science fraud is common place

Possible explanation why science fraud is common place.
Followed by no such explanation :jaw-dropp, justintime!

1. Scientists have a great understanding of science especially in their field :eek:.

2. They are generally knowledgeable about the history of their fields, and often of others.

3. The same ideas being tried repeatedly means that they expect to get the same results.

4. It is reasonable for a research team to make their own conclusions about their own research (lone researchers are quite rare today).

5. The problem when ignorance of science means that you think that there are a few people veriflying research. Every scientist in a field is verifying research.

6. More ignorance: Science
Science (from Latin scientia, meaning "knowledge"[1]) is a systematic enterprise that builds and organizes knowledge in the form of testable explanations and predictions about the universe.[2][3] In an older and closely related meaning, "science" also refers to a body of knowledge itself, of the type that can be rationally explained and reliably applied. A practitioner of science is known as a scientist.

Of course lying about Dinwar's post Just because someone has a good science background... in the How good is your theory? thread is just bad, justintime :(.
That thread is not about scientific fraud. The post in that thread is not addressing scientific fraud.
 
Last edited:
We have and you are just wrong or lying, justintime. In a thread not about scientific fraud, Dinwar's post (not about scientific fraud) is:
Just because someone has a good science background doesn't mean that their understanding of science is good. Most scientists I've met have an extremely good understanding of their chosen field, but a very, very poor understanding of science itself. They are generally ignorant of the history of their fields, let alone anyone else's, for example. This results in ideas being tried repeatedly, and getting the same results.

There have always been attempts to formally designate and differentiate between theories with varying degrees of support. They all fail for the simple reason that each researcher is obliged to come to their own conclusions about this issue. This is one of the foundational concepts of science: each researcher is independent and obliged to follow the data, resulting in the increase in knowledge along all fronts and the ability to self-correct. Establishing a formal system to designate well-supported theories vs. unsupported vs. disproven undermines this, since someone has to do the designating. Even if we say "Everyone can do it", in practice you'd still end up with a small handful of people making these determinations. That's not science; that's politics.

Your list is not in that post which (one more time :)) is not about scientific fraud. It is about how to classify theories..
 
Last edited:
To clarify what I meant, because I feel rather dirty that JiT twisted my words:

Dinwar said:
Just because someone has a good science background doesn't mean that their understanding of science is good.
This was slopy verbage on my part. What I meant was that it's entirely possible to understand a field of science without understanding grand-scale perspectives on science. Philosophy of Science is not a course most scientists take, so they tend to accumulate their understanding of how science works piecemeal. They understand how THEIR science works, but an understanding of the scientific process, viewed from the perspective of philosophy of science, is outside the scope of most scientists.

The issue in question highlighted this. Several geological theories were portrayed as being far less well-supported than they actually were, not because the data weren't there but because the person establishing the ranking for theories wasn't a geologist and didn't know how to evaluate the data, much less how well supported the theory was. The knowledge of individual scientists is insufficient to establish a universal metric for evaluating the strength of a theory; in that limited sense knowledge of one's field does not mean one is knowledgeable about science as such. I'm a good paleontologist; not hte best, but no slouch either. I'm a horrible astrophysicist, only slightly above average for high school graduates because I've picked up a few of my wifes books to read on long plane rides. And astrophysicists likewise make horrible paleontologists. No shame there; it's not our field. But it's important that we recognize it in the context of evaluating theories from other fields.

Also, I wasn't ruling out the posibility of someone being knowledgeable about science as a whole. I was just pointing out that this one person, the one proposing the metric for evaluating theories, wasn't.

Most scientists I've met have an extremely good understanding of their chosen field, but a very, very poor understanding of science itself.
Again, by "science itself" I mean theories of the philosophy of science--the epistemological foundations, the history of the fields, etc. Most paleontologists know Lyelle. Not many know de Vrise. Most know Darwin; not many know the graduate students who figured out how important the Burgess Shale is. That sort of thing. Science classes teach the state of the field, not really the history; we're on our own there.

They are generally ignorant of the history of their fields, let alone anyone else's, for example. This results in ideas being tried repeatedly, and getting the same results.
Here I was specifically thinking of recurring controversies in science. I've been reading on the history of taxonomy, and the field tends to bounce between being dominated by lumpers vs. being dominated by splitters. In biology you have people like Dawkins talking about infintesimally slow changes, despite the fact that Neocatastraphism, Punctuated Equilibrium, and de Vrise' primrose experiments demonstrate that evolution is far more abrupt than his metaphor of the hairpin turn justifies. Scientists understand the foundational theories of theiri diciplines, but they spend their time learning the state of the art, which unfortunately leads to oscilations in fashion among some researchers. That said, the self-correcting nature of science eventually smooths these out. The controversy between Uniformitarianism and Catastraphism is pretty much over; even the self-identified Uniformitarianists agree with Neocatastraphist ideas, they just word it differently. A deeper understanding of history can mitigate this.
 
To clarify what I meant, because I feel rather dirty that JiT twisted my words:

This was slopy verbage on my part. What I meant was that it's entirely possible to understand a field of science without understanding grand-scale perspectives on science. Philosophy of Science is not a course most scientists take, so they tend to accumulate their understanding of how science works piecemeal. They understand how THEIR science works, but an understanding of the scientific process, viewed from the perspective of philosophy of science, is outside the scope of most scientists.

The issue in question highlighted this. Several geological theories were portrayed as being far less well-supported than they actually were, not because the data weren't there but because the person establishing the ranking for theories wasn't a geologist and didn't know how to evaluate the data, much less how well supported the theory was. The knowledge of individual scientists is insufficient to establish a universal metric for evaluating the strength of a theory; in that limited sense knowledge of one's field does not mean one is knowledgeable about science as such. I'm a good paleontologist; not hte best, but no slouch either. I'm a horrible astrophysicist, only slightly above average for high school graduates because I've picked up a few of my wifes books to read on long plane rides. And astrophysicists likewise make horrible paleontologists. No shame there; it's not our field. But it's important that we recognize it in the context of evaluating theories from other fields.

Also, I wasn't ruling out the posibility of someone being knowledgeable about science as a whole. I was just pointing out that this one person, the one proposing the metric for evaluating theories, wasn't.

Again, by "science itself" I mean theories of the philosophy of science--the epistemological foundations, the history of the fields, etc. Most paleontologists know Lyelle. Not many know de Vrise. Most know Darwin; not many know the graduate students who figured out how important the Burgess Shale is. That sort of thing. Science classes teach the state of the field, not really the history; we're on our own there.

Here I was specifically thinking of recurring controversies in science. I've been reading on the history of taxonomy, and the field tends to bounce between being dominated by lumpers vs. being dominated by splitters. In biology you have people like Dawkins talking about infintesimally slow changes, despite the fact that Neocatastraphism, Punctuated Equilibrium, and de Vrise' primrose experiments demonstrate that evolution is far more abrupt than his metaphor of the hairpin turn justifies. Scientists understand the foundational theories of theiri diciplines, but they spend their time learning the state of the art, which unfortunately leads to oscilations in fashion among some researchers. That said, the self-correcting nature of science eventually smooths these out. The controversy between Uniformitarianism and Catastraphism is pretty much over; even the self-identified Uniformitarianists agree with Neocatastraphist ideas, they just word it differently. A deeper understanding of history can mitigate this.

Dinwar: anyone reading with good will got it--Jamal (Justintime) does not scruple to twist anything he can get his hands on, nor does he cavill at outright falsehood. He has used the same argumentation style on multiple fora, and multiple threads here.
 
It is ridiculous to suggest when someone is using a computer to communicate he is actually doing science.

Nobody is suggesting that, as you well know. No science, no computer, to carry on with this charade.
 
It is ridiculous to suggest when someone is using a computer to communicate he is actually doing science.
It is ridiculous to make up fantasies by misinterpreting a simple statement, justintime.
When someone states "someone is using a computer to communicate" then they are stating that someone is communicating using a computer :jaw-dropp!

They are not as you think "actually doing science".
They are using a device that was developed using science.
 
It is ridiculous to suggest when someone is using a computer to communicate he is actually doing science.

No one is suggesting that. As has been spelled out to you explicitly several times, the claim is that the computer is a product of applied science. Do not put different words into your critics' mouths.

A computer is a device. As a tool it is an improvement from a calculator as a calculator was an improvement from an abacus as an abacus was an improvement from counting with ones fingers.

And the thing that allowed that progression is called "science."

You can use computers to do scientific work. Even here the application/software is what allows the computer to be used in scientific research. But without such applications it is a pretty dumb input/output device.

The knowledge that enabled such a thing as "software" to exist is also called science.

What were scientists thinking when they invented the computer?

Initially, breaking codes (Turing at Blechley Park) and artillery aiming tables (ENIAC).

Code-breaking (cryptoanalysis) is a rigorous science based on mathematics and statistical probability. Artillery aiming is applied Newtonian dynamics.

The computer fills a dual role in enabling modern science as well as being the product of science. None of your desperate straw-man claims, handwaving, and assiduous evasion/denial has affected that statement.
 
The knowledge that enabled such a thing as "software" to exist is also called science.

That is one bone that I have to pick with the modern university curriculum; although I am a graduate of a "Computer Science" program, I do not consider myself a scientist, because popular culture views "science" as the set of experimental disciplines rather than the mathematical disciplines. I don't write code in a lab coat.
 
What were scientists thinking when they invented the computer?
JayUtah pointed out the practical applications that lead to the development of computers.
Scientists also invented the computer to replace computers :D
The term "computer", in use from the early 17th century (the first known written reference dates from 1613),[1] meant "one who computes": a person performing mathematical calculations, before electronic computers became commercially available.
 
It is ridiculous to suggest when someone is using a computer to communicate he is actually doing science. A computer is a device. As a tool it is an improvement from a calculator as a calculator was an improvement from an abacus as an abacus was an improvement from counting with ones fingers.

You can use computers to do scientific work. Even here the application/software is what allows the computer to be used in scientific research. But without such applications it is a pretty dumb input/output device. Unless you tell it what to do it just stares back at you. What were scientists thinking when they invented the computer?

They were thinking: here's a nifty device for pulling in data,controlling equipment, crunching numbers and executing programs.

Science: you should try it sometime. Beats looking for all your answers in a random collection of scrolls that has been retranslated for centuries. And doesn't contain a lick of science.
 
Justintime said:
It is ridiculous to suggest when someone is using a computer to communicate he is actually doing science.

I never said that and you know it. I said that computers are the result of science.

You also need to acknowledge that the % of fraud is 0.005%, not 7000.
 
Justintime how do you feed yourself and get any work done with those fingers in your ears?
 
''Wow cool. We're using science to invent a computer!''

Science invented many things and science should take both credit and blame for some very irresponsible inventions.

1. Computers/internet are the primary cause for cyber fraud, cyber bullying and cyber crime.

2. Bombs are destructive and nuclear bombs are even more destructive.

3. Biochemical agents are used to destroy innocent populations.

4. Chemicals and fossil fuels are destroying the planet by polluting and creating a greenhouse effect.

5. Industrial waste and radioactive material are major cause of cancer and birth deformities.

So not only is science fraud common place the adverse effects of scientific inventions are even more common place. Much of the science fraud is the concealment of the detrimental effects of short sighted solutions by scientists that leave long term devastation behind.

Companies get sued for contaminating the environment. But the scientists who created the toxic chemicals are not penalized. They are the true criminals contributing to our global crisis.
 
Science invented many things and science should take both credit and blame for some very irresponsible inventions.

1. Computers/internet are the primary cause for cyber fraud, cyber bullying and cyber crime.

2. Bombs are destructive and nuclear bombs are even more destructive.

3. Biochemical agents are used to destroy innocent populations.

4. Chemicals and fossil fuels are destroying the planet by polluting and creating a greenhouse effect.

5. Industrial waste and radioactive material are major cause of cancer and birth deformities.

So not only is science fraud common place the adverse effects of scientific inventions are even more common place. Much of the science fraud is the concealment of the detrimental effects of short sighted solutions by scientists that leave long term devastation behind.

Companies get sued for contaminating the environment. But the scientists who created the toxic chemicals are not penalized. They are the true criminals contributing to our global crisis.

Suddenly science us uber effective and the cause of all ills?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom