science fraud is common place

Science invented many things and science should take both credit and blame for some very irresponsible inventions.

1. Computers/internet are the primary cause for cyber fraud, cyber bullying and cyber crime.

2. Bombs are destructive and nuclear bombs are even more destructive.

3. Biochemical agents are used to destroy innocent populations.

4. Chemicals and fossil fuels are destroying the planet by polluting and creating a greenhouse effect.

5. Industrial waste and radioactive material are major cause of cancer and birth deformities.

So not only is science fraud common place the adverse effects of scientific inventions are even more common place. Much of the science fraud is the concealment of the detrimental effects of short sighted solutions by scientists that leave long term devastation behind.

Companies get sued for contaminating the environment. But the scientists who created the toxic chemicals are not penalized. They are the true criminals contributing to our global crisis.

Of course Motherhood is the cause of all ills that plague mankind.
 
Science invented many things and science should take both credit and blame for some very irresponsible inventions.

1. Computers/internet are the primary cause for cyber fraud, cyber bullying and cyber crime.

2. Bombs are destructive and nuclear bombs are even more destructive.

3. Biochemical agents are used to destroy innocent populations.

4. Chemicals and fossil fuels are destroying the planet by polluting and creating a greenhouse effect.

5. Industrial waste and radioactive material are major cause of cancer and birth deformities.

So not only is science fraud common place the adverse effects of scientific inventions are even more common place. Much of the science fraud is the concealment of the detrimental effects of short sighted solutions by scientists that leave long term devastation behind.

Companies get sued for contaminating the environment. But the scientists who created the toxic chemicals are not penalized. They are the true criminals contributing to our global crisis.

Well at least you've abandoned any pretence of having a rational argument to present.
 
Science invented many things and science should take both credit and blame for some very irresponsible inventions.

1. Computers/internet are the primary cause for cyber fraud, cyber bullying and cyber crime.

2. Bombs are destructive and nuclear bombs are even more destructive.

3. Biochemical agents are used to destroy innocent populations.

4. Chemicals and fossil fuels are destroying the planet by polluting and creating a greenhouse effect.

5. Industrial waste and radioactive material are major cause of cancer and birth deformities.

So not only is science fraud common place the adverse effects of scientific inventions are even more common place. Much of the science fraud is the concealment of the detrimental effects of short sighted solutions by scientists that leave long term devastation behind.

Companies get sued for contaminating the environment. But the scientists who created the toxic chemicals are not penalized. They are the true criminals contributing to our global crisis.

You are here conflating science and engineering technology. But I am assuming you knew that when you wrote it.
 
Science invented many things and science should take both credit and blame for some very irresponsible inventions.

1. Computers/internet are the primary cause for cyber fraud, cyber bullying and cyber crime.

No, human behaviour is the primary cause for cyber fraud, cyber bulling, etc. Without a computer, fraud, bullying and crime would still exist.

2. Bombs are destructive and nuclear bombs are even more destructive.

And?

Clubs, axes, knives and spears are still responsible for most of the violent deaths in human history, but I'm sure you simply blame those on the application of newtonian physics right? Your beef is more properly directed at human behaviour again which has a strong tendency to violence.

3. Biochemical agents are used to destroy innocent populations.

And to act as pesticides and weedkillers allowing better and more productive agriculture.

4. Chemicals and fossil fuels are destroying the planet by polluting and creating a greenhouse effect.

Destroying - no.

Changing - yes.

They are also the reason that we are not limited to only local agricultural products to feed ourselves.

5. Industrial waste and radioactive material are major cause of cancer and birth deformities.

Your evidence for this assertion - derived from non-scientific means of course.

So not only is science fraud common place the adverse effects of scientific inventions are even more common place. Much of the science fraud is the concealment of the detrimental effects of short sighted solutions by scientists that leave long term devastation behind.

You've not been able to assert that "science fraud" is common with any degree of accuracy, in fact the sources YOU'VE PROVIDED point to it being insignificant.

Companies get sued for contaminating the environment. But the scientists who created the toxic chemicals are not penalized. They are the true criminals contributing to our global crisis.

The "true criminals" behind the "global crisis" are people - nothing more or less.
 
No, just elements of what he said dishonestly juxtaposed with your failed claim.

There were literal quotes from what Dinwar said about scientists.

Compare the points again.

1. Scientists have a poor understanding of science even though they might be qualified in their field.

2. They are generally ignorant of the history of their fields, let alone anyone else's,

3. Same ideas being tried repeatedly, and getting the same results while expecting a different result.

4. Left to the researcher to make their own conclusions about their own research.

5. The problem when a few people are responsible for determining the veracity of all research.

6. Science is politics as practiced by the scientific community.

Dinwar wrote:
Just because someone has(1) a good science background doesn't mean that their understanding of science is good. Most scientists I've met(1) have an extremely good understanding of their chosen field, but a very, very poor understanding of science itself.(2) They are generally ignorant of the history of their fields, let alone anyone else's, for example. This results in (3)ideas being tried repeatedly, and getting the same results.

There have always been attempts to formally designate and differentiate between theories with varying degrees of support. They all fail for the simple reason that(4) each researcher is obliged to come to their own conclusions about this issue. This is one of the foundational concepts of science: each researcher is independent and obliged to follow the data, resulting in the increase in knowledge along all fronts and the ability to self-correct. Establishing a formal system to designate well-supported theories vs. unsupported vs. disproven undermines this, since someone has to do the designating. Even if we say "Everyone can do it", in practice you'd still (5)end up with a small handful of people making these determinations. (6) That's not science; that's politics.
 
It plays a role in all of science and engineering--we're constantly learning new things and testing the limits of our capacity, and failure is data. We don't throw out data merely because we discovered it unexpectedly (and it's fairly disrespectful to the people who die in engineering disasters to ignore the data from those disasters).

"Trial and error" suggests a scattershot technique--throw enough crap against a wall and some of it is bound to stick. Given justintime's posting history, I've little doubt that was his intent. In contrast, engineering and science use past knowledge to make the best judgments about how to move forward, and when failures do happen scientists and engineers examine them to determine why and how to fix them. When a theory fails, scientists pour over the data to try to figure out why. When a design fails, engineers pour over the data to try to figure out why. The next theory or design takes those into account--so at the very least, any failure will be a NEW failure. This is not trial-and-error; this is a systematic examination of events to determine their root causes, and application of that knowledge to revisions to the system.
The reason you do not consider science a trial and error method is because you stated earlier it is more a repetitive process. The same ideas being tried repeatedly.

You wrote: This results in ideas being tried repeatedly, and getting the same results.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9761076&postcount=10
 
There were literal quotes from what Dinwar said about scientists.
[\QUOTE]

Quotes you are ripping out of context. And I note that you continue to ignore my statements on the subject. If anyone had any dilusions about your honesty, rationality, or integrity, this action alone is sufficient to destroy them.

DO NOT QUOTE ME AS SUPPORTING YOU. Doing so is extraordinarily dishonest. I made those statements in a VERY different context, one which WAS NOT related to this discussion. IN THAT CONTEXT the statements were clearly not intended to mean that scientists were incompetant, only that they were not competant outside of their areas of expertise.

If the rule for courtesy on this forum had any meaning, you would be banned for such behavior.

The reason you do not consider science a trial and error method is because you stated earlier it is more a repetitive process. The same ideas being tried repeatedly.
I have already explained that. Since you refused to read my explanation, preferrinig instead to rip my statements out of context and twist them to your own purposes, I see no reason to continue to discuss this with you.

You erred in including my entire quote, by the way. Anyone with half a brain can see that you didn't even include the entire statement. For example,
5. The problem when a few people are responsible for determining the veracity of all research.
The actual statement is as follows:

Dinwar said:
Establishing a formal system to designate well-supported theories vs. unsupported vs. disproven undermines this, since someone has to do the designating. Even if we say "Everyone can do it", in practice you'd still end up with a small handful of people making these determinations.
I made it very clear that I was discussing a very specific hypothetical. You dishonestly removed that context, altering the meaning of my statements. The rest are equally bad. And now you've presented it for the whole world to see.
 
Dinwar: anyone reading with good will got it--Jamal (Justintime) does not scruple to twist anything he can get his hands on, nor does he cavill at outright falsehood. He has used the same argumentation style on multiple fora, and multiple threads here.

I figured as much, and thanks. :) I just want to make it very, very, very clear that nothing I said should be construed to be supporting JiT's nonsense. I know I should know better, but cherry-picking my statements still annoys me.
 
And at this point Justintime's intellectual dishonesty compels me to add him to my ignore list where he can keep company with Anders Lindman.
 
Science invented many things...

Thank you for conceding your claim.

...and science should take both credit and blame for some very irresponsible inventions.

No. Do not attempt to shift horses to a moralist argument. Can we expect anything from you beyond variations on "I hate science"?

So not only is science fraud common place...

It is not.

...the adverse effects of scientific inventions are even more common place.

So there was never any evil before science? I think you're laying blame at the wrong doorstep. Please try again.
 
The reason you do not consider science a trial and error method is because you stated earlier it is more a repetitive process. The same ideas being tried repeatedly.

The first sentence is a reasonable paraphrase of Dinwar's statement.

The second sentence is your attempt to interpret it, and in the process trying to interject a different claim. Your posts are based almost entirely on misquotation, misrepresentation, and wholesale attempt to restate what your critics say. Why is your position so weak that it cannot stand up to direct scrutiny?

As I wrote in an earlier post, science became a rational pursuit when its iterations were governed not by random and uninformed manipulation of the relevant variables, but when the subsequent repetitions were built upon astute and rational analysis of the preceding trials. The methods used to organize that analysis and improve its utility are what we call "science."

That's how science transformed the abacus into the modern digital computer. It wasn't by random fiddling with bits of wood and string. It was by attempting to understand what it means to compute and directing one's efforts more productively.
 
Science invented many things and science should take both credit and blame for some very irresponsible inventions.

1. Computers/internet are the primary cause for cyber fraud, cyber bullying and cyber crime.

2. Bombs are destructive and nuclear bombs are even more destructive.

3. Biochemical agents are used to destroy innocent populations.

4. Chemicals and fossil fuels are destroying the planet by polluting and creating a greenhouse effect.

5. Industrial waste and radioactive material are major cause of cancer and birth deformities.

So not only is science fraud common place the adverse effects of scientific inventions are even more common place. Much of the science fraud is the concealment of the detrimental effects of short sighted solutions by scientists that leave long term devastation behind.

Companies get sued for contaminating the environment. But the scientists who created the toxic chemicals are not penalized. They are the true criminals contributing to our global crisis.

You should boycott science and all products of scientific research starting with the internet.
 
Just for some humorous diversion. I think just in time got his info from cracked.com today. "Six shocking studies that prove science is totally broken"

It does go to show though where this attitude comes from and how it gets perpetuated.
 
You should boycott science and all products of scientific research starting with the internet.

But the OP denies that these are the products of science. In his argument, they're just the product of ingenious tinkering. He has a private definition of "science," which seems to refer generally to academic, "ivory tower" science. He has not yet acknowledged that science embodies chiefly those things that have an eventual practical application.

In addition to ordinary engineering, I have worked in companies such as Herman Miller doing what is essentially no different than "ivory tower" science -- in my case, science in biomechanics, man-machine interfaces, and mechanical engineering that is meant to drive product design. However, the principal investigators in our work were also given leave to publish some of the results in "ivory tower" scientific journals in the fields of gerontology, behavior, and ergonomics. (It was paid for by the company, so it qualifies as "private" science. Nevertheless, the payoff for the principals we hired temporarily is the ability to publish results.)

We followed the scientific method, not because we're ivory-tower scientists, but because that's what you do when you want to have the best chance of getting the right answer.
 
But the OP denies that these are the products of science. In his argument, they're just the product of ingenious tinkering. He has a private definition of "science," which seems to refer generally to academic, "ivory tower" science. He has not yet acknowledged that science embodies chiefly those things that have an eventual practical application.

.


He's going to be heart-broken when he finds out that the first connection on what would later be called the internet was between UCLA and the Stanford Research Institute.
 
justintime said:
Companies get sued for contaminating the environment. But the scientists who created the toxic chemicals are not penalized. They are the true criminals contributing to our global crisis.
This makes even less sense than you normally do. Most scientists who develop chemicals are very careful to delineate safe handling procedures for those chemicals. However, they have no control over the storage or handling of the chemicals outside of their own labs (except in extremely rare cases where they retain the right to inspect the holding and handling facilities). What normally happens is that some random person is told "Those drums need to be shifted to Building C", and they shift the drums. Each company is obligated to have safety procedures, including procedures in the case of spills or releases, which are based on the nature of the chemicals they handle--which in turn are based on the scientific study of those chemicals.

I spent a few years cleaning up such spills and releases (not necessarily the same thing). Most of the spills and releases I dealt with were due to improper handling of the material or faulty equipment (such as ruptured underground storage tanks, which led to an interesting rule in my life: I'm no longer allowed to propose lighting Special Forces bases on fire, regardless of how effecient the process would be at removing contamination). The only time I've ever seen the scientists even involved in the handling of HAZMAT has been on military bases, where they were experimenting with various methods for building and fueling rockets, and with various missiles and the like. When you're blowing up Soviet tanks, HAZMAT releases aren't really a major concern.
 
Dinwar, your view and opinion of scientists support the stereo type that scientists are self absolved in their research and may know very little outside of their chosen field and have an even poorer understanding of science itself. That is why the number of retractions are increasing.

It also helps the public to understand why peer-review oversight fails because those on the board according to you "are generally ignorant of the history of their fields, let alone anyone else's." So how can they expose fraudulent papers when scientific knowledge is so limited/restrictive for each individual scientist.

You also highlight the flawed trust in the self correcting obligation researchers have in the pursuit of knowledge. But the limitations of the peer review process becomes apparent because it still ends up a small handful of people making these determinations.

And finally the public will agree most of the science fraud that is so common is because what the scientists are practicing is not science, it is politics.

No one is disagreeing with your analysis.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom