science fraud is common place

MaartenVergu

Illuminator
Joined
Nov 19, 2010
Messages
3,146
Most of what occurs in the practice of science goes on behind closed doors, beyond the prying eye of the public. Nevertheless science and the scientists who conduct its research seem to enjoy an almost religious-like reverence, having been granted a virtual hands-off policy by the public at large to advance and mold the future.
Against this backdrop however, science is increasingly accused of fraud in the pursuit of useful research findings, applications and profits. Scientists like the rest of us try to cut corners, get the papers published, have their ideas for research funded, compete with co-professionals, and vie for glory. It is alleged by many that science fraud is commonplace in a society driven by money and ambition. To be sure science is not a career for the faint of heart. On the contrary science is an aggressive, ruthless business.
Still the practitioners and institutions of science are accused of going beyond mere ambition in the eternal quest for knowledge. Our researchers pressured by the need to produce are venturing beyond the boundaries of honest science into the forbidden territory of science fraud. Despite this revered social standing, scientists are now more than ever motivated toward the falsification of research in pursuit of hefty corporate grants or public recognition. The scientific process has changed greatly over the years. For the scientist the pressure of obtaining funding, which often is tied to professional advancement, is coming both internally from the employer and externally from the grant giving bodies.
Modern science is a large-scale enterprise heavily funded and highly directed. Its dominant players are large corporations and the US government, both of whom have definite stakes in the outcome of any given research. In the mainstream media of today, tales of science fraud abound. Further complicating these financial challenges, season-scientists find themselves competing for finite funds in a glutted field, going up against much younger comparatively inexperienced practitioners. This competition for grants, status, position and money makes the temptation to veer away from the straight and narrow almost irresistible.

Source: science fraud: the price for fame and fortune
See documentary:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lKbdzGTM5cM

So, do not just trust on science, but think for yourself.

In the documentary they show you that Isaac Newton intentionally scewed data to make the work of a rival appear less important. He was a fraud...
 
Last edited:
almost religious-like reverence

LOL. even more than religion atleast for me. because they are real and actually work.
gods and religions not.
 
I stopped reading there. Anyone who says this clearly doesn't know the first thing about science, so his opinions are not worth reading.

its merely the transcript from the docu.
im half way of the docu. and so far its alot better than one might think considering the OP and posting history of Maartenn100. it looks like from the 90's however.
sofar it seems legit.
 
I stopped reading there. Anyone who says this clearly doesn't know the first thing about science, so his opinions are not worth reading.
.
That's the common stopping point when trying most of the OP's threads. There's no there there.
 
I stopped reading there. Anyone who says this clearly doesn't know the first thing about science, so his opinions are not worth reading.

Seconded!

I did the same thing.

So I stopped reading his opening, and very incorrect (to put it politely), statement as well.
 
Newton was a fraud! We're all being held down by a fake. Gravity is just a hoax being perpetrated by BIG SCIENCE!
 
Maartenn100 said:
Most of what occurs in the practice of science goes on behind closed doors, beyond the prying eye of the public.
As a professional scientist, I can assure you that this is not true. I've often had the public (or their representatives) directly observing me.

Nevertheless science and the scientists who conduct its research seem to enjoy an almost religious-like reverence, having been granted a virtual hands-off policy by the public at large to advance and mold the future.
Nonsense. Most scientists are heavily regulated, with many areas of study completely blocked off by either de facto or de jury bans. Try to raise an emusaurus.

Also, I've yet to have someone treat me with almost religious-like reverence. At best, I've had kids who want to be paleontologists look up to me with hero-worship--but they do the same with John Wayn or Batman.

Against this backdrop however, science is increasingly accused of fraud in the pursuit of useful research findings, applications and profits.
I'd love to see evidence that fraud is more common per 1,000 researchers today than a hundred years ago. You are aware of Owen's history, yes?

It is alleged by many that science fraud is commonplace in a society driven by money and ambition.
It's alleged by many that the Earth is 6,000 years old. Allegations aren't proof of anything.

To be sure science is not a career for the faint of heart. On the contrary science is an aggressive, ruthless business.
True, but not in the ways you imagine. We're aggressive and ruthless, but we're fair and generous to a fault. James Randi has often pointed that last one out as a serious flaw in our process.

Our researchers pressured by the need to produce are venturing beyond the boundaries of honest science into the forbidden territory of science fraud.
None that I've met. A few disagreements about contract terms is as close as they got.

The scientific process has changed greatly over the years.
A trivially true statement. Science is constantly changing, as we learn that different methods work better. The rise of open-source journals and blogs is a major shift that we, like all of society, are still working out how to deal with.

For the scientist the pressure of obtaining funding, which often is tied to professional advancement, is coming both internally from the employer and externally from the grant giving bodies.
This has been true for most scientists for most of science's history.

Modern science is a large-scale enterprise heavily funded and highly directed.
Not nearly as much as you think--but whenever I hear someone talk about "science" it generally means they're thinking of physics. Physics certainly has largely moved away from questions that can be cheaply answered.

Its dominant players are large corporations and the US government, both of whom have definite stakes in the outcome of any given research.
You know, I work for a large corporation (Fortune 500, multinational, big enough to purchase outright whole companies that we'd otherwise have to compete with). The #1 thing that I've been told by everyone--even in the middle of a rather serious dispute about some findings--was that my scientific integrity was paramount and to not give an inch to anyone, be they the client, my manager, or the head of my research team. False data is of no value.

In the mainstream media of today, tales of science fraud abound.
Proof of nothing but the fact that such tales sell.

Further complicating these financial challenges, season-scientists find themselves competing for finite funds in a glutted field, going up against much younger comparatively inexperienced practitioners.
Which happens in every field of human activity. However. given the increasing emphasis of cooperation in science, I've little doubt that this will come to a happy conclusion--more senior researchers operate more as managers anyway, with much if not most of the grunt work done by us young bucks.

This competition for grants, status, position and money makes the temptation to veer away from the straight and narrow almost irresistible.
Not really. The consequences are catastrophic--proof of fraud ends careers, pure and simple. A slight advantage is nowhere near sufficient justification for risking one's livelyhood.

So, do not just trust on science, but think for yourself.
No practicing scientist that I've ever met has argued otherwise. In fact, they've all lamented the lack of critical thinking in the public--just about the only thing I can get them all to agree on.

In the documentary they show you that Isaac Newton intentionally scewed data to make the work of a rival appear less important. He was a fraud...
In the details, yes, but not in principle. Same with Mendel--his workers (he did little of the work himself) fudged the numbers a bit, which resulted in under-reporting of mutations. But the principle was sound.

Also, I love how you start with "Fraud is increasing in modern science!!!!!" yet your description of your only source is "Newton was a fraud". Real convincing there. :rolleyes: For a REAL discussion of fraud in science, there's this book. What you'll find is that scientists are humans, and have committed every sin humans as a whole commit. But I don't find that they commit any more than is normal among similar-sized groups of people. You get some frauds, some stupidity, some mistakes, but the majority are honest. And the fun part is, science is the system by which these frauds are generally discovered--those who attack science never seem to uncover anything new.
 
Most of what occurs in the practice of science goes on behind closed doors

while i do not reject it as others have done, as i don't really know. its hillarious to see in the docu itself, researchers doing research while there actually is a boat with people is driving in their lab like in a disneyland show so people actually see what they are doing lol. (20:19)
 
Nonsense. Most scientists are heavily regulated, with many areas of study completely blocked off by either de facto or de jury bans. Try to raise an emusaurus.

Psst! It's "de jure"! ;)

And the fun part is, science is the system by which these frauds are generally discovered--those who attack science never seem to uncover anything new.

Oh come on, Dinwar, we know that isn't right.

They constantly come up with new ways to re-present the same tired old arguments they've used all along, even when they were successfully answered the first time.

:D
 
Maartenn100, have you watched it? it contradicts your title directly.
 
the docu is legit, starts sensationalist, but at the end, totaly contradicts Maartenn100.
check and balance are in place, science is in better shape than people are led to believe, mainly because the media rather like to report on fraud than on scientific breaktroughs.

examples of fraud were al legit as far i know. pilt down , newton, mendelson, COLD FUSION lol.

but not realy worth a watch, its indeed from the 90's
 
DC, sometimes it's good to have an extreme opening post, otherwise you have no discussion at all. I don't have statistics about science fraud, so I honestly have no idea about how common it is. But the title can make some people write here on te forum. I like to be a little bit provocative here on the forum, in order to have a good discussion and to have some fun.

Sometimes we need to hear the other side of the story too.

By the way: I discovered that peerreviewers don't check the data with experiments, described in a submitted manuscript to an editor, in order to publish the manuscript in a journal.

They just publish the paper, without having done the experiments themselves and checking the data. Only when other scientists repeat the experiment in order to falsify the theory in the published paper, then the theory will be faslified.
So, peerreview is not really a good test.
 
Last edited:
People reject science because science is overrated. The scientific community are made up of short sighted people barely able to cope with the immediate problems and have little use for long term goals that are less sensational. For every problem science solves it creates a host of other problems. It doesn't help when amateurs join in the circus running around skeptic forums promoting scientism and pseudoskepticism. Add to the circus the conspiracy theorists an extreme band of skeptics who have managed to created the type of sensationalism scientists have been craving for.

Scientists like skeptics are their own worst enemy. Their disdain for the general public and an inability to articulate their discipline garbled in esoteric mambo jumbo provides them the protection under the disguise of science. To add insult to injury there is a tenfold increase in scientific fraud, widespread misconduct in retracted scientific research publications.
http://www.theguardian.com/science/2012/oct/01/tenfold-increase-science-paper-retracted-fraud
That scientists are beholden to big corporations is questionable. Even the tobacco companies relied on scientists to produce the data and ended up being sued when the data was inaccurate, misleading and dangerously inept. What corporation would want to be sued for the incompetence of scientists hired to deliver the evidence?

What use do major corporation have in the cloning of sheep? It is sensationalism that scientists crave for and Dolly is a perfect example. Are sheep so unique in appearance or genetically different that they have to be cloned to advance their lot?

Scientists even developed a baloney meter that proved useless because it was so biased towards science. I say, give us a break!!!!!
 
DC, sometimes it's good to have an extreme opening post, otherwise you have no discussion at all. I don't have statistics about science fraud, so I honestly have no idea at all how common it is. I like to be a little bit provocative here on the forum, in order to have a good discussion.

By the way: I discovered that peerreviewers don't check the data with experiments. They just publish the paper, without doing the experiments. Only when other scientists repeat the experiment in order to falsify the theory in the published paper, then the theory will be faslified.
So, peerreview is not really a good test.

with that you destroyd a totaly legit point from the documentary.
influence of money in science and the fight for grants. a legit proble that surely can hive nice material for a good debate.

a lie in the title is not the way to go.
and btw, you should have watched the deco before making the post.
 
People reject science because science is overrated. The scientific community are made up of short sighted people barely able to cope with the immediate problems and have little use for long term goals that are less sensational. For every problem science solves it creates a host of other problems. It doesn't help when amateurs join in the circus running around skeptic forums promoting scientism and pseudoskepticism. Add to the circus the conspiracy theorists an extreme band of skeptics who have managed to created the type of sensationalism scientists have been craving for.

Scientists like skeptics are their own worst enemy. Their disdain for the general public and an inability to articulate their discipline garbled in esoteric mambo jumbo provides them the protection under the disguise of science. To add insult to injury there is a tenfold increase in scientific fraud, widespread misconduct in retracted scientific research publications.
http://www.theguardian.com/science/2012/oct/01/tenfold-increase-science-paper-retracted-fraud
That scientists are beholden to big corporations is questionable. Even the tobacco companies relied on scientists to produce the data and ended up being sued when the data was inaccurate, misleading and dangerously inept. What corporation would want to be sued for the incompetence of scientists hired to deliver the evidence?
What use do major corporation have in the cloning of sheep? It is sensationalism that scientists crave for and Dolly is a perfect example. Are sheep so unique in appearance or genetically different that they have to be cloned to advance their lot?

Scientists even developed a baloney meter that proved useless because it was so biased towards science. I say, give us a break!!!!!

those that hire Fred Singer for his AGW denial?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom