies of mass destruction.


"Many were increasingly of the opinion that they all made a big mistake in coming down from the trees in the first place. And some said that even the trees had been a bad move, and that no one should ever have left the oceans." - Douglas Adams, The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, Fit the Second.
 
Scientists using science developed weapons, chemicals and technology capable of mass destruction without which the threat of global annihilation would not be possible. The scientific method lacks the safeguards to control scientists who are irresponsible in their research and short sighted in their inventions totally oblivious to the extent of damage their inventions can cause when put in the wrong hands. Even here safeguards cannot prevent proliferation of the technologies of mass destruction. Scientists should be held accountable for their application of science.

'I've Created a Monster!' On the Regrets of Inventors
http://www.theatlantic.com/technolo...a-monster-on-the-regrets-of-inventors/249044/

Building the atom bomb was a political decision not a scientific one. The project was so great a task it required government organisation and funds to achieve. The responsibility of a scientist in these situations is to inform policy makers and the public. And scientists did famously speak out about the decision.

Discovering that something like a fission bomb is possible arises out of scientific research. The decision to apply that knowledge to the production of technology is a societal one.
 
Scientists using science developed weapons, chemicals and technology capable of mass destruction without which the threat of global annihilation would not be possible.

Scientists did not invent war, nor do they especially advocate it.

The scientific method lacks the safeguards to control scientists who are irresponsible in their research...

Actually the results show exactly the opposite -- a fact which you have addressed only with blatantly erroneous arithmetic.

According to you, useful inventions are produced not by applied science, but by mere tinkering and inevitable refinement. Where are the safeguards in that process to prevent malfeasance using those products?

...and short sighted in their inventions totally oblivious to the extent of damage their inventions can cause when put in the wrong hands.

If you agree that "wrong hands" exist and that those hands belong to someone who isn't the originating scientist, why are you so afraid to hold those "wrong hands" accountable?

Scientists should be held accountable for their application of science.

No.

Your own argument clearly identifies two different parties: (1) the scientists who create technology, and (2) the people who use those technologies for nefarious ends. You're arguing that the blame for misuse should not rest with the "wrong hands."

That's just silly.
 
justintime said:
Scientists using science developed weapons, chemicals and technology capable of mass destruction without which the threat of global annihilation would not be possible.
Sure it would. Science tells us what's true about the world; without science, atomic power would still exist. There have been, for example, naturally occurring nuclear reactors--enough uranium gets concentrated in one place to go critical. None are active today, to my knowledge, but some ancient ones have been found.

The scientific method lacks the safeguards to control scientists who are irresponsible in their research and short sighted in their inventions totally oblivious to the extent of damage their inventions can cause when put in the wrong hands.
Actually, the scientific method, including peer review and public analysis, is one of the best safeguards we have against exactly what you're talking about. When a scientist comes up with a new idea, everyone can hear about it--and if that idea is dangerous, people will figure out how to mitigate that danger.

But again, you seem to want to place on science the guilt of nature. NATURE allows for nuclear power. NATURE allows for dangerous chemicals. All science does is figure out how that happens. These facts exist; science discovers them, it does not create them. Without science, these facts would still be here, as a dangerous and potentially deadly unknowns.

Even here safeguards cannot prevent proliferation of the technologies of mass destruction.
Anything is dangerous if used improperly. Abuse does not negate use.

Scientists should be held accountable for their application of science.
Only in so far as they contributed to those applications. If they had no knowledge of them, they are innocent if not victims.

JayUtah said:
Scientists did not invent war, nor do they especially advocate it.
Very true. Wars interfere with the free exchange of ideas that is the heart and soul of science.

According to you, useful inventions are produced not by applied science, but by mere tinkering and inevitable refinement. Where are the safeguards in that process to prevent malfeasance using those products?
To be fair, I can't imagine a less efficient methodology than random tinkering. If that's what we relied upon, we'd still think bows and arrows were amazingly advanced technology.
 
Scientists using science developed weapons, chemicals and technology capable of mass destruction without which the threat of global annihilation would not be possible.

They also eliminated smallpox.

Can we get back on topic, here, and you telling me that I am correct when I say that 7000% is impossible, and that the real proportion of fraud is 0.005% ?
 
Scientists using science developed weapons, chemicals and technology capable of mass destruction without which the threat of global annihilation would not be possible. The scientific method lacks the safeguards to control scientists who are irresponsible in their research and short sighted in their inventions totally oblivious to the extent of damage their inventions can cause when put in the wrong hands. Even here safeguards cannot prevent proliferation of the technologies of mass destruction. Scientists should be held accountable for their application of science.

'I've Created a Monster!' On the Regrets of Inventors
http://www.theatlantic.com/technolo...a-monster-on-the-regrets-of-inventors/249044/

People have been trying to kill each other, and grab more resources since we became hominids. We started getting good at it when we started using tools like rocks, sticks and fire and then refined them initially by trial and error, then gradually in more systematic ways. Those same tools that we use to kill also allow us to better feed and clothe ourselves. Given that we are now at one of the most peaceful parts of human history, and that it is science's ability to feed us, clothe us and keep us alive longer that cause to use more resources, not our ability to use better and better means of killing each other that would be more of a risk to humanity.

But of course, if we'd only stayed as arboreal apes we'd be prey. I'll take what we have,
 
justintime; said:
And finally the public will agree most of the science fraud that is so common is because what the scientists are practicing is not science, it is politics.
You seem to share many beliefs with Sth East Indian anti-science Maoist political groups. Have you read or are you reading their material?

You do not appear to offer an alternative in your posts as to what should replace science. May I ask what you think should replace "science" in society? Do you support a return to agrarian based economics?
 
But again, you seem to want to place on science the guilt of nature. NATURE allows for nuclear power. NATURE allows for dangerous chemicals. All science does is figure out how that happens. These facts exist; science discovers them, it does not create them. Without science, these facts would still be here, as a dangerous and potentially deadly unknowns.


All these "discoveries" were made by scientists. Since scientists are, according to Justintime, all fraudulent, none of the things they discovered actually existed. All the victims died as a result of fraud, not the nonexistent bombs or chemicals. ;)
 
But again, you seem to want to place on science the guilt of nature. NATURE allows for nuclear power. NATURE allows for dangerous chemicals. All science does is figure out how that happens. These facts exist; science discovers them, it does not create them. Without science, these facts would still be here, as a dangerous and potentially deadly unknowns.

I think this is an important point that needs to be highlighted. If no scientist had ever existed, there would still be arsenic, and it would still be poisonous. There would still be plant and animal toxins, and they would still be deadly. There would still be bubonic plague and smallpox and all the other illnesses that have killed people forever, and there would be a greater incidence, and more people would die because there would be no medicine. There would still be cliffs and mountains to fall from, and acceleration would still be 32 feet/second2, and you would still be shattered when you landed. Meteorites would still smack into the earth. There wasn't a scientist to be seen when the dinosaur extinction event took place.

The fact that we have learned how to identify and measure and classify and explain all these things doesn't make them more likely to happen.
 
I think this is an important point that needs to be highlighted. If no scientist had ever existed, there would still be arsenic, and it would still be poisonous. There would still be plant and animal toxins, and they would still be deadly. There would still be bubonic plague and smallpox and all the other illnesses that have killed people forever, and there would be a greater incidence, and more people would die because there would be no medicine. There would still be cliffs and mountains to fall from, and acceleration would still be 32 feet/second2, and you would still be shattered when you landed. Meteorites would still smack into the earth. There wasn't a scientist to be seen when the dinosaur extinction event took place.

The fact that we have learned how to identify and measure and classify and explain all these things doesn't make them more likely to happen.

It's a point that folks like Justintime will never quite get, though, since the whole point of religion is to insist that there can be no division between a non-normative "nature" and a god who is "normative" personified (to be accurate, deified); and that science, in "messing with things that man wasn't meant to know!" is eeeeevil.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom