science fraud is common place

I think this is an important point that needs to be highlighted. If no scientist had ever existed, there would still be arsenic, and it would still be poisonous. There would still be plant and animal toxins, and they would still be deadly. There would still be bubonic plague and smallpox and all the other illnesses that have killed people forever, and there would be a greater incidence, and more people would die because there would be no medicine. There would still be cliffs and mountains to fall from, and acceleration would still be 32 feet/second2, and you would still be shattered when you landed. Meteorites would still smack into the earth. There wasn't a scientist to be seen when the dinosaur extinction event took place.

The fact that we have learned how to identify and measure and classify and explain all these things doesn't make them more likely to happen.

That is a false premise. Humans have survived catastrophic natural disaster in the past. But the new threat from science and scientists are of a magnitude unparalleled before in human history.

From Bostrom’s paper:

Humanity has survived what we might call natural existential risks for hundreds of thousands of years; thus it is prima facie unlikely that any of them will do us in within the next hundred. This conclusion is buttressed when we analyze specific risks from nature, such as asteroid impacts, supervolcanic eruptions, earthquakes, gamma-ray bursts, and so forth: Empirical impact distributions and scientific models suggest that the likelihood of extinctionbecause of these kinds of risk is extremely small on a time scale of a century or so.

In contrast, our species is introducing entirely new kinds of existential risk – threats we have no track record of surviving. Our longevity as a species therefore offers no strong prior grounds for confident optimism. Consideration of specific existential – risk scenarios bears out the suspicion that the great bulk of existential risk in the foreseeable future consists of anthropogenic existential risks – that is, those arising from human activity.

http://www.infowars.com/science-will-destroy-humanity-says-team-of-scientists/
 
That is a false premise. Humans have survived catastrophic natural disaster in the past. But the new threat from science and scientists are of a magnitude unparalleled before in human history.

You've been corrected on this lie before. I can only surmise that your ignorance of said corrections is willful.

Science isn't the threat. It's the use we make of the tools given to us by science, just like the use of hunting spears led to more deadly wars.
 
Science is about understanding how the cosmos works. This understanding in the form of technology can be used in ways that threaten our survival. To save ourselves we must cast understanding aside in favour of ignorance. In terms of the survival of our species, ignorance is strength!
 
You've been corrected on this lie before. I can only surmise that your ignorance of said corrections is willful.

Science isn't the threat. It's the use we make of the tools given to us by science, just like the use of hunting spears led to more deadly wars.

There were no tools of mass destruction until scientists began to invent them. They created weapons of mass destruction (nuclear bombs), biochemical agents to destroy innocent populations, cluster bombs to deal with densely populated areas. Now they are into global warming and genetically modified foods. Ironically for all their scientific endeavors they have never created a living organism in the lab....their focus have always been on the destruction of life.
 
There were no tools of mass destruction until scientists began to invent them. They created weapons of mass destruction (nuclear bombs), biochemical agents to destroy innocent populations, cluster bombs to deal with densely populated areas.


Don't worry. Your claim that science is fraudulent means that none of those worked.
 
There were no tools of mass destruction until scientists began to invent them. They created weapons of mass destruction (nuclear bombs), biochemical agents to destroy innocent populations, cluster bombs to deal with densely populated areas. Now they are into global warming and genetically modified foods. Ironically for all their scientific endeavors they have never created a living organism in the lab....their focus have always been on the destruction of life.

Again, bombs are engineering applications of chemistry and physics. The knowledge came out of scientists attempting to come to greater understandings of the world, albeit many of them doing it with Baconian motivations of this knowledge providing power over our surroundings and bearing technological fruits.

How we apply the knowledge is a societal question. If you don't like how we apply scientific knowledge, then use the democratic options at your disposal to seek change. Or are you suggesting that you would prefer to live in a world prior to fundamental understandings of physics and chemistry which allowed for the development of bombs?
 
Last edited:
That is a false premise. Humans have survived catastrophic natural disaster in the past. But the new threat from science and scientists are of a magnitude unparalleled before in human history.

There's serious debate about that (see Peter Ward's "Future Evolution"). Regardless, you are still laying on the heads of science guilt for properties of nature. As others have said, there are perfectly peaceful and practical uses for these technologies--power plants, industrial processes, medical processes, etc. Abuse does not negate use, and all scientists do is figure out the rules, we don't make them.

They created weapons of mass destruction (nuclear bombs), biochemical agents to destroy innocent populations, cluster bombs to deal with densely populated areas. Now they are into global warming and genetically modified foods. Ironically for all their scientific endeavors they have never created a living organism in the lab....their focus have always been on the destruction of life.
Most of those were built based on discoveries made for peaceful uses. Nuclear power was known for a long time before nuclear bombs were made, and many of the people involved in things like H-bomb development were astrophysicists (who else knew about fusion at the time?). And no, science HAS NOT been focused on destruction of life. Science is the reason that there can be so much life on the planet now.

If you don't like science, I'm sure there's a subsistance farm somewhere you could go to where they never use anything discovered by science. Go there for a week. If you are sane, you will come back thanking scientists for their work. It has done tremendous good for the planet and for everyone in it. The few destructive outcomes are anomolies, not the rule.
 
To be non-hypocritical that would mean that you may not plant any seeds that are not harvested from wild plants - practically all seed crops have been modified by people practicing agricultural science since we tried to make our lives easier by planting seeds and we wouldn't want you contaminating your purity with evil science.
 
To be non-hypocritical that would mean that you may not plant any seeds that are not harvested from wild plants - practically all seed crops have been modified by people practicing agricultural science since we tried to make our lives easier by planting seeds and we wouldn't want you contaminating your purity with evil science.

Well, I'm willing to accept planting seeds from any breed that was developed before, say, the Napoleanic Wars. Much of domestication wasn't a scientific process, but rather trial and error on the part of a huge number of individual groups. But yeah, any breed, strain, hybrid, or other type of crop that science has touched is out.
 
Language is also a technology and scientists have picked apart its structure, origins and 'rules', they have also created artificial languages, perhaps we should stop using it too?

Don't worry. Your claim that science is fraudulent means that none of those worked.

Well how do you expect Justintime to keep track of all the stuff he makes up?
 
There were no tools of mass destruction until scientists began to invent them.

Arbitrary distinction. From the first hand tools wielded by prehistoric man to the modern nuclear stockpile there has been a steady progression in the scale of energies and forces at our disposal. Those tools have always had both beneficial and detrimental uses.

By the way, the conventional bombing of Dresden during World War II dwarfed the scale of energy and destruction by the atomic bombs dropped on Japan. Reconcile that, if you please.

Ironically for all their scientific endeavors they have never created a living organism in the lab....their focus have always been on the destruction of life.

Why is the creation of life suddenly the sine qua non of your moral approbation? Justify that standard, if you please.

Further, your two statements here are factually false. The neighbor two-doors-down from where my mother used to live clone a sheep. Yeah, he was that guy.

As to I and my colleagues focused solely on the "destruction of life," that patently false and also very personally insulting. Would you be willing to say, in front of all these people, that I personally have no other focus than the destruction of life? Go ahead, make that argument. I dare you.

If not, retract it and let's have no more of this animosity-laden rhetoric from you.
 
Last edited:
Language is also a technology...

Language can be used to harass, bully, and defame. On the one hand, why isn't justintime decrying that? And on the other hand, it demonstrates that knowledge per se and the willingness to use knowledge immorally are two separate concepts that justintime insists on conflating.

Well how do you expect Justintime to keep track of all the stuff he makes up?

We're keeping track of them for him. We've been constantly reminding him of the blatant contradictions in his own posts, but so far no reconciliation has appeared.
 
There were no tools of mass destruction until scientists began to invent them.

Science is also responsible for tools of mass salvation, but that doesn't factor into your thinking at all.

Life-saving medicines and procedure, cheap and abundant energy, abundant and nourishing food, clean and efficient transportation -- these are all things you and the rest of the world enjoys, which are the product of science. In your arguments you explicitly take all of them for granted while laying at the feet of science every human ill you can possibly imagine. How is this anything other than uninformed animus?

The modern airplane is a product of science. It can be used to ferry medical supplies, food, and clothing quickly to the victims of natural disasters such as the Asian tsunami of several years ago. Or, in the hands of evil persons, it can be flown into a building with the intent to cause great loss of life. Which is the "true" intent behind the invention of the airplane? And what evidence can you provide that the scientists who invented it envisioned exactly that intent?

This is only the latest of several examples you have been shown (and have summarily ignored) that simply don't fit your characterization of science. You base your arguments on a comically-drawn caricature of what science is, who scientists are, and what they do.

But you can't stay consistent.

You tell us that it's the responsibility of science to keep its inventions from falling into the "wrong hands" (your words). You admit there are people with questionable moral foundations who use scientific inventions for their own evil ends. You distinguish them from the scientists. You have to, since the only way one group could limit its aid to another is if they're two separate groups.

So if one group are the moral villains, and the other group are the scientists, how does your knee-jerk vilification of science actually work? You clearly already accept that science itself is amoral, since you pin the moral agency on a different group. Your own line of reasoning does this; it's nothing we've done.

In other words, you've already refuted yourself.
 
Science is also responsible for tools of mass salvation, but that doesn't factor into your thinking at all.

Life-saving medicines and procedure, cheap and abundant energy, abundant and nourishing food, clean and efficient transportation -- these are all things you and the rest of the world enjoys, which are the product of science. In your arguments you explicitly take all of them for granted while laying at the feet of science every human ill you can possibly imagine. How is this anything other than uninformed animus?

The modern airplane is a product of science. It can be used to ferry medical supplies, food, and clothing quickly to the victims of natural disasters such as the Asian tsunami of several years ago. Or, in the hands of evil persons, it can be flown into a building with the intent to cause great loss of life. Which is the "true" intent behind the invention of the airplane? And what evidence can you provide that the scientists who invented it envisioned exactly that intent?

This is only the latest of several examples you have been shown (and have summarily ignored) that simply don't fit your characterization of science. You base your arguments on a comically-drawn caricature of what science is, who scientists are, and what they do.

But you can't stay consistent.

You tell us that it's the responsibility of science to keep its inventions from falling into the "wrong hands" (your words). You admit there are people with questionable moral foundations who use scientific inventions for their own evil ends. You distinguish them from the scientists. You have to, since the only way one group could limit its aid to another is if they're two separate groups.

So if one group are the moral villains, and the other group are the scientists, how does your knee-jerk vilification of science actually work? You clearly already accept that science itself is amoral, since you pin the moral agency on a different group. Your own line of reasoning does this; it's nothing we've done.

In other words, you've already refuted yourself.

How science touches every aspect of our lives from food to the air we breathe to our ability to procreate. But is science a positive contributor or as the article ponders. Human race being terminated by 'scientific suicide'
http://www.naturalnews.com/035790_scientific_suicide_humans.html

"Scientists are death engineers and the human race is being murdered in the name of science."
So you see, I am not alone in my concerns.
 
justintime said:
So you see, I am not alone in my concerns.
Bandwagon Fallacy. The fact that you can find other people arguing the same nonsense does not, in any way, demonstrate that it's not nonsense.
 
How science touches every aspect of our lives...

That's just the same sort of devoid-of-fact rant you've been writing here yourself, only this-time penned by someone else and linked to by you. It doesn't address a single point in my post, especially the part where your own line of reasoning refutes itself. No link can save you from logical contradiction.

Please try again.

So you see, I am not alone in my concerns.

That doesn't mean those concerns are correct, fairly considered and stated, or have any fact to support them.

Now please address my actual points, not just randomly link to people who agree with you.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom